Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Understand the Resentment Some Feel Towards Refugees ?

115 replies

wantaholiday · 06/07/2022 21:33

I've name changed for this because I'm a regular poster and don't really want it known I've taken in a Ukrainian family.

We are a family with teenager school children and a Ukrainian mum and her six year old child are living in our house with us as in our spare bedroom as part of our family. We are very, very lucky because the family are lovely and a joy to have. It was a big gamble taking them as we didn't know them and just because you're escaping a war doesn't make you a nice, easy to live with person. Likewise for them, offering space doesn't mean we'll be easy.

They have been given a lot of help (this is great) such as, our oversubscribed and full village primary school made extra space to take child in. People in the village have been very welcoming, they've received loads of donated toys and clothes (that they needed). They've also gone out of their way to invite mum and kid to things and offer lifts (also needed) to the mum. Even the dentist, you can't get an NHS dentist for 50 miles in any direction from where I live, this was even on the news a while ago, my dentist has made an exception for them and taken them on as NHS patients.

All this is great, and I'm very happy about all of it and shows what a great place the world is. My issue is how we treat our own poor. So many people in the UK live in real long term grinding poverty with no end or hope in sight, they and their kids get none of this special treatment and are even blamed for their own circumstances. I can understand if they might feel resentful towards my guests. For what it's worth I think they're completely blaming the wrong people, it's not the fault of refugees that poor people in the UK live in such dire conditions, it's the fault of government. Absolutely no sympathy understanding or excuses given to people living comfortably lives who also resent refugees though.

I've turned off voting because I don't want any vote to be read as if we are right to be resentful of refugees .

OP posts:
THisbackwithavengeance · 08/07/2022 08:18

"Normal" i.e non Ukrainian refugees who are granted asylum in this country are given access to benefits, free education, given priority housing, can work etc. for example, I know quite a few refugees who've done masters degrees completely free of charge where their English counterparts had to pay £££.

Failed asylum seekers are not allowed to work or claim benefits. Their asylum claims have been refused. They have no legal basis to be in the UK hence they do not qualify. I think people often get these subsets confused. They do get access to housing and some money from the state but it's a different budget.

The Afghan interpreters will be treated just as well as the Ukrainians in terms of benefits and state help but they haven't had the same media sympathy and public donations so no free Xboxes etc.

Ukrainians have been treated very, very sympathetically though compared to everyone else and I totally understand that if you're already resident in the UK and on the bones of your arse, refused a place at your local school, can't get a dentist etc that must be galling.

I think the basis of the help given to Ukrainians was that they are expected to return to Ukraine once all this over but it will be interesting to see if many do leave or not particularly as they must think money grows on trees in the UK with all the freebies.

BeethovenNinth · 08/07/2022 08:16

I think the poverty in the UK is unacceptable. We have the worst pensions in Western Europe. I’m in Scotland and more children are living in poverty now than a decade before. Elderly left for years waiting for operations for conditions they die with. CAHMS wait times are two years for all but the suicidal.

absolutely right to help refugees but the will isn’t there to help the many living in desperate conditions here. Why?

SaintHelena · 08/07/2022 08:10

Many of our poor are addicts or have other mental health problems - putting money there would help but it needs to be a lot of money. Hence why it's not done, I presume.

SaintHelena · 08/07/2022 08:08

Our Gov is who is voted in - seems not enough people want to give money to the poor rather than to their own so vote that way.
Blame the majority of the British Public.

theworldhas · 08/07/2022 07:50

It’s not just the poor of course. Over the past decade plus of Tory government, many reasonably well off Brits married to a non-EU partner have, in some cases, had to live apart from their spouse/young kids for years on end because they failed to meet some or other small bit of government legislation. The only small minority which the Tory government will consistently treat with any decency or consideration is the super rich. Have a couple million quid lying spare? Welcome! Here’s a golden visa. Oh you were some kind of Russian/Chinese gangster were you, who almost certainly faked your police forms? Shrug.

The irony of course is that Britain’s real response to the Ukrainian refugees crisis has been utter shite. In terms of refugees it’s taken about 15% the number of Germany and only twice as many as Ireland - a country with a population/resources 13x smaller. As usual, Brits really overestimate the generosity of their country.

Maireas · 08/07/2022 07:36

Off topic, but why did you name change just because you took in Ukrainian refugees?

chickadeee · 08/07/2022 07:35

Be angry and resentful towards this absolute shit show of a government. It is them. It is ALL them. They have the money and ability to help our poor but they don't. They push more and more of our most vulnerable into absolute poverty.

Rummikub · 08/07/2022 07:34

IDreamOfTheMoors · 08/07/2022 04:12

“If you can convince the lowest white man he's better than the best colored man, he won't notice you're picking his pocket. Hell, give him somebody to look down on, and he'll empty his pockets for you.”
—Lyndon B. Johnson (American President)

This is the attitude many Americans have towards refugees and immigrants, thanks to you-know-who. You know, the guy who claims to be a billionaire but continues to pick the pockets of his supporters for hundreds of millions of dollars.

Our own government looks for “wedge” issues too to divide the population opinions. It works in their favour I’m sure.

There is a stark difference in how Ukrainian refugees are being treated compared to other asylum seekers. Others cannot claim asylum
unless they are on U.K. soil. Even if they have family here. Where are their safe routes?

SnowyLamb · 08/07/2022 07:24

I find "our" response to Ukrainian refugees really uncomfortable.

We're falling over ourselves to support them in a way we don't support our own disadvantaged people and yes of course they should be supported after the horrors they are escaping, but this government, the whole Brexit, thing basically came about because the public was determined not to help people fleeing wars in other parts of the world.

Yes, I do understand why people who can't get housing or an NHS dentist would think we have enough people here already. I don't understand why Ukrainians are so welcome when others aren't.

I'd like to live in a country where we can and will help everyone, but I don't.

Suzi888 · 08/07/2022 06:54

KissThaRain · 06/07/2022 21:47

They’ve lost their home, their livelihoods, their way of life, everything they’ve grown up with, believing in. To be put in a foreign country where the majority of the people don’t speak their language, have little understanding of their culture all because Putin wants his swan song. They have had more devastation in their lives that most of us will ever see.
should we turn our backs on them and say fuck off we have to sort our own first? What makes our needy more deserving than the poor souls who’ve lost everything because of Putin

What makes our needy less deserving?

Seymour5 · 08/07/2022 06:51

The thread title mentions refugees. Its clear the women and children from Ukraine are refugees from war. The origins of the people (mainly young men) who enter the UK by irregular means, (dinghies for example) from a European country not at war, are unknown. They appear to then be looked after better than some UK citizens, and that has bred resentment.

Runnerbeansflower · 08/07/2022 05:54

Charlieiscool · 08/07/2022 05:45

HotPenguin · 06/07/2022 22:20
I think there are good reasons why people are more willing to help Ukrainians. The vast majority are women and children. I think far fewer people would take in a single male.

this ^^
Seeing young men getting away and just leaving their women, children and elderly in terrible circumstances is never going to make us feel like we do when it’s only the women and children (for the most part) coming from Ukraine while the men stay behind to fight.

Alternatively, you can see it as men making the dangerous journey in order to pave the way for women and children to be able to come by a safer route.

Charlieiscool · 08/07/2022 05:45

HotPenguin · 06/07/2022 22:20
I think there are good reasons why people are more willing to help Ukrainians. The vast majority are women and children. I think far fewer people would take in a single male.

this ^^
Seeing young men getting away and just leaving their women, children and elderly in terrible circumstances is never going to make us feel like we do when it’s only the women and children (for the most part) coming from Ukraine while the men stay behind to fight.

LuaDipa · 08/07/2022 04:38

The solution is to help those people more rather than to help Ukranians less. The money was there all along because the government was able to magic it up when the war started so why haven't people who were already here been helped properly?

This hits the nail on the head. We are still very much a wealthy developed country. No one should be relying on food banks to eat. We need to do more to help our own poor as well as continuing to support refugees.

The money was there in a second for unfit ppe that had to be thrown away, and Mr Dyson’s innovative new ventilators (that never actually appeared). Why isn’t it there for the people who need it the most?

IDreamOfTheMoors · 08/07/2022 04:12

“If you can convince the lowest white man he's better than the best colored man, he won't notice you're picking his pocket. Hell, give him somebody to look down on, and he'll empty his pockets for you.”
—Lyndon B. Johnson (American President)

This is the attitude many Americans have towards refugees and immigrants, thanks to you-know-who. You know, the guy who claims to be a billionaire but continues to pick the pockets of his supporters for hundreds of millions of dollars.

ladydoris · 08/07/2022 02:52

SammyScrounge · 08/07/2022 00:50

Ukranians are perceived as admirable. It's not about blond hair and blue eyes, it's about men saying goodbye to their families and sending them to safety while the men go back to fight their war. They are making a stand, making an incredible effort against Putin. Who would have believed they could make such a dent in Russia's might?
We've heard of the war crimes they suffer, we've seen their devastated cities. All European countries are taking in Ukranians in vast numbers for the same reasons. Rightly or wrongly they have our sympathy. I'd say rightly.

This is the narrative that was sold to us. And we all bought in. Why not? They genuinely need help. Ukraine is suffering and the maps does not show any type of winning on their side. Each day, it's a little bit more of Ukraine disappearing. They too bought into the narrative. Your families will be taken care off. Just go and die already. They will be safe.
Why are no other refugee treated the same? None. All the other refugees have admirable stories, they just are not told. They don't fill the BBC night after night reporting on a first person narrative the atrocities going on a little further away with gripping personal stories that you can relate to and identify with as victims.
Ukrainians were treated as individuals, all the others are treated as a mere number, a class, a group, faceless, usually male. It's all about the dingy, a panoramic view of the sea, the rescuers, the police, the army, a Politian or two, back to the reporter, back to the studio.
Maintaining emotional distance does wonders to perpetuate prejudice. Us vs them is not the reality.
This crisis should sober us all, all of a sudden there was money a will and a way. I believe the outcry was general and everybody stepped up to the plate, and somehow, the government to. Let's face it, it is a disgrace for all the others in need that are simply ignored day in day out in this country. We should do better. Yes it is a disgrace, but beware of replacing a rigged system with another rigged one. I would say let's not be attracted to even a zest of racism and populism, this is a recipe for disaster. Humane and unethical do not mix.

Rummikub · 08/07/2022 01:53

Aren’t Ukrainian and Russian forces quite evenly matched in troop numbers?

Arent the people of Afghanistan worthy? Those that worked for the British?

SammyScrounge · 08/07/2022 00:50

Jalisco · 06/07/2022 22:17

The vast majority of refugees are not treated in the same way that some Ukrainian refugees are. For starters, most of them have to fight - and fight hard - to be classed as refugees rather than asylum seekers. And very, very few are welcomed by the majority of people despite getting none of this preferential treatment. Whilst I can't begrudge Ukrainians the opportunities being offered to them, it's also a tad patronising and condescending that, as a society, we have decided to be nice to the poor refugees (provided they are the sort we like). I know that individually lots and lots of people have given generously in so many ways, but I do wonder how much of that is about "us" and not "them". Would / are people so generous to other refugees? We already know the answer to that.

Ukranians are perceived as admirable. It's not about blond hair and blue eyes, it's about men saying goodbye to their families and sending them to safety while the men go back to fight their war. They are making a stand, making an incredible effort against Putin. Who would have believed they could make such a dent in Russia's might?
We've heard of the war crimes they suffer, we've seen their devastated cities. All European countries are taking in Ukranians in vast numbers for the same reasons. Rightly or wrongly they have our sympathy. I'd say rightly.

fatfrenchprick · 07/07/2022 23:44

Where I live the hotels are brimming with refugees from different countries. It's a very poor town but the middle classes from the surrounding rich areas love to do collections and such. They always post about it on Facebook complete with pictures

We have no infrastructure in place for these people, that is the issue. You can't find an NHS dentist and it's a struggle to get your kids into local schools. Food banks are used regularly by locals and everyone is feeling the strain

Don't even try to apply for social housing because you won't get a house. It's sad what has become of my town of Runcorn, and it's frightening to go out after dark

WanderingFruitWonderer · 07/07/2022 23:12

AnnaMagnani · 06/07/2022 21:52

My gripe is that if we can do this for Ukrainians why can we not do this for other refugees?

Much of the Afghan war was of our own making, many of the Afghan refugees trying to come to Britain are coming because they worked for the British armed forces. And they are given absolutely nothing. Not allowed to work, no visas, no Universal Credit, none of the things given to the Ukrainians. Same for any other refugee from any other country in the world. In fact now we just tell them they should go to Rwanda.

But apparently we could have given them all benefits and jobs and visas all along.

I agree with this. I felt we had a particular moral duty to the Afghan refugees, and we failed them terribly

Toddlerteaplease · 07/07/2022 22:57

antelopevalley · 07/07/2022 01:59

It is the same with lots of issues. When my mum had cancer there were MacMillan nurses, Maggies Centre, and neighbours all ready to offer help and support. But have another life-threatening illness and there is far less support and help out there.
Some causes get more public support and help than others.

This really annoys me. There are other illnesses just as serious and many with absolutely no hope of a cure. But the support oncology patients get just isn't there for other things.

DespicablyYou · 07/07/2022 02:54

It isn’t the same. Local poor people are not in a war zone. Refugees are literally escaping with their lives.

Besides, it’s not ok to resent refugees their right to life because there are vulnerable people locally.

It should not be one or the other, it should be both.

The blame culture is carefully constructed by the powerful to turn the little people against each other and distract them from the appalling imbalance of power and distribution of wealth in the UK. Don’t fall for it.

No person in the UK is poor because of a refugee. They are poor because there is a corrupt and morally bankrupt government.

Nat6999 · 07/07/2022 02:43

It's like the thing that if you are drowning & there are two others drowning with you, save yourself before saving anyone else. There wouldn't be an outcry if this country looked after it's own properly, made sure that everyone had suitable housing, enough money to feed & clothe themselves, be warm & dry. When there are people being forced to live in B & B accommodation or a family in a one bed flat with not enough money to manage & people are having to choose between heating & eating, not being able to get a doctors appointment, see a dentist or find school places for children you can expect people to not be happy.

antelopevalley · 07/07/2022 01:59

It is the same with lots of issues. When my mum had cancer there were MacMillan nurses, Maggies Centre, and neighbours all ready to offer help and support. But have another life-threatening illness and there is far less support and help out there.
Some causes get more public support and help than others.

Toddlerteaplease · 07/07/2022 01:31

Are refugees from other countries being treated the same? I very much doubt it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread