Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School Awards Assembly

58 replies

blueswans · 04/07/2022 18:34

Today DD11 in Year 7 had her end of year awards assembly (private school so last week of term this week). All of Y7, maybe 100 kids and 100 parents in the hall. They started with Maths, English, Science awards, No DD. Then History, Geography, Languages, PE, Technology, Arts, Drama etc. then Attendance, Charity Fundraiser, Sportsperson, Overall Achievement etc.

No DD.

The kids all walk out of the hall across the stage. DD is the only kid without a certificate or an award.

I'm not the type of person that thinks everybody should win and get a participation trophy, but I feel so bad for DD. It was obvious that she was the only kid without something, she's had a hard year (lost her dad, my DH in January) and I just think more care should have been taken to ensure that there wasn't just one child without something. If ten kids or even two wouldn't have had something, I wouldn't be upset but she was the only one!

She's not a super high achiever, or a future Olympian but she is a genuinely good, nice person. And I'm upset for her, she says she's fine about it and not bothered by a laminated bit of paper but I can't help but feel bad for her.

I'm not going to do anything but I guess AIBU for finding this unfair?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
XelaM · 06/07/2022 13:49

caringcarer · 06/07/2022 10:58

@redredskyatnight, I would far rather the subject prizes went to the student with the highest grade as objective and fair, as all had equal chance in test. My DS is really good at Sport, plays at county level and just made England training squad for winter coming. He is autistic. He did not win sports trophy. He would not mind if another high sporty child got award but no, child who won Sports trophy was awarded as they helped teacher tidy up equipment after lesson in break time. This was supposed to be an attainment award on programme. My DS got 100 percent Attendance Award and Form Role Model, neither of which he cared about and actually threw both Attendance certificate and Role Model perspex award in bin outside assembly. It was all made worse by I was invited as pre told he had won an award. His teacher saw him do it and rushed over to us and told me he was by far best Sports person but he could not win 3 things. It just made me sad that they did not know DS at all as he would happily have gone without other awards and only one he wanted to win was the Sports award and student who tidied up equipment is crap at sport according to my son, who is autistic, he said they think I am worse at sport than X who won trophy. I must be even more crap at sport than X then. This did not happen with other awards. Student who best at Art got Art award etc. Student who ended up getting Sports award not in one school sports team. DS in county cricket team, swims for his town and county and was Aquathlon champion 2 years running and in school teams for cricket, rounders, swimming and cross country.

That's crazy! Sports awards are usually quite objective. Your son's school is totally nuts. My daughter just had sports awards at her school and actually she thought the school would give her the Sports Woman award, as she was the only girl in her whole school to volunteer to do long-distance cross-country racing and had to race against the boys. But I actually thought her school did well in handing the award to a girl who actually had outstanding achievements in sport rather than just recognise my daughter for being a good sport. It's mental to not give your son the award, but it sounds like he is doing superbly and good luck to him in the England camp!

Daftapath · 06/07/2022 13:37

At ds' school, the same children would always get awards, some of them multiple awards. Parents only had an invite (unless a leaver) if their child had an award.

I always thought that they should give them to a wider group of children and maybe had a rule that a child could not get the same award two years running. Maybe that was just sour grapes on my part though!

redskyatnight · 06/07/2022 13:24

Well people either like "objective and fair" awards or they like inclusive awards.

As OP's DC clearly goes to a school that likes their awards to be objective and fair this means that some children won't get awards and that this might appear to be unfair. Guess it's good she's worked this out in Year 7.

caringcarer · 06/07/2022 10:58

@redredskyatnight, I would far rather the subject prizes went to the student with the highest grade as objective and fair, as all had equal chance in test. My DS is really good at Sport, plays at county level and just made England training squad for winter coming. He is autistic. He did not win sports trophy. He would not mind if another high sporty child got award but no, child who won Sports trophy was awarded as they helped teacher tidy up equipment after lesson in break time. This was supposed to be an attainment award on programme. My DS got 100 percent Attendance Award and Form Role Model, neither of which he cared about and actually threw both Attendance certificate and Role Model perspex award in bin outside assembly. It was all made worse by I was invited as pre told he had won an award. His teacher saw him do it and rushed over to us and told me he was by far best Sports person but he could not win 3 things. It just made me sad that they did not know DS at all as he would happily have gone without other awards and only one he wanted to win was the Sports award and student who tidied up equipment is crap at sport according to my son, who is autistic, he said they think I am worse at sport than X who won trophy. I must be even more crap at sport than X then. This did not happen with other awards. Student who best at Art got Art award etc. Student who ended up getting Sports award not in one school sports team. DS in county cricket team, swims for his town and county and was Aquathlon champion 2 years running and in school teams for cricket, rounders, swimming and cross country.

YesNoMaybeNot · 06/07/2022 10:58

Obviously I can’t be 100% sure that DD was the only one without one,

So you don't know if they were the only one that didn't get anything then.

itsjustnotok · 06/07/2022 10:37

@woulducouldushouldu that’s down to the school. My DD rarely got anything in primary school. She told me regularly it was because she was weird and not as clever. Secondary school for her has been a turning point and we are very lucky going by some of the threads I’ve read recently. She won an award because of her attitude towards learning. She’s in bottom
sets for a few including maths and science but she tries hard even if she doesn’t do well. Her school rewarded her for her effort and attitude. She was shocked to hear her name and it boosted her confidence no end. It’s a shame that this isn’t recognised more.

WhereIsVillanelleWhenNeeded · 06/07/2022 10:28

DD is the only kid without a certificate or an award

It was obvious that she was the only kid without something

Obviously I can’t be 100% sure that DD was the only one without one

It doesn’t sound obvious

Spudina · 06/07/2022 10:27

My DM died when I was doing my A Levels. It’s really hard to carry on when something so catastrophic and life changing happens. Your DD reserved recognition for that in the least, as that shows incredible resilience. Most people don’t deal with that pain until they are well into adulthood. It was cruel of the school to leave her out. I would say something.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/07/2022 10:15

Yes 99 kids out of 100 getting prizes is incredibly unfair.

lanthanum · 06/07/2022 10:12

00100001 · 05/07/2022 06:52

But maybe she WAS a good influence on them and needed some sort of recognition for her good behaviour/attitude as part of her behaviour management plan?

Most kids that are bullies have some sort of shit going on in their lives.

To begrudge a 13yo a relatively meaningless school prize that might have just helped tip her behaviour to that if the better and boycott the ceremony seems a little over the top...

I agree that this may have been quite reasonable (although obviously we don't know the detail). If she had been ostracised by the year group, then probably the bullying was in the past, and she might have seen the error of her ways. It's hard to turn around behaviour like that, because everyone still sees you as "the bully", which means your self-esteem stays at rock-bottom. If she was forging some positive relationships with the younger children, that's progress (education, even), and some encouragement will have been entirely appropriate.

Pushingthe50 · 06/07/2022 09:56

God! If your daughter was the only one out of 100 kids I’d definitely say something. That’s not fair. My son just left primary school this a few weeks ago. Scotland. For years I have watched the same kids getting the awards right through the years, son got bugger all. . I sat and cried for him getting an award for outstanding effort the other week. I was so happy for him. Sorry I had to tell everyone this. He’s so quiet, timid and shy. Not really a high achiever, he does try though. He does play the bagpipes Beautifully.

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 06/07/2022 09:49

It really isn't hard at a leavers achievement assembly to give a little something to every child, even just as a keepsake. When so many were on offer it seems unfair to leave on child out, even without the awful trauma she has experienced.

10HailMarys · 06/07/2022 09:34

Obviously I can’t be 100% sure that DD was the only one without one,

Quite different from your original post, then.

YesNoMaybeNot · 06/07/2022 09:25

redskyatnight · 04/07/2022 18:42

I think this is a private school "thing" tbh - they seem to set clear definitions for who wins what prize and don't really consider who is most deserving (e.g. the prize goes to the child who gets the highest mark in the exam even if this is because they are naturally gifted and they make minimal effort) or whether this means the same children win everything and some win nothing.

No it really isn't a 'private school thing'.

It happens in many state schools.

Bickles · 06/07/2022 09:23

This is definitely a private school thing. DS10 has never had a prize. He came top in his year in the reading comprehension exam this time and still didn’t. Trying not to be bitter 😂
I told DS that the speaker (amazing high flying career but started off doing design at a Poly) probably never won any awards at school either! And he’s done fantastically in life.
It is fairly meaningless. I won the Geography prize at A level and haven’t done geography since. I won the student research prize at Uni and haven’t researched since.
I guess it instills resilience? DS himself said it showed him that life’s not fair after the prize giving!

redskyatnight · 06/07/2022 09:13

@knockyknees I was calling it a "private school thing" because in my experience (of many children in many schools, granted I don't know every school in the country!) private schools tend to often give prizes for simply achieving the highest score in a school exam (where of course it's also dependent on perfromance on the day. State schools tend to look more at all round effort, application, enthusiasm for the subject, going over and above simply doing what is required ... And they quite often don't have formal exams that they can simply look at who got the highest score! Plus they generally have progress prizes as well - whereas private schools tend to be more focused on results.

I don't see any great value in giving a child a prize simply because they have natural ability and ignoring the child who worked incredibly hard all year and made exceptional progress but got a few marks less than the top in the exam. Although I must admit my perspective is possibly skewed by listening to my naturally gifted at maths niece show off about how she keeps getting the maths prize when she freely admits she doesn't really have to work at it. This is not sour grapes by the way - I also went to a private school and regularly got a prize for a subject I didn't try at but had natural ability. I found it totally meaningless - the school prize I most valued was when I got "service to the school", because I felt that was rewarding me for something I'd actually devoted time, energy and effort into.

