Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Understand the Resentment Some Feel Towards Refugees ?

115 replies

wantaholiday · 06/07/2022 21:33

I've name changed for this because I'm a regular poster and don't really want it known I've taken in a Ukrainian family.

We are a family with teenager school children and a Ukrainian mum and her six year old child are living in our house with us as in our spare bedroom as part of our family. We are very, very lucky because the family are lovely and a joy to have. It was a big gamble taking them as we didn't know them and just because you're escaping a war doesn't make you a nice, easy to live with person. Likewise for them, offering space doesn't mean we'll be easy.

They have been given a lot of help (this is great) such as, our oversubscribed and full village primary school made extra space to take child in. People in the village have been very welcoming, they've received loads of donated toys and clothes (that they needed). They've also gone out of their way to invite mum and kid to things and offer lifts (also needed) to the mum. Even the dentist, you can't get an NHS dentist for 50 miles in any direction from where I live, this was even on the news a while ago, my dentist has made an exception for them and taken them on as NHS patients.

All this is great, and I'm very happy about all of it and shows what a great place the world is. My issue is how we treat our own poor. So many people in the UK live in real long term grinding poverty with no end or hope in sight, they and their kids get none of this special treatment and are even blamed for their own circumstances. I can understand if they might feel resentful towards my guests. For what it's worth I think they're completely blaming the wrong people, it's not the fault of refugees that poor people in the UK live in such dire conditions, it's the fault of government. Absolutely no sympathy understanding or excuses given to people living comfortably lives who also resent refugees though.

I've turned off voting because I don't want any vote to be read as if we are right to be resentful of refugees .

OP posts:
Runnerbeansflower · 06/07/2022 22:34

Florenz · 06/07/2022 22:28

Ukraine has been a peaceful country until recently and everyone can see an understand what is happening and there is a clear "bad guy" in the situation which is Russia,

For the Middle-East there have been wars there for as long as anyone can remember, and there is no prospect of that changing, and no clear good guys and bad guys, it's just chaos. I can understand people being less than keen to house refugees from that situation.

So you can be in must as much danger when you haven't done anything to contribute to it, but are less deserving of safety?

Runnerbeansflower · 06/07/2022 22:31

bellac11 · 06/07/2022 21:48

Its an interesting question

Im always struck by conversations whereby people argue against supporting refugees by saying 'charity begins at home' / 'we need to support our own'

They are NEVER the people who support the poor and vulnerable in the UK, they are the same people that spout off about dole scroungers, single parents, feckless poor, not working hard enough blah blah blah

Yes. Sadly.

BiFoldChampion · 06/07/2022 22:30

A friend of mine who lives in catchment for their school didn’t get a place. She was number 1 on the waiting list and is now number 7 as there are 6 Ukrainians waiting.

DaddyPiglet · 06/07/2022 22:29

I think there are good reasons why people are more willing to help Ukrainians. The vast majority are women and children. I think far fewer people would take in a single male.

But in many war torn/unstable countries, we directly contributed to it. And there were literally children on some of those migrant boats, and (I hope a very small minority) people were glad they drowned... nobody is brave enough to say it in public, but Twitter comments on news articles can be a cesspit. Even if it was a boat full of children, the hardline racists are type to still turn them all back.

Nobody is obliged to take anyone, it's not about 'not taking people in' to your actual house. That would be fair enough.

Florenz · 06/07/2022 22:28

Ukraine has been a peaceful country until recently and everyone can see an understand what is happening and there is a clear "bad guy" in the situation which is Russia,

For the Middle-East there have been wars there for as long as anyone can remember, and there is no prospect of that changing, and no clear good guys and bad guys, it's just chaos. I can understand people being less than keen to house refugees from that situation.

TyneTortoise · 06/07/2022 22:27

jetadore · 06/07/2022 22:08

YABU to ‘understand’ the ‘resentment’ towards refugees for this. The anger should be directed at the system that denies these services to everyone who needs it, and those who prop it up. Never understand why so many people continuously fall for their lies.

Understanding resentment doesn’t mean you agree with it. Just that you see why people think the way they do.
And while it’s easy to say ‘direct the anger towards the government’ from a warm, comfortable home. Think of the people in dire straits, seeing lol others getting more help than them. Of course they’re Going to feel resentful.

this doesn’t refer to the well heeled btw

NellesVilla · 06/07/2022 22:26

I’m pro helping Ukrainian refugees and have made friends with a lovely Ukrainian couple (also refugees) but I’m sorry, that pisses me off about the fact they can get an NHS dentist just like that.

I can’t get one and many other tax-payers I know also can’t get one, and are just having to go without as they can’t really afford treatment.

Surely people who’ve been here for years- should be priority?

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 06/07/2022 22:21

I agree it's an interesting question.

