Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To lie about an inheritance

162 replies

PhryneFisher · 07/07/2022 06:57

A relative of mine died recently and it turns out she was worth quite a lot of money. My aunt is the executor of the will and has told me that she left me some money. They are trying to work out the details but it’s a decent amount (in the sort of £50k bracket).
I personally have never had this much money in my life and am unlikely to again so I want to make sure it’s not wasted. I’m on a relatively low income.
However there are things like a hole in my roof and a cracked window from where it slammed shut in a storm that I haven’t been able to get replaced/repaired because I couldn’t afford it, that sort of thing. Nothing flash but things that could make my life a bit better. So I was thinking of putting at least half away for the future and pretend it’s not there and spending some of the rest but not all.

My issue is my OH spends money like water. He is from a much better off background than me. But he doesn’t appreciate the value of money and as such, never has any.
He inherited £125,000 ten years ago and blew the lot in six months on a new car, holidays, gadgets, tickets. We made a few joint decisions and did some home improvements but most of it went on stuff he decided we needed, but didn’t.
He didn’t save one penny of it.
No-one will lend him money any more because he doesn’t pay it back and we (well, I) manage our finances completely separately.

This money has been left specifically to me and is going into my bank account that he can’t access (because that way I can control the spending from it).

But if I get the work done he will know I have some and he will constantly come up with things we “need” or show me the latest version of something we already have that doesn’t need replacing.

So, am I wrong to lie about the amount, tell him it’s £10,000 and enough to get the roof fixed? I will get the roof fixed anyway, I’m not asking his permission. Either way he won’t have access to it but if he doesn’t know how much I actually have, he can’t make it into an issue.

Before anyone points out the obvious, no, it’s not the most stable relationship on the planet, and we are working on that but the chances of us going the distance are 50/50 at best. So there’s also the element of if we did split up, and I hadn’t told him the true amount he would probably be entitled to half anyway, which isn’t ideal.

What would you do?

OP posts:
ItWillBeOkHonestly · 07/07/2022 08:46

I think if you're working on your relationship issues, lying to him isn't a good idea. That just adds to the mistrust.

Could you instead just say that you've come into some money but because of the way he is with money, you're not going to tell him how much as it's none of his concern, just simply there is enough to do these small jobs in the house?

Squiff70 · 07/07/2022 08:38

The problem is, lies almost always backfire when they get found out.

There is no need to lie to your husband but also you don't have to disclose the exact amount either. It will be your money, safe in your account. If you have full control over how it is used/saved, then you have to be firm and maintain that your DH doesn't have a say in it - especially large sums of it.

It's a huge amount of money - don't waste it and don't allow him to waste it either.

I'm sorry for your loss.

Testina · 07/07/2022 08:37

@SarahProblem have another go at reading the OP 🤣

Tentpegsandtantrums · 07/07/2022 08:36

I’d use that money to start over without him!

Huntswomanonthemove · 07/07/2022 08:31

SarahProblem · 07/07/2022 08:25

Do you really need to lie to manage this situation? Do you not have an honest enough relationship where you can say "I've inherited money and this is what I'm doing with it "

Did you actually read @PhryneFisher‘s opening post? 🙄

RealBecca · 07/07/2022 08:29

I'd sincerely consider splitting up and starting divorce proceedings before the money landed in my account. I couldn't live a life like that.

Otherwise at best you go the distance and never get to enjoy the money without sneaking £50 here and there or lying about it or at worse you split and have to declare it and give him half anyway. I suppose at least then youd get £25k to yourself. Well, more like £15k after the £10k on the roof, door and other bits until the divorce. Then that can go on the legal fees.

billy1966 · 07/07/2022 08:26

What a waster.

Absolutely don't tell him.
Spend the minimum you have to fix the roof.

Any money you put into a shared asset will be split.

Keep your inheritance in your account and he won't be entitled to it.

OP, he sounds like such a selfish waster blowing so much himself.

Protect yourself and tell him nothing.
That money could be a life saver for you.

SarahProblem · 07/07/2022 08:25

Do you really need to lie to manage this situation? Do you not have an honest enough relationship where you can say "I've inherited money and this is what I'm doing with it "

Penguintears · 07/07/2022 08:24

Honestly, if you're at the stage in your relationship that you're willing to lie to him about something as big as this then I think you should use the money to leave him and set up on your own.

Personally I wouldn't be lying to my partner or hiding stuff from him. I would tell him the truth but say that you don't trust him with the money because of how he wasted his inheritance. Just be honest. But sounds like the relationship is dead anyway. Move on and spend the money how you want to.

BiFoldChampion · 07/07/2022 08:24

Gosh no don’t tell him. And not to divert the reason for the thread but I don’t think I could be with someone who is so selfish and thoughtless.

BackToTheTop · 07/07/2022 08:21

Married or not it's a good idea not to let him know about the money. I agree with only telling him you've been left x amount, I think you'll still have a fight on your hands for him not to spend some of that on luxuries. Definite sounds like you need your financial security in this case with the relationship being so rocky

Do you own the house, joint names, yours or rented?

If it's jointly owned and he didn't put, at least some of his £125k into the mortgage etc, I'd be fuming, and seriously thinking about moving into my own house without him.

Pipsquiggle · 07/07/2022 08:19

Definitely don't tell him the amount and are you certain you can keep it private e.g. he won't see bank statements?

In fact I would have the work you needed doing costed up - say the quote is £3.5k - I would tell him you got £5k.

Are you married? This is crucial if you break up.

Cannot believe he wasted so much money on 'stuff' in 6 months - that could have transformed your lives if spent well

Huntswomanonthemove · 07/07/2022 08:14

RandomMess · 07/07/2022 07:23

Whether married or not I'd ring fence the entire amount and not spend a penny on the house or household so if you split it doesn't form part of the marital assets - seek solicitor advice on how to do this.

I’d do this but would also start proceedings to leave. You deserve better @PhryneFisher and now you have this money it’s time. 💐

turquoisebuttons · 07/07/2022 08:13

I can’t get over the fact he blew £125k that’s crazy 🤯

Not unreasonable at all to keep it from him although given he didn’t give you access to his inheritance I’m not sure how he can expect access to yours anyway.

Redsquirrel5 · 07/07/2022 08:09

OP
I inherited some money from my aunt which DH knew about but when my mum died I didn’t tell him how much and I banked it in my own account. It is a great feeling of security to me so I would say keep the amount secret.
The other money is invested and he reads the reports though he can’t get his hands on it personally because it is all in my name.

Blowing that much in 6 months is shocking and you have every right to keep the amount quiet especially if OH rather than DH. You may decide to split in future and that will give you the way out. Just say you received a small inheritance and make sure you destroy the paperwork and that anyone near you doesn’t blab. My sister nearly told DH how much it was. You wont regret keeping the amount quiet believe me.

godmum56 · 07/07/2022 08:04

Testina · 07/07/2022 07:51

I could not be with (married to?) someone I had to lie to because of this.
So I’d either get rid of them, or I’d be totally honest. “I have £50K and you sure as fuck are not wasting it like you did yours - if you show me a new TV on your phone one more time, I’m going to shove that phone up your arse.” (as you can see, the first option is better!)
Staying married to someone who necessitated this degree of lying just wouldn’t work for me. Plus, I’m too confident of my own financial decisions to lie about them. What a way to live.

this

EarringsandLipstick · 07/07/2022 08:03

Clearly not unreasonable but why are John with him? He frittered away €125k - huge amount - that could have transformed your life.

There's no trust there.

godmum56 · 07/07/2022 08:03

So you are going to lie to him but think the relationship is fixable? I don't think you would be wrong to lie exactly but I do think it says that some part of you has decided that the relationship isn't fixable and I think that part of you is right. So I'd keep quiet about the whole thing and dump the deadbeat.

MaggieFS · 07/07/2022 08:03

Would be buy an 'I've been saving carefully' line? My concern with a made up inheritance figure is he might push and ask more questions.

Also, are you married?

PigletJohn · 07/07/2022 08:00

Are you in employment? If not, you can still put a small amount each year into a pension fund which will also receive a notional tax rebate.

If you are earning, you can put (up to) your taxable earnings into it each tax year.

It will be away from grasping fingers if you do.

Footbal · 07/07/2022 07:58

Dont tell him. Once it's paid into your bank account I would probably transfer it to a post office account as they don't send statements.

ifonly4 · 07/07/2022 07:54

Can you ask for two separate pay outs, one to go into your joint account which you're adamant will be for repairs, the other secretly into your own account? You shouldn't be under any pressure to spend the money unless it's right for you.

My DH inherited money from his DM, in all fairness he paid the mortgage off but still has £20k in his own account - really doesn't bother me - I trust him and in the end it'll actually benefit us both, whether for a house moved, a nice holiday or him just having a few treats for himself which I'll enjoy as it'll be nice to see him enjoy them.

girlmom21 · 07/07/2022 07:53

Testina · 07/07/2022 07:51

I could not be with (married to?) someone I had to lie to because of this.
So I’d either get rid of them, or I’d be totally honest. “I have £50K and you sure as fuck are not wasting it like you did yours - if you show me a new TV on your phone one more time, I’m going to shove that phone up your arse.” (as you can see, the first option is better!)
Staying married to someone who necessitated this degree of lying just wouldn’t work for me. Plus, I’m too confident of my own financial decisions to lie about them. What a way to live.

All of this. I would either end the relationship because there's no trust or respect there or I'd be very, incredibly blunt that this is what you inherited and this is what you have decided to do. It's non-negotiable.

Testina · 07/07/2022 07:51

I could not be with (married to?) someone I had to lie to because of this.
So I’d either get rid of them, or I’d be totally honest. “I have £50K and you sure as fuck are not wasting it like you did yours - if you show me a new TV on your phone one more time, I’m going to shove that phone up your arse.” (as you can see, the first option is better!)
Staying married to someone who necessitated this degree of lying just wouldn’t work for me. Plus, I’m too confident of my own financial decisions to lie about them. What a way to live.

Gatehouse77 · 07/07/2022 07:50

If you are married I believe inheritance left to one person is typically ring fenced in any settlement as long as it's kept separate.

This is factually incorrect. If you are married when the inheritance is received it’s a joint asset. Only ring fenced if inherited before marriage.

Swipe left for the next trending thread