Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Some of my students have complained about me

108 replies

Caribou1 · 04/07/2022 19:17

I worked in EFL teaching several years ago and I've started again a couple of weeks ago.
Back then I did it for just under 3 years, got generally very good feedback and only 3 'complaints' in 3 years, so hopefully I wasn't that awful.
Anyway I have a class of 12 students, mostly in their 20s, but we have 2 who are 18.
It can be hard as 4 of them have very limited English whereas the others are intermediate, so sometimes it can be a balancing act. I sometimes give the 4 some catch up work or if not they join in.
Anyway, they're never exactly bubbling with joy, but tonight I heard 2 or 3 complaining about me to our coordinator.
I've always found that students never come and talk to you if they have a problem, it will always be to someone else.
Anyway I heard them saying it was too easy, which I can understand as I try to cater for the low level learners too. I do think it needs to be two separate groups.
Then they stated that they want more games in the lesson, and that they're sick of answering questions.
Admittedly, I didn't think people in their 20s would be too concerned with games, but I will incorporate some.
They said they aren't benefitting from it and it's boring.
I admit I was hurt to overhear it but I shouldn't take it personally. I have 2 who said they enjoy it at least.
The students who complain are usually 20 minutes late too which is rude, but they keep doing it.
In the lesson today, we looked at the 4 skills, and I always try to generate discussions.
We looked at writing a letter or an email, formal vs informal, had a discussion about transport, did some listening and reading exercises then a sentence finishing game.
We have previously used YouTube videos and quizzes.
Would be grateful for any advice. Sometimes discussion is difficult as only one word answers are given back, which isn't their fault.
I feel a bit rubbish after hearing that, especially as I've only been there a few weeks, it's not a great start.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Oceanus · 06/07/2022 23:21

In my opinion when they're young, they're more used to rules so they're still in learning mode, when they're older it's usually their money so they want to make the best out their classes, they want to learn, they want an education for their money!
Early 20s, it's usually the parents paying but it's not real school in their heads, as in it's not compulsory like secondary school! Some are there (only) for the experience of living abroad so it's hit or miss because sometimes all it takes is one bad apple for things to go a bit wrong. I'd bet they were probably acting like that before you came along! Good luck OP!

MethodToTheMadness · 06/07/2022 19:16

I've been there too! I don't know what happens to adults when they start language lessons - it seems they turn into kids again! The number of times I heard "aww not homewoooork!", "can we do this test together??", "ugh I don't want to do this exercise", or "nooo not the textboook!" - it's enough to drive anyone crazy! And these were all adult people from 25-60 in a normal working environment! On my last day before maternity leave, I had two lessons with 5 people in each. I knew one person couldn't make it but no one else turned up. NO ONE. I just thought... fuck 'em. They obviously don't respect you, so just return the favour. Don't take it personally. You're doing a great job!

elenacampana · 06/07/2022 18:29

Caribou1 · 06/07/2022 17:57

I told my coordinator they hadn't turned up and they said they'd look into it.
Honestly find it so pathetic and childish for a group of men in their 20s to collectively not turn up. If I'd just given them a worksheet for 1 hour and said 'do this' and ignored them then i could understand.

I’ve been there - I’d really try not to let it get you down, although I totally get it. They are the problem, you aren’t at all the problem! You’re unlikely to make a difference to their mindsets so focus on the students who do show up and engage with your well thought out lessons.

Caribou1 · 06/07/2022 17:57

I told my coordinator they hadn't turned up and they said they'd look into it.
Honestly find it so pathetic and childish for a group of men in their 20s to collectively not turn up. If I'd just given them a worksheet for 1 hour and said 'do this' and ignored them then i could understand.

OP posts:
woodhill · 06/07/2022 15:52

Caribou1 · 06/07/2022 15:06

I planned a lesson today with games, mixed ability exercises, everything. A PowerPoint about being on time and school policy, and then the 'complainers' didn't even bloody turn up. 4 students just not shown up, the higher level ones who are always late.
One of them briefly burst in to get his bag and told me "I can't stay, ok?" No explanation, no apology.
Sod the lot of them, rude and entitled.
I've had a nice lesson with the remaining ones anyway.

I would raise that with your line manager

If they're late or not attending it's a bit much of them to be complaining in the first place

Oceanus · 06/07/2022 15:35

It's not you! It's not you! It's not you! You're getting started so it feels like it's your fault, but I've seen that happen to others and it's not you! I want you to know that. Don't lose heart over this! What they did was so typical. Don't worry, they've probably been told they're moving down and it was a blow to their gigantic male ego! Don't worry, when they split the class for good it will change for the better, specially if they bring in new students. Don't lose heart! Your DOS is on this, so it's not you, it's them! Focus on the students you have. The best revenge is to do something awesome and for the cheeky ones outside to hear the laughter! 😁

Caribou1 · 06/07/2022 15:06

I planned a lesson today with games, mixed ability exercises, everything. A PowerPoint about being on time and school policy, and then the 'complainers' didn't even bloody turn up. 4 students just not shown up, the higher level ones who are always late.
One of them briefly burst in to get his bag and told me "I can't stay, ok?" No explanation, no apology.
Sod the lot of them, rude and entitled.
I've had a nice lesson with the remaining ones anyway.

