Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is my child too young to go on a residential trip?

87 replies

feelgoodvibes · 05/07/2022 21:36

My son is in year three and due to go on a 2 night trip with his school in two weeks. I agreed to this a couple of months back and paid for it - around £250. Me and his dad were not on talking terms back then so I told him about the trip and that DS would be going and he said he thought DS was too young and wasn't happy with it- we had no contact after that so I decided to proceed with trip as I think DS would enjoy and benefit from this trip. They will be doing adventure activities such as rafting and climbing, will have four teachers supervising.

I spoke to a friend who is also a father and he said he thought year 3 was too young also and that's made me question it, as I originally thought his dad said no out of spite and because he didn't want to pay towards the trip - he's managed to get out of paying maintenance for the last year.

DS is excited about the trip and having fun with some of his friends.

What's your verdict? Would you allow your 8 year old on a residential?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BooksAndHooks · 07/07/2022 17:32

Yes if they wanted to go. Mine went to beavers camp from when they joined just before they were six so we’re well seasoned by the time school residentials came around.

Augend23 · 07/07/2022 16:41

emmathedilemma · 07/07/2022 13:06

On the basis of having been a Cub Leader and taken kids away to camp for the weekend without parents I'd say that 99% of them will be just fine and have a blast. There's always one that's a bit homesick and might want to go home but they often stay and get it over it. I can only think of one who did actually go home and he came back the next day to take part in the activities once he'd had a night in his own bed (to be fair, that would be my ideal too rather than sleeping in a cold damp tent and being woken up at 5:30am!)

This - especially if he wants to go.

I've run (one) 3 night camp for 8 year olds and you don't get much sleep as a leader (8 hours over 3 nights which meant future camps were shorter!) - because they can't sleep/have woken up/are uncomfortable/homesick but that was across a pack of 30 or so and all in those big old fashioned tents and with no easily accessible toilet - if staying in bunk rooms with a loo attached or nearby I think they'd have found it much easier.

RoundaboutRacer · 07/07/2022 16:33

Mine do a 2 night at age 8 in their school. Had a great time.

zingally · 07/07/2022 16:31

I'm a supply teacher, so I know a lot of schools.

A lot of schools go away for a single night in Year 2, and then the "big" residential in Year 6.
2 nights in Year 3 is perfectly reasonable. Plus a lot of kids will have done nights away with Beavers/Brownies etc by that age.

Maytodecember · 07/07/2022 16:25

If your ds is happy and excited and looking forward to it mthen he’s not too young.

DontLikeCoffee · 07/07/2022 16:24

More children than you think wear pull ups or still wet the bed at residential. It shouldn’t prevent a child going. Our school are really good at being discreet about it and making sure they’re changed.

Ethelfromnumber73 · 07/07/2022 16:23

Mine went in year 3 and she's generally quite reserved. Absolutely loved it

steppemum · 07/07/2022 15:58

PetraBP · 07/07/2022 15:12

DD is 7 and only didn’t go on the school residential this year as she still wets the bed and wears pull-ups at night.

Most of her friends went and had a great time. She felt a bit left out.

Then I noticed a post which said that a teacher on a year FIVE residential had to run back to school from the coach because she had “forgotten the pull-ups”, meaning DD probably wouldn’t have been alone if she had gone!

If you think DS is ready, he probably is.

on our residential, we often have someone who is in pull-ups, and I don't mean the 6 year olds, it might be a 8, 9, 10 year old.

I also usually have 2 or 3 whose parents warn me about bed wetting, and we quietly put them on a bottom bunk for ease of sheet changes. I have very rarely had to actually change sheets, but wouldn't matter if we did.

PetraBP · 07/07/2022 15:12

DD is 7 and only didn’t go on the school residential this year as she still wets the bed and wears pull-ups at night.

Most of her friends went and had a great time. She felt a bit left out.

Then I noticed a post which said that a teacher on a year FIVE residential had to run back to school from the coach because she had “forgotten the pull-ups”, meaning DD probably wouldn’t have been alone if she had gone!

If you think DS is ready, he probably is.

DashOfMilkNoSugar · 07/07/2022 15:08

Our daughter did one night with the rainbows age 4 and our son did a couple of nights at Disneyland Paris age 7 or 8. No issues with either.

XmasElf10 · 07/07/2022 15:04

I take 7 year old on Beaver camps for a couple of nights. They almost always have a great time. Now and then we need to get a parent to pick up early and as long as you are ok to do that if needed then there’s no problem.

APurpleSquirrel · 07/07/2022 14:51

4-night residentials start in Yr3 at our school, plus at least one overnight in school too.

Marmite27 · 07/07/2022 14:46

My children have been away (only one night) with Rainbows for one night, and we’re doing Brownie camps at 7.

Bagpuss2022 · 07/07/2022 14:43

Where are all these schools that do y2 residentials? My 3 DC have gone to many schools being ex forces children and not one residential
however it’s not the age it’s the individual child two of mine would of been fine at 8 one definitely wouldn’t and still doesn’t like being away from home and he’s 18!

hope he has a blast OP and enjoy the break

riesenrad · 07/07/2022 14:33

At ds' school they did a 2 night trip in year 4 and a 4 night trip in year 6. I actually did think the first trip was a little early but he loved the trip in Y6. All kids are different. I didn't go anywhere until I was 10, and then I did a brownie trip and a school trip and was homesick on both. I was a mummy's girl!

Coffeaddict · 07/07/2022 14:12

I was a scout leader for years cubs ( aged 8) would go away for summer camp for a whole week ofter as well as a few pther weekends dotted around the year.
Even bevers ( from age 6) would have overnights away so I would say he will be fine.

hangrylady · 07/07/2022 14:01

Threetulips · 07/07/2022 13:32

Please advocate for your children and if you feel they are not ready, stand up for them and say so!

Bit what about all the helicopter over anxious parents who’s kids aren’t allowed to do anything?

My son in year 5 has a friend who is not allowed to walk to school with his friends, or go to the park without an adult. We live in a village and this boy is a 2 minute walk from both school and the park (no busy roads), and has to go with his nan and little sister while all his friends go together. I feel so sorry for the boy, its embarrassing for him.

Threetulips · 07/07/2022 13:32

Please advocate for your children and if you feel they are not ready, stand up for them and say so!

Bit what about all the helicopter over anxious parents who’s kids aren’t allowed to do anything?

Mojoj · 07/07/2022 13:23

Absolutely. It's how you raise resilient, confident children. He'll love it!

darkdaysareover · 07/07/2022 13:12

mizzo · 05/07/2022 21:44

Surely the fact the school is running the trip for his age group would suggest he's not too young.

That is a question for the parents, not the school. When you drop your DC off at at school they are still your DC and you know them best. It really worries me, this attitude of school knows best. They really don't. Please advocate for your children and if you feel they are not ready, stand up for them and say so!

Dixiechickonhols · 07/07/2022 13:08

PGL take from age 8 I think and you can sign them up for that not knowing anyone. So a school trip where he knows people is an easier first trip than that.

Dixiechickonhols · 07/07/2022 13:07

You know your son. If he’s happy to go send him. It’s an organised school trip and his peers will be going. Mine had an overnight as a rainbow age 5 then brownie camp at 7.
I do know of a dad who took his ex to court to try and stop her sending her dc on a trip (Court fully sided with her but it cost her ££ - a residential abroad with a well known youth organisation was deemed appropriate)

emmathedilemma · 07/07/2022 13:06

On the basis of having been a Cub Leader and taken kids away to camp for the weekend without parents I'd say that 99% of them will be just fine and have a blast. There's always one that's a bit homesick and might want to go home but they often stay and get it over it. I can only think of one who did actually go home and he came back the next day to take part in the activities once he'd had a night in his own bed (to be fair, that would be my ideal too rather than sleeping in a cold damp tent and being woken up at 5:30am!)

steppemum · 07/07/2022 12:57

I run a summer camp for a specific thing and it is open to age 6-12.
It is from Mon-Fri

I usually only get 6 year olds if they are with siblings, but they are fine and love it.

It really is down to your child though, last year I had a 12 year old who really really struggled with being away form home for 4 nights, she phoned mum every night and had a tearful homesick moment every day.
I phoned mum on that first evening and mum said - at 12 she has to learn that she is fine for a day or two, tough love, I'm not coming to get her!

And on the last day, her summary of the week was that it was great and she had loved it and was glad she pushed through the hard moments.

Svara · 07/07/2022 12:49

DS went on a four night one where he knew no one at 7 (school holiday government subsidised camp for age 7 to 12). Cub Scout camps were also from 7, school one was year 5.

Swipe left for the next trending thread