Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this wasn't handled brilliantly

100 replies

Runlulurunandrun · 05/07/2022 23:26

My DD8 (yr3) has been having friendship problems at school this year with being in/out of a particular group. It's escalated over the last few months and (I think) may be the cause of extremely defiant, difficult behaviour at home as she has a habit of behaving badly at bedtime when she's upset.

To try and solve the problem I went into school to see her teacher to see if they could help by encouraging other friendships, and whether she had any advice for DD (ie was contributing to situations) . I was also going tk mention that DD is scared of the teacher so she won't come to her with a problem, but had good chat with Teacher and saw no need to mention it when it came to it. Teacher was very reassuring, said she'd been bullied at school and she was keen to support DD here - she said she would speak to a 2nd group of friends that DD sometimes plays with to ask them to support DD, and also put her on the list for weekly chat with Senco (Didn't know schools did this as Dd doesn't have SEN.. I think.. But that's another thread!) At one point, I got a bit emotional because I have a very frustrating tendency to cry when stressed! However, all seemed fine and the last week or so DD has been happier, sometimes playing with new friends, sometimes playing with old friendship group happy enough.

Anyway, teacher called me at lunchtime today as there'd been an incident between a group of girls that culminated in them all being taken in at lunch and told off. Apologies, I don't know how to describe the incident without it all sounding terribly petty but it's relevant to me being a bit unsure of the teachers reaction.

Two girls from DD's new friendship group had an argument and DD told a playground assistant as one of them was crying. DD's teacher came out and ordered them all 'Inside Now' ('them' being new and old friendship group who were all somehow involved)

This culminated in DD being formally banned from playing with one of the girls in her previous friendship group (the one she has the most trouble with). Her teacher didn't have much explanation for this except that they'd made the situation worse by getting involved as what was an argument between 2 people became a group drama. I think it was also on the basis that 'everything had been fine till they played together again'.

The arguments are petty and I'm prepared to go with the teachers judgement here, but this is where I'm not sure it was handled well. Most of the six girls that got pulled in ended up crying as they were all shouted at. The teacher complained that she 'was upset dealing with it, had upset children and had upset parents coming in to see her'. It's hard to convey tone with text but it was anger at having to deal with their problems. From what DD says, It sounds to me like she went off at them in a temper and I'm particularly pissed off about the upset parents comment. DD knows that would have been me and I feel pretty annoyed that the teacher has said I was upset! DD is now adamant that I'm not to talk to school again.
My questions are
Is it normal for children to be scared of their teacher?
Is banning children from playing together realistic? We discussed this option when I met the teacher and said we'd leave it. I think it makes life harder for DD
Would you do anything? Or just grit your teeth till the end of term?

FWIW my son is just finishing year six and I've never asked school for help before.

OP posts:
Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 07:03

@Hurstlandshome I am so glad that worked well for your DD and she is happier now.

By councillor do you mean the weekly Senco chat her teacher offered? I was really surprised that they could offer her any practical support and agreed to that which is likely to start next term. DD's teacher offered to put her to the top of the list as it sounded like she could use the support more than the others on the list. Again, this is why I am surprised we've gone from 'here's all the support we can give you' to giving her a bollocking and friendship ban in less than 2 weeks

OP posts:
1AngelicFruitCake · 06/07/2022 07:00

I’m a teacher, girls this age are notorious for friendship problems. Sometimes it’s easier just to ban children playing if they are continually falling out. There is the rest of the class to think of and teaching that nerds to be done. The upset parents comment was probably to show the girls they’re upsetting their parents not just you personally.

SparklingPeach · 06/07/2022 06:57

I've never heard of a primary school child being banned from playing with another child (by the teacher rather than a parent). I'm really surprised that other posters think this is normal.

CanaryShoulderedThorn · 06/07/2022 06:55

It's the end of a long hard year. Everyone's frazzled. I'd keep on keeping calm and then concentrate on having a lovely summer together and a fresh start next year. Maybe have a few sleepovers during the summer holidays with the girls she gets on with.
Our DD had a terrible time at our village primary and it caused a lot of raised eyebrows when we took her out in year 3, but she was much happier in her new school and the old friends have grown into pretty troubled adults (drugs, self harm) despite being from "nice" families.
I don't understand those who say that moving school is wrong as kids need to develop resilience. I argue that it teaches them that they don't have to put up with unhappiness, that they have the power to change their own lives and that they dont have to put up with shit.
I wouldn't stay in a job where I was unhappy.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 06:53

@beautifulworldwhereareyou yes I can see how it can get to that point.

We did discuss it as 'next steps' but not for now and I'd rather it hadn't been done in the heat of the moment as part of a telling off.

