Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher insulting my daughter

336 replies

Lua1978 · 06/07/2022 10:59

I work as a teacher at the same secondary school my daughter attends. In the staff workroom yesterday, a couple of teachers were discussing which two pupils they'd overheard saying something about something another pupil had done which they needed to report as a safeguarding concern.

When one of these teachers (who clearly has no clue it's my daughter she's referring to) starts going into great depth discussing one of the girls appearance as they couldn't remember her name... all very personal comments. She then remembered the pupils name and said "oh yeah it's (dds name)" she's got a very unusual name and the only one in the school for sure.

TBH if they had said poorly applied fake tan and skirt rolled up to short I'd have thought fair enough! I'm not overly precious about my daughter but these comments were really personal. I just sat there absolutely stunned and then walked out as honestly I was going to lose my temper or cry if I didn't and I'm normally a really calm person who doesn't get worked up about stuff.

Should I report it- it was really unprofessional, obviously she had no clue it's my daughter but it was so derogatory

OP posts:
CauliWobble · 06/07/2022 15:00

The staffroom is a private space for teachers to decompress from the stresses of the classroom. it's not private from the other teachers though. Would you think it acceptable for a doctor to be derogatory about a patient's appearance in the staff room? I hope not.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 06/07/2022 14:57

echt · 06/07/2022 11:31

On, not one!!!

And to elaborate, if this problem was about a person at work hearing "personal" comments, posters would be saying we can't help as we don't know what you mean by personal.

No, not echt, echt.

The question, like all questions here, is one of principle - it has to be, because, as you say, no one here can ever know all there is to know - the context, both sides, all that. We have to take every OP's word for what went on - it's the only source we've got.

So the issue is, "If you overheard a teacher saying something personal..."

To want to know what exactly was said smacks of prurience, frankly.

EnidSpyton · 06/07/2022 14:52

The staffroom is a private space for teachers to decompress from the stresses of the classroom.

No child hears what a teacher says about them in the staffroom. Just like teachers (most of the time!) don't hear what the children say about us once our backs are turned!

I know I've certainly used choice language about pupils to colleagues after a trying lesson. And yes, sometimes we do have a bit of a giggle over children's interesting fashion choices. We're human! It doesn't mean we don''t care about the kids and aren't 100% professional when working with them.

Teachers aren't expected to be paragons of virtue. I'm sorry you overheard something unpleasant about your dd, OP, but this is not something to complain about to any senior member of staff. If you're really that upset about it, then speak to the teacher directly. However, if you wouldn't have been upset if the child being discussed had not been your daughter, then it's probably something you need to just let go.

Movingdecisions · 06/07/2022 14:48

If a pupil had been heard describing the physical appearance of a teacher in this tone (or how I have taken from the OPs post the tone was) she would probably have been pulled up wouldn’t she?

Young girls especially have enough to contend with without teachers being happy to have a dig at their appearance at school- even if not in front of the girl it was at school, and she thought it fine to speak that way.

Respect is earned not an automatic right and some teachers would do remember that this is mutual.

hopefully she’s reeling now someone has filled her in on your connection to DD.. but probably not, some teachers (as with all people) just think they are above being civil.

CauliWobble · 06/07/2022 14:46

Have just seen the post with the comments. Absolutely out of order and I would complain. They need to treat the children with respect. I wouldn't be happy if someone said this about an adult in a care home why would it be acceptable just because its children. I'd go so far as to say they should face disciplinary action.

Energydrink · 06/07/2022 14:42

Sunbun19 · 06/07/2022 11:19

I don't think I could have resisted telling her there and then that she was talking about my daughter, imagine how mortified she would have felt

Same!

HollowTalk · 06/07/2022 14:42

Her comments were really horrible. I think I'd speak to my line manager about it for now, before deciding whether to take it further or just approach the woman.

naturemumma · 06/07/2022 14:41

Topseyt123 · 06/07/2022 14:37

I'd seek out the teachers concerned and tell them that in future you would appreciate it if they could approach you when there is a problem with your daughter's behaviour. Say that you would prefer them to discuss things properly with you rather than making personal remarks about your DD's appearance in your earshot. Tell them bluntly that you did not appreciate that at all and that you found it both upsetting and unprofessional.

That would be my approach rather than escalating it. I hope they apologise.

This.

hangrylady · 06/07/2022 14:39

Aquilegia23 · 06/07/2022 14:28

As I said, it might not have passed today's rigid standards but it gave us all a laugh.
How many sets of pearls are you wearing?

Give it a rest, you'll be calling me a 'snowflake' next, or some other cutting insult you've picked up from the Daily Mail.

naturemumma · 06/07/2022 14:39

CoastalWave · 06/07/2022 13:16

Ok.

I stand by what I wrote about it being odd not knowing your colleagues especially in a school. For those asking, I worked in retail. To get your job done, you simply HAD to know and speak to your colleagues. That WAS doing my job.

After reading your update :

You should have confronted her there and then - SLT or not.

You obviously only recognised they were talking about her after how they described her!

It's not nice, it's not kind and wasn't great for you to have heard. I would have confronted there and then rather than letting it become an issue.

I would agree with those posters tho who are saying - 2000 pupils - you can't simply say small girl with brown hair, you could literally be talking about 100+ kids.

If her eyebrows and her resting face are a distinguishing feature, that's what you're going to describe. Would you rather they'd said, she's got enormous boobs or she's a 'big girl' - I think the latter is more polite.

I still don't understand why a teacher, who's used to dealing with confrontation day in day out off the kids, would have simply clammed up and walked off? A simple, Hi, sorry are you talking about X in Y's class? That's actually my daughter, can I help out at all?

Surely the teacher should have known the name of the child in the first place. Pretty strange that she didn't. It's not as if it's early in the year. If knowing the name was enough then clearly there wasn't the need for any descriptors, unkind or otherwise.

K8Shrop · 06/07/2022 14:38

Wombat100 · 06/07/2022 14:05

There are so many paragons of virtue on mumsnet!!

In an ideal world, the teacher shouldn’t have said what she did. However, we don’t live in an ideal world and we’ve all no doubt described someone using terms we wouldn’t actually say to their face - eg. Big girl/stick thin girl, enormous eyebrows, frizzy hair, big boobs, orange tan…that’s life. Not ideal but it is.

Can the OP honestly say she’s never said something about someone that she wouldn’t say to their face?

The student didn’t hear these things so she’s unaffected. I would drop it and move on personally.

Would you be saying the same thing if it was other girls in the school saying it about her daughter? If other students were going around calling her this and that.

No, it would be classed as bullying.

Why isn't it classed as bullying if it's a teacher saying it? Why on earth are teachers being allowed to abide to lower standards than students?

Topseyt123 · 06/07/2022 14:37

I'd seek out the teachers concerned and tell them that in future you would appreciate it if they could approach you when there is a problem with your daughter's behaviour. Say that you would prefer them to discuss things properly with you rather than making personal remarks about your DD's appearance in your earshot. Tell them bluntly that you did not appreciate that at all and that you found it both upsetting and unprofessional.

That would be my approach rather than escalating it. I hope they apologise.

Aquilegia23 · 06/07/2022 14:35

Wombat100 · 06/07/2022 14:05

There are so many paragons of virtue on mumsnet!!

In an ideal world, the teacher shouldn’t have said what she did. However, we don’t live in an ideal world and we’ve all no doubt described someone using terms we wouldn’t actually say to their face - eg. Big girl/stick thin girl, enormous eyebrows, frizzy hair, big boobs, orange tan…that’s life. Not ideal but it is.

Can the OP honestly say she’s never said something about someone that she wouldn’t say to their face?

The student didn’t hear these things so she’s unaffected. I would drop it and move on personally.

How true. We seem to have become a society of "what can I find to be offended about today?"

daisybrown37 · 06/07/2022 14:29

I worked in a secondary. c 200 staff and 2,000 kids.

Staff were rarely together, lunch was grabbed in the classroom or department office. Breaks were staggered and staff were on duty in playgrounds.

There was very little opportunity for the water cooler chats you may have elsewhere and we certainly would not have known which staff member had a child in school or which class etc.

Aquilegia23 · 06/07/2022 14:28

hangrylady · 06/07/2022 14:23

It's not about being professional, it's about not being a cunt when talking about young people and how they look. I also don't think the 70s is a good benchmark of how people should behave!

As I said, it might not have passed today's rigid standards but it gave us all a laugh.
How many sets of pearls are you wearing?

5zeds · 06/07/2022 14:27

Girls rolled up their skirts in the eighties. It’s fairly standard teenage behaviour. Fake tan surely isn’t a problem. Who cares what colour her skin is.

imo when at work you don’t make personal comments and certainly not about teenagers.

Aquilegia23 · 06/07/2022 14:27

MsTSwift · 06/07/2022 13:42

Lua I feel your pain about the skirt rolling. If a poster can provide a solution to this problem I’m all ears.

It's the school that needs to deal with it. At my local grammar school, the rules about uniform include how many stripes a tie should be showing, shirts have to have the top button closed, and the length of girls' skirts. Its last Ofsted report was outstanding.

Flossflower · 06/07/2022 14:26

@passthetena no it is not acceptable to call someone a brat because of their appearance. When I wrote my post Idid not know what had been said. OP has now told us.
My sympathy is with the daughter but not the OP who doesn't accept when she is in the staff room she is a teacher and not her daughter's mother.
I was a pupil with a parent who was a teacher at my school. I found some teachers were too nice to me and some were horrible

hangrylady · 06/07/2022 14:23

Aquilegia23 · 06/07/2022 14:02

In the seventies when I taught, there were lots of conversations about pupils.

A couple of gems I distinctly remember are:

About a talk, pale lad, "He looks like a stick of forced rhubarb."

And a girl, "She takes after her mother, except that she's clean shaven. "

I'm sure the pearl clutchers will be along in a minute. It might not have been 'professional' but it was bloody funny.

It's not about being professional, it's about not being a cunt when talking about young people and how they look. I also don't think the 70s is a good benchmark of how people should behave!

girlfriend44 · 06/07/2022 14:21

why didnt you say thats my daughter your talking about.

Ive done this when overheard people talking about my partner its great make the squirm lol.

Philisophigal · 06/07/2022 14:12

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

MidwichCuckoo · 06/07/2022 14:12

Mammajay · 06/07/2022 14:09

Hard to know without knowing the comments. Would it have been ok had they said the girl was a slender pretty girl? I would have an issue if the comments were sexualised

Op has told us the comments now in her 12.51 post

Mammajay · 06/07/2022 14:09

Hard to know without knowing the comments. Would it have been ok had they said the girl was a slender pretty girl? I would have an issue if the comments were sexualised

EmeraldShamrock1 · 06/07/2022 14:06

The vast majority have no issues speaking in a derogatory about the children in their charge to other volunteers and sometimes even other parents. I was shocked when I noticed it first. I suppose it's their way of dealing with the stresses and frustrations of volunteering. I would never ever do this.
No, they're just bitter judgemental cows that haven't learned that if there's nothing nice to say, say nothing.
Unfortunately this carry on IME is mostly from women against other women and worse used against younger women whom they should be bringing up not bringing down, there is enough abuse towards them without joining in.
I've learned as a parent that other parents lie and gossip about DC and their families.
Awful behaviour.

Wombat100 · 06/07/2022 14:05

There are so many paragons of virtue on mumsnet!!

In an ideal world, the teacher shouldn’t have said what she did. However, we don’t live in an ideal world and we’ve all no doubt described someone using terms we wouldn’t actually say to their face - eg. Big girl/stick thin girl, enormous eyebrows, frizzy hair, big boobs, orange tan…that’s life. Not ideal but it is.

Can the OP honestly say she’s never said something about someone that she wouldn’t say to their face?

The student didn’t hear these things so she’s unaffected. I would drop it and move on personally.

Swipe left for the next trending thread