Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pissed off Reception classes being split

187 replies

Irritatedmum · 05/07/2022 17:22

There are two classes in each year at my DDs school. She’s had her transition day today (moving to year 1) and has come home absolutely devastated that they’re mixing up the classes - and she’s being split from her friends. All of them. She’s devastated, I’m so upset her her. I don’t understand the reasoning for doing it (they didn’t when my oldest moved from reception) and why she’s being split from her friends. Is this a normal thing? I’ve emailed the school.

OP posts:
catandcoffee · 05/07/2022 20:54

Irritatedmum · 05/07/2022 17:49

@waveyourpompoms i could have prepared her for it - as it was her grandad picked her up and brought her home and she walked into the house crying, that was the first we knew about it. If we’d known we could have been planting seeds for a while that she might be making new friends. I can’t see why people are being like this about a (just) five year old, I’m not talking about a teenager!

I agree parents / carers should have been informed. They then could have started the ball rolling at home.

A friend collected her twins who are being separated, one is fine the other is so emotional, this could have been discussed, if the parents new.

InChocolateWeTrust · 05/07/2022 20:51

Completely normal to mix things up.

Not fair to remove a child from every single friend, unless there's some situation going on (e.g. terrible behaviour) in which case I'd expect it to be discussed with parents first.

BobbinHood · 05/07/2022 20:51

What’s the point being in a 2+ form intake school unless they mix them up sometimes?

Tentpegsandtantrums · 05/07/2022 20:47

I agree with @MisterMist - it’s not always a good thing!

ItsSnowJokes · 05/07/2022 20:25

This happens every year in my youngsters school. It never happened when my eldest was at school (there is a large age gap) I can see pros and cons. There were definitely some children I would have preferred my eldest not to be with all the way through school, but she would have been devastated if her boy best friend and her were split up.

Jijithecat · 05/07/2022 20:05

I think it's a positive thing. There are some very tight cliques in my eldest DC's school. If they shuffled them around more they might be more adaptable.
My youngest DC's class was mixed last year and it's been really positive. They now have more friends because they've been given the opportunity to play and mix with different children.

cptartapp · 05/07/2022 20:03

Ds2 was one of six four year old reception children put in with the year 1 class from the word go after a months initial assessment to determine those most suitable. Lots of promises about how they would make sure this group would mix with the other 24 in reception to form friendships etc, in reality it never really happened and this small group stuck together and really missed out socially.
Interestingly, these six were among some of the highest performing academically at 16 in GCSE's, but it wasn't the best start to primary school.

LouisRenault · 05/07/2022 19:55

I would raise it with the school. They may not be able to change it but could at least explain the rationale behind it.

They'll only be able to discuss it in the most general terms, because of pupil confidentiality. So OP will probably end up none the wiser.

CallOnMe · 05/07/2022 19:42

but at 5 years old it just seems so cruel.
They’re at the stage where friendships and playing is just so important, and after spending a year building relationships for them to be taken away, you know?

5 year olds make friends much easier then older ages.

Most bigger primary schools do this every year and I think it’s a good idea for them to mix up as it gets them used to making friends with new people and it really benefits them and their confidence.

I’ve always felt very sorry for children who go to tiny primary schools and then have to transition to massive secondary schools.
The one near me has 26 pupils in total so less than 5 in each year group and the majority have been there since reception and will finish in year 6 with the exact same children in the class.

Hermione101 · 05/07/2022 19:36

She just needs to get on with it. They’re splitting up my son’s year 1 class after two years together in nursery and reception. They’re 5, they’ll live and move on and make new friends. It’s really not a big deal.

Hesma · 05/07/2022 19:32

Your being very precious

SunnyNights · 05/07/2022 19:31

Plus my DS's class were asked who they wanted in the senior school mentor class so it can be done that way - and that's in a huge secondary school.

SunnyNights · 05/07/2022 19:29

I would raise it with the school. They may not be able to change it but could at least explain the rationale behind it.

WhereIsVillanelleWhenNeeded · 05/07/2022 19:27

Theres always a parent that contacts the school and very rarely do they change their mind. It will probably happen when she enters KS2, again when they start secondary school and again when options are picked. It’s upsetting each time but they do get over it and make new friends. You need to be positive about it in her presence so as not to upset her any more than she is already.

