Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

August Babies -starting school

84 replies

notnow86 · 05/07/2022 19:35

My friend has a DD born in Oct, my DD was born in Aug. They'll both be starting school in September.

Friend keeps making comments about how she's worried that my DD will be behind and how she's so little and she won't be achieving great grades etc...

I've never been worried until now when I'm thinking maybe she's right?! AIBU to think she shouldn't be making these comments ? Her mother used to teach and apparently all august born children are dumb and never catch up

However my DH insists August born children aren't lacking at academics and will catch up eventually.

Any experience? Please tell me my DD will be fine! 🙈 I'm really anxious now

OP posts:
notnow86 · 05/07/2022 20:13

Thank you so so much everyone.

You have no idea how much this helps. I've been an emotional mess today feeling guilty that I didn't have her a few months earlier 😂🙈

I could keep her back for a year but DH thinks it's silly and she'll be just fine & absolutely refuses to discuss her not starting school this sept As he thinks you're either smart or you're not regardless of the month you were born in.

OP posts:
sageandrosemary · 05/07/2022 20:13

Is your friend potentially coming from a good place but going about it in the wrong way?

DD is summer born and will be starting reception this year at CSA. I'm sure it was the right decision for her but I know that doesn't mean it's the right decision for every summer born child.

From your post, it doesn't sound like your friend is being very nice, I must admit, but I thought it might be worth considering that she has just wanted to make you aware of other options but hasn't been very tactile about it.

Happyhappyday · 05/07/2022 20:12

So there is some research showing that kids who are on the very young end are diagnosed with learning disabilities at significantly higher rates than their older peers and that this persists throughout their time at school. Obviously all younger children do not have higher needs by virtue of being born in August… thinking is that they are exhibiting age appropriate behavior in the wrong class. Have experienced this with my own very verbal 3yo, she’s in a mixed Montessori classroom. Teacher expressed vague SEN concerns but when she was assessed by two pediatricians they both said she’s completely neurotypical as far as they can see. We also see it in her gymnastics class in reverse, she is by far the calmest child & has no difficulty following directions but she is now almost the oldest. The new kids are all just turned 3 and seem very immature by comparison.

if your child is socially mature, likely not to have any problems but it is worth thinking about whether keeping back a year is sensible if she is not.

We were leaning towards sending DD to school early because her verbal ability is ridiculously advanced but socially she is no way ready & I don’t want her to get stuck with a label she doesn’t need.

SkylarFerris · 05/07/2022 20:11

Tell her to stop being so rude.

my DS is an August baby and has got predicted grades of 7-8 in most GCSEs

tell your mate to back off

Kidsaregrim · 05/07/2022 20:06

Summer born DS, very very end of august and currently the youngest in the whole school!

academically in all the top sets and achieving top grades. Great friendship groups, gets on with everyone!

however he is on his arse in terms of emotions, he wants to be in wellies playing in the mud, he comes home every day looking like he has been physically assaulted, he gets into trouble for the most RIDICULOUS of things and sometimes makes some absolutely stupid decisions.

I see him with his friends and they are all heads and shoulders bigger than him and much more mature.

Hindsight, would I change anything? Nope, he is happy, enjoys school, and enjoys his friends, I just hope he grows up slightly this summer

RaspberryParfait · 05/07/2022 20:06

My late July born Yr 7 is currently at a prize giving ceremony at a prestigious Uni for an eco science project that he did with Yr10s and 11s. DH and DS1 went as I couldn’t due to work unfortunately.

He has had 100% in all assessments this year and as his tutor said to me a few weeks ago, at parents evening, he is a joy and a revelation to all the teachers in the school. Not a boast and my other 3 DC certainly didn’t have that said about them! Socially, he is probably the maturer one in his peer groups

I was crapping myself about him starting school at 4 years and 1 month and did consider deferring for a year but he wanted to go. He was so tiny. Now he’s one of the tallest in his year if not the tallest. He hit the ground running at primary and absolutely loved it.

