Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

August Babies -starting school

84 replies

notnow86 · 05/07/2022 19:35

My friend has a DD born in Oct, my DD was born in Aug. They'll both be starting school in September.

Friend keeps making comments about how she's worried that my DD will be behind and how she's so little and she won't be achieving great grades etc...

I've never been worried until now when I'm thinking maybe she's right?! AIBU to think she shouldn't be making these comments ? Her mother used to teach and apparently all august born children are dumb and never catch up

However my DH insists August born children aren't lacking at academics and will catch up eventually.

Any experience? Please tell me my DD will be fine! 🙈 I'm really anxious now

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TwiggletLover · 06/07/2022 08:45

There is a reason why the government has changed the law to allow summer born children to be deferred. ALL of the statistics show that summer born children are at a disadvantage. Lots or people are focusing on the academic side but actually it's the emotional impact which is more concerning. Summer borns are more likely to have mental health problems, commit suicide or go to prison. These are the factors that have persuaded me to defer my DC. I did a lot of research and came across hardly any disadvantages to deferring. My DC is bright and would probably have coped with school this year but deferring will mean that they are 100% ready and thrive.
My brother was born in August and academically and professionally he has done extremely well however emotionally it was a struggle and thought it was a very good idea for us to defer.
In most countries including Scotland it is very common to defer, or children start later anyway.

Curiosity101 · 06/07/2022 08:45

@Lessofallthisunpleasantness you can apply to send any child born April 1st - Aug 31st to school in reception at compulsory school age (aged 5). There's no guarantee that they'll get approval but it's meant to be whatever is in the child's best interests. There's very few children who will benefit from missing reception so I'd definitely recommend a delayed CSA reception start over skipping reception and going straight into Yr1

LMS123 · 06/07/2022 08:11

I have an August birthday and am naturally academic so I excelled at school. My brother who is September born and isn’t academic struggled immensely.

Your friend’s behaviour isn’t very friendly. I agree that it sounds like she’s insecure and is trying to make you feel the same.

Piglet89 · 06/07/2022 08:09

My friend also made me feel shit about this; she deferred her son who was born around the same date as mine in August (just 3 years earlier).

she Was quoting all the stats about impact on summer born boys; I was like “why are you doing this when we have already told you we have chosen not to defer him?”

as a PP said, people like this are competitive nightmares.

changingforthebetter3 · 06/07/2022 08:04

My child is year 4, born end August, exceeding expectations in all areas. My year 1 child is December born & behind in most areas.

Change123today · 06/07/2022 07:47

My daughter has 3 August friends all did very well in their GCSE & Alevels. Only two of them knew each other, interestingly all 3 took a year out - not sure if it was a mix of lockdown & turning 18 so much later in the year. All going this September to go medics, vet & art degrees :)

My worry is you always going to have to have someone the youngest! How this mix could affect things like grade boundaries in GCSE if we don’t have this more even spread. Or access to 11+

I have a September born & I remember back when she turned 4 thinking if she had been born earlier she wouldn’t have been ready for school….but by the November she was bored at nursery and I changed my mind 😂

Lancrelady80 · 06/07/2022 01:28

They would start in Yr1 rather than Recep

Not true!

It used to be, but there was a massive campaign around summer born babies to try to stop this happening, and the then Ed Sec wrote to schools strongly recommending they listened to the parents. It's now far easier to start later if necessary without the mountains of evidence I had to collect for ds. And they should start in Reception and stay with that cohort, although some schools /LAs may try to shift them back up to make the computer happy. But they do NOT miss out Reception or another year to make up!

Lessofallthisunpleasantness · 06/07/2022 00:35

I am August born. slow ish to start reading my Mum said but I got straight As at GCSE, decent A'levels, a good degree and a professional qualification on top of that. Don't worry, it all shakes down through the years. If you think they aren't ready just keep them out of reception and send them in yr 1.

TheSoapyFrog · 06/07/2022 00:33

Your friend is wrong, and weird tbh.
However, my son is early August, and I do kind of wish I had kept him back a year. He really struggles with the work set for his year group. But then it's possible the time off school during the pandemic may have affected him also.

hellosunshineagainx · 06/07/2022 00:31

Statistically yes summer born children do worse at school.

But there are so many other factors that are more important to a child doing well at school than the age they started.

I'm summer born and I struggled to get to 'average' academically until year 5, was in all the special classes before then. But then I really continued to blossom in all ways and was in top sets etc by year 8 in secondary school.

Please try not to worry. I have an aug born little boy too but I'm not worried xxx

Vikinga · 06/07/2022 00:28

It can even be advantageous for bright kids so they don't get bored.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 06/07/2022 00:19

I’m August born and I am a banking lawyer in the City with the mythical MN 6figure salary.

