Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this wasn't handled brilliantly

100 replies

Runlulurunandrun · 05/07/2022 23:26

My DD8 (yr3) has been having friendship problems at school this year with being in/out of a particular group. It's escalated over the last few months and (I think) may be the cause of extremely defiant, difficult behaviour at home as she has a habit of behaving badly at bedtime when she's upset.

To try and solve the problem I went into school to see her teacher to see if they could help by encouraging other friendships, and whether she had any advice for DD (ie was contributing to situations) . I was also going tk mention that DD is scared of the teacher so she won't come to her with a problem, but had good chat with Teacher and saw no need to mention it when it came to it. Teacher was very reassuring, said she'd been bullied at school and she was keen to support DD here - she said she would speak to a 2nd group of friends that DD sometimes plays with to ask them to support DD, and also put her on the list for weekly chat with Senco (Didn't know schools did this as Dd doesn't have SEN.. I think.. But that's another thread!) At one point, I got a bit emotional because I have a very frustrating tendency to cry when stressed! However, all seemed fine and the last week or so DD has been happier, sometimes playing with new friends, sometimes playing with old friendship group happy enough.

Anyway, teacher called me at lunchtime today as there'd been an incident between a group of girls that culminated in them all being taken in at lunch and told off. Apologies, I don't know how to describe the incident without it all sounding terribly petty but it's relevant to me being a bit unsure of the teachers reaction.

Two girls from DD's new friendship group had an argument and DD told a playground assistant as one of them was crying. DD's teacher came out and ordered them all 'Inside Now' ('them' being new and old friendship group who were all somehow involved)

This culminated in DD being formally banned from playing with one of the girls in her previous friendship group (the one she has the most trouble with). Her teacher didn't have much explanation for this except that they'd made the situation worse by getting involved as what was an argument between 2 people became a group drama. I think it was also on the basis that 'everything had been fine till they played together again'.

The arguments are petty and I'm prepared to go with the teachers judgement here, but this is where I'm not sure it was handled well. Most of the six girls that got pulled in ended up crying as they were all shouted at. The teacher complained that she 'was upset dealing with it, had upset children and had upset parents coming in to see her'. It's hard to convey tone with text but it was anger at having to deal with their problems. From what DD says, It sounds to me like she went off at them in a temper and I'm particularly pissed off about the upset parents comment. DD knows that would have been me and I feel pretty annoyed that the teacher has said I was upset! DD is now adamant that I'm not to talk to school again.
My questions are
Is it normal for children to be scared of their teacher?
Is banning children from playing together realistic? We discussed this option when I met the teacher and said we'd leave it. I think it makes life harder for DD
Would you do anything? Or just grit your teeth till the end of term?

FWIW my son is just finishing year six and I've never asked school for help before.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NaTFlop · 06/07/2022 13:23

GoodnightRain · 06/07/2022 11:34

Thanks @MrsVeryTired and @NaTFlop - love your suggestions!

OP, you sounds like a wonderful Mum and you are doing all you can to support your DD. Big hugs to you and I hope the new term is a much more positive one for your fam 💕 x

Agree 😘

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 12:03

@GoodnightRain thank you for saying that, it means a lot :)

OP posts:
GoodnightRain · 06/07/2022 11:34

Thanks @MrsVeryTired and @NaTFlop - love your suggestions!

OP, you sounds like a wonderful Mum and you are doing all you can to support your DD. Big hugs to you and I hope the new term is a much more positive one for your fam 💕 x

GoldenSongbird · 06/07/2022 11:14

My family and friend circle is full of teachers. They would be fine with you speaking to them about 'friendship' issues, etc. These problems can escalate and lead to bullying, isolation, school avoidance, etc. Plus, since you're worried about DD at home, it's good to get a perspective on how she is at school and start to work with the school to support her.
But you now have to trust the school and her teacher. There have been at least three months of issues with this friendship group. The teacher hasn't 'jumped' to ban them from each other. It's also a fairly common technique. Sometimes teachers enforce the bans and sometimes it's just about telling the DCs so they realise the current behaviour can't go on.
You did the right thing. The teacher did the right thing. Let it play out over the last few weeks of term. And as PP have said, find some clubs with different DCs for your DD over summer. It really helps to diffuse the pressure on school friendships.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 11:09

Thank you - she does do some hobbies she enjoys and has started Brownies too this term. The idea being that even when school sucks you can go and have a good time somewhere else. It does help actually - Brownies has been particularly good and she seems very happy there.

I've also booked quite a lot of time off over the summer holidays, about 4 weeks in total as she is always better when I am around more. She seems to really like being actively cared for (things like helping her get dressed/brushing her teeth for her) that I wasn't doing for my son at this age. I wonder if it takes some of the burden/pressure off her? It's the polar opposite to my son who was doing everything independantly at a young age and its taken me a while to learn that what she needs/wants is really different.

OP posts:
NaTFlop · 06/07/2022 11:01

@WhatsInAMolatovMocktail
My dd having been through dramas in year 4 handled this very calmly, told her bestie that it was “her loss” and when bf came back crying a month later because the popular crowd had dumped her, my dd said something along the lines, “it is your own fault you’ve got no one left to play with. You’re not my friend any more. You’re on your own.” Which I think was pretty much a perfect reaction and my mum job definitely done! I didn’t need to do anything except make sympathetic/ outraged noises.

I love your dd's style 😎

NaTFlop · 06/07/2022 10:56

MrsVeryTired · 06/07/2022 10:15

Great post by @GoodnightRain above 👏

Agreed 😍
OP, with your additional posts about your dd really kicking off at home, especially the hiding under the table, it's clear your dd is not happy and going trough something. This is indeed a leaning opportunity. Help her understand that these sort of things do happen and that even teachers can suck at solving problems so that your dd understand people make mistakes and can learn and move on.

I wouldn't say anything further to the school, new year, new teacher, new opportunities.

The best thing you can do right now is to see if you find an out of school or holiday activity that works with your dd's strengths, is she good at gymnastics, athletics, drama or music? Is she into anything like cycling, roller blading, pets or particular type of stories and books? Arrange activities and opportunities around what your dd enjoys and let her become really good at something so that she grows in confidence, half your problems will be solved.

Eatingchips · 06/07/2022 10:54

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 10:40

@Eatingchips I have considered this. There are likely neuro divergent people in my family (only one niece actually diagnosed with ADD though). She is very similar to my niece so I can see some of the same behaviours. I was also a very similar child (uncontrollable emotions, for one). It was one factor on my mind in talking to the teacher in case the home behaviour is a piece of evidence that ties in with other behaviours at school.
The reports from school though are universally that she is well behaved, focused, good social skills, no issues etc. I did wonder if her having the appointments offered with the senco would flag anything up. It's a tricky one because it's such a go-to answer when children are having any kind of difficulty and she's very young still so not easy to unpick what is just part of development and what is likely to be a more long term issue.

Yes I completely agree about it as the go to answer and you are obviously completely on the ball with it as a possibility. The holding it together in school and losing it at home are common especially for girls. The social issues and very significant meltdowns are small reg flags for ASD of course but you yourself know the bigger picture with your daughter.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 10:40

@Eatingchips I have considered this. There are likely neuro divergent people in my family (only one niece actually diagnosed with ADD though). She is very similar to my niece so I can see some of the same behaviours. I was also a very similar child (uncontrollable emotions, for one). It was one factor on my mind in talking to the teacher in case the home behaviour is a piece of evidence that ties in with other behaviours at school.
The reports from school though are universally that she is well behaved, focused, good social skills, no issues etc. I did wonder if her having the appointments offered with the senco would flag anything up. It's a tricky one because it's such a go-to answer when children are having any kind of difficulty and she's very young still so not easy to unpick what is just part of development and what is likely to be a more long term issue.

OP posts:
AnotherAnxiousMess · 06/07/2022 10:26

My DB and SIL are both primary school teachers and say that the most common thing parents come to talk to them about is drama between the girls friendship groups, almost on a daily basis… And I honestly don’t know if it’s fair to put that on the teachers all the time. Sounds like the teacher got fed up with it and dealt with it very poorly. I would leave it for now though as she’ll have a new teacher in September. Have you spoken to any of the other parents of her friends? Could you encourage certain friendships over the summer holidays? I do feel for you, my DD is starting school this year and I’m dreading all of this stuff. But sounds like you’re trying to deal with it as best as you can.

Eatingchips · 06/07/2022 10:26

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 09:40

One last thing, lots of people have said I'm making a drama out of nothing. Does that also apply to the original conversation with the teacher to make her aware of the troubles DD is having at home?

I think a previous poster said that if she's kicking off at home she's probably kicking off at school. That absolutely isn't the case, by the way. I got nothing but positive feedback from the teacher about her behaviour at school. It's more she keeps a lid on everything at school and then explodes at home. If she's behaving well at school then they can't know that she is struggling.

The upset sometimes goes on for hours, hiding under the table/being defiant and then ends in sobbing and sorries. I've got much much better at handling it now and I think (hope!) we're coming out of this phase but I have been very worried about her. Especially with her wetting herself at school too, she's quite old to be doing that.