Obviously you know your child, I wouldn’t defer unless you think they will really struggle. They would start in Yr1 rather than Reception missing out on a lot of social bonding with peers who will be with them all the way through primary, and experience of being in a school environment so will have to catch up. Not advisable.

NewYorkLassie · 05/07/2022 20:05

I wasn’t worried at all about the academics when summer born DC1 started school, and I was right not. They are the top reader in the year and now on a book band 3 years above.

I was worried about the practical side of school. Making sure they could get changed independently, would ask for the toilet if they needed it and could clean themselves up properly after a poo. So we worked on things through the summer. I spent the first few months worried they would starve because they were a bit fussy and rubbish with a knife and fork.

They honestly came on leaps and bounds with the practical life skills very quickly.

Noodledoodledoo · 05/07/2022 20:00

My son is August born, just finishing Year 1. So has missed half of school nursery and chunk of reception. He is finishing the year one of the highest reading level groups and gets taken out of the class for extra maths most days.

There is some evidence they are behind, but lots of contributing factors have helped my son - being the second has definitely helped as he wants to keep up with big sister!

The hardest thing I have found is not comparing them, they are in consecutive years so really hard not to but they are 2 years apart age wise, as I can recall what eldest did when!

Like any thing - so much is down to the individual circumstances - so many factors can influence outcomes. Does your friends daughter understand her big words or is she just parroting them! My daughter says all sorts but doesn't always know what she is on about!

MiniMoosey · 05/07/2022 19:58

My daughter is very end of august but she was at nursery full time since 2 so I knew she was ready. She was and still is far exceeding the work of others in her class, including some of the children in the year above (they are in mixed classes.)

it very much depends on the child.

mummydoingamasters · 05/07/2022 19:58

@notnow86 your friend sounds like she's projecting her insecurities at you and your DD. Ignore ignore ignore!

School is tough enough without other parents trying to take her down before she evens starts 🙄

SmileyPiuPiu · 05/07/2022 19:57

notnow86 · 05/07/2022 19:53

Thanks again everyone. Feeling much better.
None of my friends / family have August babies so I started to panic a little today after my friends comments.

DH just said my Friend who's birthday is in September was terrible at school 🙈 (they used to go to the same school) and he'll love to remind her 🙈

I think she's fine socially. She's been going to nursery 4 days a week, and they always say how confident she is and how she gets involved with everything and everyone. So I'm not worried about her being too immature, it was just the academic side, as my friend pointed out how much better her DDs speech was compared to mine( her DD can use big words-
More intellectual words I guess)

Shes not your friend. She's a competitive nightmare

therarebear · 05/07/2022 19:55

We started our Summer-born daughter a year later at Compulsory School Age (so she started at 5 not 4). Academically she was ready, but emotionally not. We're very glad we did this as she is thriving in her adopted cohort. But equally so are some of her Summer-born friends in her year who started at 4! You know your child best and whether or not they're ready! Your friend sounds like a bit of a dick.

daisychainsandrainbows · 05/07/2022 19:54

The difference between just 4 and almost 5 is pretty huge and summer born children can certainly appear noticeably younger when starting school and take a bit longer to get into the flow of full time school than their autumn born peers. But that doesn't mean that all or even most summer born children are going to struggle.

As they get older the gap becomes proportionately less and, for example, just 10 vs nearly 11 isn't really significant at all.

Your friend is a dick though, and frankly so is her mum to say that any children she taught were dumb. Don't worry about it OP, I'm sure your daughter, like many hundreds of thousands of summer born children before her, will be fine.

manysummersago · 05/07/2022 19:53

Well, there are obviously numerous examples of august borns doing brilliantly.

On a general rather than individual level, this isn’t true. It does tend to be boys rather than girls who are most impacted, though.

notnow86 · 05/07/2022 19:53

Thanks again everyone. Feeling much better.
None of my friends / family have August babies so I started to panic a little today after my friends comments.

DH just said my Friend who's birthday is in September was terrible at school 🙈 (they used to go to the same school) and he'll love to remind her 🙈

I think she's fine socially. She's been going to nursery 4 days a week, and they always say how confident she is and how she gets involved with everything and everyone. So I'm not worried about her being too immature, it was just the academic side, as my friend pointed out how much better her DDs speech was compared to mine( her DD can use big words-
More intellectual words I guess)

OP posts:
YouCantSpellAmericaWithoutErica · 05/07/2022 19:52

Your “friend” is a rude, condescending twat and if it’s true her mother as a teacher made such sweeping generalisations about August born children, then she’s probably a shit teacher.

I’m a summer baby and struggled at school but my siblings who are summer born too thrived at school and left with excellent grades.

mummydoingamasters · 05/07/2022 19:52

I'm august born and doing ok. My two children are august born and will also be fine. It's nothing to do with when they are born and more to do with how much effort they put in.

With mixed classes, kids will be challenged and encouraged to work above their age where possible anyway so it will all balance out and those that need support will get it regardless of when they were born!

You're friend sounds a bit twatty to be honest.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 05/07/2022 19:52

My brother was born end of August. He got a First Class Masters in Maths from Durham... he was top of the class from Yr1!

My June born girl struggled a lot more than my March born girl. But... she has Dyslexia. Her birthdate is irrelevant in that. The March born one would have been fine going at 3.5years.

Statistically, the younger ones are more likely to struggle, especially at first. But its not inevitable. They are often smaller and had less time in preschool. But a good school helps them all achieve their potential.

Perplexed0522 · 05/07/2022 19:50

Your friend was being pretty insensitive however there has been lots of research done into this issue and statistically there are disadvantages (socially, academically and mentally) to Summer born children starting school at such a young age.

There will be lots of stories of people with well achieving summer born babies and they are of course most likely true as not all summer babies will struggle, but like I said, from a statistical point of view there are associated difficulties.

My August born son ‘should’ have started school last year, 2 weeks after his fourth birthday, but me and DH had always known from when we found out I was pregnant with a summer baby that we would defer his start. As a result he’s starting Reception this year, two weeks after his fifth birthday.

Please don’t worry yourself and just see how she managed and if she does struggle there is the option to take her out and just restart her in reception the following year with the schools agreement.

Lancrelady80 · 05/07/2022 19:50

(Apr to Aug, obv!)

HerRoyalHappiness · 05/07/2022 19:49

I'm August born and was in the gifted and talented groups.
DS2 is also August born and hasn't ever struggled academically (which made it harder getting his autism diagnosis)
I don't buy into the whole August borns are dumb etc. At the end of the day your friend doesn't sound much of a friend if she's trying to convince you your child will be behind.

Lancrelady80 · 05/07/2022 19:48

Well, your friend isn't being all that friendly.

There's no hard and fast evidence. They're certainly not dumb just because of August birthdays! But they may be a bit less mature and be having to tackle things they are not developmentally ready for. It's really dependent on the individual child, and you know them best. There was a big campaign for summer born babies (April-Sept) to be allowed to start a year later, and that is now a lot easier to do if you feel it is right. But equally, some children are as ready as older peers.

You could also look into starting them within the same school year but a term later, as that's an option too if you are very worried. But to me that's the worst of both worlds - still v young and now a term behind classmates in making friends, learning how to be in school etc.

Personally I think all children should start formal school later, but that's another issue)

Really, it does just depend on the individual child. Your friend needs to back off.

astersugar · 05/07/2022 19:47

My August boy is just finishing year 1. Academically he's flying but he did struggle incredibly with tiredness all through reception and most of the way into year 1. Where I live it is not common to delay entry for summer born children but if it were then I would have done this. He's coping well at school but children shouldn't have to just cope: they should thrive. Given his abilities I do think he would have been bored academically if we had been able to delay him but I think it would have had benefits in terms of his maturity, tiredness and social interactions.

motogirl · 05/07/2022 19:46

I'm an August birthday, I was fine, my dp is also August born, he did fine. By year 3 you can't tell, often sooner

notnow86 · 05/07/2022 19:46

Thanks so much everyone for the reassurance! Exactly what I need to read right now.

Well done to all your end of summer babies for doing soo well 😃

I'm hoping the same for DD regardless of the month she was born

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread