Do you really think Starmer, who spent much of his career prosecuting domestic abusers, is anti-women?
He may not have articulated his stance well enough, as he is a kind man who doesn't want to offend a group of vulnerable people by cruelly stating that, regardless of how they are navigating a tricky situation, they have not and never will be a woman because they may still have a penis.
I am conflicted, confused and struggle with many aspects of the Trans debate, probably because I haven't taken the time to fully educate myself enough to form strong opinions, but the kindness I feel in my heart understands the notion that, should my son decide to identify as a woman, he would still need to be included in prostate cancer screening so shouldn't be filtered out of any group invited. Likewise, I want my daughter to have safe spaces where appropriate.
This is, I think, where we get the clumsy language around 'pregnant people', 'people with a cervix' etc. As with all huge change it takes shifts backwards and forwards to get to a middle ground, but to go after Keir Starmer for not playing into the media's hands by 'making a statement' on whether a woman has a penis is lazy - this becomes the stick to beat him with and serves as a distraction to the fact the Tories are dismantling many of our institutions and guardrails in plain sight