OP posts:
elenacampana · 06/07/2022 12:38

Oceanus · 06/07/2022 12:25

I 100% know they're not always a bad thing (nor have I said that) but she's got more pressing matters. If this class is ending as it is (it's being split) she would benefit more from being observed in the next class and the first few days (for sb who's getting started) are not the best imho. They're for getting to know the ss, so having a stranger in the room means they'll likely be super quiet so it won't be under normal conditions.
There's no such thing as a free observation imho. If she's being observed she needs a better lesson plan and a better everything to feel at ease. She's already so stressed why add to that now?

I wholeheartedly disagree with you (esp about what observations can be), but this thread isn’t about what you or I think re training methodology and a difference of opinion. I don’t want to derail and get away from the OP’s original post.

OP, I really hope you can get through this sticky patch and wish you all the best. You’re in a tough industry with oftentimes impossible expectations and as can be seen above, a lot of people assume the way they look at it is the only way. It’s a very personal experience with no right or wrong. You’ll find your path :-)

Oceanus · 06/07/2022 12:25

I 100% know they're not always a bad thing (nor have I said that) but she's got more pressing matters. If this class is ending as it is (it's being split) she would benefit more from being observed in the next class and the first few days (for sb who's getting started) are not the best imho. They're for getting to know the ss, so having a stranger in the room means they'll likely be super quiet so it won't be under normal conditions.
There's no such thing as a free observation imho. If she's being observed she needs a better lesson plan and a better everything to feel at ease. She's already so stressed why add to that now?

elenacampana · 06/07/2022 12:16

Oceanus · 06/07/2022 11:35

Honestly, don't ask to be observed now. Get comfortable with your class, you don't need the added stress of an observation imho! Get to know them first (and go over the rules on the first day)!

Observation doesn’t mean a full observation with an in-depth plan, it can be a quick drop in to have a look. I found these helpful, especially when things were hard, which they were in the early days. They made a huge amount of difference to me and I learned an awful lot from them, so don’t assume they’re always bad things. They aren’t.

mizu · 06/07/2022 12:00

We have 7 levels now - ESOL though and not EFL - and have over 400 students.

Some students have very spiky profiles but are generally in the right level class which helps.

Mixed level classes are, as I said before, tough to teach and it depends on the students how you manage it. Higher level with lower can work but some higher level students aren't keen on this.

mizu · 06/07/2022 11:57

Ah, we only use Kahoot a couple of times a year - and always create our own quizzes so they follow what we have taught that year.

MattoMatto · 06/07/2022 11:53

Kahoot is always good.

Kahoot was removed from a course I study because there were complaints it was too stressful. While I wasn’t one of the complainers, I was quite pleased when it was dropped as I didn’t like the ranking at all. It’s quite brutal in a small class, and to this day the Kahoot music puts me on edge Grin Give me a gentle vocab quiz or something instead to warm up. OTOH Kahoot was very motivating as I studied like crazy to avoid embarrassing myself in it, so perhaps on balance it’s a good choice.

Re the op, as a former TEFL teacher of a couple of years and a language dabbler veteran of dozens of language classes, the thread has surprised me as to how common mixed level courses are. They sound absolutely crap for students. I don’t want to be held back by people who don’t understand the basics once I get beyond beginners and nor do I want to spend half my class bewildered by things above my level. I wonder if this explains some of the disengagement- knowing they are about to sit down to an hour or so of stuff that is mostly too easy or too hard. As a student, the best classes for me have been where we are all at a very similar level - we have the same questions, we have roughly the same vocab and you’re motivated to keep up when you see your peers making progress. I think I’d be looking for a job where students sit a test and are put into appropriate courses.

Oceanus · 06/07/2022 11:35

Honestly, don't ask to be observed now. Get comfortable with your class, you don't need the added stress of an observation imho! Get to know them first (and go over the rules on the first day)!

Oceanus · 06/07/2022 11:32

You're not rubbish, it takes time to feel comfortable! You've been validated by the DOS if your class is being split into different levels! Most of your problem was right there. It's almost impossible to control even just one student (let alone more) who should be in a lower level as they won't understand things so they use that time to piss off rattle the teacher and the other students with all their free time.

elenacampana · 06/07/2022 11:22

Caribou1 · 06/07/2022 11:14

I've got them again today. Luckily as of next week they will be split into 2 different classes based on level. I've got some games planned and more explanation of what the class is about. I still feel like I'm rubbish at the job and that they don't like me.

You will probably feel completely different in a week or so’s time OP. EFL teaching is a really difficult job, but on the happy side, so much of the time it’s very rewarding. You can always ask for an observation from your DOS if you want feedback on your lessons, I found this really helpful in my early days.