I know this is MN favourite but have you considered any possibility of neuro divergence. Those are pretty big reactions and could be an indication of meltdowns. Ignore if it doesn’t apply. As a parent of ND kids sometimes I see these things written out and it crops into my mind.

ancientgran · 06/07/2022 10:21

Regardless of anything else I think your DD should be praised for seeking help for another child who was distressed. I can't get my head round that as I'm pretty sure that is what most people would expect an 8 year old to do.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 10:20

Yes, thank you @GoodnightRain it was really helpful
And others too - it does help to hear a range of different views

OP posts:
WhatsInAMolatovMocktail · 06/07/2022 10:19

Hi, I had something very very similar with my dd, except not quite so extreme with the acting out at home part. Summer is a long term; Everyone needs a break including the teachers. The ban is likely only needed to make things crystal clear to everyone - “this is how we are going to stop ANY more of this ridiculous playground drama for the test of term.”

With girls these dramas are absolutely normal at this age. It will be rinse-and-repeat through to end of year 6.

The teacher is NOT able to stop them being normal little girls and she can’t police their friendships in playtime to the extent you think is possible. She can step in if there is bullying. Your job as mum is to teach your child to navigate these tricky situations. Yes, it is YOUR job. Buy some girls’ manuals/books on Amazon about handling friendship drama, read them with your daughter. be there to help her face each day, help her to plan in advance a good reaction/response to any given situation. Let her know these squabbles and dramas are normal and it is part of growing up to figure out who your really good friends are, and how to maintain healthy friendships, let her know it is okay to have bad days and try again the next day. Help her think about whether what she is doing is triggering someone - how could she avoid that happening in future? If she is adamant she isn’t annoying anyone, then advise her to try to step away and play elsewhere. If stepping away leads to them following her around and being mean, teach her to say firmly and kindly, “I would like to play with you and be friends but only if you are nice to me. But when you are not nice, I don’t want to play with you, so for now I’m going to play with my other friends and you should go and play with someone else too. We can play together again another day when you’re ready to be a proper friend.”

where you can’t work out what going on and it’s escalating wildly - why not talk to her friends’ mums? It’s very likely they are hearing about the playground dramas too. And if not, that is a likely indication their dd is maybe more to blame! And the other mum can have a quiet word to ask their dd if everything is going ok within the friendship group and perhaps fix it from their side too.

from your point of view: it is stressful but don’t feel you need to worry too much. Your dd will grow through this, and come out the other side better for it, if you focus on what she can learn about friendship through these difficulties she will be on a straight path to the end of y6 avoiding the worst dramas.

ps in year 6 we have had some real shockers with my dd - one of her best friends telling my dd she is “too ugly” to be her friend now and she only wanted her around if the popular crowd wasnt available. My dd having been through dramas in year 4 handled this very calmly, told her bestie that it was “her loss” and when bf came back crying a month later because the popular crowd had dumped her, my dd said something along the lines, “it is your own fault you’ve got no one left to play with. You’re not my friend any more. You’re on your own.” Which I think was pretty much a perfect reaction and my mum job definitely done! I didn’t need to do anything except make sympathetic/ outraged noises. You’ll get there op!

MrsVeryTired · 06/07/2022 10:15

Great post by @GoodnightRain above 👏

MrsVeryTired · 06/07/2022 10:13

I agree with you, this was not handled well. You were right imo to talk to the teacher about the issues your DD is having but some teachers are better than others at handling this sort of thing.

Some have the "oh more crap stuff for me to deal with", they are human, its been a difficult few years and some have definitely forgotten the whole "teach the whole child" idea.
The "I'm just here to teach them, not to help with their emotional resilience" brigade, erm no! especially not as a primary teacher, it is part of the job.

Can you have a good chat with your DD, obviously don't say the "little bitches" part Grin but emphasise that some are not kind and the teacher is (trying to hopefully) look out for her and is probably a bit stressed atm. 8yr old girls can be mean!
Is there a playground assistant type person that DD can talk to who is more sympathetic? I think DD got the "shoot the messenger" response.

Hope you can help her be happierSmile, it is a big drama over v little but it is a big deal to those involved (your DD).

Elsiebear90 · 06/07/2022 09:56

I think this sounds like way too much drama for a bunch of 8 year olds. I would strongly encourage her to make new friends because this friendship situation she’s got clearly isn’t working and is disruptive and upsetting for her.

The teacher is clearly at the end of her tether having to deal with all of this, and I’m not surprised because from your posts it sounds exhausting.

Itwasntmeright · 06/07/2022 09:54

no, I don’t think your conversation with the teacher was unnecessary or out of order. it’s helpful for school to know if there are problems happening at home. Don’t worry that you got upset either, it’s obviously frustrating and upsetting for you. Please try to stop worrying so much about what other people think. I think if you could do that it would help.

GoodnightRain · 06/07/2022 09:49

Primary teacher here and if this was my DD, this is the sort of thing I would lose a bit of sleep over. I know it might seem insignificant in the grand scheme of the teaching day - but it's a big deal to your DD and you are experiencing the impact at home.

I think it is unprofessional to insinuate the girls are 'little bitches' and this phrase feels like an indication of her attitude towards girls. Also, a lack of education surrounding the fact that this kind of playground drama is developmentally normal. I would put some support in place for the girls, and do some PSHE lessons around relationships. I would not ban certain people from playing together, it's not sustainable and what happens when they come together and have problems again (which they will)?! This needs to be viewed as a learning opportunity. Children cannot learn to play nicely together if they are not taught how and are just reprimanded instead of supported. Petty or not petty, it is the biggest thing happening in your DDs world right n
ow.

Also, I take issue with teachers weaponising feelings and making children feel response for their mood. She is putting a lot of guilt and pressure on these kids by making them feel they have burdened her and upset her in this situation. It's a normal Y3 issue! She might have been having an off day but this was not handled well. In my opinion, It is not normal for children to be scared of teachers, especially in this day and age. If she is going off on them like that frequently, then I'm not surprised they don't feel like they can go to her.

If this was the beginning of term I'd definitely speak to the head teacher - but if I'm honest, at this point I would just focus on DD. I would have chats with her about it and help her to get excited about next year and a new teacher. I would also be super vigilant about how this is being handled in the first term after summer if the problem continues. X

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 09:40

One last thing, lots of people have said I'm making a drama out of nothing. Does that also apply to the original conversation with the teacher to make her aware of the troubles DD is having at home?

I think a previous poster said that if she's kicking off at home she's probably kicking off at school. That absolutely isn't the case, by the way. I got nothing but positive feedback from the teacher about her behaviour at school. It's more she keeps a lid on everything at school and then explodes at home. If she's behaving well at school then they can't know that she is struggling.

The upset sometimes goes on for hours, hiding under the table/being defiant and then ends in sobbing and sorries. I've got much much better at handling it now and I think (hope!) we're coming out of this phase but I have been very worried about her. Especially with her wetting herself at school too, she's quite old to be doing that.

OP posts:
Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 09:36

I'm not concerned she got told off as such, thats part of life. My concern was/is that I've inadvertently taught her that if you reach out for help it potentially makes things worse for you.

Also I know I'm making a big deal out of it here but that's because I haven't in real life! I've asked DD what happened, given her some more advice to avoid these situations and that's honestly it. I haven't even discussed it with DH. I was just lying in bed last night with the whole situation going round in my head and thought it might help to get some different perspectives on the situation. I don't really want to discuss it with friends in real life, because I hate gossip and therefore won't talk about the teacher/other children at the school to other parents there. Anyway real life friends would probably just agree with me because I'm their friend, and it's no help to have an echo chamber!

OP posts:
Itwasntmeright · 06/07/2022 09:10

OP, I can hear you’re feeling conflicted about this, but ask yourself, is this really a big deal? The worst case scenario is that your DD got included in a telling off when it wasn’t her fault. That’s annoying and nobody enjoys that but it happens, and being able to handle it is part of growing up If you let it drop it’ll be forgotten by the end of the week. 8 year olds change their mood more often than they change their pants. You risk turning what is a silly childhood drama into a big upsetting deal.

look OP, please take this in the spirit that its intended, and I had an awful time at school so I understand this probably pushes buttons, but this is all very small and silly, and if you make any more of it it’ll probably become bigger and worse, and you’ll end up feeling more misunderstood than you already do. Honestly, it’s not a hill worth dying on, it’s just life. What I’m saying is try not to let your own insecurities get involved, otherwise you risk making a mountain out of a mole hill, and worse, setting your DD an unhelpful example.

MargaretThursday · 06/07/2022 09:10

The teacher who was definitely the one people were scared of at my primary was also the most popular who everyone wanted to be in their class. He was a great teacher. I remember when he left and he had years worth of old pupils coming back to see him in the last week.

NaTFlop · 06/07/2022 09:02

@Itwasntmeright I’m shocked that so many people are horrified at the teacher mouthing that a group of girls are little bitches. she’s probably right, they probably are little bitches when they get together, in fact isn’t that the whole premise of this post?

How would you feel if Op's dd or other girls called their female teachers 'bitches'? Not a great conversation style, is it and? And not a great role model in terms of showing how to deal with conflict either. The teacher shouting or being robust is ok IMO, name calling is not at all ok, unless she wants to teach the students that this is how you behave when you are frustrated. Imagine calling your clients bitches to their face or your colleague. She was out of order and needs to learn to control her anger.

OP, teach your dd to focus on the positives, don't sweat the small stuff, be a bit more discrete and do activities during playtime rather than sitting around and talking about boring stuff. Do not feel embarrassed about crying it hurst when our dc are left out but more often than not, they behave in ways that contribute to the conflict.

Teach social skills and resilience, is my best tip. Any mothers of older girls who can share strategies, please share your wisdom!

BellePeppa · 06/07/2022 09:01

I was scared of all my teachers at that age but then that was the days when the head walked around carrying a cane!

Swipe left for the next trending thread