If it's relevant the children have all been spoken to once about not getting on about 3 months ago. When I saw DD's teacher last week she said she thought it all died down as she didn't hear anything from them (it hadn't, it just hadn't made its way to her)

OP posts:
Hurstlandshome · 06/07/2022 06:53

This sounds similar to the friendship groups in my DD's school. The teacher said she'd never worked in a school where the children were as catty towards each other and so much drama.

My daughter (now 9) had problems settling into a friendship circle, and one girl was particularly horrible to her.

She had 12 weekly sessions with the school councillor and it has transformed her and her relationship with the girl. They will play together in a group (loosely) but the teacher would never pair them or put them on the same table. She also had a diagnosis of dyslexia which helped her better understand why she didn't always 'get it' like the other kids. She is now very happily settled, very popular, and loves school - all changed in one year!

If you suspect SEN then make sure she has the tests and don't rule out the councillor. It has been transformational.

Bednobsbroomsticks · 06/07/2022 06:50

Two girls later and this is usual stuff. Girls are like wolf packs quite honestly and turn at moments notice. Thread is quite confusing but all I can say is if you get involved in these things every time they happen you will not have time for anything else.
My kids were bullied and left out and told off. We taught them resilience and comebacks and to always be better person. They got through fine and tough as old boots now. Yours will too

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 06/07/2022 06:48

Can't your daughter just play with other kids? The teacher has done the best thing and said the two children having issues should avoid each other. Which is common sense tbh. As for kids being a little scared of the teacher, when they get told off that's bound to happen.

WhatNoRaisins · 06/07/2022 06:47

I think your DD made a mistake reporting that the other girl was crying, I don't mean that it was the morally wrong thing to do but that in my experience teachers tend to be wary of people who repeatedly come to them with problems and can start to see them as the trouble makers. It's a learning experience and she needs to learn when to keep her head down I think.

beautifulworldwhereareyou · 06/07/2022 06:45

I have children I have had to ban playing together because otherwise every single day it’s arguments and winding each other up and telling on each other for nothing, plus phone calls and messages from parents. They also won’t tell anyone in the playground about it and then come in hysterical to me right before I need to teach. 😬 It had been going on since year one by the time they got to me and all manner of conflict resolution work hadn’t managed to crack it.

The difference was I spoke to parents and we decided together that this was the best course of action and the children seem much happier now.

I don’t really blame the teacher but wouldn’t have done this without speaking to parents as it’s very easy for children to assume they’re the one being blamed in this situation.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 06:42

@DockOTheBay yes maybe although to be fair to DD, the teacher also said it wasn't her. She also asked if I was happy with how she'd handled it and if not she'd call them all back in and speak to them again.

I think quite possibly, in frustration she may have jumped to conclusions and banned them from associating and then on investigation found out it wasn't actually that much to do with them. I asked her how it ended in DD and other girl not being allowed to play and she said it was because everything had been fine until they started playing together again. This might be true, or it might be a frustrated teacher seizing on a known issue in the heat of the moment to 'solve' the problem.

OP posts:
LisaSimpson77 · 06/07/2022 06:41

Sounds like the teacher is fed up to the back teeth of dealing with a group of girls daily squabble drama...it does sound exhausting to be fair.
It can be challenging when you have 101 teaching pressures to navigate, you have the class settled and working for you then they get a bit of free time and suddenly they've all got involved in some petty squabble, start crying and getting their mums to come in and complain and you lose your lunch time and some of your teaching time trying to deal with it.
Also, if your dd had problems with one group, was found a new group to play with and now both groups are having issues, it's highly likely that she's part of the problem.
Sorry my sympathy is with the teacher here.

cansu · 06/07/2022 06:37

I would also recommend that you take what your dd says with a pinch of salt. Children often tell highly partial stories of fall outs.

cansu · 06/07/2022 06:35

If children are not getting along they should play with someone else. The teacher sounds like she is spending a lot of time dealing with their petty squabbles. Teachers listen and try and help but ultimately they may well have to tell kids to stop it and this does mean being strict eventually. Saying that the squabbles are wasting staff time and causing upset to parents is true and sometimes needs saying. telling your dd to stop playing with the child she has problems with is a good thing. Sometimes this is the solution. You may need to adopt a sterner approach if you want this to stop.

DockOTheBay · 06/07/2022 06:33

There tried discouraging it but they were still getting involved with each other and it sounds like the two of them have caused a bit scene. Your daughter has told you all she did was see a friend upset and tell a teacher but 8 year olds do have a tendency to 'forget' parts of the story and there may be more to it.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 06:29

@Confusion101 I don't think it's a bad thing to remove yourself at all. It's just that 'banning' it rather than discouraging it means you need to worry about getting in trouble. DD's old friendship group is 3 other girls but she mainly has trouble with one of them. The other two girls have been told they either play with DD or the other girl but not both. Feels like it will be a hard one for 8 year olds who are already struggling to navigate friendships, to achieve without causing more trouble and upset.

