Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Will I be that parent?

59 replies

Bagpuss2022 · 06/07/2022 14:53

My DD is in y7 never so much as a missed homework wins awards very good kid, she had technology yesterday they have to bring in a container to bring food home in we pay school for the supplies (brilliant Idea BTW)
she got a detention for not bringing one only she did but it was not big enough ,
she did a lunch time detention lunch is only 30 minutes she did not eat lunch because of this.
I want to contact school as would much preferred her to after school detention as lunch is so short and did she even deserve a detention apparently the teacher said they needed a large container last week but DD says she can’t remember.
is it not a bit OTT this close to end of year and how exemplary she is it’s not like she’s had lots of issues she’s had non or do I leave it and put it to a life lesson ?
o

OP posts:
Tentpegsandtantrums · 06/07/2022 18:06

3 issues

Overzealous punishment - why?!

Lunchtime detention - surely this shouldn’t mean no food?!

Inability to eat = serious risk to health.

This is not a good school, OP, despite what you might have experienced in the past. The punishment is draconian and over the top, denying a child food is ridiculous and the fact she could have been very unwell as a consequence is actually very serious.

I think I’d be going beyond the head and to the governing body/LEA (if what your DD has told you is 100% true).

Threetulips · 06/07/2022 17:58

Who gave her her insulin at lunch?

Willdoitlater · 06/07/2022 17:47

OMG! I was going to say its completely unreasonable to make a kid miss lunch, even before you said she is type 1 diabetic.

lanthanum · 06/07/2022 17:18

The big issue here is not whether this particular misdemeanour merited a detention, but that it is not acceptable for a child to have no opportunity to eat their lunch ESPECIALLY where there is a medical need. At the very least she needs a card or something to show to any teacher trying to give her a lunchtime detention that says that she must either be allowed to eat her lunch in the detention or that it must be an after-school detention.

As for punishment for not bringing a large enough container, only being allowed to take home what will fit seems quite sufficient, but presumably it's a school with an "automatic detention for not having equipment" policy.

RedHelenB · 06/07/2022 17:13

I've bever known lunchtime detentions to kean missing eating your lunch. Have you asked her why that happened?
As to being a good kid, she didn't listen or write down what she needed to bring , therefore the punishment has to be the same as any other kid would have got.

LisaSimpson77 · 06/07/2022 17:02

@givemushypeasachance

It's a giant logistical faff.

Well, not really. This is where natural consequences would work so much better than a detention.

You make it the student's responsibility to get the stuff home and make this clear at the start of each school year.

You tell them what sort of container will be required (if you're kind you'll have a stache of disposable foil containers so that they can get one warning.)

After that, getting it home is their responsibility.
Forgotten container? They can take as much as they can carry or stuff in their pockets but anything left over gets binned (or put on Olio?)

I often despair at Secondary schools' prolific use of detentions for tiny rule infringements, what do they do if somebody really misbehaves?

kedavra · 06/07/2022 16:56

I would be that parent , my child also has T1.

Whilst it isn't primary school, all staff should be medically aware and reasonable adjustments made for her to be safe at school. I would make a formal complaint and I would absolutely point out that the hypo could have been avoided, meals must be eaten and arrangements should be made for any detention to not affect meals. I would request a lunch pass and suggest staff receive training.

( that is a ridiculous reason for a detention too)

Blueeilidh · 06/07/2022 16:43

Regardless of the diabetes, lunch time detention should not prevent a school child having lunch, even if they are limited in the time given to eat and eating in silence separate to their friends, they should still be allowed time to eat and to go to the toilet.

LadyDanburysHat · 06/07/2022 16:34

The reason for the detention was nonsensical in the first place. But putting that aside, a lunchtime detention should not preclude the ability to get food.

HelloThereObiWan · 06/07/2022 16:23

Oh god, I'm glad you sent an email. I only have primary aged kids and I'm dreading them starting secondary school after reading some of the horror stories on here.

Bagpuss2022 · 06/07/2022 16:14

Email sent, I think as I have been a type one parent for many years I have become a bit more relaxed it is dangerous and like I have said they are brilliant with her like they were with my son, both of them are academic and my other son wasn’t he was encouraged in other areas I think it’s a rogue teacher end of year and burnout but she needs to be professional as a fellow ex teacher I understand I was polite but firm my DD is my priority she was low low at tea last night 2.3 for those in the know she’s so well managed I don’t think it’s a coincidence

OP posts:
Loveisnotloving · 06/07/2022 16:00

No way does she deserve that! Poor kid, I would be seriously pissed off OP.

hangrylady · 06/07/2022 15:58

The teacher was a dick. I'd complain.

10HailMarys · 06/07/2022 15:56

Even if she had remembered the teacher saying 'large' container, the word 'large' is so open to interpretation that it's almost meaningless. Plenty of people would think of a lunchbox as a large container, I think. So it's pretty outrageous to punish a child for bringing in a container that was slightly smaller than what the teacher was envisaging. Especially as she was able to fit her food into it anyway.

It's extremely bad that they made a Type1 diabetic child skip a meal, but I also don't think any school should be making any child go without lunch in order to complete a detention. Make them eat alone or give them ten minutes to eat and then they spend the rest of the time in detention, or even make them go and collect a sandwich from the canteen which they then bring back and eat during the detention. Being fed and hydrated is about the most basic requirement there is; it's not like lunch is some kind of treat.

TuftyMarmoset · 06/07/2022 15:48

I’d be that parent too. I mean, what are the consequences of having a slightly small box - she can’t bring home all of her biscuits. How is that in any way a problem worthy of a detention? They just eat them/redistribute to people with spare capacity/bin them. Completely absurd.

Covidagainandagain · 06/07/2022 15:44

They made a type 1 diabetic skip a meal because she didnt bring in the right size container?

Be that parent. Your DD should never have been in this position.

Personally I would also tell your DD that she has your full permission in future to request an after school detention and if that is denied politely explain that she cannot attend a lunch time detention because she has to eat because she is a diabetic, and explain that you will deal with any fallout with the school from it.

ZuliKyanLarsFoz · 06/07/2022 15:43

That is an absolutely ridiculous reason for a detention. I'd love to hear their response justifying that!

BuffaloCauliflower · 06/07/2022 15:42

I’d definitely complain, you’re not being ‘that’ parent she shouldn’t have had a detention at all, what a ridiculous punishment especially when the food did fit! Not allowing a T1 diabetic to eat is also very dangerous, she could have ended up in hospital.

Wishihadanalgorithm · 06/07/2022 15:42

I am a teacher and really believe in tough love but this has made me gasp! The teacher has been OTT. What a ridiculous punishment for a minor inconvenience. Seriously, they sound like a bully.

I would be sending the email in and awaiting a reply. I would be emailing the line manager of the teacher as well. They need to know what poor judgment the teacher has displayed.

PuckeredArseFace · 06/07/2022 15:39

T1D and no lunch? I'd complain for that alone
A large container could mean anything

Mariposista · 06/07/2022 15:36

So she is a well behaved child with a medical condition who made a mistake over the container size and got a punishment. It’s not like she forgot! If that is how they treat the good kids I dread to think how they treat the bad. If I were her I would think what is the point in trying hard. Take it all the way OP.

Bagpuss2022 · 06/07/2022 15:36

I will email a carefully worded email I do agree DD should of been listening and taking note in her planner but the fact it actually fitted and a lunch time detention when lunch is only 30 minutes.
the only reason I haven’t gone in all guns blazing is I have had two sons go through the same school they age adults now and one is also type 1 diabetic and they were brilliant with him and so far same with DD.
i may request she only has after school detentions with my prior notice on future although this won’t happen she’s too well behaved,.
the school on the whole is a brilliant school I don’t want to sully that relationship but I would do anything to protect my DC and am willing to be that parent

OP posts:
Tothemoonandbackx · 06/07/2022 15:33

She's Diabetic!!!!!!!! DEFINITELY DEFINITELY complain.....Pleeeeeeeease, this could have been way more serious, I'm Type 1 and know what it's like when you don't get the chance to eat properly, she could have gone into a Hypo if it wasnt for the fact she'd had a sandwich earlier,

ShadowoftheFall · 06/07/2022 15:33

This is exactly the type of thing that has made me decide to home educate. And I was a goody two shoes monitor and head girl in my day.

DayreeMilk · 06/07/2022 15:31

I'd also speak to them, very OTT response from the school,

Swipe left for the next trending thread