Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be totally on the anti UPF bandwagon and think this may finally be how I crack my food addiction?

184 replies

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 05/07/2022 15:20

Listened to the podcast by the Van Tulleken brothers, and then read some of the Brazilian research and the experiment with UPF/whole food diet. Listened to some Giles Yeo. Oh my goodness. Mind blown!

I have a binge eating disorder and it was getting so out of hand. Spent fortunes a week on extra secret food, all of it crap. Gaining a lot of weight. I could eat 6 supermarket hot cross buns at a time and still feel like I wanted more even while feeling sick. Whole packets of biscuits in minutes. It didn't make any sense to me but I felt like I just couldn't stop. Now it makes a lot of sense why - I've basically been eating the food equivalent of heroin.

I've cut it out this past week or two - whenever I have been craving it I just go and listen to an episode or two of the podcast again and am horrified anew so resist. I've also accepted the fact I'm never going to manage to not eat with willpower alone so have packed my bag with healthy whole food snacks - nuts, Greek yoghurt, chopped vegetables, hummus - so I don't 'need' to go to the shop for some lunch (and walk out with a load of garbage).

I felt much better almost instantly. Clear headed. Less bloated and sluggish, less achey. Less sick obviously. And much, much less hungry. Staying within calorie limits (that always seemed laughably low and restrictive whilst eating junk) suddenly incredibly easy. In not weighing myself as my scales are broken but how I feel is worth it on its own.

Over the weekend my DD got a vomiting bug for the millionth time this summer, bad nights sleep, feeling grotty etc. So Monday I decided to treat myself t a toasted panini from the work cafe. Supermarket bread, weird cheese etc - real comforting junk food of the type I just can't get enough of usually.

Reader it was DIABOLICAL. It tasted AWFUL. I've eaten these things so many times before and loved them. But it was horrible. I literally could not eat it, had two mouthfuls, spat the second one out and threw it in the bin.

I honestly feel like I've had some sort of damascene conversion. Every time I think about buying some crap now I just remember the horrible, inedible crapness of that panini and the urge just goes away again.

AIBU to think this could actually change my life??? Can simple awareness really override such a lifelong, established addictive behaviour? Or will this just be a flash in the pan?

OP posts:
Steelandsparkles · 07/07/2022 22:16

I’m glad to have found this thread and all the links. I’ve just started a 28-day programme aimed at supporting the body’s natural detox processes and as part of that the focus is on whole real food (plus things like eliminating dairy and gluten and sugar for the month).

one of the things I’m finding incredibly helpful is learning about my body; having a better understanding of what eg my kidneys do and all the biological processes that can be impacted by problematic substances in foods etc is making things click for me much more than just telling myself not to eat crap. I’m sure the recommended podcasts will also help so I really appreciate the suggestions.

it feels really empowering to make decisions about what I put in my body in order to optimize my body, rather than eating things for the momentary enjoyment while it’s in my mouth. And for me,
learrning more is making a huge difference.

WoolyMammoth55 · 07/07/2022 18:32

Hi OP, so glad you started this thread! I'm a life-long binge-eater who has been trying to be low carb/ paleo ish for the past month and feeling (for once) confident that I can do/be/live better. (I'm aiming for 80:20 for the rest of my life!)

Didn't know what UPF was when I clicked your thread :) but it really resonates! I've been eating from scratch, lots of veg, some fruit, goats cheese, meat, fish, olive oil, bit of butter now and then...

The biggest thing is that once you switch off the blood sugar spikes and crashes by cutting out the sugary crap, the binge eating takes care of itself! If I'm craving something after the kids are asleep, I have a few tsps of whole peanut butter and a square of 100% chocolate and I'm satisfied (like a PP, I realise this makes me sound like a wanker! :) Sorry!) Before it would have been a 2nd helping of dinner or some multi-pack of something...

Part of what clicked for me was taking an online course with this lady, Elle at www.eatforhealthuk.com - she actually advocates clean plant-based as the 'optimal' way of eating, which I'm not doing right now as have a lot of weight to lose... But she told this story about Nestle's food R&D department, which flicked a switch in my brain:

Nestle R&D has existed for 50 years (i.e. since early 80s) and in that time has spent, annually, the GDP of a small country. This insane money has been invested in finding the exact combination of ingredients, additives, and lab-created "edible substances" that can over-ride every biological function which signals satiety. Literally: once you start you can't stop.

And where Nestle lead, the rest have followed...

This money could have eradicated poverty. Instead they created hyper-addictive food-adjacent-substances that contribute to millions of avoidable deaths each year.

It's got nothing to do with an individual's willpower, and actually not much to do with disordered eating - it's just global capitalism at it's most toxic.

Getting rid of processed shit is not just a great thing to do as an individual - it's also a brilliant thing to do for the human race! So go you, OP. And best of luck xx

Bertieboo82 · 07/07/2022 17:15

In that case I apologise

@MiniPiccolo what on earth is your issue with the Op specifically?

BrightYellowDaffodil · 07/07/2022 16:53

If you make a Victoria sponge cake with unimproved flour, it has baking powder (yes I know, but still), eggs, sugar and butter in, plus jam which is fruit and sugar. We pay a price for buying convenience food from supermarkets.

I cannot find it for the life of me but I've seen another MNer reference it on a similarly-themed thread so I know it definitely exists, but there was an episode of the Food Programme that gave the example of a Bakewell tart (or a cherry Bakewell, but lets go with the tart as an example).

If I was making that there'd be flour, butter and water in the pastry, maybe eggs or sugar depending on what type I was making. The frangipane would be butter, sugar, ground almonds and eggs. The jam would be fruit and sugar (and more of the former than the latter).

But when it's made by a big food manufacturer, there isn't any butter or eggs, or fruit or almonds. Instead there's alternatives, flavourings, emulsifiers, stabilisers and other various things designed and tested in labs to smell, taste and feel the same in our mouths. It's cheaper, it has a longer shelf life and so on, but there's very few ingredients that any of us would actually recognise. And yet it looks the same.

And the companies who make this crap get all sanctimonious and say "Well, it's to make it affordable" which really boils my blood because it's effectively saying that people who are poorer should have to put up with, and be grateful for bad food that may well be doing them harm.

It's the same with convenience food or the current fad for 'plant based' food - people who don't have time or money or cooking skills or who are simply trying to do the right thing are being tricked into eating ultra-processed rubbish.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 07/07/2022 13:41

@Bertieboo82 It's not just this post, she's a frequent flier on posts where the OP expresses some sort of problem or vulnerability and she loves to pop up and give them a kicking, sneer and in some way imply they are a weak and shitty person.

See the thread by the poster who was miserable with her debilitatingly large breasts, and expressed in her OP she was considering self-harm because she could get no help on the NHS in her area due to CCG rules. Up pops Piccolo telling her OP that it's actually perfectly possible to get the help she has been categorically told she cannot get, and that OP simply 'can't be arsed for the fight'. And plenty of other threads.

I say in my OP I have a longstanding binge-eating disorder. It's not like I didn't KNOW I was eating badly, didn't KNOW the food I was eating was bad food, and didn't KNOW I'd feel better if I stopped doing it. I have a disorder, not a brain bypass. What I am remarking on is that, for the first time, an understanding of the science behind why I have NONETHELESS continued to eat the shit I know is bad for me, in volumes that make me feel sick, has enabled me to gain some control over this lifelong habit. So her 'well durrr' vcomment was not relevant, was not useful, and did nothing except give her a little thrill of being able to kick at someone with an illness.

Some posters are just nasty and mean and bring nothing to any discussion. I don't want her here. Obvs it's a public forum and I can't stop her, but I can at least make it plain.

OP posts:
Bertieboo82 · 07/07/2022 13:24

Bloody hell! Given all the anger directed at @MiniPiccolo i looked forward to find her post and being aghast at the rudeness of it

but she basically speaks the truth!

