Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children have so much these days they don't treasure their things?

192 replies

UndertheCedartree · 05/07/2022 14:32

I've been sorting out my DC's book shelves today. They have so much. So many books - fiction and non-fiction, my DD has so many art supplies and art books, colouring books etc. It makes me think back to my childhood. I grew up with much wealthier parents than I am but I had far fewer books etc. The books I had I treasured and re-read so many times. My DC haven't read half their books. I'd read mine inside out. My dad used to video films for us off the TV and I watched them over and over. My DC can just put whatever they want on Netflix.

OP posts:
spinachmonster · 06/07/2022 12:13

I completely agree! I've been trying to do the minimalism thing for a few years now and find The Minimal Mom on YouTube really good. (Especially about toys).

m.youtube.com/watch?v=k7kLvtKvhGA

The only thing I think shouldn't be reduced too far is books, I reduced my 6 large boxes of my own books to a shelf and a half (which does feel fine) but I grew up in a house full of books so I don't limit the childrens ones.

UndertheCedartree · 06/07/2022 11:24

CoffeeWithCheese · 06/07/2022 11:09

Both of mine are readers - DD1 exceptionally so. I try not to limit books - I do regularly restrict the number they leave in the bathroom for their bloody toilet reading habit though cos it drives me mad, but I do encourage them to see the distinction between the sort of book you'd buy to read once on holiday and then pass on, and the sort of books you return to time and time again - DD1 in particular is starting to get that distinction, helped by the fact a friend runs a local monthly bookshop and she can get new stuff there! (Doesn't work with DD2 who just sends her old books and then returns with her even older previous books)

We had a toy tat cull fairly recently - what they have tends to be sets of things - so a set of those our generation dolls, a set of rainbow high stuff, a mountain of playmobil they're kind of that cusp of outgrowing but return to from time to time - and stuff that's getting outgrown tends to go to grandparents houses for them to play with there, and pass on to their younger cousin - lots of construction and the like has gone that way. Other stuff that never grabbed their interest - however much I tried they never got into lego or wooden train sets - that went to school and gets played with daily there - very little actually gets thrown away.

Craft supplies however - I'm a craft hoarder and DD1 is going the same way - she has a trolley of art stuff and she will sit with it beside her admiring it like Gollum with the bloody one ring! She wants a craft room shared with me and her when we move house!

I know what you mean about toys. DD is 10 and mainly plays only with her baby dolls. But now and again she will want to get the Playmobil out or her Barbie's. My daughter and I would love a craft room!

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 06/07/2022 11:20

Chouetted · 06/07/2022 10:57

As a child I once counted I had about 200 books. (I was a voracious reader). A significant amount were hand-me-downs from my equally voracious father, which may be where the difference really is.

I own one book inherited from my grandfather, given as a school prize in 1913, and handed down to his children, and now to me. That was genuinely a different time.

Wow! I would have loved that! My mum read a lot but it was Mills & Boon which I wasn't interested in. My dad didn't read a lot but he had a set of Agatha Christie novels that I read.

I often read on my Kindle now or if a hard copy book if I know I won't read it again I either give it to my friend, her daughter or my son depending on who I think will like it best. My son and his best friend swap books too.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 06/07/2022 11:16

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 06/07/2022 10:55

Very true in the case of my Gdcs I’m afraid.
It’s not their fault, but they have WAY too many toys and books to be able to appreciate more than a very few.
And I’m no fan of minimalism, but so much kids’ stuff everywhere makes it well nigh impossible to keep the house reasonably tidy.
TBH (with a few exceptions) I doubt they’d even notice if half the stuff was binned or charity-shopped tomorrow.

Yes, it's true. When people say 'a child can never have too many books' - well, surely there comes a point that you don't have the space to store any more! We are heading that way!

With my DD there have definitely been times when I've had that feeling!

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 06/07/2022 11:13

LouLou198 · 06/07/2022 07:32

I was thinking the same a couple of weeks ago when I was having a clear out of dc's stuff. Like you, I had a few books I would read over and over, I was coming across books my dc had read once. I had a handful of vhs videos, many of which my dad taped from the tv, then later on a few cassette tapes. My dc have access to Netflix, Disney + and an Alexa!

I know, things have changed so much!

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 06/07/2022 11:12

VestaTilley · 06/07/2022 07:23

I’m not sure I agree - it’s about the culture you foster in your home. A child can never have too many books - do your DC see you reading? If they do they’ll be more inclined to read themselves.

My DS has lots of toys, but he adores four teddies in particular, and has favourite trains and books. He’s not allowed to just watch hours of TV, so we can still build in the delayed gratification of “not now, but at the weekend”.

What’s the answer anyway? We intentionally deprive our children? No thanks. They can have plenty of stuff without being spoilt, and while still treasuring their favourites - you just have to show why things are special, and to say why we’re fortunate to have so many nice things.

I disagree, I think they can have too many! Yes, they see me reading every day. I have a pile of books on my bedside cabinet. They both read every day. My DD and I also always have a book on the go we are reading together. I also read to her every night and, depending on the book, my 15yo likes to listen too. Then she goes to sleep listening to a story on her Yoto. DS always reads before bed as do I.

This thread has made me realise actually my 15yo does have books and figures that he treasures. DD's most treasured things are probably all her baby dolls (she has about 10!) and maybe some cuddly toys.

No, I'm not suggesting we should deprive them. It's just nostalgia for that feeling of re-reading favourite books/watching favourite books. I do think have too much 'stuff' is overwhelming too so I encourage them to give outgrown things to their cousin/the charity shop.

OP posts:
CoffeeWithCheese · 06/07/2022 11:09

Both of mine are readers - DD1 exceptionally so. I try not to limit books - I do regularly restrict the number they leave in the bathroom for their bloody toilet reading habit though cos it drives me mad, but I do encourage them to see the distinction between the sort of book you'd buy to read once on holiday and then pass on, and the sort of books you return to time and time again - DD1 in particular is starting to get that distinction, helped by the fact a friend runs a local monthly bookshop and she can get new stuff there! (Doesn't work with DD2 who just sends her old books and then returns with her even older previous books)

We had a toy tat cull fairly recently - what they have tends to be sets of things - so a set of those our generation dolls, a set of rainbow high stuff, a mountain of playmobil they're kind of that cusp of outgrowing but return to from time to time - and stuff that's getting outgrown tends to go to grandparents houses for them to play with there, and pass on to their younger cousin - lots of construction and the like has gone that way. Other stuff that never grabbed their interest - however much I tried they never got into lego or wooden train sets - that went to school and gets played with daily there - very little actually gets thrown away.

Craft supplies however - I'm a craft hoarder and DD1 is going the same way - she has a trolley of art stuff and she will sit with it beside her admiring it like Gollum with the bloody one ring! She wants a craft room shared with me and her when we move house!

UndertheCedartree · 06/07/2022 11:03

I would say reading and gaming are my 15 yo's favourite things. Art and online games with friends are my 10 yo's. Reading and her baby dolls would come in next.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 06/07/2022 11:01

Ahgoonyegirlye · 06/07/2022 07:16

Maybe they don’t like to read as much as you did? There are a lot more distractions for them…
children treasure the oddest things though don’t they. You can give them an expensive toy and their favourite thing could be a collection of gem stones that you got at a gift shop that cost £1.

Yes, that's very true. They do like to read but yes, I agree they have lots of other things they like to do too. My DS does love to have a whole day free to read when he gets a new book!

OP posts:
VoiceaFromUranus · 06/07/2022 10:59

stayingpositiveifpossible · 05/07/2022 15:18

Eee yes, when I were a lad....we lived in't cardboard box on't motorway...

....getting up before we went to bed....

You had a cardboard box? LUXURY I TELL THEE!

We had a large rhubarb leaf between the 12 of us and counted ourselves lucky.

UndertheCedartree · 06/07/2022 10:58

Kanaloa · 06/07/2022 07:04

Well if they ask for books ask them to organise the ones they have and ask if they’re sure they’ll read them. Or ask which book they want and buy just one, then another when they’ve finished that one. Or just keep buying loads if you want but then you can hardly complain that they’ve got too many and don’t read them all.

Their books are organised and if I really wanted a book and someone said 'are you sure you will read it' of course I'd say yes. It may take some time to get around to reading it, though especially if I was also given some book sets at the same time! Their are also class reads, books you might get to address a certain issue etc. Anyway, let's agree to disagree. You think it's simple to cut down on books, I don't!

OP posts:
Chouetted · 06/07/2022 10:57

As a child I once counted I had about 200 books. (I was a voracious reader). A significant amount were hand-me-downs from my equally voracious father, which may be where the difference really is.

I own one book inherited from my grandfather, given as a school prize in 1913, and handed down to his children, and now to me. That was genuinely a different time.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 06/07/2022 10:55

Very true in the case of my Gdcs I’m afraid.
It’s not their fault, but they have WAY too many toys and books to be able to appreciate more than a very few.
And I’m no fan of minimalism, but so much kids’ stuff everywhere makes it well nigh impossible to keep the house reasonably tidy.
TBH (with a few exceptions) I doubt they’d even notice if half the stuff was binned or charity-shopped tomorrow.

UndertheCedartree · 06/07/2022 10:48

Florenz · 06/07/2022 00:19

I always limited my kids to 30 things that they could own. When they got something new they had to give something old to charity. That doesn't include household items or stuff for school or anything like that, but toys and books and devices etc.

Interesting.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 06/07/2022 10:47

limitededitionbarbie · 05/07/2022 23:59

I feel exactly the same. I can remember certain toys that I absolutely treasured, even when I was too
Old for them!

My dd doesn't treasure anything toy wise where
You have to take everywhere! It's all screens. Because their friends are on screens playing online games.

I find it really sad but the generation before is probably felt the same.

It seems more and more the generations are more and more becoming insofar and doing everything online now.

Work, courses, banking, socialising.

Yes, it is the way things are now.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 06/07/2022 10:44

BlackandBlueBird · 05/07/2022 23:38

8, 6 and 3.

It is lovely that they have things they treasure.
When mine were younger it was more like this (they re-read/I re-read them toddler/little kid books) but now my DS is 15 he doesn't 'grow out' of books so they just keep multiplying and his toys/younger books are kept for my DD.

OP posts:
LouLou198 · 06/07/2022 07:32

I was thinking the same a couple of weeks ago when I was having a clear out of dc's stuff. Like you, I had a few books I would read over and over, I was coming across books my dc had read once. I had a handful of vhs videos, many of which my dad taped from the tv, then later on a few cassette tapes. My dc have access to Netflix, Disney + and an Alexa!

VestaTilley · 06/07/2022 07:23

I’m not sure I agree - it’s about the culture you foster in your home. A child can never have too many books - do your DC see you reading? If they do they’ll be more inclined to read themselves.

My DS has lots of toys, but he adores four teddies in particular, and has favourite trains and books. He’s not allowed to just watch hours of TV, so we can still build in the delayed gratification of “not now, but at the weekend”.

What’s the answer anyway? We intentionally deprive our children? No thanks. They can have plenty of stuff without being spoilt, and while still treasuring their favourites - you just have to show why things are special, and to say why we’re fortunate to have so many nice things.

Ahgoonyegirlye · 06/07/2022 07:16

Maybe they don’t like to read as much as you did? There are a lot more distractions for them…
children treasure the oddest things though don’t they. You can give them an expensive toy and their favourite thing could be a collection of gem stones that you got at a gift shop that cost £1.

Kanaloa · 06/07/2022 07:10

stayathomer · 05/07/2022 21:51

Well, as I said in my own experience (not just reading articles and listening to podcasts but actually working with kids for 10 years)
As I said I have also worked in childcare and I have 4 children so it’s experience too (meant in the nicest possible way but just so you know!!)

Surely if you’ve worked in childcare then you’re aware that it’s unusual for a teacher to say her students ‘can’t imagine?’ Like none of them. They just aren’t capable of imagination. As a childcare practitioner you’ll surely have seen children imagine every single day!

Kanaloa · 06/07/2022 07:08

And it literally is that simple. If dd asks for art supplies take her upstairs and point out all the art supplies there. If ds asks for a book ask him to go and organise all the books he has and sort out those that are ready for donation since there are so many unread - or encourage him to look on the online library app to see if he can borrow it. Or, if you just enjoy shopping then enjoy it but accept that it means you’ll have too many things if you like to buy lots of things you already have.

Kanaloa · 06/07/2022 07:04

UndertheCedartree · 05/07/2022 22:24

It's a little more complicated than that. Now, I admit, I love books and I do buy them some for Birthday/Christmas. But DD has all of DS's books. So can I never buy her any books? Also other people buy them books (and as I said often sets) and then there are the class reads that school encourages you to get and that she loves to get. My DS usually only asks for books for Christmas/Birthday - should I just never get him any books he asks for? And then there are Mumsnet threads with recommended books for kids and I get tempted! My DS already buys his own books and DD buys Art supplies.

My DC do have 'too mich' but I've never said they're spoiled or it's their fault.

Well if they ask for books ask them to organise the ones they have and ask if they’re sure they’ll read them. Or ask which book they want and buy just one, then another when they’ve finished that one. Or just keep buying loads if you want but then you can hardly complain that they’ve got too many and don’t read them all.

Florenz · 06/07/2022 00:19

I always limited my kids to 30 things that they could own. When they got something new they had to give something old to charity. That doesn't include household items or stuff for school or anything like that, but toys and books and devices etc.

limitededitionbarbie · 05/07/2022 23:59

Georgeskitchen · 05/07/2022 14:42

Totally agree. As a child I had one large toy that I chose for Xmas, a selection box and a few small bits. One item for birthday and any pressies I got at birthday party. One Easter egg which tbf were much bigger than today's measly offerings. The expectation nowadays seems to be kids getting new toys and stuff virtually every week. I'm aghast at the amount of stuff my grandchildren have and no they don't really appreciate it.

I feel exactly the same. I can remember certain toys that I absolutely treasured, even when I was too
Old for them!

My dd doesn't treasure anything toy wise where
You have to take everywhere! It's all screens. Because their friends are on screens playing online games.

I find it really sad but the generation before is probably felt the same.

It seems more and more the generations are more and more becoming insofar and doing everything online now.

Work, courses, banking, socialising.

BlackandBlueBird · 05/07/2022 23:38

UndertheCedartree · 05/07/2022 22:07

How old are they, out of interest?

8, 6 and 3.