On a purely pragmatic level, the causes of poverty (other than the cost of living crisis) are often complex - it can be a cycle that's really hard to break and tie into culture, expectations, education and other issues such as abuse and it's sometimes a really difficult thing to address in the long term.

In reality it's probably pretty easy to help a lot of the refugees and make economic sense - a lot of refugees are educated and were working in skilled professions and if the government invest a relatively small initial amount of money to help them transition to life in the uk, they will likely end up being net contributers. And comparitevly there arent that many of them. Breaking the cycle of poverty already in the uk is a lot more complex and expensive in comparison and I'm not sure many people have the answers

Also morally I'm never really sure about the 'charity begins at home' argument. Why? It's completely random where a child is born and to me, we should help those first who need it most.

HotPenguin · 06/07/2022 22:20

I think there are good reasons why people are more willing to help Ukrainians. The vast majority are women and children. I think far fewer people would take in a single male.

Many homeless people in our own country have complex problems like addiction or mental health issues which makes it harder to help them. Ukrainians have a right to work here, so with a bit of help they should be able to make successful lives and contribute to our economy. Unfortunately most refugees are not allowed to work so they are seen as "spongers".

Where I live there are lots of volunteer efforts to help poor British families, like food banks and play schemes.

I think it's poor form to criticise people for helping Ukrainians but not other refugees - it's a bit like criticising someone who donates to cancer research because they don't support the British heart Foundation. I wonder if those criticising ever did anything themselves to help Syrians or poor British people?

Jalisco · 06/07/2022 22:17

The vast majority of refugees are not treated in the same way that some Ukrainian refugees are. For starters, most of them have to fight - and fight hard - to be classed as refugees rather than asylum seekers. And very, very few are welcomed by the majority of people despite getting none of this preferential treatment. Whilst I can't begrudge Ukrainians the opportunities being offered to them, it's also a tad patronising and condescending that, as a society, we have decided to be nice to the poor refugees (provided they are the sort we like). I know that individually lots and lots of people have given generously in so many ways, but I do wonder how much of that is about "us" and not "them". Would / are people so generous to other refugees? We already know the answer to that.

Northernsouloldies · 06/07/2022 22:14

A racists go to is always whataboutery, and wait for the, what about our homeless etc. When you know full well they look down their nose at people with issues and wouldn't give the steam off their piss.

HeleenaHandcart · 06/07/2022 22:13

I think for every story like this about Ukrainian refugees there is another story about ones treated awfully. It’s incredibly patchy between councils and areas.
In my area to a council has been obstructive at points, over things like school places or processing payments (schools and hosts are yet to receive money). There are no particular schemes, and they are actually blocked from some as they aren’t actually refugees and have no rights as such (eg childcare support access here, English classes…). It’s a liberal area and generally welcoming to refugees and diverse, but there’s been a pretty big back lash sliver perceived special treatment. And stories about racist Ukrainians. Organised protest letters over things to do with special treatment (free schools meals, uniform), but actually things that already exist for all refugees. A lot of ‘oh they love them because they are blond and blue eyed’ that has gone quite far into hate talk about Ukrainians (they deserve it… Putin should finish the job…). Dh is Ukrainian and I am half, and we’ve had friends treat us like we’ve morphed into horrible racist chancers in a few cases, I’ve had a few direct hurtful messages. Others have simply shared a lot of false narratives that are hurtful, such as how they are part of Russia/ they are really the aggressors/ deserve it/ racists deserve no sympathy and so on.
Dh and I have actually worked with refugee family for many years, but it’s been totally forgotten.
I think if you are in a white majority area there are some amazing grass roots activities and a lot of support, but go into an inner city and you wouldn’t recognise how it is different.

Rummikub · 06/07/2022 22:11

The best way to tackle it is to look at the whole community, rather than just the refugees within it. Projects and infrastructure that support refugees and the host community go down much better locally. Also, dialogue projects can help to build relationships between refugees and others in the community, which breaks down fear/prejudice etc.

Agree with this too.

it seems a lot of the community type places have been defunded. Libraries and Sure start children’s centres etc. These places were great for communities coming together. I know some churches/temples/ mosques open their doors to the community but more of these opportunities would be great.

jetadore · 06/07/2022 22:08

YABU to ‘understand’ the ‘resentment’ towards refugees for this. The anger should be directed at the system that denies these services to everyone who needs it, and those who prop it up. Never understand why so many people continuously fall for their lies.

Glitteratitar · 06/07/2022 22:04

I think what you’re not appreciating is that they are getting this support because they are Ukrainian. Refugees from other countries do not get this much level of support from the government and the community. There is a massive difference in the response towards Ukraine when compared to other refugees.

