Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be totally on the anti UPF bandwagon and think this may finally be how I crack my food addiction?

184 replies

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 05/07/2022 15:20

Listened to the podcast by the Van Tulleken brothers, and then read some of the Brazilian research and the experiment with UPF/whole food diet. Listened to some Giles Yeo. Oh my goodness. Mind blown!

I have a binge eating disorder and it was getting so out of hand. Spent fortunes a week on extra secret food, all of it crap. Gaining a lot of weight. I could eat 6 supermarket hot cross buns at a time and still feel like I wanted more even while feeling sick. Whole packets of biscuits in minutes. It didn't make any sense to me but I felt like I just couldn't stop. Now it makes a lot of sense why - I've basically been eating the food equivalent of heroin.

I've cut it out this past week or two - whenever I have been craving it I just go and listen to an episode or two of the podcast again and am horrified anew so resist. I've also accepted the fact I'm never going to manage to not eat with willpower alone so have packed my bag with healthy whole food snacks - nuts, Greek yoghurt, chopped vegetables, hummus - so I don't 'need' to go to the shop for some lunch (and walk out with a load of garbage).

I felt much better almost instantly. Clear headed. Less bloated and sluggish, less achey. Less sick obviously. And much, much less hungry. Staying within calorie limits (that always seemed laughably low and restrictive whilst eating junk) suddenly incredibly easy. In not weighing myself as my scales are broken but how I feel is worth it on its own.

Over the weekend my DD got a vomiting bug for the millionth time this summer, bad nights sleep, feeling grotty etc. So Monday I decided to treat myself t a toasted panini from the work cafe. Supermarket bread, weird cheese etc - real comforting junk food of the type I just can't get enough of usually.

Reader it was DIABOLICAL. It tasted AWFUL. I've eaten these things so many times before and loved them. But it was horrible. I literally could not eat it, had two mouthfuls, spat the second one out and threw it in the bin.

I honestly feel like I've had some sort of damascene conversion. Every time I think about buying some crap now I just remember the horrible, inedible crapness of that panini and the urge just goes away again.

AIBU to think this could actually change my life??? Can simple awareness really override such a lifelong, established addictive behaviour? Or will this just be a flash in the pan?

OP posts:
MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 06/07/2022 08:23

@Harridance my 5yo lass actually quite likes a sourdough sandwich! But an alternative in thinking of (still just working on myself right now!) is just skipping sandwiches altogether. My kids never eat a sandwich as a sandwich anyway, they always pick it apart and eat the filling first and then the bread and butter 😆 so I'm thinking when I'm making packed lunches (she's on free school lunches at the mo as reception) I might just make pots with cooked chicken, cheese cubes, hummus, chopped veg etc. Although to be fair it matters not what I put in front of her on any given day she may want everything or nothing and there's no rhyme or reason!

OP posts:
NoAprilFool · 06/07/2022 08:23

Omelette and salads are 2 things my daughter would not eat sadly (DH and I often have that for lunch when she’s at school though)
@Harridance ive been wondering about making my own wraps for packed lunches but not sure how they’d keep

Fere · 06/07/2022 08:14

@Harridance look for Vogel bread

RoseWindow · 06/07/2022 07:52

‘Home’ not ‘tips’ in my previous post, bad autocorrect. There’s only so many omelettes and salad that I can force on them..

Harridance · 06/07/2022 07:45

My issue is what bread is a good alternative to make pack lunch sandwiches out of?, because unless it's sliced, shop bought - its bigger, dryer, harder etc and not so easy to make sandwiches for the kids out of, any suggestions appreciated

NoAprilFool · 06/07/2022 07:35

@RoseWindow that's one of my main issues too - what to make that the rest of the family will eat 🙄

RoseWindow · 05/07/2022 18:17

I think most shop bought biscuits are probably UPF given the fats or flavourings and sometimes preservatives that are not typically found at tips.

I really want to eat in this way (non UPF) and loved the BBC podcast, but with fussy eater preteen DC I find they look very warily at things I cook.

They seem to have complete focus on eating anything out of a packet with a nice picture on. Even if I have cooked it. So non-UPF recipes/food ideas to eat with kids would be very welcome. I’d also love anyone’s sourdough recipe if they’d care to share it! Well done everyone who’s getting there with this, I think it has to be a really positive thing to do.

Bertieboo82 · 05/07/2022 18:15

This is great Op

but you sound incredibly excited and it’s only one week down. Don’t be disappointed if you fall off the wagon (which you will inevitably at some point), just climb back on and crack on

good luck!

pastaandpesto · 05/07/2022 18:12

LaurieFairyCake · 05/07/2022 17:53

Is a digestive biscuit a UPF?

When I was a child that was the healthy biscuit Grin

Very much UPF I'm afraid!

(but like you I still can't quite shake my childhood opinion that they are a healthy biscuit!)

Fairislefandango · 05/07/2022 17:57

YANBU. It's fascinating and horrifying in equal measure. I started listening to the Chris & Xand podcast too - I must finish it.

The other thing with these foods is that they seem to circumnavigate your natural "I'm full now" feeling

Yes, definitely. I think one theory is that it's because they don't have enough actual nutrients in them to trigger satiety.

LaurieFairyCake · 05/07/2022 17:53

Is a digestive biscuit a UPF?