DS1 is August born 3 very good a levels. Just finished the first year of his science based degree at a Russell Group Uni with a first.

DS2 also August born (I know - planned that well🤣🤣) is finishing year 10 with good predicted GCSE grades.

DN2 August born - just completed 2nd year of a science degree at a RG Uni.

They can start a bit slower but I found mine really started to catch up by Yr3-4. By secondary there was no noticeable difference eg once they can read, they can read.

Dancingwithhyenas · 06/07/2022 00:10

Your friend is being unkind and talking about ‘grades’ is a bit bizarre for reception children.
Statistically summer born children do leas well even up to GCSE compared with winter born peers, but that doesn’t mean your child will. Clearly many summer born children (as above!) do very well indeed.

Some parents choose to defer their summer born a year because they aren’t ready and some don’t. You know your child best. I would ignore her.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 05/07/2022 23:53

I was an August baby… the only disadvantages I had were my friends could excuse themselves from school at 18, but I had to have a parent note. Oh and I was the last to turn 16 so I was the last of my friends to get my drivers license… an drink legally at 21 (US). Other than that zero difference.

PMAmostofthetime · 05/07/2022 23:16

@notnow86
Stop worrying they will all be learning the same things.

Me and my best friend were August and September babies. We were both in top sets, we both went to university and both have good jobs. There was a year between us but we were taught the same.

If this was the case there would be uproar and staggered school starts.

X

TwiggletLover · 05/07/2022 23:09

Very rude of your friend but just to pick up on others comments there is a considerable amount of evidence which shows that summer born children do worse all the way through there time at school and even into adult life. This is why we've decided to defer our summer born DC

pinksquash13 · 05/07/2022 22:56

This data is a bit old now but I doubt it's changed. There are statistical differences between autumn and summer children's performance but of course this doesn't mean your summer born won't cope / be smart. As you can see, the gap is very small by gcse. I also think it's interesting to note that SEN is more likely to be diagnosed in summer born (like someone else said, proving that it's age appropriate behaviour in wrong class). There is also evidence about performance in sport because you're often playing with physically more developed pupils. The data doesn't tell the story for every child (obviously) and of course there's loads of successful adult summer borns.

August Babies -starting school
Flubbler · 05/07/2022 22:46

Ah don’t worry. My august baby is miles ahead of children older than her , my October baby is wonderfully average.

Funkyblues101 · 05/07/2022 22:45

My end of August girl is now 12 and one of the cleverest in her year. She was chomping at the bit to go to school. Her teachers said they would never have guessed she was the youngest. If your child is keen to go then they will probably be fine.

EllaDuggee · 05/07/2022 22:43

"All August born children are dumb" - your friend is the dumb one. That makes no sense. I was born in August and always way ahead academically.

NotthatKindofpickle · 05/07/2022 22:21

My DD is born end of August. She is excelling academically.

However, where I can see she's lagging behind is in in terms of confidence, social skills and gross motor skills and I see similar in the other summer born kids.

I wish she'd been born a bit later or that we had deferred. All her nursery and pre school teachers strongly advised us not to hold her back by a year as they thought she was too advanced and would get bored but I wish we had.

I don't think it matters when they are older but there's a big difference between a four year old and a five year old developmentally.

Palmtree9 · 05/07/2022 22:09

August baby here. Was always at the top end of grades amongst my friends, did ok at uni in both under and post grad courses, then a PGCE and now a teacher.
Couldn't tell you in my classes who is a September baby and who is an August one. I can tell you, though, who has been raised by loving parents/loving home/nurtured Vs those who have not had this.
Best advice? Ignore friend.

turquoise1988 · 05/07/2022 22:07

@user29 Did you read the full OP?

The OP's friend said, "all August children are dumb" and that her child "won't get good grades."

Hmm
turquoise1988 · 05/07/2022 22:05

Statistically, many summer born children struggle.

In reality, many don't.

My daughter is August born and has always done well, socially and academically.

I have taught many summer-born children who are far more academically able and socially confident than their much older peers.

Birthdays can matter, but how much support a child gets at home matters more.

I would also add that whilst I've taught many able
Autumn-born children, I have also taught many who are too confident and sure of themselves, to the point where they think they already know everything and don't have to bother putting in the effort. They can become disengaged and also be what I would deem 'at a disadvantage' because they would have been more suited to the year above.

user29 · 05/07/2022 22:01

She is right though.It is a well documented fact that overall summer borns are still slightly behind autumn borns even at GCSE

Swipe left for the next trending thread