Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Some of my students have complained about me

108 replies

Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 19:17

I worked in EFL teaching several years ago and I've started again a couple of weeks ago.
Back then I did it for just under 3 years, got generally very good feedback and only 3 'complaints' in 3 years, so hopefully I wasn't that awful.
Anyway I have a class of 12 students, mostly in their 20s, but we have 2 who are 18.
It can be hard as 4 of them have very limited English whereas the others are intermediate, so sometimes it can be a balancing act. I sometimes give the 4 some catch up work or if not they join in.
Anyway, they're never exactly bubbling with joy, but tonight I heard 2 or 3 complaining about me to our coordinator.
I've always found that students never come and talk to you if they have a problem, it will always be to someone else.
Anyway I heard them saying it was too easy, which I can understand as I try to cater for the low level learners too. I do think it needs to be two separate groups.
Then they stated that they want more games in the lesson, and that they're sick of answering questions.
Admittedly, I didn't think people in their 20s would be too concerned with games, but I will incorporate some.
They said they aren't benefitting from it and it's boring.
I admit I was hurt to overhear it but I shouldn't take it personally. I have 2 who said they enjoy it at least.
The students who complain are usually 20 minutes late too which is rude, but they keep doing it.
In the lesson today, we looked at the 4 skills, and I always try to generate discussions.
We looked at writing a letter or an email, formal vs informal, had a discussion about transport, did some listening and reading exercises then a sentence finishing game.
We have previously used YouTube videos and quizzes.
Would be grateful for any advice. Sometimes discussion is difficult as only one word answers are given back, which isn't their fault.
I feel a bit rubbish after hearing that, especially as I've only been there a few weeks, it's not a great start.

OP posts:
Mariposista · 04/07/2022 21:41

ESL teaching can be so rewarding when you get a lovely class, but if you don't time it can be so soul destroying. You put time, enthusiasm and energy into it, only to get entitled students who don't want to put the work in, don't take language learning seriously, are just doing it because they 'need the certificate', expect to reach the required level 'because they've paid for it' and then have the nerve to complain.
I would definitely take action over the lateness. It isn't fair to you or those who arrive on time.

Oceanus · 04/07/2022 21:35

I taught ESL back in the day, when I could still spell, and we had a problem with students coming in whenever they wanted. The whole school had to be really strict with that. I told my students, you can be 15 minutes late for the first class of the day, after that you'll have to wait and come in after the break. If you have a problem talk to the DOS. It happened a couple of times, the DOS told them those were the rules and that was it. They stuck to it. I only allowed exceptions when it was beyond anyone's control like tube strikes, nothing else.
You need to talk to the DOS because you need backup. This needs to be for the whole school, not just for you. Where's your DOS in all of this?!

Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 21:22

That's a good idea, thanks.
I will make sure I implement these things next lesson!
I record it on the register, and it reflects on their final attendance percentage but doesn't seem to stop them.
I've always considered frequent lateness as a lack of respect for the other person, providing they don't have any cognitive issues.
No sadly, paid for hours in the classroom only!
Yes, all men, and only one woman!
It could be that, yes. Though a couple are always on time and very polite.
The other annoying thing some of them do is leave the room for 15 minutes to 'take a call'. Every lesson.

OP posts:
Oceanus · 04/07/2022 21:20

You need to take sth else into consideration, without being rude because I think this is the rule but it has its exceptions, students from the Middle East are not used to having a woman boss them around. So, if they're male they might try to get the upper hand and be the ones to boss you, which can be really disruptive, so be super friendly but don't be a friend because you need authority. Put your foot down, they need to respect you or they'll keep on trying to get away with things, which is cr*p particularly for those students who are in a class which is a level above theirs imho.
Send students down if need be, don't dumb down your classes.

Drivebye · 04/07/2022 21:17

You could put a summary lesson plan on the board/wall at the start of the lesson so if they are late they can see they have missed the quiz/games linked to previous sessions.

I would not tolerate lateness and would be recording this, it's not acceptable and disrespectful.

I understand you don't get paid for prep, do you not get any additional time? How do you record progress/achievement of learning outcomes?

You mention that they like the male teacher and they are from Saudi. Are they men? Could it be that there is a cultural problem with you being a woman?

Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 21:16

It does feel unfair on the lower levels too. They can't access the same work at all, so it ends up being 2 different lessons with one

OP posts:
Crinklecuts · 04/07/2022 21:15

I did EFL classes previously and I found adults loved games! Why don’t you stronger students with weaker students in teams and design games like that. The other thing you can do is listening exercises that way the stronger students will get more from it.

mizu · 04/07/2022 21:11

I've taught EFL / ESOL for 25 years + and still love it and your post about students being late made me smile.

