Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you could stay friends with people committing benefit fraud/tax evasion?

135 replies

WanderingWildflower · 06/07/2022 14:53

Out of curiosity. This situation really annoys me but equally they are nice people and it's none of my business.

So these friends of mine are a couple. She owns a house outright that was purchased using inheritance. They both live in it and have done for over a year. He has a mortgage on his own house, bought before they met, and rents it out to a mate.

She doesnt work (small kids) but claims UC, not declaring that her partner actually lives with her. Meanwhile his friend pays him his rent in cash.

So essentially they have fraudulently claimed UC, a full time wage plus untaxed rental income coming in and no housing costs.

I suppose with the cost of living crisis it gets to me a little that we are having to tighten out belts a lot while they live the high life tax free/fraudulently.

I'm not the sort to cut people out but I'm so ethically opposed to people who do this that it sort of makes me question our friendship.

Could you stay friends in this situation?

OP posts:
SirChenjins · 06/07/2022 15:56

Nope, I couldn’t stay friends with them - it’s thieving and I don’t care if ‘others do it more so a little bit is ok’.

WeeOrcadian · 06/07/2022 15:53

FemmeNatal · 06/07/2022 15:11

No, and I’d report them for it too.

I am happy for my taxes to support people in need, not for them to be taken fraudulently.

Snap. There are people are who struggling to make ends meet and have to decide whether they have a shower or a meal. Disgusting humans.

Covidagainandagain · 06/07/2022 15:52

FemmeNatal · 06/07/2022 15:45

Attitudes like yours are why we should look at providing people with food and accommodation directly, rather than money. There seems to be an entire underclass now who have no issue with stealing from the state.

No

Because

That wont pay their electric bills, or their gas bills, or their water bills or their phone, broadband (what if they work from home for example) bills

Because people don't just need accommodation and food. They need clothes, and sanitary products and cleaning products and deodorant, shampoo, soap

Because they might want to go to the cinema, or buy an ice cream, or have a day out, or buy a bike for their kid so they can get a job doing the paper round

Because children need books, and money for school trips and christmas and birthday treats and maybe some toys occasionally

Because the amount of benefit fraud is tiny and the costs of administrating this system would probably cost more than they would save

Because the cost of big corporations avoiding tax is far higher and thats who we should be targetting

Because companies should be paying their employees who work full time enough to live on so that nurses and carers shouldn't be having to claim benefits

Because she should treat people with respect and dignity and not assume they will cheat the system before they even have chance to prove they wont

misssunshine4040 · 06/07/2022 15:50

daisyjgrey · 06/07/2022 15:50

I couldn't give a shit. Benefit fraud and low level tax evasion is a drop in the ocean compared with the fuckery that happens with billion pound companies. When MP's pay tax properly and companies like Amazon and Boots pay full corporation tax, I'll start caring about Martin and Sue down the road who are getting an extra £60 a week more than they're entitled.

Absolutely this

daisyjgrey · 06/07/2022 15:50

I couldn't give a shit. Benefit fraud and low level tax evasion is a drop in the ocean compared with the fuckery that happens with billion pound companies. When MP's pay tax properly and companies like Amazon and Boots pay full corporation tax, I'll start caring about Martin and Sue down the road who are getting an extra £60 a week more than they're entitled.

GCRich · 06/07/2022 15:49

I could overlook a bit of minor benefit fraud (eg failing to inform of a change in circumstance that would lead to a small reduction in UC). I could not overlook major fraud or failure to declare rental income.

Tax evaders are prioritising their right to say "screw everyone else" over my right to half decent healthcare. That suggests they hate me, so I hate them back.

misssunshine4040 · 06/07/2022 15:48

@FemmeNatal I'm not justifying it. It's very wrong.

I'm simply saying that there is such a huge divide that "stealing from the state" is going to happen until the welfare system is overhauled.

Dehumanising people who claim assistance because of a few fraudsters is not the answer

CavernousScream · 06/07/2022 15:48

This is a problem for single mothers, if a new partner moves in they often have to give up financial independence. So I’d have some sympathy for her. I’d also assume that the friend renting her boyfriend’s place is more like a lodger and they have a plausible explanation for it.

I couldn’t however remain friends with the poster above complaint about her DH paying 40% tax above a certain level and how terribly unfair it is. He pays that because he’s a higher rate taxpayer and a redistributive tax system is a good thing.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 06/07/2022 15:47

I don't know how I would feel about someone who was living an affluent lifestyle funded by benefit fraud. But I know plenty of people who have fiddled the system a bit (undeclared income from cash in hand work, boyfriend moved in but officially still living with his parents, etc) and it has never had any impact on our friendship. In every case they were just getting by.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 06/07/2022 15:47

No I wouldn’t be friends with someone in that situation because they are going out of their way to steal money that they aren’t entitled to from the taxpayer. People like that deserve to be reported.

Someone not declaring a little side income could be classed as tax evasion, but that wouldn’t worry me as much. There is a difference between keeping your own money that you have legally earned even if some tax is due on it, and making the effort to put in a fraudulent claim and take money that other people have earned.

FemmeNatal · 06/07/2022 15:45

misssunshine4040 · 06/07/2022 15:43

@Annoyingkidsmusic but why are you not angry at the government instead of the individual?

There is a rarely a benefit cheat rolling in cash is there.

The organised criminal ones maybe but the average "scammer" is just making a few extra quid in a broken and massively unfair system

Attitudes like yours are why we should look at providing people with food and accommodation directly, rather than money. There seems to be an entire underclass now who have no issue with stealing from the state.

ineedafairygodmother · 06/07/2022 15:44

TBH it's none of your business and you could be coming the the wrong conclusion about your friends finances.....
-If you friend isn't working and has small children she is entitled to claim UC, she won't get any housing benefit as she owns her home outright and she will still have all of her other bills to pay just like everybody else. She might have a joint claim with her partner living there and they are still under the threshold so are entitled to UC
-your friends partner renting his home out for 'cash' he is still liable to pay the council tax and mortgage for that property and potentially other bills, he could be getting peanuts in rent from his friend..... and if the house is not 'technically' rented out, your friends partner will still be classed as living there

I personally think people take far too much interest in other peoples lives. It seems to me that your a little jealous

misssunshine4040 · 06/07/2022 15:43

@Annoyingkidsmusic but why are you not angry at the government instead of the individual?

There is a rarely a benefit cheat rolling in cash is there.

The organised criminal ones maybe but the average "scammer" is just making a few extra quid in a broken and massively unfair system

Annoyingkidsmusic · 06/07/2022 15:40

misssunshine4040 · 06/07/2022 15:23

You are clearly a very high earning income household if you pay that much "disproportionate " tax though.

Why are you taking it personally, someone on benefits, even if they are scamming a few extra quid, is nowhere near living your standard of lifestyle

It is disproportionate in comparison to other households where both adults have f/t wages under a certain threshold- we pay more tax by thousands, yet a similar household income.

The tax thing, the scamming, people working cash in hand (many self employed high earners do this too) renting houses they own to family members who receive benefits to pay the “rent” etc etc, the fraud of it, I find it personal- lots of tax payers do 🤷🏼‍♀️

GabriellaMontez · 06/07/2022 15:30

WatchoRulo · 06/07/2022 14:59

Whenever this type of post appears I marvel at how much financial detail people have about their friends. I have no friends for whom I'd know this level of detail.
Also, dealing in cash can facilitate tax evasion, but it isn't proof of it.

This! I don't share this level of financial detail with anyone!

Eatingchips · 06/07/2022 15:28

I don’t think I’d know or want to know my friends financial ins and outs so it would never arise as a question for me.

I have heard one or two dodgy dealings along the way, all of them made sense to me in the context they were done, i.e. food bank or no food bank.

Gsds · 06/07/2022 15:27

You sound jealous of their income rather than morally opposed to their methods of gaining it 🤷‍♀️ Says as much about you as it does about them.

FemmeNatal · 06/07/2022 15:23

misssunshine4040 · 06/07/2022 15:21

Yes, why could you not stay friends?
Because you are jealous they have sore money?

They have made the choice to take stupid risks that could land them in jail, I don't see how the stress is worth it but I wouldn't fall out with someone over it, it's not personal.
And before someone starts, it's really NOT personal, the government rob us blind on the daily.

How is the government robbing you?

misssunshine4040 · 06/07/2022 15:23

Annoyingkidsmusic · 06/07/2022 15:00

No, I couldn’t stay friends with them. My oh’s salary is taxed at 40% over a certain amount, yet we have 3 children and I work p/t around his hours, so for me this kind of thing gets very personal. As a household we pay a very disproportionate amount of tax. People like this often end up with a disposable income greater than ours. So I couldn’t stay friends with people like that.

You are clearly a very high earning income household if you pay that much "disproportionate " tax though.

Why are you taking it personally, someone on benefits, even if they are scamming a few extra quid, is nowhere near living your standard of lifestyle

misssunshine4040 · 06/07/2022 15:21

WanderingWildflower · 06/07/2022 14:53

Out of curiosity. This situation really annoys me but equally they are nice people and it's none of my business.

So these friends of mine are a couple. She owns a house outright that was purchased using inheritance. They both live in it and have done for over a year. He has a mortgage on his own house, bought before they met, and rents it out to a mate.

She doesnt work (small kids) but claims UC, not declaring that her partner actually lives with her. Meanwhile his friend pays him his rent in cash.

So essentially they have fraudulently claimed UC, a full time wage plus untaxed rental income coming in and no housing costs.

I suppose with the cost of living crisis it gets to me a little that we are having to tighten out belts a lot while they live the high life tax free/fraudulently.

I'm not the sort to cut people out but I'm so ethically opposed to people who do this that it sort of makes me question our friendship.

Could you stay friends in this situation?

Yes, why could you not stay friends?
Because you are jealous they have sore money?

They have made the choice to take stupid risks that could land them in jail, I don't see how the stress is worth it but I wouldn't fall out with someone over it, it's not personal.
And before someone starts, it's really NOT personal, the government rob us blind on the daily.

Footbal · 06/07/2022 15:18

BIL and SIL did this. He was working abroad earning 7k a month. She was claiming housing benefit and single parent allowance.

They put down a very hefty deposit on a house for 500,000 euros and bought a brand new BMW a few weeks later. Who said crime doesn't pay.

Purplebunnie · 06/07/2022 15:17

Is she also claiming single person discount? Report them

Doorsdoyle · 06/07/2022 15:12

Report them then.

FemmeNatal · 06/07/2022 15:11

No, and I’d report them for it too.

I am happy for my taxes to support people in need, not for them to be taken fraudulently.

madasawethen · 06/07/2022 15:10

I'd warn your friend about disclosing all her business to you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread