Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be totally on the anti UPF bandwagon and think this may finally be how I crack my food addiction?

184 replies

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 05/07/2022 15:20

Listened to the podcast by the Van Tulleken brothers, and then read some of the Brazilian research and the experiment with UPF/whole food diet. Listened to some Giles Yeo. Oh my goodness. Mind blown!

I have a binge eating disorder and it was getting so out of hand. Spent fortunes a week on extra secret food, all of it crap. Gaining a lot of weight. I could eat 6 supermarket hot cross buns at a time and still feel like I wanted more even while feeling sick. Whole packets of biscuits in minutes. It didn't make any sense to me but I felt like I just couldn't stop. Now it makes a lot of sense why - I've basically been eating the food equivalent of heroin.

I've cut it out this past week or two - whenever I have been craving it I just go and listen to an episode or two of the podcast again and am horrified anew so resist. I've also accepted the fact I'm never going to manage to not eat with willpower alone so have packed my bag with healthy whole food snacks - nuts, Greek yoghurt, chopped vegetables, hummus - so I don't 'need' to go to the shop for some lunch (and walk out with a load of garbage).

I felt much better almost instantly. Clear headed. Less bloated and sluggish, less achey. Less sick obviously. And much, much less hungry. Staying within calorie limits (that always seemed laughably low and restrictive whilst eating junk) suddenly incredibly easy. In not weighing myself as my scales are broken but how I feel is worth it on its own.

Over the weekend my DD got a vomiting bug for the millionth time this summer, bad nights sleep, feeling grotty etc. So Monday I decided to treat myself t a toasted panini from the work cafe. Supermarket bread, weird cheese etc - real comforting junk food of the type I just can't get enough of usually.

Reader it was DIABOLICAL. It tasted AWFUL. I've eaten these things so many times before and loved them. But it was horrible. I literally could not eat it, had two mouthfuls, spat the second one out and threw it in the bin.

I honestly feel like I've had some sort of damascene conversion. Every time I think about buying some crap now I just remember the horrible, inedible crapness of that panini and the urge just goes away again.

AIBU to think this could actually change my life??? Can simple awareness really override such a lifelong, established addictive behaviour? Or will this just be a flash in the pan?

OP posts:
ChandlersDad · 06/07/2022 23:11

Vegan Mayo is easy: 100ml light olive oil, 50ml unsweetened soya milk, 1tsp Dijon mustard, 1 tsp white wine vinegar, salt to taste. In a Pyrex, blend with stick blender for 5 secs.

scissorsandsellotape · 06/07/2022 21:21

QueenLagertha · 06/07/2022 21:00

There were threads about UPFs last year when the programme was on tv. Yes I agree that it is life changing. I overhauled my diet over a year ago. I feel like a new person

This sounds amazing. This is what I want.
I am def getting there.
Since the program I have been much more cautious
I am trying to explain to my children about the insidious manufacturers. The whole "once you pop"
It's hard to get them out of "biscuit o clock" but will get on more to making our own treats over summer

Like a PP I have to finish up the freezer and start again and slowly phase it all out.
I do want to mske my own mayo but someone did say it's poss to buy it and have less than with eg Hellman's

scissorsandsellotape · 06/07/2022 21:06

What is Chorley wood

scissorsandsellotape · 06/07/2022 21:05

Omg op are you me?
Place marking and off to read

QueenLagertha · 06/07/2022 21:00

There were threads about UPFs last year when the programme was on tv. Yes I agree that it is life changing. I overhauled my diet over a year ago. I feel like a new person

DoNutSweatTheSmallStuff · 06/07/2022 20:48

Really interesting thread, thanks OP!

Eileen101 · 06/07/2022 19:20

Good for you OP!
I have started with the van tulleken series and have been increasingly aware of UPF. I'm trying to decrease ours as much as possible and this month have vowed that I will go back to doing more cooking as opposed to convenience that I've ended up with since having kids.
Reading with interest.

Summerwhereareyou · 06/07/2022 17:08

All good thank you!! Appreciate it.

Allthegoodnamestakken · 06/07/2022 16:55

@Summerwhereareyou 500g plain flour, yeast about 10g but I never measure, 325ml warm water (warm will make it rise faster but don't use hot or the yeast is killed. A good glug of olive oil and then mix with a stand mixer until dough is formed. I let it rise for about 30 minutes and then split into about 8 balls, let these rise for another 20 minutes and then in a hot oven for 10-15 minutes.
Rise times may be longer as I am in a warm country at a high altitude which increases rise rate.
If you have time let it rise for an hour before shaping and 40 minutes before baking as this makes it fluffier but I don't usually bother and its perfectly acceptable as rolls. If you want them soft not crusty brush with butter and they also work great if you knead in some cheddar to make cheesy bread.
I love a nice slow fermented sour dough but I just don't have the time to make it often so this is my go to each week for sandwiches.

Whatsthisallaboutconfused · 06/07/2022 16:44

Just a thought about the bread - presumably it doesn’t have to be sourdough? Any bread that has been slow risen, and is made with only flour, yeast, water and salt should be fine too. Ie proper bakery bread. Not supermarket, force risen crap.

venusandmars · 06/07/2022 15:38

I think one of the concerning things currently is that so much of 'Plant Based Food' is uupf (ultra ultra processed). There is so much 'fake' meat, bacon, sausage, chicken etc. I thought that the whole idea of eating less meat was that for a few meals each week you eat more veg/pulses/nuts.

I was listening to something on R4 yesterday which suggested that the resources required to make some of the plant based 'chicken' uses more carbon than raising real chickens.

In eating less upf I find a real delight in the simplicity of meals - good tomatoes, with mozarella cheese and tomato, dressed with olive oil. In-season british asparagus with black pepper and butter. A salad made from cumin-roasted carrots, puy lentils, feta cheese, rocket, olive oil. Hugh FW's roast squash and walnuts two ways. HFW's beetroot and peanut butter blitz... Oh I could go on... (and on!).

I use herbs for flavouring rather than relying on artificial ingredients - fish with lemongrass, ginger, lime; chicken with blitzed corriander, basil, mint; veg with cumin, corriander seeds, fenugreek, chilli.

Several people have asked about breakfast. Most cultures didn't have sweet, starchy breakfasts until a certain Mr Kellog persuaded us all that sweetened cereal was the way to go. Look at other cultures: Mexico - huevos rancheros (eggs with spicy beans / red peppers / tomatoes). Chile was the first place I had avocado for breakfast (20 years before it was a 'thing' here). Vietnam - meat and veg soup.

Or try the Rose Elliot nut granola:
55g desicated coconut
85g chopped brazil nuts
85g chopped walnuts
85g ground almonds
85g sunflower seeds
115g melted butter
1tsp cinamon
1tsp vanilla extract
-
85g flax seeds

Put everything (except flax seeds in a bowl and mix) put on a baking tray and bake for 10-12 minutes. Return to bowl and add flax seeds.

I think the original recipe included stevia as a sweetener, but I find I don't need it. A small spoon of this, with some full fat greek yogurt and a couple of crushed strawberries - amazing.

Summerwhereareyou · 06/07/2022 15:22

@Allthegoodnamestakken

What is the bread recipe please

Summerwhereareyou · 06/07/2022 15:20

Re breakfast I'm also far far better without it!

Scianel · 06/07/2022 15:17

I buy Bassinet Bakery sourdough. It's got three ingredients.

Summerwhereareyou · 06/07/2022 15:15

Why is sourdough Vetter?

Somethingsnappy · 06/07/2022 14:41

Are there certain types of bread which are OK? I see sourdough has been mentioned. What about bakery loaves, or are they just as bad?

blobby10 · 06/07/2022 14:38

I remember reading something many years ago (and my memory isn't brilliant at exact recall so please don't quote me!) about big tobacco companies realising that the world would fall out of love with smoking and that they needed to get the population hooked on something else so they transferred all the additives used in cigarettes to junk food.

Am loving reading about how so many of you have started making your own bread/wraps/pittas etc. I'm another 'since I left home' binge eater but only on food I've bought - my son bought a jar of Nutella which I find it easy not to touch but if I buy it it would be gone in a day ! Need to get my mindset back to just not buying it! I certainly don't buy it for the taste or enjoyment of eating so wondering what on earth I waste my money on it for.

Somethingsnappy · 06/07/2022 14:35

This is an inspirational thread, thank you!

Allthegoodnamestakken · 06/07/2022 14:24

@NoAprilFool I make my own wraps using flour, oil and water they taste great the day you make them but the don't keep hugely well. Same for home made pitta and home made yeast rolls. They all however freeze pretty well, for wraps I will cook them until they are not quite done and then freeze with sheets of baking paper between you can then stick in the pan straight from frozen and finish cooking in the morning and it will still be fine at lunchtime.
My DH now refuses to eat shop bought wraps
Sourdough keeps much better on the counter but is much more of a faff to make.