Bracing myself for the chorus of fuck offs! 😂

FangsForTheMemory · 07/07/2022 12:41

The most eye-opening comment I've ever read, and I wish I could remember where I read it, was on the lines of 'supermarkets are full of products that are sold as food but are not really food at all'. Think, for example, a sponge cake. I've just randomly looked at one online and the following ingredients are listed:
vegetable glycerol,
disodium diphosphate, potassium hydrogen carbonate
potassium sorbate
trisodium citrate

I haven't a clue what these are although the blurb tells you what they do (raising agents, preservatives etc). If you make a Victoria sponge cake with unimproved flour, it has baking powder (yes I know, but still), eggs, sugar and butter in, plus jam which is fruit and sugar. We pay a price for buying convenience food from supermarkets.

CosmopolitanPlease · 07/07/2022 12:09

Can I join in the chorus of 'fuck off's with a couple of middle fingers.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 07/07/2022 11:55

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 07/07/2022 09:04

Are plant milks UPFs? There are certainly a lot of weird ingredients in the oat milk i (regrettably) feed my CMPA daughter...

I work on the principle that if it has ingredients in that I wouldn't go to a supermarket to buy then it's UPF. Oats? Fine, I'd go to Tesco and buy a bag of oats. But I wouldn't go and buy a bag of E403 or a packet of stabilising agent.

And @MiniPiccolo , please do fuck off with your sanctimony.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 07/07/2022 11:38

@MiniPiccolo

Allow me to offer you a cheery "fuck off dear", @MiniPiccolo. You're a mean-spirited bitch on literally every thread you go on, so can you please just bugger off mine full of nice people sharing tips and being interesting? Your sarky arsiness is simply totally not required. Byeeee!

OP posts:
TooManyPJs · 07/07/2022 11:35

BrightYellowDaffodil · 05/07/2022 16:34

@schoolsweats

There's a really good article here: www.theguardian.com/food/2020/feb/13/how-ultra-processed-food-took-over-your-shopping-basket-brazil-carlos-monteiro

Also, this is the Nova system they reference: world.openfoodfacts.org/nova (quite the eye opener!)

That is so helpful, thanks for posting! This list in particular:

Ingredients and categories only found in group 4 (ultra processed):

colour
colour stabilizer
flavour enhancer
sweetener
carbonating agent
firming agent
bulking agent
anti-bulking agent
de-foaming agent
anti-caking agent
glazing agent
emulsifier
sequestrant
humectant
flavour
casein
lactose
whey
hydrogenated-oil
hydrolysed-proteins
maltodextrin
invert-sugar
high-fructose-corn-syrup

MiniPiccolo · 07/07/2022 11:32

NotMeNoNo · 07/07/2022 07:36

If you search online, it the industrial bread making process with (I think) enzymes and high speed mixing which makes the bread faster. timetocook.org/2016/06/02/real-bread-chorleywood-sourdough-flavour-and-health/
Apart from obvious difference in taste/texture there are suspicions bread made this way is behind the rise in gluten intolerance etc.

I started making sourdough as DH finds it much better for his IBS.

It is the cause. It's also a trigger for many, many autoimmune and thyroid problems such as hashimotos, inflammatory conditions, my Consultant also suspects it plays a role in b12 deficiency and a high portion of Fibro and other myalgia diagnosis. The obscene amounts of gluten in a standard crap white loaf is sickening.

The sourdough method allows the gluten to be broken down and reduced in the proving process. It's why proper sourdough is much more tolerable for non severe coeliacs and normally entirely tolerable for those of us with gluten intolerence.

What we know as 'bread' is nothing like bread should be at all.

MiniPiccolo · 07/07/2022 11:27

CosmopolitanPlease · 07/07/2022 09:05

Can I ask what you all do if you go out for the day? I've got a trip planned and I've gone blank. Last time I took some cooked porridge in a Kilner jar but I'd like to try something else. Home made mayo tends to separate if added too early (possibly if kept out the fridge at all) so my go-to salad is out.

You're making your mayo wrong.

MiniPiccolo · 07/07/2022 11:24

Almost like if you stop shovelling shit food - packed with obscene amounts of gluten and fillers in to your body you'll feel a lot better 🤔🤷‍♀️

This isn't rocket science, OP. You knew UPF was shit food and it was shit for you. You just needed a label to latch on to.

Meat and veg was a staple for eons for a reason.

CosmopolitanPlease · 07/07/2022 11:17

@FinallyHere those are some great ideas thank you- I hadn't thought of putting the mayo in the bottom and mixing it later!

FinallyHere · 07/07/2022 11:13

Remember cutlery long enough to reach in 😀

FinallyHere · 07/07/2022 11:12

CosmopolitanPlease · 07/07/2022 09:05

Can I ask what you all do if you go out for the day? I've got a trip planned and I've gone blank. Last time I took some cooked porridge in a Kilner jar but I'd like to try something else. Home made mayo tends to separate if added too early (possibly if kept out the fridge at all) so my go-to salad is out.

I've found it reasonably easy to eat out, keeping to simply cooked / grilled meat / fish with vegetables and or salad.

For food on the go, I like to take a kilner style jar of salad. Vinaigrette dressing in a separate jar, Mayo style dressing (eg with garlic and anchovy, for a Caesar type salad) I'd put the dressing in the bottom of the jar, add lots of crunchy veg incl celery, cabbage, spring onion, bacon bits, with chicken or prawns and quail eggs on top and at the very top green leaves and chopped parsley

Freeze s bottle of water to keep in the same bag which will be unfrozen by the time I get to lunch and keep the salad cool. Shake up salad to distribute dressing and eat from the jar.

Alternatives include tuna / onion or smoked and or poached smoked Endless different possibilities.

Any veg you happen to have. A square of chocolate to have with a coffee afterwards.

ChandlersDad · 07/07/2022 09:47

That’s a very good point. You can make your own oat or nut milks, but I never have.

ChandlersDad · 07/07/2022 09:44

It depends based on factors I am not quite clear on Confused

cold soya milk and slightly more vinegar seem to mean thicker. I tried oat milk and it was very runny, but made a nice dressing.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 07/07/2022 09:05

www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0017tcz

OP posts:
CosmopolitanPlease · 07/07/2022 09:05

Can I ask what you all do if you go out for the day? I've got a trip planned and I've gone blank. Last time I took some cooked porridge in a Kilner jar but I'd like to try something else. Home made mayo tends to separate if added too early (possibly if kept out the fridge at all) so my go-to salad is out.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 07/07/2022 09:04

Are plant milks UPFs? There are certainly a lot of weird ingredients in the oat milk i (regrettably) feed my CMPA daughter...

OP posts:
BiFoldChampion · 07/07/2022 07:56

Could you share the link of this podcast please? Thank you!

carefullycourageous · 07/07/2022 07:55

ChandlersDad · 06/07/2022 23:11

Vegan Mayo is easy: 100ml light olive oil, 50ml unsweetened soya milk, 1tsp Dijon mustard, 1 tsp white wine vinegar, salt to taste. In a Pyrex, blend with stick blender for 5 secs.

Does it thicken or does it stay quite light?

I am going to try this as I find jarred mayo quite offputting, a bit jellylike!

NotMeNoNo · 07/07/2022 07:36

scissorsandsellotape · 06/07/2022 21:06

What is Chorley wood

If you search online, it the industrial bread making process with (I think) enzymes and high speed mixing which makes the bread faster. timetocook.org/2016/06/02/real-bread-chorleywood-sourdough-flavour-and-health/
Apart from obvious difference in taste/texture there are suspicions bread made this way is behind the rise in gluten intolerance etc.

I started making sourdough as DH finds it much better for his IBS.

Swipe left for the next trending thread