Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pissed off Reception classes being split

187 replies

Irritatedmum · 05/07/2022 17:22

There are two classes in each year at my DDs school. She’s had her transition day today (moving to year 1) and has come home absolutely devastated that they’re mixing up the classes - and she’s being split from her friends. All of them. She’s devastated, I’m so upset her her. I don’t understand the reasoning for doing it (they didn’t when my oldest moved from reception) and why she’s being split from her friends. Is this a normal thing? I’ve emailed the school.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SueSaid · 08/07/2022 15:51

pinkfondu · 05/07/2022 20:55

Our schools have always made sure they've got someone in the class, I'm not surprised she's upset.

This!

Honestly how hard can it be to ensure they are in the same class as one of their friends. To have all her pals in one class and none in the one she is in does seem shit op, I agree.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 08/07/2022 15:26

Svara · 08/07/2022 11:40

It's more being blindsided by the change all together which I think is more upsetting.
But they haven't been? There's still a couple of weeks left of term where I am then the whole of the holidays for parents to discuss it with the child.

Well they sort of have...unless told otherwise I would have assumed they wouldn't change class going into yr 1 and would have already been speaking to DC about next year at school. Christ some of the parents of kids in DS's class have already sent out party invites for the September parties and only invited the current class.

Part of explaining to DS about going into yr 1 has included reassuring him that it won't be much different and he'll be with his friends just a new teacher and classroom.

If I was suddenly told now, or last week even, I'd have to undo what I'd already discussed with DS which would be even more upsetting for him as he'd feel lied to or let down by me. And tbh, it would never enter my mind to have to check that his class won't be split up as I've never know this to happen until you reach middle and/or high school. I'd certainly feel blindesided.

Svara · 08/07/2022 11:40

It's more being blindsided by the change all together which I think is more upsetting.
But they haven't been? There's still a couple of weeks left of term where I am then the whole of the holidays for parents to discuss it with the child.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 08/07/2022 11:24

PeanutButterOnToad · 08/07/2022 10:12

In my experience most schools don't tell the parents to stop the 50 e-mails saying "my Johnny can't possible be split from his best friend" with the expectation that the carefully planned class grouping will be changed for them. With three kids we have had both good and bad experiences with this over the years but most schools won't accommodate preferences. At our last primary school they only told the kids which classes they were in on the first day back, when I suggested that if we knew the classes before Summer we could prepare the kids and put a positive spin on things if it wasn't what they wanted (and maybe arrange some playdates) they agreed on the proviso that if even one parent e-mailed the school to ask for a change they would stop telling us.

TBF I had meant tell the parents that it is happening, not necessarily which children will be moved or who will be in the new class. Just a public policy thing saying something like
"Each academic year we will mix up the year group classes to help broaden the children's social circles. The new classes will be based on teachers observations only and parents and carers may not request class changes unless serious issues arise" or something like that.

It's more being blindsided by the change all together which I think is more upsetting.

PeanutButterOnToad · 08/07/2022 10:12

In my experience most schools don't tell the parents to stop the 50 e-mails saying "my Johnny can't possible be split from his best friend" with the expectation that the carefully planned class grouping will be changed for them. With three kids we have had both good and bad experiences with this over the years but most schools won't accommodate preferences. At our last primary school they only told the kids which classes they were in on the first day back, when I suggested that if we knew the classes before Summer we could prepare the kids and put a positive spin on things if it wasn't what they wanted (and maybe arrange some playdates) they agreed on the proviso that if even one parent e-mailed the school to ask for a change they would stop telling us.

Blondeshavemorefun · 08/07/2022 09:53

OopsIsay · 07/07/2022 20:56

I’ve worked in a school office for many years and I would absolutely say contact the school. They may not have any idea that it is affecting your child like this. It happened to my daughter in Y1 and I can honestly say it affected her friendship groups for several years. Most schools should not mind looking at this again.

Our head refused to move any children

OopsIsay · 07/07/2022 20:56

I’ve worked in a school office for many years and I would absolutely say contact the school. They may not have any idea that it is affecting your child like this. It happened to my daughter in Y1 and I can honestly say it affected her friendship groups for several years. Most schools should not mind looking at this again.

paisley256 · 07/07/2022 20:46

Mine have all been split, one of whom from all his mates, they do see each other at break, even though it seems devastating at the time, they do cope in the end. I was gutted for my son but he was fine after a week or so.

Blondeshavemorefun · 07/07/2022 20:38

This is the first time school has done this at ours

if schools much do it. Tell the parents so they can let kids know

liveforsummer · 07/07/2022 19:27

I work in a school and we mix the classes every year. As we remind the dc, good friends don't always equal good learning partners. It's good for them to expand their friendships too.

LifesTooShortForYourNonsense · 07/07/2022 19:12

There are 2 years in each class at my kids primary (very small!) So as they move up the mix constantly changes.

I would trust the teaching staff tbh - I’m sure you find that different levels and subjects will be grouped together at different times, and it does all work out.

ChateauMargaux · 07/07/2022 17:19

There have been years where this has caused many tears in my experience of primary school.. 3 kids... not least the year DS1 was placed with his bully which I complained about onky to be told there was nothing the school was prepared to do, later to find out that they moved another child... it was terrible. Another year.. school put all of the sporty boys apart from one, in one class... the left out kid spent the entire year being miserable.

zingally · 07/07/2022 16:38

Speaking as a primary teacher, sorting classes is a bloody nightmare, always takes ages, and I can promise you, A LOT of thought has gone into it.

There are so many factors to take into consideration. At this age, your DD will be completely fine. She'll make new friends in class, and see the old ones at play and lunch time.

Liverpoolgirl · 07/07/2022 15:41

My oldest school did this every year, and it hit her hard in year 1/ year 2 because she had been bullied terribly and was being split from her best friend, but was still with some of her other friends.
I battled them over it but got nowhere, the only thing that saved her more heartache was that her bully changed schools.
The only positive was that now in year 6 they are like one big group, they all all mix well and are friends. Eventhough they are still in separate classes.

rosyAndMoo · 07/07/2022 15:06

They did this in my neice’s school one year. Only because when they get the names for reception, they don’t know anything about the kids, one year they had two classes of 30 children and one class ended up having 9 children with emotional, behavioural or learning difficulties that’s weren’t known about when they first put them in classes in reception. They amended the next year so that they were split 4 and 5 based on similar needs to allow the teachers and teaching assistants to get the right balance of kids to teach in each class. It also allowed them to share a couple of TA’s for children who ended up with EHCP’s that requires the couple of kids to have assistance in small groups, leaving the teacher more able to teach those kids without EHCP’s

Buttonjugs · 07/07/2022 12:25

I didn’t vote because I don’t think you’re being unreasonable in that you’re concerned for your daughter, but maybe unreasonable because it’s a common practice. Some children will find this really challenging, especially if they’re shy and find it difficult to make friends. I would make an appointment to go into school to discuss it if you feel that it will be upsetting for your child.

Volhhg · 07/07/2022 12:00

YANBU. Yes it's normal unfortunately but the school should have communicated this with you and other parents at the beginning of the year. It is perfectly reasonable to speak with them about the reasons behind their choice for your child especially if your child has been selected as the 15 going into a mixed year group out of a 45 cohort. It may be that they select children by age and to me that is much fairer

BotCrossHuns · 07/07/2022 11:41

We were mixed up every year (3 form entry) and it was just the norm. Nobody expected to stay as 'a class' in any way, and parents were not consulted or given any input. It's just what happened. Some years, disappointing, other years, good. It was much less of an issue that it seems to be now. You played with people from whatever class you wanted on the playground, and sometimes the year group mixed up for things like maths or spelling or whatever, into sets ,or did projects and topics with the other classes. You felt yourself part of a year group, rather than a class. It was always a surprise for the first day of school whose class you would be in, and who would be with you. Not always pleasant or happy surprises, no, and the waiting could be hard, but it was just accepted as standard.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 07/07/2022 11:25

Ah see I think if this is what the school do or are planning on doing, they need to communicate with the parents and kids (in a way) earlier on so they can be prepared.

