Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To lie about an inheritance

162 replies

PhryneFisher · 07/07/2022 06:57

A relative of mine died recently and it turns out she was worth quite a lot of money. My aunt is the executor of the will and has told me that she left me some money. They are trying to work out the details but it’s a decent amount (in the sort of £50k bracket).
I personally have never had this much money in my life and am unlikely to again so I want to make sure it’s not wasted. I’m on a relatively low income.
However there are things like a hole in my roof and a cracked window from where it slammed shut in a storm that I haven’t been able to get replaced/repaired because I couldn’t afford it, that sort of thing. Nothing flash but things that could make my life a bit better. So I was thinking of putting at least half away for the future and pretend it’s not there and spending some of the rest but not all.

My issue is my OH spends money like water. He is from a much better off background than me. But he doesn’t appreciate the value of money and as such, never has any.
He inherited £125,000 ten years ago and blew the lot in six months on a new car, holidays, gadgets, tickets. We made a few joint decisions and did some home improvements but most of it went on stuff he decided we needed, but didn’t.
He didn’t save one penny of it.
No-one will lend him money any more because he doesn’t pay it back and we (well, I) manage our finances completely separately.

This money has been left specifically to me and is going into my bank account that he can’t access (because that way I can control the spending from it).

But if I get the work done he will know I have some and he will constantly come up with things we “need” or show me the latest version of something we already have that doesn’t need replacing.

So, am I wrong to lie about the amount, tell him it’s £10,000 and enough to get the roof fixed? I will get the roof fixed anyway, I’m not asking his permission. Either way he won’t have access to it but if he doesn’t know how much I actually have, he can’t make it into an issue.

Before anyone points out the obvious, no, it’s not the most stable relationship on the planet, and we are working on that but the chances of us going the distance are 50/50 at best. So there’s also the element of if we did split up, and I hadn’t told him the true amount he would probably be entitled to half anyway, which isn’t ideal.

What would you do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EarringsandLipstick · 09/07/2022 10:03

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 07/07/2022 10:51

I wouldn't say buying a car and home improvements were squandering it and the op also stated they made some joint decisions so she spent it too @EarringsandLipstick

See this from OP's first post.

Quite clearly it was squandered - by him.

He inherited £125,000 ten years ago and blew the lot in six months on a new car, holidays, gadgets, tickets. We made a few joint decisions and did some home improvements but most of it went on stuff he decided we needed, but didn’t.

Blondeshavemorefun · 09/07/2022 09:57

PhryneFisher · 07/07/2022 17:49

I didn’t “happily spend it”. I didn’t know how much he had until he had spent it and I had to take over his finances because he couldn’t manage them.
I knew it was a lot, but not that much.

So he didn’t tell you he had £125k

uou don’t need to tell him you have £50k

i think @KittyKittyKat suggestion of aunt offering fo pay for roof is a good one

ancientgran · 08/07/2022 18:37

It was DH who was disabled due to an injury, not the 10 day old baby. That sounded a bit confusing.

ancientgran · 08/07/2022 14:39

@butterflied thank you. It can be hard but to be honest I sat in a Consultant's office with a ten day old baby on my lap when he was told his injuries were never going to get better, would probably get much worse and I've spent the last 30 years coping with fall out, bringing up the baby and the toddler who was with gran so not much defeats me.

ancientgran · 08/07/2022 14:36

Huntswomanonthemove · 07/07/2022 22:39

Honestly, I couldn’t live with a hoarder, it would drive me nuts. My problem I suppose. Also I couldn’t live with the financial separation you have. We share a life together and plan and budget accordingly. That’s me, you are evidently happy with that but I wouldn’t be. 🤷‍♀️

In any marriage or relationships there has to be some give and take. I have my boundaries, you wouldn't know he was a hoarder if you came into my house unless you decided to inspect the shed/loft/garage/his office. I leave those places to him. Hoarding is a mental health condition, I didn't move out when he became physically disabled so why would I be less supportive of his mental health?

I couldn't live with all my financial decisions being shared, if he wants to splurge on something he values and I don't as long as he has the money where's the problem and the same in reverse. We have equal money, we both contribute to the bills in proportion to our income (his pension is better than mine) and what's left is ours. I'm a grown up so like that independence.

It's worked for 40 years and if it ain't broke don't fix is a good saying to live by.

butterflied · 07/07/2022 23:12

ancientgran · 07/07/2022 12:18

The hoarding is the big issue. We have enough money and it isn't an issue, we don't live a lavish lifestyle, it isn't us, but I do long for a house that isn't crammed iwth stuff. I do have very strict boundaries and his "hoard" is in the garage/shed/loft/his "office" and a storage unit but his attitude of never getting rid of things still impinges on life to some extent.

