Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children have so much these days they don't treasure their things?

192 replies

UndertheCedartree · 05/07/2022 14:32

I've been sorting out my DC's book shelves today. They have so much. So many books - fiction and non-fiction, my DD has so many art supplies and art books, colouring books etc. It makes me think back to my childhood. I grew up with much wealthier parents than I am but I had far fewer books etc. The books I had I treasured and re-read so many times. My DC haven't read half their books. I'd read mine inside out. My dad used to video films for us off the TV and I watched them over and over. My DC can just put whatever they want on Netflix.

OP posts:
CroissantsAtDawn · 05/07/2022 16:12

I think its up to the adults. A) to model the right behaviour and B) to buy less.

Ive just spent the last 15 months ruthlessly decluttering. Starting with my stuff.

I am now single handedly packing up our home to move overseas (so everything the 4 of us own is going through my hands).

Although I still feel my DC have too much, they want it all and still play with it all, except for a couple of toys each which are too young but are sentimental to them.

They have sold and donated a lot of toys, books and clothes over the past year. So I don't want to force them to get rid of things they play with.

However, we have already seriously cut down on number of presents (going more for experiences) and will continue this. The boys don't mind as they can't think of anything they want either. For his 11th birthday, in total from all family, DS1 will be getting a phone (one of DHs old ones), a kindle, a microscope and a poster. He hasn't asked for anything except the phone.

Butteryflakycrust83 · 05/07/2022 16:04

Being bored is SO important. People cant even stand in a lift for 20 seconds without getting their phone out to scroll.

And agree, the internet is absolutely the biggest factor. Just thinking about what I used to do when I woke up on a Saturday or laying in bed - I would read or just lay daydreaming. Now I doomscroll my phone.

Its a sad state of affairs when there are adverts at the cinema to tell you what a lovely experience it would be not to look at your phone for 90 minutes!

A slight derail sorry, but connected I think! Internet and endless ability to buy whatever you want.

NumberTheory · 05/07/2022 16:02

I don’t think using something over and over because it’s all you’ve got is necessarily treasuring it. My kids have way more than I did and they seem to treasure more than I did too. I grew pretty bored with most of my toys after a while and would reconfigure them/draw on them/try them out in inappropriate ways until they broke. My kids don’t necessarily use everything they’ve ever been given that much and they are careless with many of them but they treat the stuff they like well and have favourite toys they’ve had for years and years that are still going strong.

stuffnthings · 05/07/2022 16:00

I feel just like this, every time I survey the DC bedrooms. It's not their fault, it's adults going overboard at Christmas and for Birthdays, despite previous discussions to try and limit things.

Likewise with music and film, it's all available on demand, which I don't object to at all - I actively use the services myself. But the nostalgic me does feel a bit sad that having music and film immediately available can make it 'throwaway' and less treasured. I can't talk much though, I've collected 1000s of records and CDs in the loft, but I do treasure them still and won't part with them yet!

Just10moreminutesplease · 05/07/2022 15:55

I always had lots of books as a child. Some I read and never picked up again, others I still treasure now.

If there’s one thing I wouldn’t worry about my children having too many of, it’s books.

PrimarilyParented · 05/07/2022 15:49

I think it depends. My ds has loads of books but loves books and reads them all in cycles. We also get books from the library so that he enjoys the newness but also appreciates that not everything is owned.

he’s also obsessed with cars and we regularly collect more from charity shops, but it’s more of a collection than anything and I know that used to happen in the past too as his great uncle has a huge car collection from when he was a kid (and my family weren’t wealthy by any stretch back then). I also apply the pay day treat rule. So if he asks for small things he still often has to wait until payday for them. Big things go on our imaginary ‘wish list’.

I do regularly pair things back and donate to charity any toys that are unused too and I discuss this with my DS so that he understands the need to give to charity and also not to have too much.

WeBuiltCisCityOnSexistRoles · 05/07/2022 15:46

I agree with the attention span thing too. I recently had a procedure where I had to lie for about an hour not moving and was horrified at how long it seemed and how boring. I realised just how much I automatically reach for my phone to kill time.

WeBuiltCisCityOnSexistRoles · 05/07/2022 15:43

I genuinely don't believe you can ever have too many books. Unfortunately I have had no choice but to move to a Kindle/library app as we simply have no space in the house for more books. Obviously we couldn't keep all the DCs' books forever so we did keep the "treasured" ones and full sets like Chalet School. Funnily enough a lot of my DCs "treasured" ones were mine originally! I'm still partial to a bit of nostalgia Chalet School reading.

My DCs are older so they didn't have "technology" toys like iPads, but we were really lucky where we lived and had really good charity shops/exchange places and toy libraries. We did buy and have kept extra special toys (fuck me I wish I had kept all my Star Wars toys!) like dolls houses and sets of Sylvanian families. I have quite a few DC so I'm hoping there will be another generation to love them.

I think we need to have more of a "circulation" mindset than "consumption". I think it's nice for DC to have certain things from their childhood (I myself have a couple of teddies that are a probably a hazard to human health) but otherwise it's good to pass things on to younger DC to benefit. The way the economies are going, I'm sure a lot less people will be buying new and hopefully it'll be the norm for buying and reusing second hand stuff even for Christmas and birthdays, than buying new, especially plastic stuff.

WoundTheBobbinUp · 05/07/2022 15:41

Butteryflakycrust83 · 05/07/2022 15:29

Such an interesting topic. I wonder if there is a link between a complete lack of attention span and the culture of not having to wait for anything anymore?

My friend is a teacher and she says that children just don't know how to imagine anymore. She thinks it's because they're bombarded all the time with unlimited TV and activities. Children don't have a chance to be bored anymore, and if they do then the parents are likely to feel guilty because of what they see on social media. Children being constantly entertained is a modern thing. Without the chance to be bored, children stop being inventive!

easyday · 05/07/2022 15:41

Yes and I have probably three times as many clothes than my mother ever did. She grew up comfortable but as an adult and married with small kids had little money and we got one main one small present at Christmas- and I don't recall ever comparing myself to other kids either.

FourTeaFallOut · 05/07/2022 15:41

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 05/07/2022 15:38

Conversely, I didn't have many material possessions as a child, but was happy to get rid of pretty much all of them.

Yeah, this is me. I'm not a sentimental type. I don't cling to things and don't feel a compulsion to carefully carry them through life. I have things, then they break or they survive beyond their usefulness and then I pass them on. My kids are the same.

WoundTheBobbinUp · 05/07/2022 15:39

I totally agree, I was saying this to my mum the other day. Without meaning to judge (though yes I know, I am judging) I can't stand all these things like Christmas Eve boxes - as if kids don't get enough on Christmas Day! On Valentine's Day a couple of my friends even put together "Valentine's Boxes" for their DC. What is that about?! I can't believe how people are consuming more and more, despite the current push to save the planet and cut down on waste. It boggles my mind. I also agree that the more nice things you have, the less special they become.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 05/07/2022 15:38

Conversely, I didn't have many material possessions as a child, but was happy to get rid of pretty much all of them.

Aquilegia23 · 05/07/2022 15:36

Butteryflakycrust83 · 05/07/2022 15:29

Such an interesting topic. I wonder if there is a link between a complete lack of attention span and the culture of not having to wait for anything anymore?

I think the lack of attention span is more about the internet than having too many toys.

Everything is faster today. Newsreaders speak more quickly than they used to. TV adverts flash images every half a second. Children flick from one image to another without giving much attention to what they're watching.

Parcels are delivered the next day (well, mine are, and I get very impatient if something is late).

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 05/07/2022 15:36

It depends on the child, surely. DS has lots of stuff, but it doesn't stop him forming inconvenient strong sentimental attachments to certain items whenever I attempt to declutter.

Butteryflakycrust83 · 05/07/2022 15:29

Such an interesting topic. I wonder if there is a link between a complete lack of attention span and the culture of not having to wait for anything anymore?

Ylvamoon · 05/07/2022 15:26

We are a very materialistic society.
Having "Stuff" rather than a few "Treasures" seems to be the norm all over. I think kids are just used to having whatever they want. The individual item is less "valuable" and can easily be replaced. Isn't that what we teach them?
Hopefully, with the way things are currently going (cost of living & raw materials) we will move away from this towards a less is more society.

Most of it is just plastic tat anyway....

stayingpositiveifpossible · 05/07/2022 15:18

Eee yes, when I were a lad....we lived in't cardboard box on't motorway...

....getting up before we went to bed....

Fluffruff · 05/07/2022 15:15

An interesting observation. I was an 80s kid growing up abroad and I read books over and over but I think it was mainly because I was bored!!. My parents were working so there were long hours to fill. There were foreign cartoons on for one hr a day. I think today’s children would be be expected to occupy themselves from say 1-6pm like I was. I’d lie for hours on my bed reading. So perhaps a bit of that in making the difference and also as you say, too much stuff. I buy my kids lots of books because it seems to me that you can never have too many! 😂

CrispieCake · 05/07/2022 15:14

I think part of it is that our houses are generally quite small and kids have too much stuff for the space. To be treasured, toys and other things need to be treated properly and have their own space where they can be put away. If everything is in a random pile in the corner, it's hard for kids to treasure things.

minimadgirl · 05/07/2022 15:13

Can you ever have too many books? We have loads but most of ours all come from the charity shop, very rarely do I buy brand new books and if I do they are the classics.

We perhaps have too many toys though, but again they are all from my local charity shop which we like supporting and when finished with will go back there.

SparklingPeach · 05/07/2022 15:03

I agree with you that kids have too much stuff, but we as adults need to take responsibility for that, we gave it to them! Time to cut down on birthday and Christmas presents when you're thinking this way OP.

Hardbackwriter · 05/07/2022 14:59

I don't know how old you all are - maybe I'm unusually young for the thread - but I remember my grandparents saying exactly this about my brother and I in the 80s/early 90s.

AppaTheSixLeggedFlyingBison · 05/07/2022 14:57

I think a lot of it is the amount of people who buy presents for them now.

So whilst you could limit it to 3 pressies yourself, then their grandparents, aunts, uncles, family friends, friends, etc all get them something and all of a sudden they have more than 20 presents.

Birthdays to an even larger extent as in a lot of schools whole class parties are encouraged

TheWayTheLightFalls · 05/07/2022 14:53

I agree with a pp - we all have too much stuff.

Swipe left for the next trending thread