Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Some of my students have complained about me

108 replies

Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 19:17

I worked in EFL teaching several years ago and I've started again a couple of weeks ago.
Back then I did it for just under 3 years, got generally very good feedback and only 3 'complaints' in 3 years, so hopefully I wasn't that awful.
Anyway I have a class of 12 students, mostly in their 20s, but we have 2 who are 18.
It can be hard as 4 of them have very limited English whereas the others are intermediate, so sometimes it can be a balancing act. I sometimes give the 4 some catch up work or if not they join in.
Anyway, they're never exactly bubbling with joy, but tonight I heard 2 or 3 complaining about me to our coordinator.
I've always found that students never come and talk to you if they have a problem, it will always be to someone else.
Anyway I heard them saying it was too easy, which I can understand as I try to cater for the low level learners too. I do think it needs to be two separate groups.
Then they stated that they want more games in the lesson, and that they're sick of answering questions.
Admittedly, I didn't think people in their 20s would be too concerned with games, but I will incorporate some.
They said they aren't benefitting from it and it's boring.
I admit I was hurt to overhear it but I shouldn't take it personally. I have 2 who said they enjoy it at least.
The students who complain are usually 20 minutes late too which is rude, but they keep doing it.
In the lesson today, we looked at the 4 skills, and I always try to generate discussions.
We looked at writing a letter or an email, formal vs informal, had a discussion about transport, did some listening and reading exercises then a sentence finishing game.
We have previously used YouTube videos and quizzes.
Would be grateful for any advice. Sometimes discussion is difficult as only one word answers are given back, which isn't their fault.
I feel a bit rubbish after hearing that, especially as I've only been there a few weeks, it's not a great start.

OP posts:
PAFMO · 05/07/2022 14:40

@Charlieiscool
No, you didn't say they were. You asked if they were. Though you assumed they were on benefits.
"Are they refugees thinking they can piss around and then suddenly be high earners? Does attending affect their benefits? They should either go out and work or else properly apply themselves to study."

daretodenim · 05/07/2022 14:08

The other annoying thing some of them do is leave the room for 15 minutes to 'take a call'. Every lesson.

How on Earth are you supposed to teach a class with students rolling in 20 mins late and go over what they've missed plus have students leaving for phone calls for 15 mins?!

I think it would be worth raising with your line manager - out of concern that if students are missing so much of class plus the entire class is being disturbed at least twice every lesson (latecomers and phone call takers) - that the students may not meet the class targets. My suggestion would be that as this is quite serious that firstly you would like to speak to them and if it continues you would like the sponsors of the offenders to be contacted and told. Or go straight to sponsors.

I studied languages at uni and when the year above me was in their language school abroad they weren't taking it seriously. The language school contacted our uni department and the students got a very strongly worded email outlining the consequences of not passing this course plus the behaviours expected of them. There were dramatic behavioural changes after that.

If they're paying privately then I think you together with the head of the language school need to have a discussion with them about requirements of the class including attendance to whole class. If they're missing an hour every three lessons they will have a problem - and there aren't refunds available in this case.

Oceanus · 05/07/2022 13:48

BIWI · 05/07/2022 10:01

Teacher? I thought you were a part-time carer?

Are all part or full-time carers uneducated fools who've not done anything, been anywhere or had a proper life before besides changing diapers and cleaning poo? That's like saying all SAHM are overweight id*ots who stay at home with the kids because nobody would want them.

daretodenim · 05/07/2022 13:47

veiledsentiments · 04/07/2022 23:08

Am also an EFL teacher and worked in the Middle East for 25 years. These kids are taking the piss. They say in the ME there are two times. English time and ME time. Don’t stand for it. Late is late. Don’t let them in, tell them why, nicely and stick to it. They’ll start showing up. No mobile phones, or taking a call. EVER. You are going to have to stick to your guns on this one. In the end they’ll respect you more for it. Saudis can be polite, but they can also be great time wasters, and like to lay the blame elsewhere. As their teacher you have to lay down the rules and be tough, but fair. Good luck.

^^ this

Charlieiscool · 05/07/2022 13:38

PAFMO
I didn’t say they were after refugee status and a job at McD did I? I have worked with many who have worked hard to be granted refugee status (not those after it anymore) and then they’ve gone on to mess about in college getting nowhere. I think they have unrealistic expectations about the value of these courses and it’s when they work and start to integrate outside their own community that their English improves and they adjust to the life they can build. Of course those that come already highly qualified in their own countries have a much clearer pathway.