Caribou1 · 06/07/2022 11:14

I've got them again today. Luckily as of next week they will be split into 2 different classes based on level. I've got some games planned and more explanation of what the class is about. I still feel like I'm rubbish at the job and that they don't like me.

OP posts:
Anycrispsleft · 06/07/2022 05:43

I don't envy you teaching EFL. I studied German along with other immigrants to a German speaking country and there were a fair few of us who were not happy to be in the class or in the country, and that can easily come out in frustration about language classes, where the main aspect of your not fitting in to the country is tackled head on. In fact I remember coming on here and expressing my frustration about the class and the teacher's efforts to make it fun and entertaining to get us to open up about ourselves. My husband had just been made redundant in the UK and could only find a job abroad. I'd had to leave my home country and my job and was facing an uncertain future, I dragged my two toddlers across town at 7 in the morning for that course (because the local council sponsored ppl (not me) to go on it, it had to be early so as not to have locals accusing foreigners of having a cushy life) and put them in the language school creche they hated, every morning, left them crying with a lady who didn't speak their language. By the time I got to the class I really didn't want to have fun, I wanted to work, you know? People have a lot of baggage in these situations.

WiddlinDiddlin · 06/07/2022 05:21

Yes if the school itself has a lateness policy - sure, if they don't... and my friends employer didn't (because I think literally all their extremely wealthy students would simply not attend at all) so she was unable to implement her own.

Starting point has to be to find out EXACTLY what the school will back you up on, for real (and not just the stuff they say and then throw you under the bus over later on, the stuff they really mean and have in writing!).

elenacampana · 05/07/2022 23:52

WiddlinDiddlin · 05/07/2022 22:03

You will have to get sneaky - its highly unlikely your immediate bosses will back you up in actually shutting late students out, or refusing to explain what they missed.

However if you ensure the fun is at the start of the lesson, and that they will look really stupid in front of the others for having to ask what they missed.. that might be sufficiently aversive that they start arriving on time.

For those unaware of what teaching EFL is like in some places - some of these students will be FULLY expecting to pass a course without doing any work at all, some of them will expect to actually learn something without doing anything. They absolutely will not expect to be reprimanded by a tutor, they haven't experienced it from anyone (or if they have, that person was fired by their Father soon after!) ever before!

It doesn't really matter where they are from, thats the type of students some schools are marketing their courses at - I spent two years listening to a good friend let off steam about such pupils in another part of the world entirely. It is potentially absolutely infuriating and for very little money.

I agree with everything you’ve said @WiddlinDiddlin, with exception to the part about punctuality. The two schools I worked at in the U.K. had lateness policies that were printed out and put on the doors of classrooms. I always adhered to them, in one school it was no entry after 15 mins (I was senior teacher there) and in the other it was no entry after 10 mins. I didn’t allow entry after either time and this never caused me any hassle with management. The management also don’t like getting complaints from students who arrive on time and have their lessons interrupted by late comers. The rest of your post was, in my experience, very accurate.

WiddlinDiddlin · 05/07/2022 22:03

You will have to get sneaky - its highly unlikely your immediate bosses will back you up in actually shutting late students out, or refusing to explain what they missed.

However if you ensure the fun is at the start of the lesson, and that they will look really stupid in front of the others for having to ask what they missed.. that might be sufficiently aversive that they start arriving on time.

For those unaware of what teaching EFL is like in some places - some of these students will be FULLY expecting to pass a course without doing any work at all, some of them will expect to actually learn something without doing anything. They absolutely will not expect to be reprimanded by a tutor, they haven't experienced it from anyone (or if they have, that person was fired by their Father soon after!) ever before!

It doesn't really matter where they are from, thats the type of students some schools are marketing their courses at - I spent two years listening to a good friend let off steam about such pupils in another part of the world entirely. It is potentially absolutely infuriating and for very little money.

katscamel · 05/07/2022 21:33

Just to add...listen to @veiledsentiments .... she is pretty much a Middle East expert and used to give really useful advice to newbies to the region in terms of classroom management and how to cope with a number of situations that cropped up.

elenacampana · 05/07/2022 16:29

2bazookas · 05/07/2022 16:09

For a start, any adult student who consistently arrives late should be refused entry to the class.. They are disrupting the lesson and distracting you and the other students.

I

It’s not this simple unfortunately. Schools are dealing with agents who take their business elsewhere. Teachers have to abide by the school’s policies and most teachers are on 0 hour contracts, it’s not a very good industry for boat rocking.

2bazookas · 05/07/2022 16:09

For a start, any adult student who consistently arrives late should be refused entry to the class.. They are disrupting the lesson and distracting you and the other students.

I

Oceanus · 05/07/2022 14:53

@Charlieiscool Saudis in the UK studying English are unlikely to be refugees and chances are they have a heck of a lot more $$$ than you. Most will likely be spoilt little brats living in Kensigton and paying 2000 quid for a room with friends... When they're off school you'll find driving the posh card daddy sent over and shopping.