Allthegoodnamestakken · 06/07/2022 14:16

I also find UPF a really interesting topic, I have been slowly trying to eliminate them apart from in situations where I really don't have time to cook. I haven't lost any weight at all but I have stopped gaining it and have stayed the same weight for the last 6 months despite not really watching my diet whereas before I was in a cycle of gaining and crash dieting.
I haven't cut out things like bread, cake, biscuits, granola etc. but instead I make these all from scratch, I love cooking and baking and I use a really simple bread roll recipe that has fresh bread on the table in an hour with nothing weird or wonderful in it. I have really enjoyed learning to cook all the things I would usually buy and agree with a pp. that things are often considered ok based on very old recipes. In the 1920s bread was yeast, flour, oil, salt now the number of ingredients are insane.
I am also a breakfast skipper because I can't stomach savory food in the morning and find if I eat even home made granola I am actually more hungry and end up snacking.
Going to give these podcasts a listen so thanks OP

sociallydistained · 06/07/2022 12:46

Also a life long binger here. I managed to lose weight before pregnancy with binges from time to time but right now at 5 months pp I am relying on food again and quick convenience food too. I don’t think I even enjoy most of it and hate the too full feeling. I’m exercising again and feeling strong but am ultimately fat because of my food addiction. I need to change this now!

well I’ve just had an omelette for lunch as my little man is down for a nap. Not having bread (shop bought) for lunch hasn’t happened in ages. My mum bakes bread so I am going to see if I can stay away from bread until I see her next week and then I’ll enjoy one of her homemade loaves.

SquirrelSoShiny · 06/07/2022 11:33

Yes, on the binge eating thing - one of my best strategies personally is accepting and allowing 'controlled' binges on junk food (usually crisps or a bar of chocolate). I find 1 or 2 days a fortnight is enough for me. I don't feel any shame in it and ironically I've lost weight doing this because it strips the cycle of self loathing and then eating more of its power. I'm trying to work towards 80/ 20.

My biggest problem is my incredibly fussy, faddy family. It's already a faff remembering to shop and cook; having to do multiple meals for multiple people makes it ten times worse. E.g. my husband won't eat pulses but I'm vegetarian. He won't eat tomato sauces or anything spicy, doesn't like sauces generally. So often we end up eating meat, potatoes and veg but me eating some ultra-processed meat sub instead of meat. My health is really suffering on this diet now.

I have great plans to batch cook single portions of healthy veg food but there are barriers in the sense of - the whole process. So I need to clear the freezer... then food plan ... then shop... then prep... then cook... then freeze. Which all seems like meaningful effort for a family but not just for me. So I need to change my thinking and realise that actually, I deserve decent food too.

FinallyHere · 06/07/2022 11:14

@MaybeIWillFuckOffThen

when I'm on my own I binge eat total garbage

This has been a big thing in my life, too. My mother cooked great tasting food with carefully controlled treats. I couldn't wait to leave home and be in controlling my own food. And have pretty much put on weight steadily ever since.

Overeating is a guilty, private secret.

Some of the things which have helped me keep clear of overeating (currently 'clear' since 10th Jan 22, and yes, I see a very clear link to keeping off alcohol and other drugs) include:-

MN's own low carb boot camp which is a very warm and supportive space supporting eating good quality low carb food with lots of great recipes to inspire and chat amongst like minded people, avoiding UPF (though I didn't know that was what they are called)

The Zoe project health approach including the Tim S talks mentioned above

Gillian Riley's work which looks at the all the many things which contribute to overeating https://www.eatinglessonline.comm*

There are so many contradictory messages around, I've been glad to find that these, although completely independent, are all broadly aligned in approach.

elfycat · 06/07/2022 11:10

I've been avoiding UPFs for about a month after listening to the Van Tullekens (got DDs interested in it), but DH went shopping Monday and came back with all the old stuff. I read out the back of the packets and reminded him. I'm not totally UPF free, but it's about awareness and using those foods sparingly.

I think I'm irritated by the sneaky tricks - like adding extracts of flavours, rather than using real herbs/spices etc to trick our taste buds into thinking something is has extra nutritional elements. Or using gum-shite to thicken up foods to make it creamy/rich, but without making it creamy or rich.

I have needed to stop being a lazy slattern get on with cooking a little more - so I've made chocolate cupcakes for lunches rather than a store bought individual chocolate roll thing. But I made a large batch and froze half of them so I can take then out 2 at a time.

I've stopped snacking. Just stopped because there's not junk in the cupboards. If I'm hungry I eat something - about to have (full fat) natural yogurt with a chopped apple and toasted almonds, with a sprinkle of sweet cinnamon (much nicer than the usual dry-powdery tasting cinnamon and very recommended. I know Asda do it)

Fere · 06/07/2022 11:03

Here is the link to The Food Program's episode about bread which was mentioned above

www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m0018wxp

Swipe left for the next trending thread