One horrible effect of hoarding is that if I think of him dying, he's a few years older than me and disabled so likely he will go first, my immediate thought is I will have to sort it all out. That is much sadder than worrying about how much money we each have in the bank.

I understand all of that. It's difficult.

Huntswomanonthemove · 07/07/2022 22:39

ancientgran · 07/07/2022 22:07

Because he's a hoarder?

Because he's a spender and I'm a saver?

Because we've been happily married for 40 years?

Because we keep our money separate by agreement?

I can't see why any of them are a good reason to end a happy marriage. Think of the women on here who have husbands who are unfaithful, women who are subject to domestic violence, women who have no money and stay in marriages but you'd walk away from a 40 year happy marriage for what?

Honestly, I couldn’t live with a hoarder, it would drive me nuts. My problem I suppose. Also I couldn’t live with the financial separation you have. We share a life together and plan and budget accordingly. That’s me, you are evidently happy with that but I wouldn’t be. 🤷‍♀️

ancientgran · 07/07/2022 22:07

Huntswomanonthemove · 07/07/2022 14:58

I would walk.

Because he's a hoarder?

Because he's a spender and I'm a saver?

Because we've been happily married for 40 years?

Because we keep our money separate by agreement?

I can't see why any of them are a good reason to end a happy marriage. Think of the women on here who have husbands who are unfaithful, women who are subject to domestic violence, women who have no money and stay in marriages but you'd walk away from a 40 year happy marriage for what?

Testina · 07/07/2022 21:56

PhryneFisher · 07/07/2022 17:49

I didn’t “happily spend it”. I didn’t know how much he had until he had spent it and I had to take over his finances because he couldn’t manage them.
I knew it was a lot, but not that much.

How did you not know how much he had?
It would just be odd not to ask… so did he lie?

coodawoodashooda · 07/07/2022 18:57

PhryneFisher · 07/07/2022 17:49

I didn’t “happily spend it”. I didn’t know how much he had until he had spent it and I had to take over his finances because he couldn’t manage them.
I knew it was a lot, but not that much.

Honestly. Leave him now. I had a spendthrift. It just gets worse.

PhryneFisher · 07/07/2022 17:49

I didn’t “happily spend it”. I didn’t know how much he had until he had spent it and I had to take over his finances because he couldn’t manage them.
I knew it was a lot, but not that much.

OP posts:
Ilady · 07/07/2022 16:31

I don't know if your married to this man or not. If your married he may have a claim on this money. You have told us that your trying to make this relationship work. You have also told us that in the past your oh got £125,000 of an inheritance and blew it within 6 months.
You know that if he finds out that your going to get £50,000 and possibly more he will expect you to pay for all the things he now wants. In other words your going to be left with none of this money.

He has already shown you that he is not financially responsible and that he is known for this.
The money he blew could have been a large house deposit or put a good dent in paying off a mortgage. That money could have been put towards a holiday, home improvements, savings, investments or into a pension. It could have improved your and his life in any number of ways both then and in the future.

My advice is that you end things with him and use this inheritance to move your own life forward. He has already shown you his true colours regarding money.

The reality is that as an adult you have to learn to manage money. You can't keep buying things and spending needlessly. You have to have some savings for a rainy day that you can access and some money aside in longer term savings including a pension. This is especially true in the case of your oh who got a large lump sum. He should be in a good long term position unlike most people who can't put money aside due to the current cost of living.
Your house roof and windows should have been fixed via the lump sum he got.

A few years ago one of my friend's came into some money and they kept quiet about it for various reasons. They knew that certain family members would have expected some of this money. These same family members left my friend struggling with various things over the years when they could have helped and made my friends life easier. My friend decided that then that had to think about their own life both then and in the future. Even now my friend is working towards changing their current set up because they don't want to be as available for certain people in the future.

You expecting to get £50,000 plus so you need to consider you current situation and what you want for yourself long term. I think that this money could be used to leave your oh. Long term you don't want to be struggling for money because he spends to much or trying to live on a state pension because you let him spend this lump sum.

5zeds · 07/07/2022 15:33

Op doesn’t want not to share with him just not to waste it on consumables. To my mind reducing your mortgage payments is the easiest way to do that.

Huntswomanonthemove · 07/07/2022 14:58

butterflied · 07/07/2022 09:11

That's not at all surprising if she lives with a hoarder. I would do the same.

I would walk.

KosherDill · 07/07/2022 14:27

justasking111 · 07/07/2022 13:09

My friends husband inherited a seven figure sum. When they divorced the judge wouldn't include it. You fix the roof and put the rest away

Inheritance is generally not a matrimonial asset if kept separate. Once it's spent on something joint, like paying down a mortgage, it cannot be retroactively ringfenced.