Blondeshavemorefun · 05/07/2022 19:25

The teachers didn’t have a say in it. They found out the same time as us

all the head

and no she isn’t swapping any children about

i wouldn’t mind so much but there are 3 girls including dd from her old class. She doesn’t really play with either and prefers
any of the other think 11 which are now 5 and 6 split into the other 2 new classes

why not if 15 girls split 555 to the 3 new classes

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 05/07/2022 19:18

Its completely normal at ds school he was separated from all his friends because he messed around with them and the next year he was back with a few then rejigged again, they normally don't tell parents the classes in advance ro stop all the parents complaining there kids have been separated from friends

RedWreck · 05/07/2022 19:16

It might be normal but it still really hurts when it's YOUR dc that appears to have been separated from their friends.
OP this happened to my dd as she started Y3. I was absolutely gutted & doubt any parent would be happy about it! She was in a different class to ALL her friends & with a lot of children with behaviour issues.
I spoke to the headteacher who tried to put my mind at rest but I was very upset. It was awful.
However, it was all for the best. She became much more independent & developed communication skills that saw her through her teenage years & was able to converse & be diplomatic with anybody. She is now a very well balanced young woman who is well equipped for the world.
If she'd gone with all her friends it might have been different. She still saw them of course but it took them out of each others pockets.
Just as a disclaimer, the school staff still talk about how difficult a lot of her class was even 10 years later!
There will be a positive side to this but I do feel for you.

mizzo · 05/07/2022 19:15

I'd speak to the teachers, they did this with DC1 but it wasn't out of the blue. We'd discussed at parents evening how DD was being overpowered by her friendship group.
However they also did it with DC3's class and it was due to a majority of children with additional needs in the other class and two children who's parents had formed a relationship and didn't want the children to be in the same class. They simply picked the same amount from DC's class to swap,
I asked for DC to stay and as it happened another parent wanted their DC to switch so mine stayed with his friends.

Lorzest · 05/07/2022 19:06

Blimey - parents at my Child’s school are constantly asking teachers stuff. I’m often what the heck?! There are 30 kids and one teacher, how can they follow up on every trivial thing. In my book though, this is a pretty big deal, too big, to do it completely unannounced. My child got to choose three friends for a 2 night residential and we were talked through the details of the trip. I get that it might be desirable to make some changes if that possibility is there, however in single class intakes it’s not an option and everyone seems to survive. You are your child’s advocate. Don’t ‘complain’ just ask for further information on the rationale and relay how upset she is. That way you can support your daughter by explaining the why or see if a change is feasible if the change seems unwarranted. You never know, there may be another parent thinking the same so a swop could be made. I am sympathetic to teachers overwhelmed with trivia but on this one I think you reap what you sow - choose to share no information with parents and you can expect lots of individuals contacting the school.

Popsicales · 05/07/2022 19:02

A little upsetting for her but a normal thing for schools to do. Just use it as an opportunity to build her resilience! There’ll always be lots of changes/things she’s unhappy with at school and it’s important you don’t give off the message of ‘mum will email and sort it out’. I say this as a teacher of a Y6 class with lots of parents who constantly complain about the slightest inconvenience. Their children are now on a secondary transition week and are struggling MASSIVELY despite all the work we’ve put in.

woodhill · 05/07/2022 19:01

Very normal unfortunately

ladygindiva · 05/07/2022 18:59

op my twins go into year 1 in september ; also a dual class system and theirs is being mixed up too. I've been led to believe from a member of staff that one class had a much larger number of children needing more attention for various reasons so evening out the classes benefits just about everyone. I understand your disappointment though;and it may be worth just mentioning your dds upset at being with none of her friends to see if anything can be done.

Outwiththenorm · 05/07/2022 18:57

Absolutely do contact the school. My Dsis is a primary teacher and reports instances of management stepping in and making random switches of children for god knows what reason after the teachers have spent hours on class lists. Your DD should be with at least one friend.

redskyatnight · 05/07/2022 18:55

Irritatedmum · 05/07/2022 17:40

Thank you everyone. I do understand theres more to it than parents would realise, but at 5 years old it just seems so cruel. They’re at the stage where friendships and playing is just so important, and after spending a year building relationships for them to be taken away, you know?

She will still see them before school, at breaks, at lunchtimes, after school and any time you choose to set up a playdate.
And in year 1 there is much less free play time during actual lessons.
My DC went to a school that mixed classes every year. They took the approach that this meant they could make new friends whilst still seeing old ones. Your child will only be "devastated" if you encourage her to be.

russianred · 05/07/2022 18:53

I would imagine it is also linked to your concern about being excluded from the secondary friendship that the mothers of all the girls have. I have seen this play out for my children and professionally. It is never a big issue at all, but parents love to make it one.

The number of times parents have complained about the set their child is in, or the peers their children is with or something else a parent perceives to be wrong is astonishing. It’s incredibly entitled. Teachers strive to do the absolute best for every child and then the class overall. It’s an impossible task. Their priority is not who plays with who at lunchtime. They also witness far more of the nuance of interactions than a parent ever will.

Swipe left for the next trending thread