Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say you take both or you don't get DD

588 replies

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 14:43

I have two children, DS is nearly eight, autistic and has additional needs. DD is four and neurotypical.

Neither side of the family has ever offered us practical support or help with DS, never offered to babysit or take him out. The only help I received with him was a few hours while I had planned c section for DD and then my husband had to go home by teatime to put him to bed.

DD is growing and developing at the same rate as her peers, she's a very funny and outgoing little girl who makes us all laugh. We put a lot of effort into giving her our attention and support so that she doesn't feel resentful of time that we have to give to her brother, who she loves.

She is getting to the age now where both sets of grandparents are talking about having her go to their houses to stay, or taking her on holiday. But when they talk about this they only ever mention her. Never my son.

My heart says you don't get to pick and choose which of my kids you give this attention to. But I don't want to deny DD happy memories. AIBU?

OP posts:
ToadiesCouzin · 07/07/2022 17:06

Yeah no, I wouldn't send my child away on a holiday with grandparents who hadn't also invite their sibling. I completely get they might find taking him away too daunting, and they're not obliged to take either of them away. So don't take either, take both or non at all. My kids have never been on holiday alone with their grandparents, and I doubt they ever will. I suspect lots of kids have never been taken on holiday by their grandparents, so your DD is hardly missing out on an important bonding experience if she doesn't go. You could suggest you all go on holiday together, or not, depending on how much you like spending time with these people. But the fact they thought it appropriate to only invite the NT sibling doesn't paint them in a very good light, they sound insensitive to say the least. I'd say no and I wouldn't pull any punches when explaining why.

wandawhy · 07/07/2022 17:05

Some of the reasons I think you are wrong have been described above. On a similar topic I previously posted our experiences when our two were young, boy and girl 2yr difference. No special needs but strong likes and dislikes.
Both enjoyed staying with both sets of Grand Parents from very young ages. Youngest 18 months. They kept toys and trinkets in their houses and built up their own worlds with the GPs. They were taken to new places places. Some quite mundane, different Supermarket, market on Wednesday, went on local buses, met the neighbours. They had things to tell us about and to gossip to each other about. They enjoyed it and will still remember odd things.

Bertieboo82 · 07/07/2022 17:05

Op I recall your others threads

tou are a full time carer for your DS
and, for example, you have a system of locks on all cupboards etc in your kitchen otherwise he will access

unless the grandparents are set up like presumably you are - I don’t blame them in the slightest for thinking beyond their capacity to have your DS on his own

CrapBag39 · 07/07/2022 17:04

The fact they’ve said they now get to do ‘normal’ things would be it for me. They’d not see either of my kids again. They sound utterly shit.

cestlavielife · 07/07/2022 17:01

Sorry wrong way round
Let dc nt go if she wants to and will enjoy
She needs space away
Seek respite opportunities for ds with asd

Blueblell · 07/07/2022 16:59

It’s a difficult one - I understand you wanting them to be treated the same. However I would allow her to go as she will benefit from the one to one with grandparents and it will help you. But I would also feel as you do, I suspect they feel they wouldn’t cope with him?

NumberTheory · 07/07/2022 16:59

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 16:07

The way I see it, you get out of it what you put in. If you put nothing at all in with my son, what do you get back from him? Nothing.

So then I am asked if DD can go to caravan in x for x number of days next year with grandparents I'm going off their prior record with DS arent I? Because it's all I have to go on.

Many grandparents don't do the hard work bits with any of their grandchildren. They do the easy bribe-'em-with-sugar-and-give-'em-what-they-want bits and get the smiles and puppy love, then hand them back to their parents when it gets difficult. Many grandparents are over the difficult bits of parenting and have no wish at all to go back to them.

So if there is no "easy" with DS then there probably isn't the same sort of grandparenting to be done. While the impact of that on DS would be ableist, it wouldn't necessarily be because their view of him is that he isn't worth as much as DD. It's that they don't want to work hard with any child.

I think it's pretty awful of them not to offer you some support or show any interest in DS. But I also think you should take up the offer of them having DD if it's going to be fun for her and give you the ability to take it a little easier and/or have some 1:1 time with DS. Parents of kids with special needs don't get enough support so even though it may feel tainted, you should probably use it anyway. It must be hard not to feel resentful towards them, but that's not a reaction that's going to help you make the best life for you, DS or DD.

cestlavielife · 07/07/2022 16:58

You let ds go.
He needs space away doing typical things
You fight to get respite for dd with SEN
You will need it
She has differing specialist neefs
They dont have the same needs
Some people will only manage the NT child
It s harsh but true
You cannot force them and could be bad for dd

Scout2016 · 07/07/2022 16:58

It's the gulf in approach that's the problem. The lack of any effort with one grandchild while wanting to take the other on holiday with them. And not acknowledging that they are doing it, although that wouldn't make it ok, but it would be a start.
Sadly your daughter will likely have lots of opportunities over the years that her brother won't and I understand why condoning his own grandparents excluding him feels wrong and I think I would feel as you do.

If they can't manage both together they should make the effort to do something with them separately.

Gerwurtztraminer · 07/07/2022 16:57

OP You do sound very angry with both sets of grandparents and I suspect you intepret their offers as them saying they love your DD more than DS. And I can see that would hurt a lot. Whereas as other psoters have tried to point out, it's probably a lot more complex than that, including them feeling unable to cope.

And even if you are right and they do feel less of a bond to him then DD, your questions was, is it fair if you deny her those opportunities? And that's doubly hard to answer if in your heart you feel you are doing it more about the point of principle that makes you so angry (that they SHOULD love them equally/want to spend time with both) and that you want to punish them for not doing so. On balance, I'd let you DD go and continue to encourage GP's to build a relationship with hom, even if it makes you angry and upset that you have to do that and they aren't doing it without being pushed.

I do see this in my own family; great niece (13) is ASD and one set of grandparents won't now spend time with her alone but will do a lot more with her 3 siblings (day trips. sports, babysitting). I think they are scared of getting it wrong as it doesn't take much to upset her and then it can result in fairly big tantrums. Her parents have accepted this as GP's do play and interact with her when a parent is present to keep an eye on it and step in when needed. Like you son she's not overly difficult if left to her own devices, is verbal and intelligent but very very anxious, rigid about food and almost agoraphobic so will usually not go out with GP's anyway so they are stuck at home .

Personally my view is you have years ahead of supporting your DS in his interactons with the world at large and upsetting grandparents and possibly ending up in family arguments over this isse with DD is energy better saved for that bigger battle.

calmlakes · 07/07/2022 16:57

It may work better to stop stressing about fairness, a rather nebulous and unachievable state.
And focus instead on what would be best for each individual child.
It is well recognized that individual time is important for dc in a young carers situation (your dc would be identified as heading into that as pp says) So individual time with GPs would seem to be a positive for her.

For your ds going from nothing to that would seem a big leap and quite possibly one he would not enjoy. But inviting family members for afternoon outs doing activities he enjoys and helping starting to build bonds would seem to be sensible.

We have a NT dc and a ND dc keeping the balance as they age is really hard at times and cutting off support for either would have been shortsighted. I am ND and have different needs to some of my NT siblings and that is ok as well.
Hopefully your family can be encouraged to support both dc but it doesn't need to be in the same way.

TolkiensFallow · 07/07/2022 16:57

Have you discussed this with your parents OP?

strawberrylacey · 07/07/2022 16:56

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 16:23

Because of the absolute deluge of ableism contained in the responses, that people aren't even aware of. It's depressing.

It's not "ableism", its realism,

Your DS has a severe mental disability that means his little sister is in effect his big sister and has to care for him. She deserves to have some respite to have some time to be a kid. And when grandparents suggest just that, you accuse them of favourite-ism.

Saz12 · 07/07/2022 16:56

Can you suggest all going away together? Explain to them how left out ds will feel if only DD gets to go. Ask them why they’re worried about taking DS. If it’s just that they perceive him as being harder going then could they not just take them for a shorter time, on a really straightforward trip - so they can get the food in advance with familiar brands (if that’s an issue), take familiar activities, have plenty of private “chill” time built in, whatever DS needs.

PracticalAdviceNeeded · 07/07/2022 16:55

Is it that they are being naive maybe and have Google searched what neuro diverse means and therfore have warped expectations of what your son would like? Have you ever done day trips together so they can see what strategies or additional requirements (if any) are needed? Have you tried coaching them on how to be a grandparent to him and built their confidence? It must be really tough not seeing your children treated equally and it should be human nature to be kind and considerate and understanding to all humans but it isn't and quite often people need to be shown

Bertieboo82 · 07/07/2022 16:55

how old are the grandparents?

and…. Why are you angry? Is it because you think their motivations are dark ie they don’t want to be judged by other people if our abs about with your son?

because with 2 sets of otherwise loving grandparents I would presume that they simply do not think they are capable

hands up - I wouldn’t be.

Sirzy · 07/07/2022 16:54

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 16:40

Nobody here has even considered my son's feelings for a single second, as if he is a pet or a cyborg.

But surely the best thing there is for you and your husband to talk to the grandparents to facilitate things?

have you actually sat down with them and spoken to them about how their help would be useful? How you want to facilitate their relationship because you know it’s harder because of his additional needs.

DS has a whole host of additional needs and I fully appreciate that i have to help facilitate relationships and give people the skills and confidence needed to look after him for them to be able to. Burying my head in the sand about the difficulties in looking after him wouldn’t help anyone.

SpaceJamtart · 07/07/2022 16:54

And i do really understand that the grandparents should be taking him out and they should care about him, especially enough to learn how to do it properly. And i would be heartbroken if my family didnt care about my siblings because they had so many extra needs.
It is not fair and it is unkind.

But that doesnt stop it being important for your daughter. It only happened a few times for me but my siblings knew I was going somewhere they would hate like the beach or the shops. And my older sibling knew that they got more time with mum so I got more time with grandma.
Luckily for my family, when we were all together, the extended family paid a lot of attention to my siblings- they knew they were loved too, just like they knew that they didnt want to go to the beach.

Clymene · 07/07/2022 16:54

He's not violent nor does he run away.

My parents are brilliant with my autistic child. They've asked questions, they've learned and he spends time with them happily on his own.

It's not as easy. But you have to want to try. It doesn't sound like the OP's parents want to.

Musti · 07/07/2022 16:53

Bertieboo82 · 07/07/2022 16:48

Why on earth would you want to leave your autistic DS with grandparents that don’t have experience or feel they have the capability to proper look after him?

one of my friend’s son is severely autistic. He needs 24/7 care. Non verbal. Hardly sleeps. Destructive. My friend’s mum is around a lot helping but usually with my friend too.

im sure op knows her child and there is a sliding scale of autism from my boyfriend who you can hardly tell and fully independent to the other end of the scale

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 07/07/2022 16:53

I wouldn't be forcing someone to look after my child if they didn't want to. I think it would be horrible to have to spend the day with someone that didn't like me and didn't want me around. I wouldn't want to leave my child in the care of anyone who isn't confident in their abilities to look after them either. So, I think your ultimatum is unreasonable for your son's sake. Stopping your DD from going is neither here nor there imo, if she doesn't know about it yet then no harm will come of it.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 07/07/2022 16:52

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 16:21

I really wouldn't worry about DD, she's thriving.

But that's one of the points of the thread that you mention in your OP?

I don't want to deny DD happy memories

You seem with your snippy responses that you've made your mind up though?

jamoncrumpets · 07/07/2022 16:52

whumpthereitis · 07/07/2022 16:48

I wouldn’t deny her the opportunity to have a relationship with her grandparents and extended family.

it’s understandable that you’re focused on your son, and while your DD is young she’s not going to care, but that will change as she ages. Some siblings do grow to become resentful of having to miss out because of disabled siblings. Others don’t of course, but your DD very well might, and it’s wise to consider the impact that may have on not only your relationship with her, but her relationship with her brother in years to come. I have a cousin that has almost nothing to do with her mother and autistic sister because she spent her entire childhood playing second fiddle (and was expected to take over care pretty much as soon as she hit 18).

I'm not focused on my son. I'm focused on both of my children equally.

OP posts:
Bertieboo82 · 07/07/2022 16:52

He can get very anxious and upset in new or busy situations

would this be precisely that. A new situation

SueSaid · 07/07/2022 16:51

'If GPs can't cope with 2 nothing wrong with alternating if the OP is happy with that'

Exactly. If they can't manage both then alternate but to give one dc a trip or a sleepover and not the other is just heartbreaking. Are they stupid, have they no idea of the negative impact this will have on the whole family?

Swipe left for the next trending thread