Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder if BAME people care more than others about women’s rights?

294 replies

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 04/07/2022 18:09

Do BAME people care more about women’s rights?

Today I read about attorney general Suella Braverman opposing the SNP’s plan to
speed up gender self-ID. By allowing anyone to claim to be the other sex, self-ID would of course give every man (trans or not, sex predator or not) access to all women’s services and spaces.

Yesterday, it was the equalities minister Kemi Badenoch stating that all new public
buildings must have single-sex toilets.

Health secretary Sajid Javid has told the NHS to stop replacing words that have a female meaning (such as ‘woman’) with expressions such as ‘person with a uterus’. The NHS and many large organisations have been doing this to avoid offending trans people. But it is baffling to many people, who then risk missing vital health information.

Dame Kelly Holmes supports the Fair Play for Women campaign to stop males competing in women’s sports, despite transactivists’ aggression.

And so many heroic resisters have been fighting legal battles: Allison Bailey, Keira
Bell, Raquel Rosario Sanchez, Shahrar Ali …

And it’s not only the fight to keep women’s single-sex rights. Sajid Javid has also
refused to shut up about grooming gangs, despite being (unfairly) accused of racism.

Those are just the few I can think of on the spur of the moment. I know there are
many more.

Of course there are many other, non-BAME feminists and allies fighting against the
withdrawal of women’s rights and protections. But the percentage who are BAME seems very noticeable.

Any ideas why?

OP posts:
ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 05/07/2022 10:57

psydrive · 05/07/2022 09:06

I believe OP was referring to people in the UK.

Thanks, psydrive, yes I was musing about events I’d just read about in UK news. But these two comments add another interesting layer: the effect of being brought up in a minority culture. Are values likely to take deeper root than in people whose culture is the unquestioned majority?

And of course we’re talking likelihood, tendencies etc, as no group of people is one mass of identical clones.

OP posts:
loopyfruit · 05/07/2022 10:55

So white women care less about women's rights. What bollocks are you basing that on? Why are trying to competitively measure how much people 'care' - what does that even mean, 'caring' about something, such a genderist nurturing woman stereotype word anyway - in correlation with race/colour/ethnicity anyway, what the fuck does that achieve for women's rights?

NippyWoowoo · 05/07/2022 10:47

Palmfrond · 04/07/2022 23:08

OP gets a medal for trolliest post of the day 🏅

🏆 🥇🎗

Palmfrond · 05/07/2022 10:44

rocksonrocks · 05/07/2022 10:24

What a ridiculous comment.

The primacy of the B is pretty much inherent in the acronym; otherwise why wouldn’t it just ME? It’s an inherently hierarchical term. And exclusionary.

In my opinion transectionalism is the worst thing to ever have happened to the Left.
Almost as if it were concocted to divide resistance to the primacy of the military/industrial/financial complex.

If you don’t believe me, have a look at this very thread, where Tory stool pigeons of colour, who are happy for poor kids to go to failing schools on empty stomachs, and for British bombs to rain down on Yemeni women & girls, are lauded for pretending to give shit about who uses poor people’s changing rooms.

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 05/07/2022 10:29

Covidagainandagain · 04/07/2022 22:07

Oh yes I'm not denying its cropping up more, sorry if my post wasn't clear. Just that originally its more american, and as I say it doesn't track so well in the UK so I think could become problematic when some racist people latch onto the indigenous part

I've been hearing it for about 3-5 years but specifically until recently from American women I follow on social media

Looking this up online, I found that Zamila Bunglawala at the Cabinet Office’s Race Disparity Unit, recommends “ethnic minority” rather than BAME or BME
civilservice.blog.gov.uk/2019/07/08/please-dont-call-me-bame-or-bme/

That’s the term I remember from long ago, but presumably it was changed for a reason?

OP posts:
rocksonrocks · 05/07/2022 10:24

TruthHertz · 04/07/2022 21:57

It often seems to me that the B usurps the ME. You never hear people say brown lives matter.

What a ridiculous comment.

5128gap · 05/07/2022 10:01

StepAwayFromGoogling · 04/07/2022 19:32

Of course it fucking reflects on me! Are we OK to say 'white women... insert insulting generalisation here'? - Would it be equally OK to say 'black women... insert insulting generalisation here'? I'm a white woman. If someone makes a generalisation about white women of course it reflects on me.

Bit of an overreaction there.
And if course it doesn't reflect on you. Your personal level of care for women's rights should be evident from your attitudes and behaviour. The fact that you're part of a group that may or may not care more or less than another group is irrelevant. Not sure why it's so important to you to be part of the group that 'cares the most' either. Just do your bit. Its not a competition.

psydrive · 05/07/2022 09:06

kewgirl · 05/07/2022 08:56

What???????????????????????????????????????
Misogyny is rife in african and asian countries

I believe OP was referring to people in the UK.

everythingssogrey · 05/07/2022 09:03

kewgirl · 05/07/2022 08:56

What???????????????????????????????????????
Misogyny is rife in african and asian countries

Yes but in those countries they are not black and MINORITY ethnic, as they are in countries with a native population who are white.

everythingssogrey · 05/07/2022 09:03

phishy · 04/07/2022 19:18

Why would the race card be used against women’s issues?