Only today we had our end of year department meeting and the lateness of students was brought up again Grin - always the Syrians in our case Grin

Very difficult to teach varying levels together. I agree with pp about a quiz at the beginning and end of sessions. Kahoot is always good.

SurpriseSurprise · 04/07/2022 21:11

I’ve done a few language courses over the years and have never played games. What sort of games do they want to do?

it sounds like they are trying to intimidate you, definitely put the fun stuff at the start

Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 21:08

I've only had 5 lessons with them so far and have used games once or twice, online quizzes and such.

OP posts:
Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 21:07

I can totally understand if they're under a lot of pressure. However why arrive 20 minutes late if that's the case, they could come on time and get the most out of their money.

OP posts:
dottymac · 04/07/2022 21:05

I've had Saudi/middle Eastern students (post-grad aswell as other courses)
and mine were never shy to complain, I wouldn't say it was personal. One thing I had to consider was that some of them had overcome massive obstacles to get where they were, even leaving behind families and sinking all their money into their studies, so are under immense pressure to learn and succeed. I know it affected them greatly and it could be projected outwardly. Pretty crappy that you don't get paid prep time, I don't blame you for not spending hours on that. Hopefully you'll be able to locate/put together some solid fail safe resources as you go along.

poppyseed68 · 04/07/2022 21:05

I find it really odd that adults expect you to be providing games and entertaining them in class. These are not kids who are being dragged through compulsory education - they've chosen to be there, and should be motivated to engage in the lesson, even if it feels dry at times (which pretty much any lesson will, surely)

Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 21:05

I just can't understand how you can be consistently late. I'm not that sort of person and I'm only late in a genuine emergency.
I don't think they collectively have severe organisational issues, I just don't understand how anyone who's a decent person can think it's ok to be frequently late.

OP posts:
SurfBox · 04/07/2022 21:04

Some boys are brought up to believe they are little princelings (not just Saudis) and they overestimate their value in the world. Maybe a woman making demands of them isn’t welcome

meh it's human nature more than a gender thing. I've seen umpteen girls do similar to what op describes as I have seen female colleagues cause similar trouble too. Just certain people both male and female in all workplaces you have to look out for.

Threetulips · 04/07/2022 21:01

I would start the lesson

Game - based on previous learning to add confidence in their ability.

Reading - Start with some phonics - then look at whole class reading - use an IPad and go through one chapter - highlight interesting words, use the dictionary function to understand words, highlight something you’re working on, personification, metaphors, etc - look at speech marks or emphasis etc

During these lessons, you read, next lesson they read a bit each, then look at the text and ask them to high light interesting sections, write a list of words that are new - ask the better ones to research each word and use them in sentences. Other ideas available! Even a question sheet for the text. Better ones can get one, you help the lower ones.

Move on the a grammar section - or sentence structure - similar sounds etc

Finish on a question and answer session, you find if you ask ‘how did you do’ they’ll give feed back - or ask for a thumbs up or thumbs down - so you can check their understanding next time and it gives them a voice and shows you’re listening.

mrpenny · 04/07/2022 21:00

I taught EFL for many years and the late arrivals were a pain in the neck. My line manager told me to put a sign on the door, in the L1 if necessary, saying that the class has started and to go and do self-study in the library until break time. No problems after that.

Charlieiscool · 04/07/2022 21:00

Some boys are brought up to believe they are little princelings (not just Saudis) and they overestimate their value in the world. Maybe a woman making demands of them isn’t welcome.

Siepie · 04/07/2022 20:58

I don't know much about Saudi culture, but from teaching/living in a few European countries, I've found that Brits are much less likely to complain than some other nationalities. As a British person, I always took complaints personally or thought that the complainers must be very disappointed. But in some cultures, it's expected that you complain about any small problem and receiving complaints isn't seen as an issue at all.

While it's not your fault that you have such a mix of abilities in the class, I do understand why they complained. If I were paying for a class in order to reach a certain level for work/study, and the school mixed me with people who only know a few words, I'd be annoyed too. As well as the suggestions PP have given for extension work, I can only suggest that you make it clear to the students that you're not in charge of the class lists.

SurfBox · 04/07/2022 20:53

Ah...are they Saudi? they will not consider themselves late. And it is in their culture to complain...it is to pass on responsibility. They will never say it to your face. Try not to take it personally

plenty of English students do that too

Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 20:52

In fact, she's always early

OP posts:
Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 20:51

All male yes, I have one woman! And she is never late.

OP posts:
Charlieiscool · 04/07/2022 20:50

They sound like a rude a disrespectful bunch of students. I don’t know how you put up with them rolling in late and then being rude. It isn’t how they’ll behave in the workplace. Are your students mostly male?

Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 20:46

I have 2 40 year olds in the class who are taking it very seriously!

OP posts:
Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 20:45

I do a task where I write a response and tell them to come up with the question, but apparently they're bored of questions.
I will include spelling tests too!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread