Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Understand the Resentment Some Feel Towards Refugees ?

115 replies

wantaholiday · 06/07/2022 21:33

I've name changed for this because I'm a regular poster and don't really want it known I've taken in a Ukrainian family.

We are a family with teenager school children and a Ukrainian mum and her six year old child are living in our house with us as in our spare bedroom as part of our family. We are very, very lucky because the family are lovely and a joy to have. It was a big gamble taking them as we didn't know them and just because you're escaping a war doesn't make you a nice, easy to live with person. Likewise for them, offering space doesn't mean we'll be easy.

They have been given a lot of help (this is great) such as, our oversubscribed and full village primary school made extra space to take child in. People in the village have been very welcoming, they've received loads of donated toys and clothes (that they needed). They've also gone out of their way to invite mum and kid to things and offer lifts (also needed) to the mum. Even the dentist, you can't get an NHS dentist for 50 miles in any direction from where I live, this was even on the news a while ago, my dentist has made an exception for them and taken them on as NHS patients.

All this is great, and I'm very happy about all of it and shows what a great place the world is. My issue is how we treat our own poor. So many people in the UK live in real long term grinding poverty with no end or hope in sight, they and their kids get none of this special treatment and are even blamed for their own circumstances. I can understand if they might feel resentful towards my guests. For what it's worth I think they're completely blaming the wrong people, it's not the fault of refugees that poor people in the UK live in such dire conditions, it's the fault of government. Absolutely no sympathy understanding or excuses given to people living comfortably lives who also resent refugees though.

I've turned off voting because I don't want any vote to be read as if we are right to be resentful of refugees .

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bumblingbovine49 · 08/07/2022 13:31

gnilliwdog · 08/07/2022 12:08

@bumblingbovine49 that is very perceptive. I am bemused why governments don't prioritise their own citizens, I must say though. I would have thought that's the point of them, to have a primary duty to their own people.

Absolutely. It is in my view the government's job is to do this. To actually mitigate the worst of human tendancies. Unfortunately what happens is that they play down to them instead, well worst governments do anyway

T1mumtobe · 08/07/2022 13:18

SomePosters · 06/07/2022 23:42

You’ve got to be astoundingly self centred to be jealous of someone who has fled thei country due to war and doesn’t know what family or home will be there to go back too.

surely we can see it’s not the treatment of the refugees that is wrong here but the lack of support and services for those who were born without land or money

where’s the ire for the billionaires and their extreme hoarding problem?

Agreed!

Daftasabroom · 08/07/2022 13:04

It's unfair to blame asylum seekers and refugees for our governments repeated inability to tackle social inequality, the housing crisis or poverty.

Hardbackwriter · 08/07/2022 13:02

tttigress · 08/07/2022 12:54

I understand op. It's amazing how so many well off (both in terms of money and mental contribution) people were chomping at the bit to "adopt" a Ukrainian.

Yet, these people would never consider doing the same for a native Brit, whose life they could really change by supporting them at school etc.

I think an important part of this is also that it was widely expected that the Ukrainian refugees would be here temporarily. That's not as clearly the case if you take on a middle Eastern refugee, and it's certainly not if you take on a struggling British family. It's one thing to open your home for a temporary crisis (though I'm not sure people really even thought that through enough), doing it for people whose need is due to entrenched, long-term patterns is a commitment very few could make.

CupidStunt22 · 08/07/2022 12:58

poor people in the UK live in such dire conditions

Do most poor people live in dire conditions? Poverty is relative. Most poor people in the Uk would be seen as doing pretty well by poor people in many other countries.

I don't disagree with your premise, but your definitions are wooly

tttigress · 08/07/2022 12:54

I understand op. It's amazing how so many well off (both in terms of money and mental contribution) people were chomping at the bit to "adopt" a Ukrainian.

Yet, these people would never consider doing the same for a native Brit, whose life they could really change by supporting them at school etc.

theworldhas · 08/07/2022 12:35

Literally the only thing of note the Tories have achieved in 12 years of government is Brexit. Which is arguably the greatest act of self harm a modern Western nation has ever inflicted upon itself. Meanwhile wages stagnate, public services rot, people can no longer afford homes. Who keeps voting for these clowns?

gnilliwdog · 08/07/2022 12:08

@bumblingbovine49 that is very perceptive. I am bemused why governments don't prioritise their own citizens, I must say though. I would have thought that's the point of them, to have a primary duty to their own people.

