Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Understand the Resentment Some Feel Towards Refugees ?

115 replies

wantaholiday · 06/07/2022 21:33

I've name changed for this because I'm a regular poster and don't really want it known I've taken in a Ukrainian family.

We are a family with teenager school children and a Ukrainian mum and her six year old child are living in our house with us as in our spare bedroom as part of our family. We are very, very lucky because the family are lovely and a joy to have. It was a big gamble taking them as we didn't know them and just because you're escaping a war doesn't make you a nice, easy to live with person. Likewise for them, offering space doesn't mean we'll be easy.

They have been given a lot of help (this is great) such as, our oversubscribed and full village primary school made extra space to take child in. People in the village have been very welcoming, they've received loads of donated toys and clothes (that they needed). They've also gone out of their way to invite mum and kid to things and offer lifts (also needed) to the mum. Even the dentist, you can't get an NHS dentist for 50 miles in any direction from where I live, this was even on the news a while ago, my dentist has made an exception for them and taken them on as NHS patients.

All this is great, and I'm very happy about all of it and shows what a great place the world is. My issue is how we treat our own poor. So many people in the UK live in real long term grinding poverty with no end or hope in sight, they and their kids get none of this special treatment and are even blamed for their own circumstances. I can understand if they might feel resentful towards my guests. For what it's worth I think they're completely blaming the wrong people, it's not the fault of refugees that poor people in the UK live in such dire conditions, it's the fault of government. Absolutely no sympathy understanding or excuses given to people living comfortably lives who also resent refugees though.

I've turned off voting because I don't want any vote to be read as if we are right to be resentful of refugees .

OP posts:
sst1234 · 07/07/2022 00:38

Let’s be honest. Refugee resettlement schemes in Europe are a response to the replacement rate crisis. The continent needs more labour and mostly cheap, unskilled labour. It’s not the milk of human kindness. So it’s nothing to do with distribution of resources.

SomePosters · 06/07/2022 23:42

You’ve got to be astoundingly self centred to be jealous of someone who has fled thei country due to war and doesn’t know what family or home will be there to go back too.

surely we can see it’s not the treatment of the refugees that is wrong here but the lack of support and services for those who were born without land or money

where’s the ire for the billionaires and their extreme hoarding problem?

TerffLonDon · 06/07/2022 23:32

SomePosters · 06/07/2022 23:23

Exactly my first thought!

donyou think it’s deliberate that the predatory capitalist looks like Rupert Murdock?

Yes, it’s supposed to be the likes of the right wing Murdoch press making you look not at the real culprits (the government and the capitalist cronies) but look towards those who have even less than you and blame them instead

Meraas · 06/07/2022 23:31

Florenz · 06/07/2022 22:28

Ukraine has been a peaceful country until recently and everyone can see an understand what is happening and there is a clear "bad guy" in the situation which is Russia,

For the Middle-East there have been wars there for as long as anyone can remember, and there is no prospect of that changing, and no clear good guys and bad guys, it's just chaos. I can understand people being less than keen to house refugees from that situation.

All those words just to say Ukrainians aren’t brown and Muslim.

listsandbudgets · 06/07/2022 23:29

Which is how long the family staying with us waited. Theyd actually managed to get a job and get paid before their UC got sorted out.

I understand what you are saying OP. People will always resent it if someone else suddenly turns up and gets something they don't get when they're desperate then. It is inevitable

TerffLonDon · 06/07/2022 23:28

Catslovepies · 06/07/2022 21:44

And no @TerffLonDon I fully blame our absolute mess of an incompetent and selfish government.

Yes, that’s the point of the picture……..

SomePosters · 06/07/2022 23:26

lollipoprainbow · 06/07/2022 21:52

It's a shame all these do gooders couldn't do more for people here in need, very misguided.

If you want something done your way then you do it!

people get to invest their energy in what they think is worthwhile.

SomePosters · 06/07/2022 23:23

TerffLonDon · 06/07/2022 21:36

Summed up by this…

Exactly my first thought!

donyou think it’s deliberate that the predatory capitalist looks like Rupert Murdock?

Glitteratitar · 06/07/2022 23:20

Florenz · 06/07/2022 23:15

We can't win with the Middle East, we either leave tyrants like Saddam Hussein in power, killing and torturing his own people and those of other countries he invades, or we intervene and "impose" democracy on people who don't want it and reject it, and we are to blame for that as well. Look at all the hatred directed at Israel, by any measure the most democratic and free country in the entire region.

Ok…so why do you think the UK and the US invaded Iraq in 2003? Saddam hadn’t invaded another country in quite some time, and his regime was no different to that of other dictators.

And you honestly believe Israel is a free country? Does that apply to the Palestinians too?

bellac11 · 06/07/2022 23:18

Rummikub · 06/07/2022 23:12

It’s impossible to agree 100pc with a political manifesto. You have to decide what’s most important to you but that could result in things you dont want.

Absolutely, and the people in this country have made a choice and this is what the outcome is. No school places, no dentist, long waits at hospital, no where for granny to go when she needs a care package, libraries shut, public amenities privatised and unaffordable for the poor, public transport outside of London prohibitively expensive, housing system inaccessible to many, the list is endless.

Octomore · 06/07/2022 23:17

Look at all the hatred directed at Israel, by any measure the most democratic and free country in the entire region.

I don't think the Palestinian people get much benefit from that democracy and freedom....

Octomore · 06/07/2022 23:16

Glitteratitar · 06/07/2022 22:04

I think what you’re not appreciating is that they are getting this support because they are Ukrainian. Refugees from other countries do not get this much level of support from the government and the community. There is a massive difference in the response towards Ukraine when compared to other refugees.

The government can help. It’s just very selective about who to help. That’s what the bigger problem is.

Absolutely this.

Classism, racism, populism and prejudice all have an impact when the government decides who it will help and who it won't.

Florenz · 06/07/2022 23:15

Glitteratitar · 06/07/2022 23:00

Are you actually serious? Clearly you know nothing about the Middle East, but it is the actions of the US and the UK over the past 40 or so years that has directly caused the unrest in the Middle East.

I know you think anyone who has heritage from elsewhere should be deported when they commit a crime, but please try and open your mind a bit rather than blindly following the Daily Mail.

And your comments re democracy…democracy in the western world was developed over hundreds of years. Democracy in the Middle East was imposed over a couple of years. Imposed on countries after war which resulted in the deaths of thousands and which are still suffering from numerous issues. It doesn’t take a genius to realise that democracy is viewed differently in different circumstances.

We can't win with the Middle East, we either leave tyrants like Saddam Hussein in power, killing and torturing his own people and those of other countries he invades, or we intervene and "impose" democracy on people who don't want it and reject it, and we are to blame for that as well. Look at all the hatred directed at Israel, by any measure the most democratic and free country in the entire region.

Octomore · 06/07/2022 23:14

KissThaRain · 06/07/2022 21:47

They’ve lost their home, their livelihoods, their way of life, everything they’ve grown up with, believing in. To be put in a foreign country where the majority of the people don’t speak their language, have little understanding of their culture all because Putin wants his swan song. They have had more devastation in their lives that most of us will ever see.
should we turn our backs on them and say fuck off we have to sort our own first? What makes our needy more deserving than the poor souls who’ve lost everything because of Putin

The OP's point is that our needy are treated appallingly in comparison, and have access to less help in this country than refugees.

It is possible to believe that refugees deserve any assistance we can give them, while also recognising the fundamental unfairness and inhumanity in how poorer people are treated in this country, and believing that those people deserve more help than they get.

Rummikub · 06/07/2022 23:12

bellac11 · 06/07/2022 22:44

So for people who cant get a dentist or who have friends who cant get a school place for their child - what have they or their friends been doing politically, voting wise to ensure that the right people are voted in who will ensure that the services are in place that their local area needs? What campaigning do they do, what complaints have they made or are they only riled into action if someone from a war torn country comes along and gets a service for something?

The general public have voted to run down, not invest and not future proof our public services and then wonder why they're not fit for purpose.

It’s impossible to agree 100pc with a political manifesto. You have to decide what’s most important to you but that could result in things you dont want.

QueenOfHiraeth · 06/07/2022 23:07

While I agree with you in many ways, I think part of this problem is that many people in the UK perceive the refugees as being in this situation through no fault of their own, whereas they see the poor here as somewhat responsible for their situation. If only they had paid attention at school, if only they'd get a job, if only they managed their money better, if only they had fewer children and so on.
It's the new version of the deserving and undeserving poor

Glitteratitar · 06/07/2022 23:00

Florenz · 06/07/2022 22:44

I don't know whether that's true. I read an article today about more and more people in the Middle-East not believing in democracy. You cannot have a peaceful, prosperous country without democracy. Most of the problems in the Middle-East are caused by the people there preferring to support strongmen leaders and religious zealots.

Countries become peaceful, places to live because the people of that country work hard to make them peaceful, pleasant places to live. It doesn't just happen at random, people have to want it and be prepared to put in the work and make the sacrifices to make it so.