ChitChatChatter · 05/07/2022 12:38

It’s a question of respect or rather, their lack of respect for you.

in every class I’ve attended as an adult learner, the policy was that there was no expectation that the teacher would revisit work missed by the student arriving late. Of course, reasonable tutors cut us some slack in the case of genuine difficulty but persistent lateness and disappearing to take calls during class - just no.

PAFMO · 05/07/2022 12:38

elenacampana · 05/07/2022 11:59

I wouldn’t advise this sorry @Skodacool. It wouldn’t go down well at all with management. It’s for the DOS or Principal to say and they 99.9% of the time definitely wouldn’t.

True.
As for the poster who thinks the Saudi students are after refugee status and a McJob stolen from Darren down the road, give us a break.
The Saudis will be here sponsored by their govt as part of their degrees/post-grad courses and will be paying handsomely.
No, that doesn't make it OK if they are disrespectful to the teacher, but it does mean that it almost certainly would not be the student who gets told off for complaining about their class/teacher.

katscamel · 05/07/2022 12:35

I understand completely how you feel having been in EFL for 20+ years with probably about half of that spent in the Middle East.
Punctuality is a major problem and there really is no excuse for their lateness....its just 'a cultural thing'. Another issue is the lack of accountability... Unfortunately in some cultures / nationalities there is this idea that if its meant to happen it will.....and if not someone else will pick up the pieces/do the work for them or they can just pay for the result they want.
I used to love teaching my Middle Eastern guys...a lot of the time it's getting that relationship right....depending on your age its the whole mix of daughter, mother, sister, fabulous species of womanhood who they then want to impress.
Sorry if you've already mentioned this but what coursebook are you using and is it appropriate? Could you incorporate some work on intercultural communication and teamworking? Look at transferable skills and see how they can be incorporated into what you're doing.
Good luck.....it is frustrating but often great fun.

elenacampana · 05/07/2022 11:59

Skodacool · 05/07/2022 06:57

In that case, don’t. You’re just enabling their lack of manners. Keep them back afterwards and tell them that you expect them to be on time and if they’re not happy they can leave the course.

I wouldn’t advise this sorry @Skodacool. It wouldn’t go down well at all with management. It’s for the DOS or Principal to say and they 99.9% of the time definitely wouldn’t.

MRex · 05/07/2022 10:34

I teach a mixed ability class, possibly entirely different than language but I find it helps to teach to the highest ability then downgrade expected outcomes from the lower ability.

Thinking of equivalents:

  1. Write down in English as many excuses for being late as you can think of in 10 minutes, in proper sentences, then read them out in small groups.
  2. In two teams using whiteboard name everything you can see on a picture, hand out pictures of a car / house / party etc. Extra points for adding an adjective for every word.
  3. Read this text and write down in a simple list of what you need to do that you will explain to the group in your own words. Hand out copies of various letters; doctor appointment for newbies, University purchase order process or similar for more experienced.
BIWI · 05/07/2022 10:01

Teacher? I thought you were a part-time carer?

Charlieiscool · 05/07/2022 08:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

AchatAVendre · 05/07/2022 07:20

Unfortunately, this is normal amongst some groups of students, where there are a couple of moany types and they drag the rest in to support them. And yes, it does seem to be women who are subjected to these types of nit picking, not particularly genuine complaints. This is also a disciplinary issue - if these students cannot be bothered to turn up on time and disrupt the lesson by turning up 20 minutes late, then there should be some sort of warning or sanction given.

I actually stopped part time lecturing at my local university due to a complaint like this. Its not unusual for people in my professional field to teach an afternoon or so a week so that students can have a qualified professional teach them, but after my first session, I got this kind of odd complaint. One of the complaints was that my background was "too dark" - I had closed my curtains to avoid screen glare. The real reason is that they just weren't used to me. They loved me by the end of the semester, but that was because they realised that they had to focus on the work, not the teaching style, individual presentation or background of the lecturer!

But I had to give up a couple of hours of my time to discuss the complaint over the phone - unpaid. And I wasn't properly remunerated for preparation either - when the students are as nit picky as that, you need to spend 3 hours preparation in my field to cover all eventualities, not the 1 (poorly paid per hour) that you are paid for. So I just stopped doing it.

Skodacool · 05/07/2022 06:58

whynotwhatknot · 04/07/2022 23:23

sounds like rude entitled men -tell them you wont tolerate lateness or leaving to take a call how bloody rude

This.