One of the common responses to raising these issues is to bring up 'transwomen of colour' and say that the person is racist by association because their concerns have a negative impact on black women specifically.

kewgirl · 05/07/2022 08:56

What???????????????????????????????????????
Misogyny is rife in african and asian countries

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 05/07/2022 08:32

sst1234 · 05/07/2022 07:19

I think it’s because, contrary told popular belief, BAME communities largely hold conservative views. It’s actually an indictment of where society has landed that a woman being a woman is a now conservative view, rather a mainstream scientific fact.

a woman being a woman is a now conservative view — yes, weird or what! And people who call themselves left wing support the most anti-socialist me-me-me ideology, the gender identity movement. Strange days indeed.

You’ve raised something I was wondering about, regarding values that are currently out of fashion in white mainstream Britain. Things that (as it turns out) protected women and children to some extent, eg making it unthinkable that men would intrude in women’s spaces. Like common decency, which sounds silly now, but meant that men who wanted to live out their sex fantasies had to do it at home or in a private like-minded group. Or ‘the common good’, which meant individualist demands didn’t override the welfare of the community.

Does growing up in a conservative, traditional culture instil those values, to the extent that adults can fearlessly contradict a currently enforced ideology? And/ or how much does a religious background play a role?

Something gave Suella Braverman, Kemi Badenoch, Sajid Javid etc the guts to speak up where so many don’t dare.

I love and admire the feminists and allies of all backgrounds who stand up for women’s rights. But it gives me a moment of extra joy to see tough, competent BAME women in power.

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 05/07/2022 08:28

Its not just about knowing that rights are important. Its about knowing why they are important and how they work in practice.

I would hazard a guess that ethnic minorities understand that its not as simple as making a proclamation and saying everyone should believe this.

Its also about the unintended consequences and side effects to others which those virtue signalling dont always get, because they don't think and haven't the life experience to refer to.

LovingLiver · 05/07/2022 08:21

I work for a University. IME, BAME students and staff are mostly EDI and student union influenced. It's generally intersectional, rans embracing and pro gender ideology. This is especially noticeable with young traditional Muslim women who wear the Hijab and are strictly religious. They have to align themselves with this trend ideology to benefit from the inclusivity policies, if they don't they're out on their own Sad.

Sosiej · 05/07/2022 08:15

VladmirsPoutine · 05/07/2022 06:39

The UK has a massive race problem. PP is right though - some of the most insidious racism is perpetrated from other minorities to other minorities they deem 'lesser' than.

Yep, this is another reason why the teen BAME is stupid because even between groups of black and brown people there is racism and colourism. It's not a united group.

Rinatinabina · 05/07/2022 07:58

I think a lot of those people probably had to develop a very thick skin being minorities and in the public eye and perhaps what it took to get there. So sticking your head above the parapet is maybe just like “meh, may as well”.

Also a lot of women from minority groups have to deal with outright in your face misogyny from a young age from their own communities. Makes your pretty fucking angry, while white people are talking about the pay gap many asian girls are being told they are held to higher standard and control (variations on don’t be a whore) than their brothers while simultaneously being less valuable. Obviously this has changed a lot in recent decades.

I’m not convinced that theres a clearcut white VS BAME divide here. Some of my cousins are WOKE, but they are young and haven’t fully understood all the ways the world will shit on you as a woman and then tell you you need to “be kind” (yet). I think it’s more of a class/location thing tbh. Everyone knows what a woman is, but there are people who need to maintain the fiction to maintain their self image. My cousins basically went to very good unis (oxbridge type of thing) very much london based, young etc etc.

Also there is nothing more patronising than thinking that ethnic minorities owe you their intellectual loyalty. I assure you most are perfectly capable of thinking for themselves. I remember the advert during Corbyn’s campaign promising that only he could unleash the potential of us dumbasses, thank you great white saviour. I imagine many a doctor/lawyer/cabinet minister/teacher etc rolled their eyes at that one. You may not agree with them and think they are misguided but to go “oh but how could you!!! You are NIGERIAN” is just as othering as the far right imo. Also if someone 3/4 white why can’t they identify as white. If they were 3/4 black would you be as bewildered if they identified as black? That one drop rule eh.

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 05/07/2022 07:56

VladmirsPoutine · 05/07/2022 07:37

@ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus I would say that the black women who say twaw and support trans rights are doing so because they recognise the narrow framework within which a 'woman' is defined. Historically black women have been treated abysmally, experimented on and so forth. A lot of the 'strong black woman' trope rests heavily on the idea that black women can tolerate pain (physical and emotional) in a way which white women haven't really been depicted. White women in that sense are the epitome of femininity. So many black women are acutely aware that they too can find themselves next in the cross hares of those that seek to gate keep womanhood.

Vladimirs, the narrow framework within which a 'woman' is defined is biological fact.

Transactivists frequently claim that “transwomen are women just as black women are women”. The eye-boggling racism of that statement seems to elude them. Black women are women (obviously) just as white women, old women, French women etc are women.

So many black women are acutely aware that they too can find themselves next in the cross hares of those that seek to gate keep womanhood. I’d be very surprised if any woman thought that.

You are trying to link racism with women’s fight to keep single-sex spaces. There is no link. Women’s spaces are for everyone who was born female.

OP posts:
WhatNoRaisins · 05/07/2022 07:41

I think some cultures have more clearly defined different roles for the sexes and coming from that sort of background I'd expect it to be harder to be convinced that toilets and changing rooms should suddenly become mixed sex for example.

It is possible think women shouldn't have as many rights while seeing them as a distinct sex based class. It's also possible to believe in rights like abortion and equal pay while having a much more fuzzy definition of woman.

If there is any racial breakdown with regards to these views I think it makes sense to separate women's rights and sex segregation in order to get a more nuanced picture

VladmirsPoutine · 05/07/2022 07:37

@ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus I would say that the black women who say twaw and support trans rights are doing so because they recognise the narrow framework within which a 'woman' is defined. Historically black women have been treated abysmally, experimented on and so forth. A lot of the 'strong black woman' trope rests heavily on the idea that black women can tolerate pain (physical and emotional) in a way which white women haven't really been depicted. White women in that sense are the epitome of femininity. So many black women are acutely aware that they too can find themselves next in the cross hares of those that seek to gate keep womanhood.

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 05/07/2022 07:31

EdgeOfACoin · 05/07/2022 07:02

In my personal experience, the women I know who are most on board with pronouns, 'twaw' etc are black.

One woman is part of the Diversity team at work and is very careful to talk about 'cis' people and 'women and those with a female reproductive system'. I have no doubt that she would describe herself as a feminist.

I know my experience is not at all universal, but in the case of the women I know, there really does seem to be an assumption that the TRA movement is just the next step in civil rights.

Depressing, Edge. in the case of the women I know, there really does seem to be an assumption that the TRA movement is just the next step in civil rights.

So strange, when a moment’s thought reveals the huge conflict with women’s rights. Maybe we are still conditioned to put ourselves last.

I wonder if the Diversity woman knows it’s bollox but has put in a lot of work to get where she is, overcoming racism as well as sexism, and is making damn sure she doesn’t step out of line? That’s understandable.

OP posts:
sst1234 · 05/07/2022 07:19

I think it’s because, contrary told popular belief, BAME communities largely hold conservative views. It’s actually an indictment of where society has landed that a woman being a woman is a now conservative view, rather a mainstream scientific fact.

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 05/07/2022 07:11

loopyfruit · 04/07/2022 22:31

Hmm. So you're mentioning professions, like attorney general and equalities minister. Of course I would expect an equalities minister and hopefully all women in high up professional roles to care about women's rights, no matter their identity. Surely that's the correlating factor

No, that’s the thing, Loopyfruit. A shocking number of women in high positions have prioritised the gender-identity movement’s wishes above women’s needs.

Maria Miller, as minister for women and equalities, planned to ‘reform’ the Gender Recognition Act 2004 by making it very much quicker and easier for people to change their gender: therefore, for men to gain access to all women’s single-sex rights and spaces.

She said there is no threat to single-sex services, they are clearly protected in law. But as minister, she must have known that the Equality Act 2010 only gives the right (not the duty) to ringfence single-sex services.

None of the female candidates for Labour leader in 2020 supported the struggle to retain single-sex services, and two of them actually signed a pledge to organise and fight against transphobic organisations such as Woman’s Place UK, LGB Alliance and other trans-exclusionist hate groups. Yes, defending women’s rights makes you a “hate group”.

I don’t know of any leading female Labour politician who doesn’t toe the gender-identity line. And the Labour Party, and all the other main parties except the Tories, Communist Party and SDP, are committed to extending trans rights at the expense of women’s rights.

So, amazingly, very little solidarity among women in positions of power,

OP posts:
AchatAVendre · 05/07/2022 07:09

Ugh. I find this measuring of the tone of peoples' skin in terms of how dark it is so as to whether you can fit into a minority or not quite distasteful. Which parent has a mixed race person taken after the most? Some Americans do consider anyone who isn't WASP non-white, and they include Italian, Spanish, etc people in that because thats the history of Hispanic people emigrating from South America/Mexico into the US. Its creating boundaries where there should be none because of a particular country's history/culture.

EdgeOfACoin · 05/07/2022 07:02

In my personal experience, the women I know who are most on board with pronouns, 'twaw' etc are black.

One woman is part of the Diversity team at work and is very careful to talk about 'cis' people and 'women and those with a female reproductive system'. I have no doubt that she would describe herself as a feminist.

I know my experience is not at all universal, but in the case of the women I know, there really does seem to be an assumption that the TRA movement is just the next step in civil rights.

VladmirsPoutine · 05/07/2022 06:39

The UK has a massive race problem. PP is right though - some of the most insidious racism is perpetrated from other minorities to other minorities they deem 'lesser' than.

Swipe left for the next trending thread