Are you actually serious? Clearly you know nothing about the Middle East, but it is the actions of the US and the UK over the past 40 or so years that has directly caused the unrest in the Middle East.

I know you think anyone who has heritage from elsewhere should be deported when they commit a crime, but please try and open your mind a bit rather than blindly following the Daily Mail.

And your comments re democracy…democracy in the western world was developed over hundreds of years. Democracy in the Middle East was imposed over a couple of years. Imposed on countries after war which resulted in the deaths of thousands and which are still suffering from numerous issues. It doesn’t take a genius to realise that democracy is viewed differently in different circumstances.

bellac11 · 06/07/2022 22:44

So for people who cant get a dentist or who have friends who cant get a school place for their child - what have they or their friends been doing politically, voting wise to ensure that the right people are voted in who will ensure that the services are in place that their local area needs? What campaigning do they do, what complaints have they made or are they only riled into action if someone from a war torn country comes along and gets a service for something?

The general public have voted to run down, not invest and not future proof our public services and then wonder why they're not fit for purpose.

Florenz · 06/07/2022 22:44

Runnerbeansflower · 06/07/2022 22:34

So you can be in must as much danger when you haven't done anything to contribute to it, but are less deserving of safety?

I don't know whether that's true. I read an article today about more and more people in the Middle-East not believing in democracy. You cannot have a peaceful, prosperous country without democracy. Most of the problems in the Middle-East are caused by the people there preferring to support strongmen leaders and religious zealots.

Countries become peaceful, places to live because the people of that country work hard to make them peaceful, pleasant places to live. It doesn't just happen at random, people have to want it and be prepared to put in the work and make the sacrifices to make it so.

FilePhoto · 06/07/2022 22:43

I totally see your point, and can see how resentment occurs.
But I blame the government 100%.

I'm officially classed as living in poverty. Always robbing Peter to pay Paul as it were.

But I have nothing but sympathy for refugees. They might have more disposable income than me/less bills/ more access to help.
But I don't have to worry about if I'll ever be able to go 'home'. I still live in the town I grew up in. I don't have to worry about friends and family who haven't managed to get out. I haven't lost my home, my livelihood, my possessions. I don't have to start again in a country where i don't speak the language.

In short, I'm much better off omin every way other than financial. I wouldn't swap.

DogsAndGin · 06/07/2022 22:42

No I don’t think it is reasonable to begrudge someone in genuine need of charity being given just that.

Runnerbeansflower · 06/07/2022 22:40

lollipoprainbow · 06/07/2022 22:36

A friend of mine who lives in catchment for their school didn’t get a place. She was number 1 on the waiting list and is now number 7 as there are 6 Ukrainians waiting.

I would be livid. This is why people are resentful

Maybe they need it more?

Sorry your friend struggles to understand why they may be in a better position to support their children in a school that isn't their first choice

OneEyedPenguin · 06/07/2022 22:40

And while it’s easy to say ‘direct the anger towards the government’ from a warm, comfortable home. Think of the people in dire straits, seeing lol others getting more help than them. Of course they’re Going to feel resentful

This^.

I work in pensions. We have pension and pension credit claimes backlog, some pensioners have absolutely nothing and are waiting 4+ months just to hear back from us. If they phone to chase we say we'll call back in 5 working days, if we don't call back in that timeframe then we just say the same again and you keep having to hope we contact you. Ukrainian refugee claimes are fast tracked and wait only 48 hours for call backs. Any fail to calls backs get escalated to urgent.

It's not the fault of Ukrainians but you can see how the resentment builds. Perhaps the government has designed it this way to cause resentment?

Daddydog · 06/07/2022 22:40

I noticed something curious - on the local NextDoor app there was an Eastern European woman posting cleaning/ironing services. I felt sorry for her as for months she posted to every request for a cleaner and everyone either ignored her or said they were only looking for neighbours to refer their own cleaners. The only time she was ever really engaged is when people shamed her about her English or that NextDoor was not for soliciting work. Strangely, when an English sounding name replied to a request for a cleaner, they would be asked for their hourly rates and availability etc.

Then recently a woman from Ukraine posted she was looking for work and and suddenly within an hour she had 60+ replies from neighbours welcoming her to the neighbourhood and offering her cleaning jobs.

(For all we know she might have been a lawyer as she didn't even mention she was a cleaner!)

I always wondered how that other lady felt seeing that.

lollipoprainbow · 06/07/2022 22:36

A friend of mine who lives in catchment for their school didn’t get a place. She was number 1 on the waiting list and is now number 7 as there are 6 Ukrainians waiting.

I would be livid. This is why people are resentful

Swipe left for the next trending thread