Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what HR actually is?

106 replies

SummerDays95 · 06/07/2022 10:52

So I'm looking for a complete career change from teaching, been doing it for 7 years since I left uni. I've been looking at jobs in companies that I like the sound of as a starting point, as I have absolutely no clue! HR admin assistant has come up quite a lot, and I like the sound of it and I think it would suit my skillset. I don't know much about it and don't think I'm in a position to apply just yet, but would like to learn. Day to day, what does it involve, and what sort of qualifications would I need? I've never worked in admin before!

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 07/07/2022 11:51

Why on earth would we want to make people's lives more difficult?

I’ll tell you. Based on experience:

  • wishing to seem important, and key to the business, HR decides to design a lavish training programme in e.g. gender. Everybody in the business is required to do this training, which takes several hours, when a short ‘click through’ online presentation would have done the job just as well. HR can’t congratulate themselves about that, though, can they? So they make everyone’s life difficult for their own selfish ends.
  • HR make a mistake with something (examples from my experience include making an incorrect offer to a candidate, losing a candidate’s passport, failing to check whether a new starter has passed probation until two months after probation has been passed by which time it’s too late to do anything, failing to take up references, failing to adjust the payroll file when explicitly asked to do so, forgetting to file employment returns with HMRC and overseas tax authorities etc etc). Unwilling to take responsibility for their own mistakes, they turn spiteful and passive aggressive and try to assign blame to somebody else. Including organising calls and meetings where their sole aim is declaring that it wasn’t their fault, and to which they invite senior people, whose time would be better spent elsewhere. Making colleagues’ lives difficult.
  • Having been exposed as incompetent by reason of mistakes including the sample described above, HR become passive aggressive and work to rule, e.g. deliberately dragging their feet when onboarding new members of staff, being secretive about processes and SLAs. Thus making everyone’s lives difficult and damaging the business.
  • insisting on unwieldy and not fit for purpose processes being followed. The processes don’t work for the business, nor do they mitigate risk. HR can’t even explain what risks they are supposed to mitigate. Nevertheless HR designed them and want to force everyone to use them, so that they can wield a pathetic bit of power over the colleagues doing the real work. Making their colleagues’ lives difficult.
  • HR forget to end date a leaver, such that we end up paying the person for months after they leave. Then whine that it’s too difficult to get the money back from the leaver, and doing so is making them anxious because the person with all the free money is crying and pleading poverty. Requiring somebody else, with a spine, to take over and making everyone else’s life difficult.
I could go on. Would you like me to? These are my real experiences. I’m a 50 year old finance director. I’ve worked in senior finance for many years, in nine different organisations. I can genuinely say that I have only ever worked with three good HR people in all that time. Getting precious and calling your critics ‘bitter’ isn’t helping your cause of rehabilitating the reputation of HR.
ThreeRingCircus · 07/07/2022 11:30

Iamthewombat · 07/07/2022 11:15

Touched a nerve, eh? No, I’m not bitter, don’t worry. I am very honest about my experiences of HR though, and you’re not doing much to contradict them.

I'm very sorry you've had some bad experiences. As I said, there are good and bad in all industries and it's very dependent on the organisation you are in. I'm not ashamed to say you did touch a nerve, yes. Because my colleagues and I are all normal women, working hard and trying to get the balance right for our organisation and our employees. If you were an ordinary employee in our organisation you would have no idea of the work we do every day because it's behind the scenes and if all is going well, that work is invisible to you. Why on earth would we want to make people's lives more difficult? Having the right people in the right jobs and ensuring the company acts legally and treats its employees well gets the best out of everyone. I guess maybe I'm lucky to work for a decent and progressive company doing good work.

You're totally entitled to your opinion but you're the one calling us spiteful and that we have no value. I personally think that makes you sound bitter and unpleasant. We're all entitled to our opinions after all!

Iamthewombat · 07/07/2022 11:15

ThreeRingCircus · 07/07/2022 08:10

Do you get pleasure from being so nasty? Lots of HR staff (including me) have tried to make helpful contributions to this thread and of course HR departments are vastly different depending on the organisation you work for. I've met some crap ones, I've met some amazing ones but your post just reads like you're very bitter.

Touched a nerve, eh? No, I’m not bitter, don’t worry. I am very honest about my experiences of HR though, and you’re not doing much to contradict them.

hangrylady · 07/07/2022 10:48

D0lphine · 06/07/2022 14:18

To be in HR:

  • have 0 people skills and no likability but on the other hand be very thoroughly convinced you're a "people person"
  • escalate workplace grievances
  • cover sexual misconduct with NDAs
  • protect the company (rather than the employees) at all costs
  • gossip for 80% of your work day
  • force sick people out of a job
  • confidently state an employment position with no knowledge of the law.

So accurate. Some of the worst people I've ever met work in HR.

