Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what HR actually is?

106 replies

SummerDays95 · 06/07/2022 10:52

So I'm looking for a complete career change from teaching, been doing it for 7 years since I left uni. I've been looking at jobs in companies that I like the sound of as a starting point, as I have absolutely no clue! HR admin assistant has come up quite a lot, and I like the sound of it and I think it would suit my skillset. I don't know much about it and don't think I'm in a position to apply just yet, but would like to learn. Day to day, what does it involve, and what sort of qualifications would I need? I've never worked in admin before!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KatherineJaneway · 09/07/2022 06:28

HR gets a lot of hate as you can see OP and there is a lot of misconceptions as to what their purpose is.

HR admin is a good job, it is usually exceptionally busy though from my experience. You have to have a balanced view of things for it to sit right with you. Sometimes employees do not do their jobs correctly and need to be managed out of the business. Sometimes you get a bullying manager but you can't just fire them on the spot, you have to follow procedures.

whirlyswirly · 08/07/2022 20:52

A poster on here sounds remarkably like a very senior bully I worked hard to expose and get sacked. Finest HR moment of my career. Improved the working experience for so many to get them out.

Anyway, the basic answer here is that what HR is depends on your remit, the size of your organisation and the contribution you want to make.

I love my job because no two days are the same and want to add as much value as I can. If moving on, I'd be incredibly choosy about my employer. You need a Board with decent values.

ThreeRingCircus · 08/07/2022 17:19

OverTheRubicon · 08/07/2022 16:12

And some on this thread...

I completely agree😂. However, as a teacher you'll be used to dealing with these types and a lot of the skills are transferable....still treating all people with politeness and professionalism, sometimes having to be firm and explaining things clearly.

Similarly to a PP I'm in a generalist role and I love that because you have the opportunity to be involved in lots of different aspects of HR and see a bit of everything. Every day is different and you don't know what's going to come through the door or land on your desk.

Just this week I've interviewed candidates for a new position, met with a senior manager to discuss succession planning in her team as a number of them are retiring, referred a colleague dealing with substance abuse issues to occupational health, had a performance management meeting with a colleague that isn't performing and his manager and spoken with an employee as part of a regular check in on their mental health and their workload. Plus lots of other less interesting but necessary bits responding to emails, minuting meetings and dealing with payroll.

It's the variety of the job that I like most but it's definitely admin heavy. As you progress you can also end up taking things home with you and stewing on them in the evenings.....the other week I'd spoken to a member of staff having a lot of issues in their personal life and I couldn't sleep for worrying about her but you'll know that from teaching too and it's worse because they're children.

It's a great career for anyone but particularly women as it's often family friendly with lots of options for part time working or lots of career progression opportunities. I've had some amazing female bosses in very senior HR roles that have been really supportive and championed me.

OverTheRubicon · 08/07/2022 16:12

Covidagainandagain · 08/07/2022 10:54

You know how in teaching you get those parents where their little darlings can do no wrong and any marks they miss out on are due to you not doing your job properly?

Well in HR you get to deal with them as employees...

And some on this thread...

NDandMe · 08/07/2022 15:24

L&D sits withing HR, as a teacher that might suit your skills as well.

flashbac · 08/07/2022 15:22

Some people have so much vitriol about HR. Some of the arguments aren't even constructive, just ranty and very bitter. Axe to grind perhaps?
HR professionals are mostly women.
I will make of that what I will.

user143677433 · 08/07/2022 12:37

Wombat, you are the only one arguing 😂I’m just watching you run around in circles tripping over your own ill constructed arguments.

Iamthewombat · 08/07/2022 11:40

user143677433 · 08/07/2022 10:24

Are you ranting at me or just screaming into the void?

I don’t even work in HR, I just have a knowledge of and appreciation of the area because the work I do is related. If you want to insult me personally you’ll have to work a bit harder.

More than one person has mentioned HRBP.
I would suggest you RTFT, but honestly I think you might be better taking a step back.

And the way you misquote me is amusing. You seem to want to imply that I have an agenda “to rehabilitate the reputation of HR”. No, I literally just have an interest that people misconstrue the role of HRBP because of the title.

I’m ticking off the cliches one by one.

Anybody who expresses an opinion you don’t like ‘doesn’t understand’ or ‘misconstrues’.

Anybody who wins an argument with you is ‘ranting’ or ‘screaming into the void’. I’d suggest that you take the step back: you clearly can’t cope with criticism, even when you work in a ‘related field’ rather than HR. Is your ‘related field’ even more pointless than HR, I wonder, and that’s why you’re so sensitive?

Mrsherdwick · 08/07/2022 10:56

Forever forgetting to send stuff to payroll ie new starters/leavers etc and then demanding payroll sorts it out immediately.

Covidagainandagain · 08/07/2022 10:54

You know how in teaching you get those parents where their little darlings can do no wrong and any marks they miss out on are due to you not doing your job properly?

Well in HR you get to deal with them as employees...

kewgirl · 08/07/2022 10:30

It is box ticking PC nonsense

user143677433 · 08/07/2022 10:24

Iamthewombat · 08/07/2022 09:21

One poster described somebody working at board level whose title was ‘HR business partner’. Whilst generally speaking, HRBPs are much more junior, it’s the prerogative of each business to assign job titles as they see fit.

On the strength of this single post about one organisation, you have decided that “many” posters “don’t understand” HR. This sort of petty behaviour does nothing to rehabilitate the reputation of HR and makes you sound vindictive. “Criticise HR, would you? Well, I’ll call you stupid to get you back!”

Sadly, this type of personality is rife in HR. Petulant and passive aggressive. Basically, you are administrators but you just can’t settle for that. Like children, you constantly seek attention and want to sit at the big table. You have to pretend to be ‘creating a culture’ and ‘designing an organisation’. The people doing the real jobs are perfectly capable of that. You just need to get the basics right which, as I note in previous posts, has not been my experience across nine different organisations.

Are you ranting at me or just screaming into the void?

I don’t even work in HR, I just have a knowledge of and appreciation of the area because the work I do is related. If you want to insult me personally you’ll have to work a bit harder.

More than one person has mentioned HRBP.
I would suggest you RTFT, but honestly I think you might be better taking a step back.

And the way you misquote me is amusing. You seem to want to imply that I have an agenda “to rehabilitate the reputation of HR”. No, I literally just have an interest that people misconstrue the role of HRBP because of the title.

maddening · 08/07/2022 09:35

Hr deal with the admin activities of managing staff, all the paperwork, payroll etc making sure processes have been followed properly and supporting the management team at all levels to manage their staff.

Iamthewombat · 08/07/2022 09:25

Worriedatwork1 · 07/07/2022 22:13

Wow, some wonderfully brutal views of HR here, good job we’re used to being the traffic wardens of the corporate world and have thick skins!

Really? My experience of HR people is that they have the thinnest skins of any colleagues. That’s what makes them petty and passive aggressive.

Iamthewombat · 08/07/2022 09:21

user143677433 · 07/07/2022 21:37

What is interesting this from this thread is the realisation of how many people don’t know what “HR Business Partner” means. If you are expecting them to be board/partner/c-level then it is small wonder you are disappointed.

One poster described somebody working at board level whose title was ‘HR business partner’. Whilst generally speaking, HRBPs are much more junior, it’s the prerogative of each business to assign job titles as they see fit.

On the strength of this single post about one organisation, you have decided that “many” posters “don’t understand” HR. This sort of petty behaviour does nothing to rehabilitate the reputation of HR and makes you sound vindictive. “Criticise HR, would you? Well, I’ll call you stupid to get you back!”

Sadly, this type of personality is rife in HR. Petulant and passive aggressive. Basically, you are administrators but you just can’t settle for that. Like children, you constantly seek attention and want to sit at the big table. You have to pretend to be ‘creating a culture’ and ‘designing an organisation’. The people doing the real jobs are perfectly capable of that. You just need to get the basics right which, as I note in previous posts, has not been my experience across nine different organisations.

whirlyswirly · 07/07/2022 22:54

I'm head of hr in a lovely, ethical company where I don't feel compromised. I work closely with the exec directors, sit on a Board committee and get asked my view on virtually anything people-linked so I must not be too loathed.

I've done cipd to level 7, have an operational and commercial background (which really helps) and spend a lot of time on organisation design - finding the best way to use the collective skills of our people to deliver our strategy and designing new/better jobs for them is massively rewarding.

I have to say that I sometimes find networking events with other hr folk hard work. Although it's my job, I do see what other posters are referring to. There are some amazing people in hr, and some I don't feel are in it for the right reasons. Knowing confidential information is a burden and a privilege and the responsibility should never be taken lightly.

Worriedatwork1 · 07/07/2022 22:34

OP I think HR is a brilliant job, however it varies massively dependent on sector, workplace culture and individual team. I’ve done almost 20 years in a range of organisations and every single day is different. It can be hard and you can end up in situations where you feel compromised at times, but it can also be wonderful and rewarding when you’re involved in a success story. I wouldn’t do anything else other than generalist HR as I love the variety and challenge

Worriedatwork1 · 07/07/2022 22:13

Wow, some wonderfully brutal views of HR here, good job we’re used to being the traffic wardens of the corporate world and have thick skins!

user143677433 · 07/07/2022 21:37

What is interesting this from this thread is the realisation of how many people don’t know what “HR Business Partner” means. If you are expecting them to be board/partner/c-level then it is small wonder you are disappointed.

Jasminejoy · 07/07/2022 21:34

D0lphine · 06/07/2022 14:18

To be in HR:

  • have 0 people skills and no likability but on the other hand be very thoroughly convinced you're a "people person"
  • escalate workplace grievances
  • cover sexual misconduct with NDAs
  • protect the company (rather than the employees) at all costs
  • gossip for 80% of your work day
  • force sick people out of a job
  • confidently state an employment position with no knowledge of the law.

