Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NOT posting attention seeking facebooks posts means I don't care

65 replies

beenaroundtheblox · 06/07/2022 20:26

Am I being unreasonable here. Very elderly and very unwell grandmother died this week. I am the only grandchild to not post about this on Facebook. I've had a few comments (my mother and cousin) that I mustn't be as upset. I'm not being unreasonable am I? I think talking to a dead 98 year old on Facebook is fucking mental but obviously not said that to them. I'm sad but not needing attention from people I wouldn't have actually told one to one. Please talk me down as I'm starting to lose my cool.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DorritLittle · 07/07/2022 15:22

Agree @DashOfMilkNoSugar

DashOfMilkNoSugar · 07/07/2022 15:17

HeadNorth · 07/07/2022 15:10

Empty vessels make the most noise. I assume social media grievers have quite shallow emotions as they are so happy to spraff them all over the place. My deepest losses are too profound for the shallow world of social media 'likes'.

From the experience of my BIL who I posted about earlier I can tell you that some social media grievers are just trying to get through the day.

HeadNorth · 07/07/2022 15:10

Empty vessels make the most noise. I assume social media grievers have quite shallow emotions as they are so happy to spraff them all over the place. My deepest losses are too profound for the shallow world of social media 'likes'.

DorritLittle · 07/07/2022 14:46

Ps FWIW it would never have occurred to me to post about my grandmothers dying and it is totally your call OP. It is your call alone and not the law.

DorritLittle · 07/07/2022 14:44

A relative of mine was on FB a lot and we all posted tributes to him when he died. It seemed fitting and genuinely comforted a lot of people to read the messages, particularly those closest to him.

When my Dad died, I posted a picture and that's all. He didn't do Facebook so it didn't seem the right thing to do.

What I am saying is, these posts are really personal and it is really nothing to do with anyone not involved. It is very easy to judge but these are real.people who have lostsomeone

DashOfMilkNoSugar · 07/07/2022 14:37

Smokealarmwakeup · 07/07/2022 10:09

I had the same thing on the anniversary of someone dying. My response was “they didn’t have Facebook when they were alive so I doubt they will have started checking it now”

You’re all heart.
If it makes a difficult day easier for someone who are we to say that they shouldn’t write a post. Just keep scrolling rather than being horrible to a supposed friend.

creamwitheverything · 07/07/2022 11:46

I think you are showing dignity OP.I am so sorry for your loss.

BotCrossHuns · 07/07/2022 10:24

Smokealarmwakeup · 07/07/2022 10:09

I had the same thing on the anniversary of someone dying. My response was “they didn’t have Facebook when they were alive so I doubt they will have started checking it now”

😮

but why be sarcastically horrible to them? Ok, it's a bit stupid to post like that and you (like most of us) don't like that style. But they're clearly wanting a bit of sympathy for whatever reason. So you could just not post anything rather than actively trying to hurt them. You're not going to change them by being sarcastic towards them, and it's not really anyone else's job to change them anyway, unless maybe they're a young relative that you are responsible for (and even then, there are nicer more private ways of encouraging them to change). It just seems like be horrible for the sake of it, because something irritates you.

StaunchMomma · 07/07/2022 10:21

Just tell them you don't share personal details or feeling on social media and whether you do so or not is not an indicator of how upset a person is.

I can see why this would piss you off but it's not the time to argue. Just say your piece and step away from the crazy.

It's so hard losing granbdparents, you don't need this.x.

Smokealarmwakeup · 07/07/2022 10:09

I had the same thing on the anniversary of someone dying. My response was “they didn’t have Facebook when they were alive so I doubt they will have started checking it now”

BotCrossHuns · 07/07/2022 09:57

But there is a huge difference between “thinking of my grandma today who sadly passed away etc etc” which does get that sympathy than you’re talking about, vs “dear grandma, I miss you so much, you were the best granny ever etc etc” which is quite an odd open letter to someone who won’t be reading it*
*
Yes and I'm not keen on those posts either but quite happy to mute the people or scroll on by on those days, as it doesn't actually hurt me in any way, even if it's not my style. They could still be hurting and needing attention in some way, even if there are more appropriate ways of getting it. I won't change them by responding or not, so I just leave them be.

But there are quite a lot of people who do seem to feel not using social media or posting about personal things on it makes them morally superior, and it's those people that I think could sometimes think more about others who don't have a real life network, and to remember that people really don't all use social media in the same way. There are a lot of disparaging comments at times.

Shoxfordian · 07/07/2022 09:43

You’re the normal one op

Don’t worry about it

ShirleyPhallus · 07/07/2022 09:43

BotCrossHuns · 07/07/2022 09:33

Not everyone has people to support them in person. I'd be quite grateful for some additional sympathy with people that I don't necessarily see all the time - I have nobody that I could actually ring up and chat to in person - so for some of us, social media is valued. yes, I suppose it's attention seeking in some ways to post that someone close to you has died, but sometimes you need that attention, and I was grateful for supportive comments when I posted it.

In the case of the OP, that sounds like it's not the situation, but it might be in the case of some of the other people posters are talking about. it doesn't make you morally superior because you have lots of people to tell in person and to support and grieve together, and avoid social media. Social media doesn't have to be hundreds of random acquaintances from years gone by - and if you're on someone else's friend list, it doesn't mean that all their other friends have the same connection with that person as you do. Some of them possibly really do care that something has happened to them.

But there is a huge difference between “thinking of my grandma today who sadly passed away etc etc” which does get that sympathy than you’re talking about, vs “dear grandma, I miss you so much, you were the best granny ever etc etc” which is quite an odd open letter to someone who won’t be reading it

BotCrossHuns · 07/07/2022 09:33

Not everyone has people to support them in person. I'd be quite grateful for some additional sympathy with people that I don't necessarily see all the time - I have nobody that I could actually ring up and chat to in person - so for some of us, social media is valued. yes, I suppose it's attention seeking in some ways to post that someone close to you has died, but sometimes you need that attention, and I was grateful for supportive comments when I posted it.

In the case of the OP, that sounds like it's not the situation, but it might be in the case of some of the other people posters are talking about. it doesn't make you morally superior because you have lots of people to tell in person and to support and grieve together, and avoid social media. Social media doesn't have to be hundreds of random acquaintances from years gone by - and if you're on someone else's friend list, it doesn't mean that all their other friends have the same connection with that person as you do. Some of them possibly really do care that something has happened to them.

SquirrelSoShiny · 07/07/2022 08:49

This is exactly why I don't do Facebook.

bigbluebus · 07/07/2022 08:48

I hate those sort of posts. When my DD died a few years ago there were lots of people we needed to tell - but we absolutely refused to put anything at all on Social Media. I was grateful for the Messenger facility it provided as it enabled me to message people in groups with appropriate messaging and it allowed me to request that some individuals cascade the info to those who needed to know. No need for attention seeking Facebook posts with millions of sympathy comments. 180 people attendee the funeral so those who needed to know clearly got the message.

GrandRapids · 07/07/2022 08:45

This is the madness we now live in. The assumption that all life events, good and bad must be shared with an audience. It's sickens me actually.

I mean if a person chooses to do this then fine, their choice. But to be pressurised into it is just plain wrong.

When my Nan died we all grieved massively. But nobody shared it online, looking for additional sympathy. We all felt like shit and we supported one another in person.

SnackyOnassis · 07/07/2022 08:44

100% agree, YANBU.
I can't bear the attention seeking, I completely appreciate that different people grieve in different ways but the kind of displays you're talking about here are nothing to do with managing grief and everything to do with garnering attention.
I agree with PPs who've suggested nipping this in the bud, because you know that every year now there'll be an anniversary post ostensibly dedicated to the departed, but just details how their life has been so hard without their nana (who they likely wouldn't have even given a second thought were she still alive) and they hope they're 'looking down on them'...
If it's any consolation to them, there are plenty of people actually using Facebook who are looking down on them. 😑

JubileeTrifle · 07/07/2022 08:28

I hate all the heavenly birthday wishes thing. It’s nothing but attention seeking often.
we have a family member who does it about his mother. He didn’t like her, didn’t help look after her when she was unwell and probably was responsible for her untimely death. But he gets lots of sympathy.

I know someone who has just posted a massive long post about the death of her estranged mother, including all the stuff she had to sort out. A well educated, intelligent woman. I don’t know why she thinks 100s of people who have never met her mother need to know all these details.

I do know people who have posted about deaths as it’s an easy well to let a lot of people know, especially funeral details. But not relatives etc though.

TuftyMarmoset · 07/07/2022 08:26

Sorry for your loss OP. Do people actually still post statuses on Facebook? I thought that died out about 5 years ago!

SpartacusNotEsther · 07/07/2022 08:25

Sniffypete · 07/07/2022 08:22

I didn't post on Facebook about my Nan dying, but I did about my mum for the simple reason was that it was the middle of covid and I just didn't have the energy or will to make hundreds more phone calls.

That is different imo. Posting to inform is very different to the posts that irk me personally.

BotCrossHuns · 07/07/2022 08:23

I think it depends very much who you have on your friends list, as to whether you want to post personal things like that.

I did post that someone close to me had died. I have friends on there that I wouldn't ever meet up with one to one (I don't have many friends at all that are really close, sadly). These are people that I do hobby groups with, that I'm friendly with etc, but that I don't know really well. They would have noticed that I was away from the groups for a while, perhaps that I was travelling for the funeral, that I might have been quiet or not up for the social aspects of the groups for a bit, etc. I wanted to spare them the awkwardness when you have friendly conversations with someone that you see regularly but don't know hugely well "oh you've just been away, how lovely, hope you had a super time." "actually it was a funeral of close relative". "oh." awkward pause. Or a casual "oh you've not been for a drink for a couple of weeks, sure you'll come tonight hey? oh go on, why not?" "oh.". more awkwardness. You know, times when you are just have lighthearted small talk and chat, and you don't want to kill the moment by announcing it. Or, times when you know you really don't want to talk about it in front of/with those people, and yet at the same time, it will end up coming out somehow, so better to get the news-giving bit over with in advance on something like facebook, so the news is public, other people know that it's public and they can tell someone who doesn't know if they want. And then if they do say anything to you directly, it's over fairly quickly, you aren't pressed to do things ,and you can control the conversation a bit more.

I don't think anyone should be chided for whether they do or don't post on FB. It's totally up to them and has no bearing on how much you cared for the person. I find it useful as an information service for people I see regularly, and to potentially connect to people who I dont' see regularly but might care about me.

I'm sorry for your loss.

DashOfMilkNoSugar · 07/07/2022 08:22

Strugglingtodomybest · 07/07/2022 08:05

if your ‘friend’ posts something and it bothers you that much unfriend them, just keep scrolling or even better show them some compassion or empathy.

I think you misread the OP.

YANBU OP, I've had something similar and could feel myself getting upset about it. I talked myself down by reminding myself that the person who said it has no emotional intelligence and seems to not understand that everyone is different.

If you need to say something, I'd just remind them that everyone grieves in their own way.

Rather than the OP it was in response to comments like these from PP:

Grief vampiring, fake sentimentality, for likes, nobody cares

Sniffypete · 07/07/2022 08:22

I didn't post on Facebook about my Nan dying, but I did about my mum for the simple reason was that it was the middle of covid and I just didn't have the energy or will to make hundreds more phone calls.

SpartacusNotEsther · 07/07/2022 08:21

Yanbu at all.

I really don't understand the need to post everything on social media. Every anniversary of a death (which is usually by people that post every birthday of the dead relative too), every wedding anniversary (especially grating when you know about the times they have split up or one of them has cheated, and the messages are all 'people thought it wouldn't last, but look at us now!'), messages to their baby on their first/second/third birthday when they obviously can't read them for themselves.

Are people really in that much need of attention?