Dotjones · 07/07/2022 10:17

HR is Human Resources. It means managing a resource in a way that makes the company the most money. Think of it as akin to an office manager who goes to great length to secure the cheapest stationery and cuts cleaning down to a bare minumum to reduce costs as much as possible whilst providing an acceptable level of service.

That's what HR does, it's just that the "resource" for HR happens to be human beings. Efficient HR staff are able to avoid thinking of workers as human beings though, they are just another resource for the company like raw materials are a resource in manufacturing. HR need to ensure that the company spends as little as possible on staff, minimizing pay rises, not replacing leavers if the work can be transferred to other employees, and trimming headcount to the lowest possible number.

HR professionals need a special mindset. It's too easy to think of the human cost when deciding to do away with jobs with the stroke of a pen. HR people can compartmentalise this, not worry about making people redundant for example and taking away their livelihood.

SirChenjins · 07/07/2022 10:00

I’m afraid I have to agree with posters who say they are there to protect the business. Our HR dept is very much for us managers in helping us to apply policies to the letter and to using our managerial discretion to the benefit of the organisation not the staff. I tend to use them for recruitment, dealing with challenging staff and support with our online HR systems but for everything else I i

Vieve1325 · 07/07/2022 09:52

Some of the opinions on this thread about HR Professionals are sad. I’m not taking away or nullifying folks personal experiences (there’s good and bad in every profession), but all the same some of the opinions spouted on here are rather venomous.

Thing is though, historically, a high performing and effective HR Department would operate with no awareness from the average employee - we were the silent partners, the WD40 on the cogs.

The only exposure people would then get would be the ‘bad’ stuff - disciplinaries, redundancies etc.

I find myself supporting employees against over firm, over zealous or underprepared management more than I’ll ever ‘protect the business’ and yes you can argue that would be protecting the business to a degree but is it so hard to actually believe that there’s HR Professionals who genuinely do want people to be treated right whilst they’re at work?

At the end of the day, we are there to help the business succeed - but so is EVERY ROLE in the business. That is why businesses employ people. It just so happens our role is helping with the people aspect- and by the way people can be real dicks.

FortonServices · 07/07/2022 09:25

OP have a look at Civil Service Jobs. They are often open to career changers.

FortonServices · 07/07/2022 09:23

It's a huge misconception that HR are there to look after staff, they are not. They are there to protect the business.

Goes back to the tea and tampax days of personnel.

FortonServices · 07/07/2022 09:21

Covidagainandagain · 06/07/2022 11:02

I will let the actual HR people tell you about HR - but just wanted to say that if you have been in teaching have you considered a learning and development role? They quite often sit within a HR function and are responsible for general training and development of staff, running workshops, coaching etc. With your background you could be a good fit.

I came on to say this.

Look at the CIPD website too OP. I believe there is an option to specialise in L&D while doing the CIPD now as well.

If you're a teacher, I assume you will already have a post grad level qual? So I'd go straight to CIPD L7 and study while working to gain the experience to go with the qual.

OverTheRubicon · 07/07/2022 09:19

Am I one of the 'HR apologists'? I'm not in HR, but do work with them often. Ultimately though, they're aligned with management and therefore just like if you had a thread asking high school students about their teachers, you're going to get a disproportionate number of responses from the smaller number people who think they're all tyrants.
In the school example, some of those students will unfortunately be having a horrible time at the hands of poor teachers, some will be unhappy because they're lacking the support they need (whether due to poor management or because what they need is beyond the scope of the school), and some will have be the cause of their own problems, but be unable to see it, and blame it on others.

Personally HR isn't for me because I prefer to be a player than a coach or manager. However, I'm in a technical role and while I often recommend those types of jobs to career changes, it doesn't lend itself to what you're saying about a job you don't take home - and the reality is that operations and management roles are important too. I bet that lots of the people complaining would be much more upset if they didn't have someone to manage and benchmark their benefits, or to show the CEO why the gender pay gap report is embarrassing and something needs to be done, or ensure you have a valid contract, or ringfence a training budget.

Last one on that... Loads of people here recommending learning and development, I'd be really cautious about that given we're heading into a recession. HR is going to be busy with the large number of redundancies to come, but training budgets will be slashed. Might be a hard time to move there.

ThreeRingCircus · 07/07/2022 08:10

Iamthewombat · 07/07/2022 00:15

You’ve obviously worked in the same businesses as me. But you left out dithering when asked a question and falling back on, “but every case is different!” to disguise ignorance. And making up ‘initiatives’ to keep themselves busy and bolster their own self-esteem.

We’ve had a contribution from an HR apologist (it entertains me that all the people I’ve ever met who worked in HR are desperate to convince everyone doing the proper work that they, HR are very important and key to the business. Why is that, I wonder? It’s almost as if they know that nobody can see any value in what they do):

At it’s (sic) heart, HR is about managing the people-assets (sic) of a company. Recruiting and retaining the best talent at the best price. Managing the supply and demand of labour and skills through the business. Part of the hatred of the role is that people don’t like the dispassionate nature of that

Yeah, that’s right. We dislike your cool, dispassionate natures. Funny that. Everyone I’ve ever encountered in HR, and I’ve worked at a senior level in many businesses, has been passive aggressive, sulky and spiteful. The exact opposite of dispassionate, in fact.

Do you get pleasure from being so nasty? Lots of HR staff (including me) have tried to make helpful contributions to this thread and of course HR departments are vastly different depending on the organisation you work for. I've met some crap ones, I've met some amazing ones but your post just reads like you're very bitter.

ThreeRingCircus · 07/07/2022 08:03

Littlegoth · 06/07/2022 14:21

I left teaching for HR after 10 years and have been working in HR for almost as long now.

I would never go back! You might find you naturally fall into something like talent development in HR.

I worked as an HR administrator - first point of contact, preparing contract paperwork, Data entry, and maintaining accurate data on the systems. From there I went into talent management, training and development, looking after apprentices (very pastoral, almost like tutor groups, so was familiar!).
I’m now working in the public sector doing a bit of everything from HR advice, training, recruitment, admin and data analysis.

There are quite a few former teachers in HR - the skills are so transferable. I completed a CIPD level 3 over distance learning in my last year of teaching - I would recommend doing this as it’s competitive breaking into HR, and then again making the move from administrator to advisor so I once you have the level 3 you should consider doing CIPD level 5 once you are in an administrator role. No regrets, other than sticking out teaching so long in the hopes it would get better.

I agree with this and am also an ex teacher working in HR. There are quite a few of us! I too started as an HR Administrator then worked my way up from there. I'd say an HR Admin role can be really busy, often doing mundane stuff like answering emails and sending out contracts but if you find the right organisation it can also be really broad and give you insight into lots of different areas of HR. It's also a female-heavy profession and I've personally had some excellent female managers willing to champion me and help me progress my career.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 07/07/2022 08:03

Hr, send out contracts no one likes with draconian rulings.
To offset these rulings Hr then invests in promoting perks as a tangible alternative to real hard cold cash.
Basically, snake oil salespeople used to pacify/punish employees.
in tribunals, Hr is usually annihilated by employment lawyers and emotional appeals of former employers.
Not naming names.
😂😁

ToastofLandon · 07/07/2022 07:55

I think you’d be bored in HR Admin OP.

I’ve met a lot of ex-teachers in Learning & Development roles over the years - instructional designer, learning designer, technical author being a few job titles you may be interested in looking at.

Anothernamechangeplease · 07/07/2022 07:17

One of my old HR business partners left HR having gone into it because she liked people but having subsequently realised that you typically see the very worst of people in an HR role - you're constantly dealing with the stressful stuff, such as working relationships going wrong, people failing at their jobs or being made redundant etc. HR typically gets involved when there is something difficult going on in order to ensure that the correct procedures are followed. Nobody needs you you when everything is going well, so a lot of the work has quite a negative focus tbh.

Given your teaching background, a learning and development role might suit you, though, and it would have a more positive focus than many other aspects of the HR function.

WineIsMyMainVice · 07/07/2022 00:32

I’ve worked in HR for 20+ years in all kinds of industries/sectors - manufacturing, production, retail, local government, sales - multi national companies to family run companies. It’s really sad to hear so many bad experiences of HR.
If you want to DM me OP feel free, as I’ll be happy to talk openly about the job - warts and all!! 🤣
Like any industry - if you’re good at what you do, and you’re in it for the right reasons - you can make a difference!!

WineIsMyMainVice · 07/07/2022 00:21

InChocolateWeTrust · 06/07/2022 11:05

HR function manages staff.

So its everything from recruiting new staff, onboarding them, it can cover organising training, performance management and appraisals, rewards/benefits/payroll.

You need:

  • good people skills. HR are often involved when people are in a vulnerable position and need sensitive attention - managing redundancy, poor performance, maternity leaves, sickness absence especially long term
  • be super organised and good at responding promptly to emails
  • it's good to be fairly literate - HR need to be able to spot & amend details in employment contracts, sometimes will be drafting absence policies and job ads etc.

Obviously like anything at a junior level it will be more basic and generic

It is not the responsibility of HR to manage staff. That is for the line managers to do.

i completely agree with the latter part of your post about some of the skills required though.

WineIsMyMainVice · 07/07/2022 00:18

Arsewangry · 06/07/2022 11:14

Worth bearing in mind that for a lot of HR roles you will be expected to have (or at very least be working towards) a CIPD qualification.

It's a huge misconception that HR are there to look after staff, they are not. They are there to protect the business.

Someone who speaks some sense comes along! Thank you!!