When I was a child that was the healthy biscuit Grin

FlipFlops4Me · 05/07/2022 17:50

I usually do overnight oats with some chia seeds, chopped nuts and sliced fruit for breakfast. I don't bother with any sweetening as I find the fruit does the job nicely.

I used to eat a LOT of bought granola and I really don't think it did me any good. I have a nice recipe for some to make at home that I'm planning on having a go at next week.

Onlyhuman123 · 05/07/2022 17:42

Literally finished listening to the pod cast today whilst out walking...awful how manufacturers are causing the majority of the upf issues we have by creating products with the perfect ratio of sugar, salt and fat that keeps us coming back for more. And they can get away with it. Shocking really as they've probably been the major cause of the obesity problems we have.

I loved the bit where they read out ingredients from the packets and said if you can't make the product using ingredients that a normal home kitchen would have, then its a upf. Makes perfect sense.

I was sceptical that Xand, after a few weeks of being "upf and upd mindful" that he was suddenly SO adverse to upf products...I thought naaah that's a bit of a stretch but now seeing you write this I'm kinda thinking it does work!

In the 50s/60s it was very rare for individuals be overweight - we had barely any upf or upd products in those days...roll forward to the 80s and BAM the weightloss and diet industry took off in a big way - upf and upd products had started to take effect. Scary.

RudsyFarmer · 05/07/2022 17:26

I’m a careful eater but I slip. I shall look these recommendations up xx

Ylvamoon · 05/07/2022 17:25

I have been avoiding UPF for a long time... my rule is, no more than 5 ingredients and if I don't know what an ingredient is or its rubbish I don't buy it.
I also only have meat/ fish 2x week.

My best bit is: I eat a lot less and as a result spent less on food. Which again allows me to buy better quality foods especially meat.

@schoolsweats I make my own smoothie with frozen (or fresh) fruits, porridge oats and plain full fat yoghurt all topped up with boiled cooled water. Sometimes I add fresh ginger, or a carrot or some kale. I don't eat in the morning, but this usually keeps me going from around 7am until midday!

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 05/07/2022 17:09

@schoolsweats I often don't get breakfast (start work at 8 and it's mayhem in our house between 6 and 8!) but when I do it's porridge, boiled egg or half an avocado

OP posts:
FlipFlops4Me · 05/07/2022 16:58

I retired (yay!!) recently and after listening to the Tulleken brothers podcast I decided that all our meals will be cooked from scratch and they are so much nicer! And cheaper. I make soups for lunches, home made bread to go with (I have a machine, so it's easy), and the things I bought as UPF dinners when I worked are all being home cooked now.

I'm gobsmacked at the difference in flavour, and how little it takes to fill me and my DH up.

I am so lucky that I have time, but if you possibly can bulk cook & freeze, it really is so much healthier. I feel very different physically!

NoAprilFool · 05/07/2022 16:52

A lot of supermarket hummus has sunflower or rapeseed oil which isn’t great.

carefullycourageous · 05/07/2022 16:45

Omelette, porridge or fruit & plain yogurt.

carefullycourageous · 05/07/2022 16:43

1990s · 05/07/2022 16:11

have also looked into this but I’m a bit confused.

anything with more than 3 ingredients is likely UPF I saw, doesn’t that include hummus? (Interesting you said hummus as it’s a staple of mine and I’d been wondering)

No, it is if it is made in a way you can't at home with ingredients you can't use at home. Any houmous made at home has at least six ingredients!

pastaandpesto · 05/07/2022 16:42

And YY to not eating breakfast. I never eat until noon at the earliest and try not to eat after 9pm.

I find if I do eat breakfast, esp. if it is carb based, I am ravenous again by mid-morning, whereas I can comfortable fast until 1pm without even thinking about it otherwise. I think intermittent fasting is another really interesting area to explore in terms of how we metabolise food which is too often dismissed as being faddy.

pastaandpesto · 05/07/2022 16:37

I think this whole area is really interesting.

When I was a teen we had Fat Is Bad.
In my twenties/thirties we had Sugar is Bad.

Neither of these fully made sense to me. But I can completely buy into the idea that actually, it has been UPF that has actually been the problem with the modern western diet all along.

I've pretty much weaned myself off UPF naturally - just like you've found OP, the less of it you eat, the less you want it. For me, ditching sweet UPF was really easy - things like store-bought biscuits, cakes, donuts etc I genuinely do not like, although saying that out loud makes me sound like a bit of a wanker. I absolutely love homemade cake, but one slice is always enough because it tastes like real cake (sounding like a wanker again).

Savoury stuff less so - I do enjoy crisps, savoury pastries etc - but its easy enough not to buy them, so I don't end up eating them! I do cook with bacon and sausages from time to time which I know are awful but never mind.

I wish I could get the message through to teenage DS though. He's at the age where they are all buying shit from the shop after school and I can see him developing really unhealthy, bingey eating patterns.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 05/07/2022 16:35

@Member869894 Ultra processed food.

schoolsweats · 05/07/2022 16:35

Thank you, I think missing breakfast might be the best option for me too, I don't eat eggs and always end up with cereal or toast.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 05/07/2022 16:34

@schoolsweats

There's a really good article here: www.theguardian.com/food/2020/feb/13/how-ultra-processed-food-took-over-your-shopping-basket-brazil-carlos-monteiro

Also, this is the Nova system they reference: world.openfoodfacts.org/nova (quite the eye opener!)