These comments are actually very professionally offensive to many of us in senior HR positions.

The vast majority of my day is challenging leaders who want to take action that is not aligned with our company values, disciplining misconduct that damages our culture and impacts employees to whom we have a duty of care and dealing with sensitive employee issues with authentic empathy.

Luckily I work for a company that empowers me to that but please don't denigrate an entire profession because you may have had a poor experience.

BTcherokii · 07/07/2022 21:26

a high performing and effective HR Department would operate with no awareness from the average employee - we were the silent partners, the WD40 on the cogs.

holy cow, this sums up the egotism of every HR person i've worked with and met.

the level of self importance and worth in the (overly excessive) salaries commanded vs. their peers is astounding, and commonplace at every place i've ever worked with.

for example, i once worked with a brand new hire - a "senior" hire badged as an HR Business Partner. her profile and online branding talked about talent retention, business talent planning, staff retention, employee relations.. she looked amazing on paper. unforunately the reality was that she was little more than an admin pen pusher who didn't deserve to sit on the same boards as the extremely skilled and hard-working seniors in her rank.. it really did do women a disservice to see her pretending that she was of similar benefit/skill to the CFO, COO, CTO, etc.

as a women in a technical leadership position, i don't want female peers pretending they're a "woman in business" alongside me. HR is the biggest load of time wasting nonsense i've ever come across.

replace the contract and performance management stuff with a couple of mid-level legally-trained / union managing peers and shove all the HR folk underneath the COO, IMHO (not as a peer, UNDER them).

there'd be very little real difference to the actual business - no one would miss the WD40, trust me

SummerDays95 · 07/07/2022 20:58

Thanks all, some very helpful replies. I think I will look a bit further into it, maybe have a look at the course and take it from there. It sounds like the kind of thing I would be interested in, but it sounds like that does also depend on the organisation. It does sound exciting though! I'll probably have to do a bit of research into the kind of areas I would be interested in, as it's all completely new to me.

OP posts:
WatchoRulo · 07/07/2022 12:15

I agree with @Iamthewombat - although to be fair, it's not true in every case.
One place I worked had a ridiculous (HR) policy of demanding to see driving licences, insurance, MOT etc even though no car allowance was paid and driving was not in any way part of the job. They cited the possibility that the company could be held liable if someone was driving without everything being properly legal. Such legal action has never happened.

Iamthewombat · 07/07/2022 11:54

I forgot: as soon as their actions are questioned, the default response is, “I don’t like your tone”!

D0lphine · 07/07/2022 11:53

Iamthewombat · 07/07/2022 11:51

Why on earth would we want to make people's lives more difficult?

I’ll tell you. Based on experience:

  • wishing to seem important, and key to the business, HR decides to design a lavish training programme in e.g. gender. Everybody in the business is required to do this training, which takes several hours, when a short ‘click through’ online presentation would have done the job just as well. HR can’t congratulate themselves about that, though, can they? So they make everyone’s life difficult for their own selfish ends.
  • HR make a mistake with something (examples from my experience include making an incorrect offer to a candidate, losing a candidate’s passport, failing to check whether a new starter has passed probation until two months after probation has been passed by which time it’s too late to do anything, failing to take up references, failing to adjust the payroll file when explicitly asked to do so, forgetting to file employment returns with HMRC and overseas tax authorities etc etc). Unwilling to take responsibility for their own mistakes, they turn spiteful and passive aggressive and try to assign blame to somebody else. Including organising calls and meetings where their sole aim is declaring that it wasn’t their fault, and to which they invite senior people, whose time would be better spent elsewhere. Making colleagues’ lives difficult.
  • Having been exposed as incompetent by reason of mistakes including the sample described above, HR become passive aggressive and work to rule, e.g. deliberately dragging their feet when onboarding new members of staff, being secretive about processes and SLAs. Thus making everyone’s lives difficult and damaging the business.
  • insisting on unwieldy and not fit for purpose processes being followed. The processes don’t work for the business, nor do they mitigate risk. HR can’t even explain what risks they are supposed to mitigate. Nevertheless HR designed them and want to force everyone to use them, so that they can wield a pathetic bit of power over the colleagues doing the real work. Making their colleagues’ lives difficult.
  • HR forget to end date a leaver, such that we end up paying the person for months after they leave. Then whine that it’s too difficult to get the money back from the leaver, and doing so is making them anxious because the person with all the free money is crying and pleading poverty. Requiring somebody else, with a spine, to take over and making everyone else’s life difficult.
I could go on. Would you like me to? These are my real experiences. I’m a 50 year old finance director. I’ve worked in senior finance for many years, in nine different organisations. I can genuinely say that I have only ever worked with three good HR people in all that time. Getting precious and calling your critics ‘bitter’ isn’t helping your cause of rehabilitating the reputation of HR.

Agree!

Bonus points if the training is over lunch time and about mental health 🤣

Swipe left for the next trending thread