Iamthewombat · 07/07/2022 00:15

D0lphine · 06/07/2022 14:18

To be in HR:

  • have 0 people skills and no likability but on the other hand be very thoroughly convinced you're a "people person"
  • escalate workplace grievances
  • cover sexual misconduct with NDAs
  • protect the company (rather than the employees) at all costs
  • gossip for 80% of your work day
  • force sick people out of a job
  • confidently state an employment position with no knowledge of the law.

You’ve obviously worked in the same businesses as me. But you left out dithering when asked a question and falling back on, “but every case is different!” to disguise ignorance. And making up ‘initiatives’ to keep themselves busy and bolster their own self-esteem.

We’ve had a contribution from an HR apologist (it entertains me that all the people I’ve ever met who worked in HR are desperate to convince everyone doing the proper work that they, HR are very important and key to the business. Why is that, I wonder? It’s almost as if they know that nobody can see any value in what they do):

At it’s (sic) heart, HR is about managing the people-assets (sic) of a company. Recruiting and retaining the best talent at the best price. Managing the supply and demand of labour and skills through the business. Part of the hatred of the role is that people don’t like the dispassionate nature of that

Yeah, that’s right. We dislike your cool, dispassionate natures. Funny that. Everyone I’ve ever encountered in HR, and I’ve worked at a senior level in many businesses, has been passive aggressive, sulky and spiteful. The exact opposite of dispassionate, in fact.

SavoirFlair · 07/07/2022 00:14

on the other hand i've yet to meet an HR person that has an ounce of common sense or (in my particular career) even a basic comprehension of what we make, how we make profit and what our engineers actually do. it's a constant shock to me how senior some pretty stupid people can go in a company if they wave the HR flag. and i say that as someone in a senior leadership role - how they are sitting on the same bench as some of my CFO, COO colleagues i have no idea. they don't bring anywhere near the same skill or value to the organisation.

Unfortunately I can attest to this. But worse, they have now started in the last decade naming themselves HR Business Partners.

as if the last two words will now magically make folk appear strategic and align themselves with understanding the business or more likely command a higher salary for appearing such

HR Business Partner is the biggest misnomer since the Office for Budget Responsibility.

SavoirFlair · 07/07/2022 00:13

on the other hand i've yet to meet an HR person that has an ounce of common sense or (in my particular career) even a basic comprehension of what we make, how we make profit and what our engineers actually do. it's a constant shock to me how senior some pretty stupid people can go in a company if they wave the HR flag. and i say that as someone in a senior leadership role - how they are sitting on the same bench as some of my CFO, COO colleagues i have no idea. they don't bring anywhere near the same skill or value to the organisation.

Unfortunately I can attest to this. But worse, they have now started in the last decade naming themselves HR Business Partners.

as if the last two words will now magically make folk appear strategic and align themselves with understanding the business or more likely command a higher salary for appearing such

HR Business Partner is the biggest misnomer since the Office for Budget Responsibility.

Notmanybroadbeans · 06/07/2022 23:58

I think it would depend massively on the organisation and the kinds of jobs they have. E.g. a call centre full of people on low-paid zero hour contracts is probably going to involve a lot of hiring, firing, disciplinary matters, staffing rotas and sick leave admin. Some workplaces are heavily unionised and you might find yourself up against union reps, dealing with grievances. A mid-size organisation staffed by skilled professionals doing interesting work might have more of a focus on organisational development and learning. A cash-strapped little company is barely going to manage the basics and might have you staying late sorting out the payroll on an antiquated system. A big wealthy company will have a much bigger department with the opportunity to specialise in whatever interests you.

I don't work in HR but have known many who do (and have worked for various types of organisations).

I don't agree with the post that said HR manage the staff. That's misleading, managers manage their direct reports. Don't go into HR thinking you'll be in charge of people.

OverTheRubicon · 06/07/2022 23:31

whyohehy · 06/07/2022 23:04

@Flowertop845 it's just another way of saying I disagree with you.

It's not though. It's you saying that your 20 years in HR trumps her experience because you 'know what you're talking about'.

There are so many different types of HR departments - I've worked in a highly unionised industry where we all lived in fear of HR (who seemed to be remarkably immune to the redundancies that kept rolling around the rest of the business), but more recently in tech-driven businesses where the HR/People teams are actively helpful and business partners and do good things along with the thought stuff. It can be a really good path for the right people, you just have to pick your employer and role carefully.

Same thing with hours. I've seen really senior people have to do long hours, or sometimes mid level ops people if there is a major reduction in force or union issue going on, but in the places I've worked, the admin and junior team members definitely haven't had to work late, and they've always been the team.with the highest percentage of part time workers even at quite senior levels.

BrightOrion · 06/07/2022 23:09

OP have you considered teaching internationally? I would definitely recommend looking into it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread