Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone else given up with hormonal contraceptives

64 replies

Caribou1 · 05/07/2022 23:05

I was using the Depo Provera injection for around a year but it's not advised long term, and since around the age of 19 I've been on various contraceptive pills, so 11 years now.
I just want to stop hormonal contraceptives, I don't know if it's doing me any good and I think with the pill I don't know if the side effects are affecting me, or if that's just me if that makes sense.
I don't like the thought of the implant or coil at all.
I've looked into non hormonal contraceptives such as the diaphragm, I'm aware it makes things less spontaneous but just want to stop using hormones. Has anybody else used any non hormonal contraceptives?

OP posts:
SkankingWombat · 06/07/2022 07:34

I went on the pill at 16 because of irregular and excruciatingly painful periods. I came off it at 29 (9 years ago) when we decided to TTC, and will never go back to any form of hormonal contraception now. My periods can be very painful once again but are regular, however, once off the pill I realised how much it affected my mood and sex drive (neither in a good way!). After an elective CS and a category 1 emergency CS following a rupture, I have no desire to interfere with that part of my body any more so that rules out the hormone-free coil. We have used condoms in the last 9 yrs whenever not TTC/pregnant, with mixed results as we have found them to split at crucial moments on a number of occasions. DH has recently had a vasectomy, so hopefully in a few months we will no longer need to give it any thought. I am very pleased he has decided it's his 'turn' to manage it!

Fml1980 · 06/07/2022 07:32

I'm there now, I have had the implant for just over a year and its been hell!
I feel miserable, my periods are every other week with horrible peroid pain, my breasts kill.
I've put on weight and have no sex drive.
So I'm phoning to have the thing out.

MacaroniBaloney · 06/07/2022 07:31

I moved away at least 5 years ago after an implant got lost and it required x2 160 mile round trips to get it fished out.

I've since tracked my cycle and avoided dtd over fertile period. However, am aware of risks to this approach.

Triselly · 06/07/2022 07:25

Stopped using hormonal/invasive contraceptives and started using Natural Cycles (period tracking using basal body temperature) and condoms. Zero side effects, zero artificial hormones or messing around with your biology.

VestaTilley · 06/07/2022 07:25

Yep, after having DS I didn’t want to further screw up my body with artificial hormones. I stopped taking the pill and we now just rely on condoms.

DH will have a vasectomy when we’ve completed our family.

MaJoady · 06/07/2022 07:15

I tried for a few years while single. Heavy painful periods that never settled, PMT every month, bloating and even occasional flooding. I'm now on the minipill and couldn't tell you when my last period was. Bliss!

erinaceus · 06/07/2022 07:15

I had a copper coil for a decade. It did cause heavier, longer and more painful periods but to me this was a least-worst option compared to using hormonal contraceptives. I would recommend / use again.

WatchingTheCloudsRollAway · 06/07/2022 07:12

I stopped in my early 20s.
Best decision ever!
I wouldn't go back on hormonal contraception if I was paid to take it. Wreaked havoc with my body and mind. Ironically I was put on it in mid teens to control mood swings.

Footbal · 06/07/2022 07:11

Hate hormonal contraception. I'm 41 now and from the age of 18 I've probably used hormonal contraception for 2 years max. Took the pill for adult acne and had the mirena for 6 months for heavy periods but couldn't tolerate it.

DH and I would have used condoms for birth control until he got a vasectomy 10 years ago after the birth of our youngest child.

UseOfWeapons · 06/07/2022 07:04

Stopped them at 24, they made me feel like shit. Used the diaphragm for a while, then condoms. Preferred condoms long term, tbh.

jeaux90 · 06/07/2022 07:01

Stopped them years ago. He's had the snip. So freeing.

ThatsALotOfPassionfruit · 06/07/2022 06:52

I was off hormonal contraceptives after having DC and honestly I was awful. So beholden to my hormones. Back on it now and feel like a different person.
Without it I had two days a month of crippling ovulation pain and heavy, painful periods lasting anything up to 10 days!

Mommabear20 · 06/07/2022 06:52

Yup! I'm currently 18 weeks pregnant with a baby conceived while having the implant! Can't say it's convinced me of their effectiveness!

Salahwalawoowoo · 06/07/2022 06:34

I stopped after having my DC. I was advised to go onto progesterone only (Depo injection, implant, mini pill etc) after having kids which really did not agree with me. I was fine on the combined pill BTW. But I was advised the risk of blood clots was higher etc with my age, weight and blood pressure after having DC.

Physically in myself I feel better off progesterone only than I ever did on it. Even with the heavy periods and PMT.

I do miss how it feels without condoms TBH. But I definitely don't want anymore kids and nor does DH. So we've adapted.

Robostripes · 06/07/2022 06:32

I was very happily on the combined pill for over 5 years (took a few tries to find the right one) and then for another 5 on the mini pill (had to switch due to migraines). But after I had my DS I went back on the mini pill and have never managed to settle on it, just constant bleeding which is such a drag. I left it for a few years and just used condoms, then tried again and same issue.

So now we just use condoms, tbh I prefer it, much less messy! I miss being able to skip a period but I’ve taken Norethisterone a few times to delay it if we’re going away etc.

Miffee · 06/07/2022 06:24

Yep, years ago. DH has had snip now but used condoms for years. Only time we ever had issues was when we got them from a pub vending machine. We often used to get them from family planning for free.

I did use the diaphragm for a while between 1st and 2nd as it wouldn't have been terrible if I got pregnant. I had to basically demand it because the nurses at family planning tried to talk me out of it. I wasn't a fan to be honest it's all a bit messy but it workedas intended.

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 06/07/2022 06:17

I did 4/5 months on the pill many years ago and it made me feel so crappy I have never touched hormonal contraception again.

StarlightLady · 06/07/2022 05:52

Long ago! I concluded that they were not for me.

l can’t remember when l last had sex without a condom, but l feel so much better for it.

l’m not proud, l just pick them up at the supermarket as part of the weekly shop.

Fluffygreenslippers · 06/07/2022 00:29

I read about a new contraceptive the other day-the vaginal ring? That might be worth a try. Or a cap, old school but effective.
I’ve never used hormonal birth control, it never agreed with me, & my period are already heavy so copper coil is out.
For years I tracked my cycle and used condoms (or just avoided piv) during my fertile period. It worked for seven years, until the bloody covid vaccine skewed my cycle resulting in pregnancy.
DH will be getting a vasectomy.

Cameleongirl · 06/07/2022 00:27

I started to have more side effects in my mid-30’s after being on the Pill for years. I tried the copper coil twice and both times, my body ejected it! My doctor said that some people just aren’t suited to it, so DH and I discussed the options and he decided to have a vasectomy. I was equally willing to have my tubes tied, but we opted for the less invasive procedure. DH absolutely knew that he didn’t want any more children (even if we broke up and he was with a new partner), as did I, so a permanent solution made sense for us.

MangyInseam · 06/07/2022 00:27

I stopped in my early 30s and used a combination of condoms and the Billings ovulation method. It wasn't perfect but I found I felt a lot better overall.

Bellyups · 06/07/2022 00:24

Not touched hormonal contraceptives for 16 years, and I never will again.
I track my cycle, and use condoms on fertile days.
Never had a accident, never had an unwanted pregnancy. I feel normal. Hormonal contraceptives made me put on weight, which has never come back since I’ve been off of them.

hotcoldnotsold · 06/07/2022 00:19

I've only ever used condoms and I'm mid 30s. I refuse to mess about with my hormones as I think it's what determines 'me' - so I know who I am and what makes me tick and can figure out quicker if I have health issues. I enjoy sex a lot and all the guys I've been with (a lot tbf) say they enjoy sex enough with a condom and have no issues with it. I've always had regular periods that aren't heavy or painful so it's made my choice easier.

I remember reading research that hormones determine who is a good match for you biologically and women choose differently when on hormonal contraception than without - absolutely not a risk I want to take tbh.

Caribou1 · 05/07/2022 23:49

Thanks everyone, this has confirmed my decision

OP posts:
Verbena87 · 05/07/2022 23:49

I’ve used a diaphragm which I liked a lot, but it’s tricky to get the spermicide to go with it which you do need and now I’ve got a prolapse it doesn’t fit right.

Currently use fertility awareness method plus condoms unless I’m sure I’ve ovulated and am outside my fertile window. FAM is best learnt from an instructor but the sensiplan handbook is good - don’t use/trust an app, most are glorified versions of the rhythm method as far as I can tell. Give me a paper chart and an abundance of caution any day😂