OP posts:
Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 06:21

@Londonderry34 I do generally agree with this - hence why I mentioned I hadn't asked school for help before

Would you still think that if a DC was being bullied though? One reason I went to speak to DD's teacher is to try and get a better picture of what was happening, rather than just relying on DD's version of events. Based on what DD had told me it sounds like this group are being very unpleasant, what I wanted to check is whether she was just as bad and that part was edited out - my advice to her would be different then, obviously.

So I agree that you don't concern the teacher with petty two-way squabbles, but presumably you do involve the teacher if someone is being bullied? I found it difficult to tell which it was just from what DD said, maybe other parents find it easier. The teacher reacted to the situation as though DD should be helped and supported which is perhaps why I'm surprised at how the big falling out was handled yesterday.

It was also a more general conversation about being concerned about DD (she'd wet herself in school a few weeks previously) and how her emotions were playing out at home. She tries very hard at school and likes to please - she also doesn't react well to a lot of pressure and my feeling is that the combination of friendship problems and 'scary' teacher have been having a knock-on effect at home. I am talking about tantrums that can last 2-3 hours and have been having a major impact on the whole household over the last few months (fwiw, talking about this part is where I got emotional not the friendship part). They stopped all together in half term and this got me thinking that the root cause may lie in what's happening at school

OP posts:
Confusion101 · 06/07/2022 06:11

Is banning children from playing together realistic?

I think this is realistic. Is it a bad thing to teach people if they aren't happy in a situation to remove themselves from it rather than put up with it? I'm a teacher of older children and see it time and time again where (girls in particular) do not get on but insist on spending their free time together. Nobody is going to be liked by everybody in life. It is important to recognise when you are being treated poorly and be able to remove yourself from that situation which is what your DD is being told to do.

MrsPnut · 06/07/2022 05:49

There’s 2 or 3 weeks until the end of term and this year has been dreadful for schools and the children.
I’d be arranging as many play dates I could manage for the summer holidays for children you want your DD to be friendly with and hope that a new school year and a new teacher in September makes a difference.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 05:44

@GoldenSongbird I think I was very tired when I wrote my Op! I didn't mean to labour that particular point I was just trying to explain why I was bothered the teacher had referred to 'parents being upset'.

OP posts:
Londonderry34 · 06/07/2022 02:54

Don't want to diminish what has happened but honestly let teachers teach.

GoldenSongbird · 06/07/2022 02:22

You mentioned that you cried/were emotional or upset about four times in your OP. That reads as though you felt embarrassed and caught out. Otherwise you wouldn't have mentioned it so often or jumped to assume that the teacher meant you.
It's great if you feel better about it all now.

expat101 · 06/07/2022 01:56

another vote for thinking the teacher was frazzled, for whatever reason.

Our DD was wary of her last art teacher, having had two really good art teachers at another school, this one (who still actually works at the local school) grabbed her friend's pencil, broke it in half and told her to start again as her work was rubbish. The guy definitely has a temper, and his own work is pretty appalling, but he seems to be loved by others who think the world of him and his stuff.

Having said that, I'm not sure there is much you can do about this group of girls, the push pull ones apart from encourage your DD to stay right away from them.

There was a similar group of girls at DD's last school, when one of the group was away they would bitch and carry on behind her back, and then be nice as the following day and find someone else to pick on. In the final years of school, this group mostly left as early as they could however one girl remained and was invited into the ''nicer'' group of girls. Wow what a lot of damage she did, and I felt at the time, mostly to our DD and her best friend although the whole group eventually split up into smaller buddy friendships they had known before attending this school. It was such as shame as they were a really neat group of girls too with good parents.

That was 7 years ago now and to this day, there is only one girl from that school DD is in contact with. She is in contact more with the previous school buddies.

So my advice would be to encourage your DD into after hour activities that do not involve your school, to help broaden her friendship and interest group and to ignore whatever friendship bait that push/pull group at school might try.

Depending on circumstances, I might try and have a brief word with the teacher too.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 01:21

In this case, the 'scared' is scared of being shouted at in front of the class mainly? I can think of teachers who are not warm but aren't 'scary' and that is obviously OK.

OP posts:
MangyInseam · 06/07/2022 01:07

As far as the being scared, I think it depends.

Some kids are more sensitive, and will feel scared of a teacher who isn't as warm, or seems more authoritative. I had a teacher when I was 10, Mrs Sharma, who was a bit like that. I wasn't scared, but I also would have been hesitant to tell her something I felt bothered about. Some kids might call that being scared. (In hindsight she was quite an interesting lady and would have handled any problems efficiently, I suspect.)

Swipe left for the next trending thread