DS's school don't do this. He is moving into yr1 with his current reception class and will continue through his school until yr 4 when he goes to middle school and then his year group mixes with all the other feeder schools.

If I just found out suddenly that he wouldn't be with his current class next year I would be annoyed.

Blondeshavemorefun · 07/07/2022 11:08

Did the school reply to your email @Irritatedmum

Blondeshavemorefun · 07/07/2022 11:05

RockyReef · 06/07/2022 19:17

Assuming they have the same playtimes as the other class in their year group, then it won't necessarily be any different to if her friends remained in the same class. In year 1 they move (wrongly in my opinion) to much more structured learning, sitting at tables determined often by ability rather than friendship groups. So playtime is when they get to play with their friends or (which happens more commonly) they become friends with the similar-ability children sitting at their table. At my children's very small school they have composite classes with two year groups of about 10-12 children in each class - so each year their classes change because either they move up to the next class or the younger year group moves up to theirs. They all just seem to mix in and quickly make new friends or re-establish old friendships.

Our new class isn’t ability

without sounding cocky or pushy my 5yr can write her name , read well and spell simple words

least 2 in her new class can barely write their name , not sure about reading but def can’t spell simple words if having difficulty spelling and writing own name

Tillow4ever · 07/07/2022 10:33

Not RTFT but have read the OP’s comments.

My eldest got to the end of his reception class and when he was moving to year 1, not only did he not have a single friend with him, there was also only about 5 kids from his previous class going into the new one.

I talked to a friend of mine who not only had children in the school, but also helped out in the school (and later went on to become a TA then a teacher). She told me not to worry - she said that in all her years she had never seen a wrong decision over placement in new classes and that they spend a long time working out the best groupings for the following year.

Academically, she was right - he absolutely shone from year 1 onwards and perhaps separating him from his friends who were distracting him was the best plan. Friendship wise, he had friends still - but that friendship group from reception are still going strong now (aged 17) and he’s not part of that at all which is a little sad. He’s never really had many friends now that I look back and think about it - but the ones he does have are GOOD friends, really genuine and the sort he’ll have for life.

Would his friendship group have been different had he stayed with them? I have no way of knowing. But I do know he’s now looking at Russell group universities and if he hadn’t knuckled down from an early age, maybe he wouldn’t have that opportunity now!

Your daughter will be ok. They make new friends much easier at the younger age. The school is privy to a lot more than you are - maybe she sees that the friendships aren’t healthy for your daughter (my youngest was separated from his cousin after reception class because the school saw that she was bossing him around, he’d do whatever she said/asked/told him to do for example - but I didn’t see that out of school) and so they want to give her the chance to make better friends. Or maybe they’ve felt your daughter needs more support academically and do have put her in a different class. Or that her friends need more support. Perhaps your daughter is gifted so they are putting her with a group to push her.

Many schools do lots of combined year group activities, so it may only be when she’s in the physical class room that she won’t see her old friends, but for things like PE, drama, etc they might all work together still!

Please try not to worry.

angela99999 · 07/07/2022 09:51

Surely she and her current friends will still be together at playtime? This should just widen her friendship group.

MisterMist · 06/07/2022 23:54

AngelinaFibres · 06/07/2022 23:13

It's nothing to do with tough love. It's about building resilience, creating better balanced classes for the benefit of the children in them, presenting children with managed challenges. We have no idea what the situation is with Ops daughter and her friendship group and whether the dynamics of that aid or drastically hinder her or their learning.

I'd say it was more Piaget than Sigmund Freud .

I'd say it's more BS

Goldencarp · 06/07/2022 23:23

Why on earth would you email the school? It’s not uncommon and is good for the kids to form new friendships!