Skodacool · 05/07/2022 06:57

Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 19:35

I'm sick of having to re explain what we're doing 5 times each time someone else walks in late

In that case, don’t. You’re just enabling their lack of manners. Keep them back afterwards and tell them that you expect them to be on time and if they’re not happy they can leave the course.

elenacampana · 04/07/2022 23:34

Heyyy OP. I taught EFL for 8 years home and abroad and was a senior teacher, even as a senior I still got complaints - you just can’t please everyone. Mixed level classes are a nightmare, especially when beginners are involved. I never allowed lateness, I always adhered to the school’s punctuality policy and no one attempted to come in late to my lessons. You are doing the ones who arrive on time a disservice by allowing late comers in… and it’s just annoying.

Complaints are a kick in the teeth and a confidence bash. The summer months are notorious for younger students taking the mickey. It can still be a wonderful job though, some of my happiest moments have been in classrooms :-)

whynotwhatknot · 04/07/2022 23:23

sounds like rude entitled men -tell them you wont tolerate lateness or leaving to take a call how bloody rude

veiledsentiments · 04/07/2022 23:08

Am also an EFL teacher and worked in the Middle East for 25 years. These kids are taking the piss. They say in the ME there are two times. English time and ME time. Don’t stand for it. Late is late. Don’t let them in, tell them why, nicely and stick to it. They’ll start showing up. No mobile phones, or taking a call. EVER. You are going to have to stick to your guns on this one. In the end they’ll respect you more for it. Saudis can be polite, but they can also be great time wasters, and like to lay the blame elsewhere. As their teacher you have to lay down the rules and be tough, but fair. Good luck.

Oceanus · 04/07/2022 22:15

You start with an icebreaker, not a game. You can't do games every single day.

BlokeHereInPeace · 04/07/2022 22:11

Sounds like you are doing really well. I did TEFL ages ago and found that all ages liked games. On the course to teach they suggested starting and finishing with a game and hitting the grammar first followed by a discussion using that grammar. Classes of really different abilities are really hard and unfair on the students so the school can hopefully get something sorted.

WonderingWanda · 04/07/2022 22:04

Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 19:35

I'm sick of having to re explain what we're doing 5 times each time someone else walks in late

Stop doing it. If they can't be bothered to turn up on time they will have to wait for the next set of instructions while you work with the people who could be bothered to turn up on time. Just say 'I'm sorry you will have to wait as the lesson has already begun, I suggest you revise last week's vocab while you wait and turn up on time next lesson please.'

Oceanus · 04/07/2022 22:03

Adults are a lot worse than children. Children are used to going to school every day, they're used to rules. They know if they break them, they'll be in trouble. Adults, particularly males, want to assert themselves, not to you but to their peers. Classes with only males are usually harder, particularly when they're all from the same country, because there's always 1 or 2 who want to be the leaders of the pack. That's why setting rules right from the get-go is so important. Better have many rules and drop them (depending on each individual class, you decide) than not having them, realising you need them and trying to change things in the middle of the game -when you're dealing with only male adults, this will be even harder.
This is my personal (& subjective) opinion, I'm sure others will disagree, but if there's one student leading the others (and you know who it is), this is the one you will need to set straight. Stop the class and tell this student if you don't want to learn, get out and go the DOS. If they keep doing it: here's the door, go to the DOS, now. But you need to talk to the DOS first, better not go it alone.

Oceanus · 04/07/2022 21:51

Just realised you said you've only been there a few weeks... Yeah, they're trying it on to see how far they can go. Talk to the DOS and then put your bloody foot down, they were testing the waters and now you're going to show them who's in charge. Don't worry about any complaints! The DOS has been in your shoes before so don't lose sleep over it.

Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 21:47

I never thought it'd have to be like this with adults but apparently it is!

OP posts:
Oceanus · 04/07/2022 21:45

My students would not be allowed to leave to take a call... As if!
My personal tip for you... Every now an then I'd say (always) in a jokey way and laughing, with a wink here and there... guys this isn't a democracy, it's a dictatorship and I'm like Fidel Castro! hahhah I'm the boss! haha! My way or the highway! haha! (wink wink)
Again talk to the DOS before because you need backup and it's always hard when you have to enforce these rules they bloody hate that were always ignored before or that weren't exactly a rule before.
Good luck because it's difficult to get a class under control when it's gone a bit pear-shaped already but it can be done. When you get a new class always cover the rules on the first day and stick to them religiously, with time you can be more or less strict as it suits you, but be strict at first.

Swipe left for the next trending thread