Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say you take both or you don't get DD

588 replies

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 14:43

I have two children, DS is nearly eight, autistic and has additional needs. DD is four and neurotypical.

Neither side of the family has ever offered us practical support or help with DS, never offered to babysit or take him out. The only help I received with him was a few hours while I had planned c section for DD and then my husband had to go home by teatime to put him to bed.

DD is growing and developing at the same rate as her peers, she's a very funny and outgoing little girl who makes us all laugh. We put a lot of effort into giving her our attention and support so that she doesn't feel resentful of time that we have to give to her brother, who she loves.

She is getting to the age now where both sets of grandparents are talking about having her go to their houses to stay, or taking her on holiday. But when they talk about this they only ever mention her. Never my son.

My heart says you don't get to pick and choose which of my kids you give this attention to. But I don't want to deny DD happy memories. AIBU?

OP posts:
Somethingneedstochange · 07/07/2022 15:51

Suggest well if you want to take DD this time next time they take ds. It does siblings good to have a break from each other but it's not fair when they choose the easier child to look after.

I've got two with special needs but son seems to always have been favoured. Because he's easier to look after.

glittereyelash · 07/07/2022 15:51

Its a difficult one. A lot of people are afraid of the word autism alone. Do they spend much time with your child and would they be able to cope with his additional needs. Does he have meltdowns or is he a flight risk I find these are the things families struggle with most. I'm sorry it must be very tough ❤️

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 07/07/2022 15:51

I would be very careful about denying your daughter things based on fairness of her brother.

Does he get more or your time? Energy? Resources?

I have a friend with such resentment built up against her brother due to how her parents handled his needs that she has cut him off and has a very limited relationship with them

1VY · 07/07/2022 15:48

I think that you and your husband should sit them down for a face to face conversation and say

“ We understand that now that the children are older, you would like to spend some one-on-one time with them.

” This would be lovely for them both so we will need to have a discussion about how you can best manage that with DS and DD.

“We understand if you feel that you can’t manage them both together as they have such different needs so we need to plan how you can spend quality time with both of them individually. You will you will understand how important it is for us to treat both children equally and we are sure that you will support us with that.

“ How do you feel about coming over this Saturday and watching DS for three hours at our home while we take DD to the park?

[ or whatever works for your DS]

“We can see how that goes and maybe the next weekend you could take DD to your house for the afternoon? “

Hopefully they will not be blunt enough to actually say no, we are not interested in DS only in DD. If they mutter about not being sure how to cope with DS then you can just explain it’s a matter of practice and experience and you are sure that as his wonderful loving grandparents they will want to learn these skills.

Naturally the last thing you want your DD to grow up believing is that her brother never gets any fun with relatives because he’s disabled.

If the grandparents try and manipulate the situation, you can just be very strict about saying “ Actually I think it’s Dss turn to spend some time with you this weekend, mother-in-law , as DD came last month”.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 07/07/2022 15:46

It honestly depends how much additional work he is- sorry if that sounds blunt.

C152 · 07/07/2022 15:45

Maybe they don't know how to raise whatever issues they have over your DS visiting? Perhaps they're worried they'll put their foot in it and offend you? What if you bring it up with them e.g. 'it's great you want to see DD, I'm sure she would love it. DS would love to see you too. Can we arrange something?' If they um and ah about it, ask what you can do to compromise. Perhaps they feel unable to cope with 2 young kids at once and can realistically only see one child at a time? Perhaps they're worried they won't be able to meet DS's needs, so it may be they would be happy to see him if you are there as well?

calmlakes · 07/07/2022 15:43

I can totally see how unfair it looks from your viewpoint and of course your ds is just as worthy of attention.
But you relatives appear to be unable for whatever reason to give him that attention.
They are able to give it to your dd.
She will have additional challenges being raised in a household with a sibling with significant extra needs.
It may be very positive for her to have these relationships and experiences both now and in the future.
It will also enable you to spend more 1:1 time with your son.
It isn't fair but depriving your dd of this won't make life any fairer.

IGotItInTheSales · 07/07/2022 15:43

Sounds like you are setting them up to fail by saying 'you take both or you don't get DD'

Almost like she's a prize. Sit down and work through it with them

What's your DH perspective?

Coyoacan · 07/07/2022 15:42

Without knowing the extent of your son's special needs, I have a friend whose childhood was totally marred by her brother's cerebral palsy. Obviously not as much as his was, but it is easy for the siblings of such children

BlancmanegeBunny · 07/07/2022 15:41

I have a son with severe learning disabilities, my parents cope well with him but my inlaws have never tried! His neurotypical older sister has benefitted a lot from staying with both sets of grandparents and has a lovely relationship with both sets. My parents live on the same street as us and DD pops in and out all the time, it gives her a place to be made a fuss of and be the center of attention and somewhere to go to get a bit of space from her brother.
Saying that they have to take both children is very short-sighted! It may be too much for them.
Without knowing your child's needs it is very hard to say if your family are being unreasonable or not.

ancientgran · 07/07/2022 15:40

I think they should make some effort with your son, it might be different to what they can do with DD but something. OP you know your son best, is there something that would be easier for them to do with him? If they are older they might find the thought of a holiday with him too much but maybe a trip to his favourite park one afternoon or the cinema/zoo/museum, anything really.

missdemeanors · 07/07/2022 15:37

You haven't really given much more info to go on OP. But I understand you feeling hurt if none of the gps have made an effort. It would be helpful for you to discuss directly with them, and perhaps suggest activities they can do which your ds would enjoy and which will be manageable for them.

You seem focussed on sleepovers and holidays and I can't over state this: unless your ds is untypical of many children with autism, this would probably be very disruptive to his routine and stressful for him. Taking a grandchild away on holiday is a big deal anyway.... many gps wouldn't do this with a NT child.

If they're not willing to even build a relationship with him then that's awful. But please don't punish your dd by not letting her enjoy the things your ds probably wouldn't enjoy anyway

IGotItInTheSales · 07/07/2022 15:37

Op.... you haven't answered the other questions?

The practicalities... you are just focusing on the emotional aspect

csection12 · 07/07/2022 15:35

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 15:26

This is the case, they've never even tried. DS is a lot more work, but he is worthy of attention just as DD is.

Then I would have a conversation with them about saying you want to treat them in an equitable way- and suggest ways of spending 1:1 time with DS in a way that is appropriate for him.

But I definitely wouldn’t let DD miss out on holidays and things that he wouldn’t be able to cope with not enjoy.

DD will always have less attention than him, it’s a fact of life. Her brother needs more from you. Let her get it from others.

HmmLetMeSeee · 07/07/2022 15:33

but you've not gone into any detail about his behaviour.

Yes it's really difficult to give proper answers without it.

It could be such a wide range of things that make it impossible to say whether they should be able to cope with him or not.

Some autistic DC wouldn't cope at all being away from their parents on holiday.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 07/07/2022 15:32

This is the case, they've never even tried. DS is a lot more work, but he is worthy of attention just as DD is.

Nobody is saying otherwise.

You say DS is autistic and also a lot more work - but you've not gone into any detail about his behaviour.

Are either set of parents even physically capable of looking after him alone? My parents are, on the outside, fit and healthy but they would both struggle with an 8yo who needed changing, for example, or comforting after a severe meltdown.

Isaidnoalready · 07/07/2022 15:31

Most grandparents would switch it out so one day with child a one day with child b they both get attention from the grandparents and they both get attention from you

Suprima · 07/07/2022 15:29

You don’t mention what your DS’ behaviours are like?

If he exhibits very challenging behaviours and has frequent meltdowns that limit what you can do as a family, poor DD will always be affected by this and you would be very unreasonable to deny her opportunities with other family members.

Your family members may also not have the skills or the ability to keep him safe if he’s a runner or a headbanger.

If none of this applies and DS is completely fine to be away from you, out of routine, can go to the zoo/seaside/shopping centre/whatever- and you suspect they are just being prejudiced, that’s completely different.

10HailMarys · 07/07/2022 15:28

I think it depends on the extent of your son's needs and behaviours. How much extra support does he need from people? How easy is it to do things like take him on holiday that everyone else can also enjoy?

Do you think he'd actually enjoy staying with family or having a holiday with them? Or would he hate the disruption to his routine, be overwhelmed by new experiences and have constant meltdowns? Does he need physical help with things? Does he do things like lashing out or refusing to move? Because that might be hard for grandparents to cope with physically, in an eight-year-old.

I think if they've seen him in distress or struggling with certain situations, and know how reliant he is on you and your partner for support, they may not want to risk him getting upset if you're not there or things aren't the way that he's comfortable with. Does he enjoy their company? Does he indicate that he has affection for them? Just trying to get a picture of what the relationship is like and what his needs are.

Bonheurdupasse · 07/07/2022 15:28

Sirzy · 07/07/2022 14:55

I would see it as a chance for her to be focused on in a way that often isn’t possible when you have another child with additional needs.

This OP.

HmmLetMeSeee · 07/07/2022 15:27

he is worthy of attention just as DD is

Of course he is OP.

I don't want to come across as harsh so I'm sorry if I do but you need to accept him being 'a lot more work' makes him harder to cope with than your DD. She shouldn't be penalised for that.

JustLyra · 07/07/2022 15:27

It’s pretty pointless to be slating people when there’s no clues in tbr OP as to the extent of her DS’s needs.

that is absolutely critical to if there’s a nastiness or just a practicality about the situation

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 15:26

Wombat27A · 07/07/2022 15:10

I think the issue here is the silence about the older DC. If they were open and fair and discussed the issues or looked for a compromise or solution or even said we'd love to look after him but can't cope, then it would be fine to discuss plans for the little one. But they haven't and I think that's rude and unfair.

Stuff being fair to them.

Plenty of other kids haven't had GP look after and them and we grew up with a severely ill older sibling, so I have some sympathy but they're not being fair or equitable. They don't get to make plans for your DC.

This is the case, they've never even tried. DS is a lot more work, but he is worthy of attention just as DD is.

OP posts:
Loveisnotloving · 07/07/2022 15:25

Considering they could not even put him to bed when he was much younger, my guess is they don't feel capable to deal with him. Don't deny his little sister time with her grandparents. It is not done on a favoritism level but on what they are able for. Do you honestly think your son would cope if they took him on holidays? Would they be able to cope?

EsmeeMerlin · 07/07/2022 15:25

I do kind of get this. My youngest son is being assessed for autism. He is not high needs but doesn't interact much and struggles to show affection or attachment. However with understanding, support and with adults getting down to his level rather than expect him to go to them he is a rewarding and happy child. The more you give him the more he will give you. However you get some who misunderstand him, my mil says 'sod you then' when he won't give her a hug and we have a few who will only invite his older brother and leave him out. It's tough but we do also have people who do make an effort to include him and also those who will step in for ds1 if ds2 is taking my time and attention. Recently we have my nephew's birthday party and we knew it was likely to be difficult for ds2 but he was still invited and enjoyed some party food at the side of the hall and enjoyed some colouring my sister has brought to him. My sister also gave me her keys when the party was too overwhelming to take him to hers while ds1 stayed with her and enjoyed the rest of the party. She didn't just not invite ds2. However it is tough to say no to invites for just ds1 when he would enjoy it so I don't really know what to suggest you do but I do get it when you see one invited but not the other.