Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think yellow box fines are f***ed up

118 replies

Stickystitch · 04/07/2022 22:16

I have to pay Merton council £65 for stopping in a yellow box for 4 seconds because a lorry ahead of me broke suddenly - a car ahead of them randomly stopped dead in flowing traffic, waited, then took a sharp (and illegal) u-turn at the junction. I assume this car and the lorry also got fined. I was doing max 20mph (local speed limit) and there was plenty of room between me and the lorry when the traffic was moving.

The council has rejected my appeal and said I should have waited for all traffic ahead of me to exit the yellow box before entering it. The yellow box in this case is HUGE, maybe 5 car lengths. Who stops dead at a traffic junction, in full flowing traffic, to wait for all the cars ahead to cross? I have never been fined for anything in my life, never even had a parking ticket and I'm absolutely furious. Fining people £65 for shit like this needs to stop. That's more than my weekly budget gone.. and for what?

OP posts:
HeddaGarbled · 05/07/2022 11:25

There’s plenty of yellow boxes at busy traffic lights where if you didn’t enter the box when the lights were on green regardless of whether the box is empty or not, you would never get across - the lights would change back to red before the box was clear every single time and you’d be sitting there forever.

Saracen · 05/07/2022 11:20

I'm so sorry, OP. That's crazy. So you are supposed to remain five car lengths behind the car in front even if traffic is flowing well? I've never seen anyone do that. In slow traffic, absolutely. (Though it's infuriating that you can get completely stuck in heavy traffic when everyone else is ignoring this rule and blocking you from getting through the box whenever you have a green light, so you never move unless you too break the law.)

Thanks for alerting me to the fact that there are cameras monitoring this. I haven't known anyone to get a ticket for it. I don't think there are cameras where I live, but maybe there should be as it would prevent the problem I described in brackets above! Are you in London?

AtLeastPretendToCare · 05/07/2022 11:18

I have some sympathy with the OP. My neighbourhood has a yellow box function that is notorious locally for making money, I think someone did an FOI request. Due to the road layout, lights timings and other traffic lights very close it is extremely easy to get caught out inadvertently.

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 05/07/2022 11:04

Just keep moving next time and try to get alongside the vehicle in front. It's just to make you find a way out, if we didn't have fines people would dawdle. With fines people make it their priority to get out of the way. As soon as you see the car being a dick you should be looking for another way out of the junction.

SavoirFlair · 05/07/2022 10:49

The problem with a lot of comments on this thread is that it's based on the modern UK way of driving, which is let's predict what the other road user is likely to do.

Hence bizarre comments like this:

but the OP could see space for her car on the other side of it. So she’d done exactly as you’d said. 🤷‍♀️ She just didn’t predict the car infront would stop (when it didn’t need to) to do a U turn.

The problem with driving is, it isn't a matter of conjecture or debate, or prediction. Yes you can see a signal (sometimes), yes you can see a bit of movement, but unless you actually have that clear space, then it doesn't exist until it exists.

Unfortunately you will have drivers on here and in real life who will absolutely insist that 'it doesn't work like this in the real world'

And that driving is like a form of Speed with Keanu Reeves - you just have to keep going at all costs in case some angry man behind you beeps you, and then lament whatever 'suddenly changes' in front of you because someone failed to act predictably

RB68 · 05/07/2022 10:37

Learn the art of leaving enough space to continue to move even if something ahead is unexpected, the boxes are mainly in surburban areas with heavy traffic and that is why - blocked junctions when lights change are a major cause of traffic stagnation, but then again so are the idiots entering roundabouts when exit not clear and nothing is done about them.

WatchoRulo · 05/07/2022 10:34

Greenberg · 05/07/2022 10:06

I get you OP. If everyone waited until the next car had completely got across then they'd be massive tailbacks in London. If it would be reasonable to expect that your car could get across, for instance one car in front of you and a clear space past the box in front of them, then they should allow the appeal. The car that's blocked the exit due to their illegal manoeuvre should be fined but not those affected by it. You can't have someone just stop in the road past the box and then fine all the other cars affected. But I think these boxes have become money making schemes in London for struggling councils.

That's nonsense - cars ahead could be forced to stop unexpectedly for perfectly legitimate reasons. If every box junction always has a "yes but" excuse there's no point in them.

PeppaPigIsBacon · 05/07/2022 10:32

I’ve been fined for this before (in London) as the exit was clear when I entered it but because of the road layout traffic joined past the exit after I’d entered (so the exit was no longer clear), and then there was a traffic light change leaving me stranded in the junction.

Appeal was denied, but I’m really not sure what else I could have done!

I really think some of these junctions are just a money-maker.

loudbatperson · 05/07/2022 10:30

QuebecBagnet · 05/07/2022 09:39

Living in London you get used to forward planning and not entering a box junction if you are not 100% sure you can clear it (ie you can see space for your car on the other side of it, unless of course you are turning right and blocked by oncoming traffic).

but the OP could see space for her car on the other side of it. So she’d done exactly as you’d said. 🤷‍♀️ She just didn’t predict the car infront would stop (when it didn’t need to) to do a U turn.

By see a space I mean you can actually see road on the opposite side of the junction, not space in front of other cars, as people can and will stop suddenly.

uhtredbebbanburg · 05/07/2022 10:21

I sympathise OP. There is a box junction near me that has lights and I have to turn right into. As soon as you are in it, the lights green and you can go. Locals know this but non-locals don't so sometimes you are at the junction forever and the locals just have to go around the non-local sitting there for ages. The idea of a box junction is good but they don't always make sense.

SarahShorty · 05/07/2022 10:15

It's annoying, but fair. As the standard of driving gets worse and worse, you have to drive with the full expectation that someone somewhere will do something stupid to mess it up for everyone else. If you see a yellow box junction and can't clear it, don't go.

kewgirl · 05/07/2022 10:14

Break the law by all means but do not whinge of you get caught

kewgirl · 05/07/2022 10:13

"The council has rejected my appeal and said I should have waited for all traffic ahead of me to exit the yellow box before entering it. The yellow box in this case is HUGE, maybe 5 car lengths. Who stops dead at a traffic junction, in full flowing traffic, to wait for all the cars ahead to cross?"

Yes that is the law
The law applies to everyone

Essexgalttc · 05/07/2022 10:07

The council are correct but I agree we’ve all done it… you should wait until it’s clear but especially rush hour etc I don’t see anyone doing that

Greenberg · 05/07/2022 10:06

I get you OP. If everyone waited until the next car had completely got across then they'd be massive tailbacks in London. If it would be reasonable to expect that your car could get across, for instance one car in front of you and a clear space past the box in front of them, then they should allow the appeal. The car that's blocked the exit due to their illegal manoeuvre should be fined but not those affected by it. You can't have someone just stop in the road past the box and then fine all the other cars affected. But I think these boxes have become money making schemes in London for struggling councils.

sashh · 05/07/2022 09:58

Autienotnaughtie · 04/07/2022 22:36

Genuinely never heard of a yellow box junction are they everywhere or just big cities?

Everywhere.

Well perhaps not on some of the smaller remote islands.

QuebecBagnet · 05/07/2022 09:57

We’ll have to agree to disagree. I interpret the exit being clear as the road at the other side being clear. It doesn’t say the box must be clear. Guess I’d have got fined too. 😁

Rosehugger · 05/07/2022 09:54

I agree it's harsh, OP. You were proceeding with the flowing traffic and believed the exit would be clear as you entered. The only thing I would suggest is to proceed really slowly around box junctions and hesitate until there is a car's width on the other side.

I got caught speeding right in front of the national speed limit sign, you could see it on the image! I just started to put my foot down ever so slightly too early. It's a fair cop, I went along and did the speed awareness course. Annoying though.

WatchoRulo · 05/07/2022 09:50

QuebecBagnet · 05/07/2022 09:39

Living in London you get used to forward planning and not entering a box junction if you are not 100% sure you can clear it (ie you can see space for your car on the other side of it, unless of course you are turning right and blocked by oncoming traffic).

but the OP could see space for her car on the other side of it. So she’d done exactly as you’d said. 🤷‍♀️ She just didn’t predict the car infront would stop (when it didn’t need to) to do a U turn.

No she could see a space occupied by vehicles that she expected would be clear by the time she got there - that's not what the rule says.

It's really simple - you don't enter the box unless you have a clear exit.

In this case OP entered the box even though her exit was blocked. She did that because it was blocked by a moving lorry that she didn't expect to stop - but it did due the car in front.

FixTheBone · 05/07/2022 09:40

ErrolTheDragon · 05/07/2022 08:01

Maybe I've misunderstood your description, but you can go into the box to wait to turn right.

...But, only if the right turn exit is clear and it's oncoming traffic that's preventing you from making the turn / exit.

thecatsthecats · 05/07/2022 09:40

My hack for unexpected obstructions in box junctions is to leave plenty of room and keep moving incredibly slowly.

But then I barely ever need to use it, and the room-leaving usually means just following the rules anyway!

QuebecBagnet · 05/07/2022 09:39

Living in London you get used to forward planning and not entering a box junction if you are not 100% sure you can clear it (ie you can see space for your car on the other side of it, unless of course you are turning right and blocked by oncoming traffic).

but the OP could see space for her car on the other side of it. So she’d done exactly as you’d said. 🤷‍♀️ She just didn’t predict the car infront would stop (when it didn’t need to) to do a U turn.

Chasingsquirrels · 05/07/2022 09:38

captncrunch · 05/07/2022 09:04

@ErrolTheDragon possibly - so for this yellow box there is no option for straight on, you can only turn right into two lanes - one lane then goes right again and one left. So in this case I don't believe you could wait in it to turn right because if you could there wouldn't be a box junction there?

I go through a junction like this every day, the HC rule 174 Errol refers to wouldn't apply in this case, as the exit (which you are turning right into) is NOT clear.

To think yellow box fines are f***ed up
loudbatperson · 05/07/2022 09:36

Living in London you get used to forward planning and not entering a box junction if you are not 100% sure you can clear it (ie you can see space for your car on the other side of it, unless of course you are turning right and blocked by oncoming traffic).

If you pay attention and slow in approach there is no need to slam on the brakes, you come to gentle stop if the way is not clear.

Box junction cameras are so rife here, and always enforced, that if you entered presuming traffic wouldn't stop your fines would cost more than the mortgage each month.

It's a lesson to learn and I am sure you will be more aware next time. At least it happened just the once and now you know.

lolil · 05/07/2022 09:30

What you're saying is cars are expected to slam their breaks on in free flowing traffic to wait for the car/s ahead to clear the junction/yellow box before proceeding? I don't think so. Who does that? Could cause an accident.

No you are expected to read the road ahead and on approach to a junction that is not clear you would slow and anticipate a stop, or continue if the box became clear.

A few refresher lessons would probably benefit you OP because the idea you would need to slam your brakes on rather then simply pay attention to what is going on ahead is really quite dangerous.

Swipe left for the next trending thread