Keep it separate and secret OP, except for the roof repair. Don't listen to pious hogwash about needing to be "honest " with your spendthrift partner. You have every moral right to protect yourself.

entropynow · 07/07/2022 14:19

ArcticSkewer · 07/07/2022 07:27

Yes he would.

If it was kept entirely ringfenced she might have a case to keep it, but if it was needed, it would be split.

I know too many women who lost their inheritances on divorce. Really unfair as the men had not yet inherited so they got to keep all their own and half of their wife's.

This happened to my sister. 170k just like that, and he kept all his pension. Fortunately she's a high earner

Eeksteek · 07/07/2022 13:57

torquewench · 07/07/2022 07:04

Don't tell them anything except you've saved up enough to get repairs done.

The firm I work for has a couple of clients who've won millions on the lottery but haven't told anyone, not even their husbands or children as theyre also concerned the money would vanish quickly, so it is doable. Interstingly, said clients are all female and from backgrounds where £10k is an absolute fortune.

So many questions! How do they do it? What are their aims? What are they afraid will happen if they hadn’t hidden it? Do they ever get found out? Do men ever do it? What sort of firm helps people hide money anyway? (Sadly, I have no need of their services!!)

Are they all pretending to go off to work every day and leading secret double lives? What about providing for their children or gifts to wider families - are there elaborate subterfuges with pretend competition winnings and so on? Or do they just not do it?

I have EVERY sympathy. So many women are in relationships with unequal power over all sorts of things, including their own money and bodies. It’s appalling that women feel they need to hide assets because it’s not possible or easy to defend their boundaries over it. I’ve been in relationships where I’d have done it.

Fernticket · 07/07/2022 13:42

OP. Your OH sounds scarily like my ex husband. His attitude to money was one of the reasons why we split.

FuriousCheekyFucker · 07/07/2022 13:35

Take the money, buy Gold Bullion and hide it somewhere only you know.

Leave cryptic instructions for people to follow in your will in case something happens to you before you recover it.

Eeksteek · 07/07/2022 13:29

DaisyStPatience · 07/07/2022 07:23

He wouldn't be entitled to your inheritance if you divorced, so don't let that sway any decisions you make.

I don’t think this is always the case. Get legal advice before you bank on it, at least.

There’s precedent when there’s millions involved and everyone can make a good living without it. If not, it’s less clear. I would be very careful. If you are married, it’s already too late, it’s your asset and is in the pot even if you don’t have it yet. If you aren’t, it’s irrelevant anyway. But FGS don’t bank on it being ringfenced. Take every precaution.

If you feel you need to hide money, there’s a problem. The fact that a person you are in a relationship with can’t accept ‘your money, your choice’ without making you feel uncomfortable or in some way pressurising you about it shows that. (beyond acceptable living standards. In which case same problem, opposite way). It’s common though, especially with men feeling they should have more control over money (even that isn’t theirs) with potentially other pressures they can use if they don’t have unequal financial control. I’m not singling you out - happens all the time and you already know there are issues.

Who owns the house? I wouldn’t be spending money on it in this situation if it wasn’t all mine. I wouldn’t tell him at all. You’ll never be able to spend it, so either split now or wait until you do and spend it however your comfortable with.

Dashel · 07/07/2022 13:29

I couldn’t stay in a relationship like you described. I would keep completely quiet about the cash for now and put it somewhere safe where he can’t see it or see if the executors can be slow in paying you.

I would get legal advice about separating and only declare the cash if you have too. It sounds like your relationship is over don’t waste any more time on it. He isn’t going to change or grow up.

Buythebag40 · 07/07/2022 13:26

I wouldn't tell him, no.

justasking111 · 07/07/2022 13:09

My friends husband inherited a seven figure sum. When they divorced the judge wouldn't include it. You fix the roof and put the rest away

Luredbyapomegranate · 07/07/2022 13:05

absolutely lie about it, given his track record.

it’s not like you’re keeping it from him for underhand reasons, he’s just a child w money

EagleThrustSeven · 07/07/2022 13:02

If the money is left to you specifically - and he has not asked about it - then technically you are not lying.

But, in general, its best to have a policy of always telling the truth, or else you will always find an excuse to lie (or to have secrets).

How will you explain using any of it, if kept a secret?

How would you feel, if he kept something like this from you?

Indeed, you say when he inherited money he didnt keep it a secret and you had input on spending some of it for joint purposes. Does he not deserve the same from you?

Why not save or spend some of it for you, but include him on how to use another portion of it?

You say you are "working on your relationship" - is that really the case, if there are secrets about money etc?

I see the mumsnet standard of being immediately advised to leave your partner - regardless of topic or circumstances - holds true on this thread lol.

Swipe left for the next trending thread