The government can help. It’s just very selective about who to help. That’s what the bigger problem is.

Rummikub · 06/07/2022 22:04

I find it so ironic that a country who attempted global colonisation now takes issue with other nationalities arriving on its shores. It is just a tad hypocritical.

Agree with that.

ldontWanna · 06/07/2022 22:02

A lot of this seems to be community based, which is great and lovely but relies on individuals not the government to help. The government would let them all to rot just like everyone else.

That being said, why isn't the community railing around it's poor as well? Why isn't anyone taking in homeless people or women with children in a refuge? Kitting them out ,donating stuff etc. Is it because we're just as apathetic most of the time to the plights of our own as the government is? That they're just background,part of the furniture,especially the way we keep voting?I'm talking as a society not blaming anyone in particular.

Tbf, refugees are an easy target. Everyone can punch down on them. Instead of the squeezed middle against working class, working class against people on benefits and so on, everyone can "resent" the refugees.

In the meantime some people build 100k treehouses for their kids. Confused

CurbsideProphet · 06/07/2022 22:00

I'm amazed the DWP have processed the UC claims so quickly. They're always insistent that 6 weeks is an acceptable amount of time for a person in need to wait.

StillWeRise · 06/07/2022 22:00

yes the support given to the Ukrainian refugees is in very stark contrast to what is offered to other refugees (albeit that it has been badly organized by government, people on the ground have been very generous) - I think if I was a young man from Syria or Afghanistan I might feel ...jealous? unfairly treated?

Likewise British people living in poverty- many of whom are working- seem to be overlooked at best and blamed at worst. It would be understandable if they also felt jealous or unfairly treated. But it's not other British people to blame, it's the government.

wantaholiday · 06/07/2022 21:58

My parents or their friends would never have offered to take in a family who, say have an awful mould problem in their council house or have fled DV and are in a really rough temporary accommodation house but arguably these people are far more vulnerable and as at risk as their current guests. It does make you wonder.

Thing is, I don't think its appropriate to have strangers taking people in in those circumstances. The reason I think this is because people shouldn't be facing those problems in the first place. Decent affordable accommodation should be an absolute right in the first place. With a large and sudden influx of refugees, I actually think local families taking them in as the best option. They can provide a lot of informal support, and introduction to the community that they just wouldn't get in an asylum hotel.

OP posts:
bellac11 · 06/07/2022 21:58

Rummikub · 06/07/2022 21:55

Does this level of support happen with all asylum seekers or just the Ukrainian refugees?

i can see why it might seem unfair but it’s government that are making these decisions.

i have worked advising asylum seekers and they are stuck in limbo. Wanting to work, set up businesses or go to uni but they can’t- waiting many years for their status to be changed. Some highly qualified people not able to work (nurses, doctors, accountants, engineers, lots trades).

No this hasnt happened for other refugee arrivals. According to the mainstream media, its better that they drown in the channel and some people agree with that.

WanderlyWagonInWales · 06/07/2022 21:58

I am so sick of the whataboutery and thinly veiled xenophobia that threads like this bring up.
My Da always brought us up to believe that you only ever look down on someone when you’re giving them a helping hand up. We are all only a few pay checks away from being in severe financial difficulties (unless very fortunate)

The incompetence of the current government in dealing with fuel poverty, healthcare and the cuts to social care and benefits should not exclude us from helping those less fortunate.

Refugees are fleeing circumstances we dare not even think of… War, famine, rape, torture…

it shouldn’t be a them v us scenario. It SHOULD just be a case of “OK here are all the people who need help. Let’s help them.”

I find it so ironic that a country who attempted global colonisation now takes issue with other nationalities arriving on its shores. It is just a tad hypocritical.

Mahanii · 06/07/2022 21:57

I grew up on a poverty stricken council estate and this sums up most people's attitudes towards refugees and migrants in general. And of course, when their council houses are damp and mouldy, their nans have to wait 2 years for a hip replacement, their kids go to the rough local school and their bikes get nicked at the park, they are going to resent the people who they see receiving more help than them. (Obviously, I absolutely blame the government.)

I have been on the waiting list for an NHS dentist for 2 years!!

OneEyedPenguin · 06/07/2022 21:57

Does this level of support happen with all asylum seekers or just the Ukrainian refugees?

A lot is specific to Ukrainians.

Rummikub · 06/07/2022 21:55

Does this level of support happen with all asylum seekers or just the Ukrainian refugees?

i can see why it might seem unfair but it’s government that are making these decisions.

i have worked advising asylum seekers and they are stuck in limbo. Wanting to work, set up businesses or go to uni but they can’t- waiting many years for their status to be changed. Some highly qualified people not able to work (nurses, doctors, accountants, engineers, lots trades).

Swipe left for the next trending thread