MidwichCuckoo · 06/07/2022 09:08

Really sorry to hear you lost your dh. We lost my dh/kids' dad when my dds were 11 and 13. I think the school were quite thoughtless to leave your dd out after what she's been through. Our school gives effort prizes which are good as kids of any ability can earn them if they are making a good effort. Is the school offering support? One of my dds meets with a TA trained in bereavement support fortnightly.

knockyknees · 06/07/2022 08:59

redskyatnight · 04/07/2022 18:42

I think this is a private school "thing" tbh - they seem to set clear definitions for who wins what prize and don't really consider who is most deserving (e.g. the prize goes to the child who gets the highest mark in the exam even if this is because they are naturally gifted and they make minimal effort) or whether this means the same children win everything and some win nothing.

What a bizarre post. Firstly, it's not a "private school thing". Awarding the prize to the recipient with the highest score is the most normal thing in the (school) world, regardless of type of school.

Secondly, of the course the person with the highest marks deserves the prize - regardless of whether they're the smartest kid on the planet, or one who had to dedicate hours and hours each day to their studies to get the top mark. Any decent school will also present other awards - such as most improved (even if they're still bottom of the class); best effort (perhaps they always come second or third for instance), etc. But if I had got the top mark in a subject, then damn right I'd expect to receive the award for it.

My DCs schools usually had a range of prize levels - 95-100%= gold level/certificate; 90-95%= silver etc, with one student being named Dux overall. So they could have come second in everything, but still had higher marks than someone who came first in two subjects, but third/tenth in everything else.

Testina · 06/07/2022 08:56

“Obviously I can’t be 100% sure that DD was the only one without one“

Well that’s fairly important

I wouldn’t even be posting this. You’re a paying customer - why haven’t you spoken to the school? If she was literally the only child without a certificate, I think there’s an admin fuck up that you should raise. If they’ve set it up so that a really small minority don’t get something, I’d challenge that.

If it’s awards based on hard facts (e.g. everyone over 90% in exam gets maths) and that overall leaves only a few kids without - then it’s not wrong, but you need to think about why you’ve chosen a very academic and very competitive school. If it’s more subjective, then leaving a small number out is wrong.

knockyknees · 06/07/2022 08:47

A similar thing happened at one of my kids' awards day. Thankfully not to one of my DC, but to two of their friends, who I knew well. They were/are lovely, kind, children and my heart absolutely broke for them. It must have been humiliating for them.

The new-to-the-school principal decided to mess with the long standing method whereby only the recipients were called on stage, to one where every class stood on stage and the recipients were called forward to received their award. This worked reasonably well in 99% of the classes where only about 50% received something (but still awkward for the remaining 50%).

The worst part was, apparently they were supposed to get an award each, but at literally the very last minute the new principal decided not to present them for some convoluted reason. Their class teacher (a lovely, very 'motherly' woman) only found out herself moments before this debacle, and was seen standing off to the side in tears. Needless to say, hell was raised and the old system was reinstasted the following year.

This was over 15 years ago and I can still remebmer it clear as day, and the disbelief and sadness I felt for these two children.

00100001 · 05/07/2022 06:52

woulducouldushouldu · 04/07/2022 20:42

IMO Kids who get prizes either come top in the year or they (or their parents) suck up to senior staff.

For years I sat through these (incl ones where my kids got prizes). At one the girl who had basically been a deranged bully for years got "best influence on the lower school" prize. I got up from my seat mid prize giving and left. Was Ana abolîtes joke. She only got bec her parents were se far up the heads arse she had 4 legs and the girl (year 8) only played with the year 3s because no one in her year would have anything to do with her. Never been to another prize giving again

But maybe she WAS a good influence on them and needed some sort of recognition for her good behaviour/attitude as part of her behaviour management plan?

Most kids that are bullies have some sort of shit going on in their lives.

To begrudge a 13yo a relatively meaningless school prize that might have just helped tip her behaviour to that if the better and boycott the ceremony seems a little over the top...

Nahnanananahna · 05/07/2022 06:41

Our school has a resilience through adversity award that I suspect your daughter might have gotten if she went to our school (although it's one for all of secondary not one per year). I agree this is terrible and I would be complaining. The majority of people don't get an award at all.

Pleaseletmeconfirm · 04/07/2022 21:28

I find kids are fairly accepting of awards going to the top academic and top sporting/singing/chess or whatever students but that they are not accepting of unfairness or favouritism.

faffadoodledo · 04/07/2022 21:27

That's rubbish, OP. Your DD lost her dad this year. And sat there while aware after award was dished out. Have a word with her head of year (or her new one for Y8).

Jackiebrambles · 04/07/2022 21:16

Hmmm I'd probably say something, this would really have upset me especially since she lost her dad this year. You'd think they'd want to mark her resilience in doing well despite such a difficult time. Flowers for you both.

Swipe left for the next trending thread