Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to just not go to this dinner - Told DC cannot go

264 replies

feelingthepinch · 06/07/2022 16:36

Not sure what to think on this one to be honest. I've namechanged as will be outing if anyone reads it.

Been with DP almost 5 years. He has 2 sisters, one of which I see alot and we get on well, the other we don't see as much as lives further away. Get on ok but shes always been a bit off with me (she was good friends with his ex wife, so probably she feels a bit awkward or disloyal if she likes me or something). Its never been a huge problem though. We are civil and friendly.

This Dsis is having a milestone birthday meal out at end of July. All DP's family are invited, its a case of the place is booked and we all buy our own food, so she isn't paying for everyone.
We agreed we could go and my exdp was having the dc that weekend so all good.

ExDP has had to go into hospital and although nothing serious looks like it will be hard for him to have the DC on the weekend as planned as it falls after a minor operation. The older DC can stay at home but youngest is 7 and i'm not keen on the others having the responsbility of him for that long as the restuarant is just over an hour drive away.

There are other DC going to the meal, ranging in age from I think about 3 to teens.
Before we asked his Dsis if its possible to bring DC, I called the restaurant to see if needed could an extra chair be put at the table thats booked and they said yes its no problem and we can just let them know the day before. Reason I did this was because if the restaurant couldn't accommodate another person at the table there would be no point in asking his Dsis if we could bring DC anyway and I'd have to sort something out.

But as other Dc are going, Dp then asked his Dsis if we can bring him and she said No. The reason is because we are not married, and he isn't family.

If she'd of said no because there was no room or because no dc I'd of understood completely but the fact she said he isn't family just sort of stung me a bit. No we are not married, but we are engaged and live together and DP has been in DS's life since he was 3.

For the record DS is a very well behaved child, he will sit at a table and behave when out, so the reason is definitely not that hes a child who would misbehave. he is quiet, you'd hardly know he was there. Plus we are paying for our food anyway, so not like he would cost her anything.

I'm inclined to thinking I don't want to go now at all, and won't try and sort other arrangement for DS. DP thinks i'm being silly and too sensitive but its left me feeling a bit disappointed and like I'm basically an outcast and still not seen as part of the family. I do over think, but am I being silly about this or would anyone else feel a bit offended?

OP posts:
sunglassesonthetable · 06/07/2022 21:57

I totally get the ringing up the restaurant first. I have done that in the past myself. It's to pre empt causing my a big hassle to the host and putting them in an awkward position. If there's no room you're not going to make the request anyway.

You have to remember OP fully expected DSiS to say YES. She didn't do it to catch her out if she said NO.

5128gap · 06/07/2022 21:52

WitchWithoutChips · 06/07/2022 21:28

It was totally unnecessary. The only person you need to speak to is the host.

It’s academic in this case as SIL is indeed seemingly a cow but I wouldn’t recommend it with anyone with whom you want to maintain a friendship.

I must admit, while fully supporting the OP, I do agree with this.
It looks so much like an attempt to pre empt a refusal, that the two things are barely distinguishable. If someone did this to me I would think they were expecting me to lie and I'd be offended.

onlythreenow · 06/07/2022 21:51

I would find it very difficult to consider unrelated kids as part of my family. A couple could break up any time and those children would then completely disappear from our lives.

Equally a couple might never break up and "those children" would be around forever. What a charming person you sound. I have known several people who have welcomed unrelated children into their lives as grandchildren/nieces, nephews etc. and treated them exactly as their own family. Of course, some people are just straight out nicer than others.

onlythreenow · 06/07/2022 21:44

She's a bitch, and I wouldn't be going.

WitchWithoutChips · 06/07/2022 21:28

WiddlinDiddlin · 06/07/2022 21:14

@WitchWithoutChips Why the fuck would it be sly to find out if there is even room for an extra child?

There is no point asking to add another if there isn't room.
The OP has not booked an extra space.
The OP would have been paying for that extra person had they been welcomed.

IF she'd called up to catch the SIL out in a lie, if she'd called and added an extra space without asking to a meal being paid for by others, sure.. but none of that applies here!

OP - YANBU she's being a cow, don't go and make sure its clear you're not going because you're not family. If pushed on that point, as you're not family, you are not inclined to go to the effort to arrange childcare to attend a non-family and thus not important, event.

It was totally unnecessary. The only person you need to speak to is the host.

It’s academic in this case as SIL is indeed seemingly a cow but I wouldn’t recommend it with anyone with whom you want to maintain a friendship.

sunglassesonthetable · 06/07/2022 21:24

*InChocolateWeTrust
I always find it slightly odd that it should be a given that one must welcome in step children.

I would find it very difficult to consider unrelated kids as part of my family. A couple could break up any time and those children would then completely disappear from our lives.

My uncle had a partner with a child for a few years who was brought along to various things and it was just a bit odd. We never saw them enough to get to know them properly, and it's probably a good thing the child didnt form bonds with us given their mum broke up my uncle 3 years later.*

Hmmm, this is a grim considering it refers to actual young children.

I don't suppose step children know if their parents relationship are going to last either.

Best not to welcome them and form bonds eh.

Mind you we are only talking about a well behaved child sitting down at the table for a meal, not making SiL life long god parent.

Blondeshavemorefun · 06/07/2022 21:21

Dp May not be going now but he needs to deal with the drama and tell sis why

Lachimolala · 06/07/2022 21:20

Not a chance I would go, I’d take my kids out somewhere nice instead.

Arenanewbie · 06/07/2022 21:19

I’m glad OP that your DP is on the same page. He’s right in a way, you’ve got childcare emergency and at least one of you can’t go but she was so unreasonably and deliberately mean that obviously none of you want make even a tiny effort.
I just can’t really imagine treating my sibling like this.

5128gap · 06/07/2022 21:17

InChocolateWeTrust · 06/07/2022 20:06

I always find it slightly odd that it should be a given that one must welcome in step children.

I would find it very difficult to consider unrelated kids as part of my family. A couple could break up any time and those children would then completely disappear from our lives.

My uncle had a partner with a child for a few years who was brought along to various things and it was just a bit odd. We never saw them enough to get to know them properly, and it's probably a good thing the child didnt form bonds with us given their mum broke up my uncle 3 years later.

She doesn't have to. All she had to do was tolerate the presence at her meal of one quiet 7 year old who now hasn't got a babysitter for the evening. Its not some huge gesture to demonstrate the child's inclusion in the family.

mumpants · 06/07/2022 21:15

That's outrageous and nasty. I definitely would not go and would avoid her like the plague in future.

WiddlinDiddlin · 06/07/2022 21:14

@WitchWithoutChips Why the fuck would it be sly to find out if there is even room for an extra child?

There is no point asking to add another if there isn't room.
The OP has not booked an extra space.
The OP would have been paying for that extra person had they been welcomed.

IF she'd called up to catch the SIL out in a lie, if she'd called and added an extra space without asking to a meal being paid for by others, sure.. but none of that applies here!

OP - YANBU she's being a cow, don't go and make sure its clear you're not going because you're not family. If pushed on that point, as you're not family, you are not inclined to go to the effort to arrange childcare to attend a non-family and thus not important, event.

5128gap · 06/07/2022 21:11

I wouldn't go. She's said no deliberately to make a point, using your DS to show you she doesn't consider you part of her family, because she doesn't quite dare do it to you directly. I wouldn't be celebrating the birthday of someone who had such animosity towards me. If I were your DP I wouldn't go either actually, as I would not be happy with my sibling rejecting my partner if they'd done nothing wrong.

ClinkeyMonkey · 06/07/2022 21:10

Nice one OP.

LaLaLouella · 06/07/2022 21:05

Good, I'm glad your DP has come to the conclusion.

I wouldn't be going up an event where me or my children were considered 'not family'...

Lollypop701 · 06/07/2022 20:59

Good for you op, glad it’s worked out

feelingthepinch · 06/07/2022 20:56

Spoke to dp when he got in and before I’d got into it he said he’d been thinking about it today and is appalled at his dsis. When he got off the phone with her it didn’t really register with him what she was saying, as he was just thinking it’s her birthday and she said no. But thinking on it he is not happy either. He is very much of the opinion we both won’t be going.
he pretty much said to me she can shove her bday dinner up her arse.
he’s just going to message her and tell her we both won’t be coming now and leaving it at that. If she asks why he is just going to say we can’t come and not get into it all as she can be difficult and he basically doesn’t want to deal with her drama.
he has said he’ll be telling his parents the reason though if they ask why we are not going anymore.
We will post a birthday card, from all of us, but that’s it.

OP posts:
pointythings · 06/07/2022 20:53

She's being petty and mean spirited, I think you're right not to go.

Arenanewbie · 06/07/2022 20:52

you are not over sensitive at all. You’ve got an emergency situation, it’s not like you forcing a relationship on her. She was really mean, people are more understanding towards complete strangers. It looks like she was waiting for a while to make a point and just used this opportunity. There will be other DC and you will be paying themselves. You can book another table for all your DC at the same restaurant and take them there and she won’t be able to say anything. There are no any reasoning in what she’s said. Very mean and unkind.
I wouldn’t do anything ever at all for her and wouldn’t facilitate any sort of relationship either. She showed you that she doesn’t want it and she obviously wanted you and your DP to know about this.

ManateeFair · 06/07/2022 20:37

InChocolateWeTrust · 06/07/2022 20:06

I always find it slightly odd that it should be a given that one must welcome in step children.

I would find it very difficult to consider unrelated kids as part of my family. A couple could break up any time and those children would then completely disappear from our lives.

My uncle had a partner with a child for a few years who was brought along to various things and it was just a bit odd. We never saw them enough to get to know them properly, and it's probably a good thing the child didnt form bonds with us given their mum broke up my uncle 3 years later.

Well, by your argument siblings’ spouses aren’t ‘family’ either. Do you make a point of excluding them too?

Even if there’s a vague chance that a child might not be in your life forever and you don’t consider them ‘family’, is that actually any reason not to be nice to them and make them feel welcome when they’re around? Because I would just consider that a basic standard of kindness and decency.

(FWIW my brother is divorced - but his stepchildren, who are now adults, have always been my niece and nephew and will always be my parents’ grandchildren. We didn’t just stop speaking to them when my brother got divorced, any more than we stopped speaking to his biological children.)

5zeds · 06/07/2022 20:34

I’d just write back “oh I hadn’t realised it was family only, dp will come by himself” if he still wants to.

ManateeFair · 06/07/2022 20:27

zingally · 06/07/2022 16:44

She's perfectly entitled to have an adults-only meal out for her birthday. A child at the table, even a well-behaved, quiet one, changes the dynamic of the group, and the adults won't be able to speak so freely, as they'll be feeling like they have to tailor their topics of conversation for kid ears.

Saying that, she also needs to be okay with the fact that being firm on a no kids policy, may mean that some people are unable to attend.

Did you not read the whole post? There are other children going, some younger than the OP’s little boy. It’s only the OP’s child who isn’t allowed to go, because the SIL doesn’t consider him family.

londonlass71 · 06/07/2022 20:24

I wouldn't invite her to anything extra like your hen night either.

londonlass71 · 06/07/2022 20:23

She's a bitch. I wouldn't go. Yes it's her birthday and she is entitled to have who she wants there but a child who is well behaved won't make a difference. Its not like an adult you don't like coming or anything like that - you don't even have to chat to the kids that much. Moreover to say that you're not married and the child isn't family is so rude. Even if you were not engaged it doesn't matter. What if you decided you were going to be life partners but never marry. Then what? I think it's divisive. She clearly doesn't like you and is sticking to boot in. Her brother should say something. I think she has gotten away with it for way too long.

AnnesBrokenSlate · 06/07/2022 20:19

tbh you're putting a lot of weight on what your DP said that she said and I always think second hand gossip can lose or gain something in the telling. So I'm discounting the emotive language.
I think YABU on the basis that she's entitled to invite whoever she wants and that I think it's really odd you called the restaurant before you asked her. That's really pushy. The restaurant doesn't know who has RSVPed to her or not so there was no practical gain from speaking to the staff. It just looks as though you tried to go above her to prove there was room for your DC.
Go or don't go but you're not impacting the person whose birthday it is (who let's be honest won't really care) - you're impacting your DP.