Deguster · 08/07/2022 12:06

It’s not that surprising - mainly females and families arriving through legitimate means for (Putin notwithstanding) a temporary respite.

I volunteer in a food bank and at a hospice. My husband is originally from a country that is commonly a basis for asylum claims. He translates and volunteers in our nearest city. He says that sadly he has seen many cases that are not genuine. Not all, by any stretch, but enough to make him feel a bit jaundiced.

balalake · 08/07/2022 12:01

I think the resentment comes from people who have voted and consistently supported policies that have led to the very issues that matter to them most. So supported less social housing being built, sale of council houses, happy to have the cheapest food, for example.

DaddyPiglet · 08/07/2022 11:40

@neverbeenskiing I agree too, I wanted to like it but I realised you can't on here. So true. I don't really understand much of what's going on in the Middle East either, that's not an excuse or even a coherent reason for people to be so hostile.

Charlieiscool · 08/07/2022 11:36

Up until the Rwanda disgrace, people arriving as asylum seekers did get housed and given some funds, emergency healthcare and legal aid. Not much admittedly. It is the failed asylum seekers that are destitute because government support is withdrawn if they don’t win their case. They are then totally reliant on charity, or their friends, sometimes for many years until (in most cases) eventually they make a successful fresh claim and are given refugee status and can work and are entitled to housing etc.
I have housed / fed / clothed etc many of these young men and in a few cases there were problems but generally it went well. I wasn’t paid anything.
People from Ukraine, women and children, are definitely more vulnerable and we see them fleeing their bombed homes on the news. Of course people want to help them.
They are not in the same situation as failed asylum seekers but if you choose to call everyone’s response racist then fine, keep your blinkers on.

LadyKenya · 08/07/2022 11:12

neverbeenskiing · 08/07/2022 09:31

For the Middle-East there have been wars there for as long as anyone can remember, and there is no prospect of that changing, and no clear good guys and bad guys, it's just chaos. I can understand people being less than keen to house refugees from that situation.

However you try to dress it up, no one will ever convince me that the outpouring of love and empathy for Ukrainian refugees vs the way refugees from Syria or Afghanistan are treated in the UK is anything other than racism and islamaphobia. The fact that the political situation in the Middle East is more complex and people can't be bothered to attempt to understand it is no excuse. Our Government is asking the people to take Ukranian refugees into their homes and in the next breath defending their decision to forcibly deport 'other' refugees to Rwanda, they aren't even trying to hide their bigotry anymore.

This.

bumblingbovine49 · 08/07/2022 09:39

The reason we don't help the poor who live here is because poverty is generally believed by a lot of people ( underneath the veneer of civilised sentiment) to be mostly the fault of the poor themselves. They just have to work harder. After all they were born in a free democratic country with equality of opportunity, they just have been too lazy to take advantage of it 🙄

The difficulty with this is that in a tiny minority of cases there may be some limited truth in that view which means there is alway some example to draw on ' my neighbour hasn't worked a day in her ife and fraudulently claims benefits ' type references. This one anecdote is often enough to convince that this is true of the majority of the poor instead of the vast minority. Humans vastly prefer stories to numbers or data and are instinctively more convinced by them

There is no reasonable argument or vivid ' anecdote' to illustrate that a person deserves to be driven from their home by war. This is enough for most people to draw a distinction. The ' deserving poor' is a very old concept

The question about the difference in how we treat types of refugees is about distance and is we feel we can truly picture ourselves in the same position and that is always easier to do if the person is more like us. So yes racism plays a big part , if your definition of racism is having less empathy for someone and instinctively treating them less well because we see them as ' other' and not ' like us'. - which is pretty much what racism is

Instinct and our love of stories have helped us survive as a species and make us human. Like any traits however they have a dark side

Hardbackwriter · 08/07/2022 09:38

I do think racism and xenophobia plays a big part in why Ukrainians have been viewed differently by the public compared to, say, Syrians, but I do think the fact that they're largely women and children is a bigger factor. They're what people 'expect' the vulnerable to look like, and who they're most willing to help - I remember that when charities were collecting donations for the Calais camps they kept having to ask people to stop giving baby clothes, women's clothes and children's toys because the camp was mostly young men, who people just aren't willing to help in the same way. People are also a lot less frightened of having strange women in their homes than strange men, which is understandable even if awful for men needing help.

neverbeenskiing · 08/07/2022 09:31

For the Middle-East there have been wars there for as long as anyone can remember, and there is no prospect of that changing, and no clear good guys and bad guys, it's just chaos. I can understand people being less than keen to house refugees from that situation.

However you try to dress it up, no one will ever convince me that the outpouring of love and empathy for Ukrainian refugees vs the way refugees from Syria or Afghanistan are treated in the UK is anything other than racism and islamaphobia. The fact that the political situation in the Middle East is more complex and people can't be bothered to attempt to understand it is no excuse. Our Government is asking the people to take Ukranian refugees into their homes and in the next breath defending their decision to forcibly deport 'other' refugees to Rwanda, they aren't even trying to hide their bigotry anymore.

LadyKenya · 08/07/2022 09:21

Florenz · 06/07/2022 22:28

Ukraine has been a peaceful country until recently and everyone can see an understand what is happening and there is a clear "bad guy" in the situation which is Russia,

For the Middle-East there have been wars there for as long as anyone can remember, and there is no prospect of that changing, and no clear good guys and bad guys, it's just chaos. I can understand people being less than keen to house refugees from that situation.

Ah yes, the good old deserving, and undeserving refugee.Hmm

K8Shrop · 08/07/2022 09:15

Also I agree with another poster, the only people I know who are very vocal with their "charity starts at home!!" mindset wouldn't give a penny to anyone. Usually bitter about the hand they've been dealt, and resentful of the benefit system. Everyone has it better than them so why should they help type of mindset!

K8Shrop · 08/07/2022 09:13

I am so conflicted about this topic.

The outpour of support for Ukrainian refugees on my social media, news etc was constant, I have never seen anything like it. Which is exactly why I feel conflicted, why Ukrainians? why not Syrians? I just find it so glaringly obvious and it doesn't sit well at all with me.

People don't have to help everyone. It's not possible I know. But these people who have extra room, and space available to offer - why now?

But as you say, they wouldn't offer it to a family from here with a mould problem, or a domestic violence case. It's just odd to me that the situation in Ukraine has been handpicked as being the chosen one.

hangrylady · 08/07/2022 09:07

AnnaMagnani · 06/07/2022 21:52

My gripe is that if we can do this for Ukrainians why can we not do this for other refugees?

Much of the Afghan war was of our own making, many of the Afghan refugees trying to come to Britain are coming because they worked for the British armed forces. And they are given absolutely nothing. Not allowed to work, no visas, no Universal Credit, none of the things given to the Ukrainians. Same for any other refugee from any other country in the world. In fact now we just tell them they should go to Rwanda.

But apparently we could have given them all benefits and jobs and visas all along.

I think we know why don't we.

plugee · 08/07/2022 09:04

There seems to be something in the psyche of many British people that makes them vote not to benefit themselves (and everyone else) but to make sure other people have less. If we all stopped looking down on people who have it tougher than we do, accept that we should move away from our capitalist economic model and towards something more social democratic then we would all be better off and the divides wouldn't be so stark.

This! There's also a weird thing of not liking policies that you think one day may harm what you aspire to have. They don't realise that it then makes it harder for them to get.

Rummikub · 08/07/2022 09:02

Once an asylim
seeker is granted refugee status then they are treated as a U.K. citizen as they should be. U.K. citizens can access funding for postgrad courses too.

XelaM · 08/07/2022 09:00

TerffLonDon · 06/07/2022 21:36

Summed up by this…

Brilliant 👍

pointythings · 08/07/2022 08:40

I understand your point completely, but I'm afraid British voters shouldn't complain when the consequences of their votes come back to bite them. There seems to be something in the psyche of many British people that makes them vote not to benefit themselves (and everyone else) but to make sure other people have less. If we all stopped looking down on people who have it tougher than we do, accept that we should move away from our capitalist economic model and towards something more social democratic then we would all be better off and the divides wouldn't be so stark.

LivingLifeOnTheVeg · 08/07/2022 08:34

All I understand is that people have this resentment because they’re ignorant, unaware and/or racist.

This thread is just an excuse for some covert racism. I recognise some names here already.

Swipe left for the next trending thread