Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder if BAME people care more than others about women’s rights?

294 replies

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 04/07/2022 18:09

Do BAME people care more about women’s rights?

Today I read about attorney general Suella Braverman opposing the SNP’s plan to
speed up gender self-ID. By allowing anyone to claim to be the other sex, self-ID would of course give every man (trans or not, sex predator or not) access to all women’s services and spaces.

Yesterday, it was the equalities minister Kemi Badenoch stating that all new public
buildings must have single-sex toilets.

Health secretary Sajid Javid has told the NHS to stop replacing words that have a female meaning (such as ‘woman’) with expressions such as ‘person with a uterus’. The NHS and many large organisations have been doing this to avoid offending trans people. But it is baffling to many people, who then risk missing vital health information.

Dame Kelly Holmes supports the Fair Play for Women campaign to stop males competing in women’s sports, despite transactivists’ aggression.

And so many heroic resisters have been fighting legal battles: Allison Bailey, Keira
Bell, Raquel Rosario Sanchez, Shahrar Ali …

And it’s not only the fight to keep women’s single-sex rights. Sajid Javid has also
refused to shut up about grooming gangs, despite being (unfairly) accused of racism.

Those are just the few I can think of on the spur of the moment. I know there are
many more.

Of course there are many other, non-BAME feminists and allies fighting against the
withdrawal of women’s rights and protections. But the percentage who are BAME seems very noticeable.

Any ideas why?

OP posts:
Sosiej · 05/07/2022 19:09

You're offended at somebody describing black people positively. I didn't say white suprematist, that's from your mouth. I just think you're a one of those who don't like to hear about black people complaining because you feel left out.

VladmirsPoutine · 05/07/2022 19:09

SummerPuddings · 05/07/2022 19:03

To be replaced with....?

To be replaced with more specific terminology. Inter-minority racism is so vehemently pervasive. My aunts used to joke how they'd hope the person at immigration control when going through UK arrivals was white because if not it was gonna be a long night. But even recently one of the police officers who'd apparently been sending racist messages in a whatsApp group was South Asian. I really don't bother with 'BAME' networks tbh. I consciously choose to use my resources to support black girls.

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 05/07/2022 19:08

We just still know what a wrongun is. We don't have pomo discussions about when is a nonce a nonce.

Palmfrond · 05/07/2022 19:05

Sosiej · 05/07/2022 19:00

I’ve no idea what colour voice that poster has, but they are claiming to speak for the entire black population of planet earth, which is preposterous.

And you're not even black. Who said you get to be offended on my behalf? Away you go.

lol, you know nothing about me, but if you must rush to the defence of a supremacist nutter that is your right.

Covidagainandagain · 05/07/2022 19:05

Palmfrond · 05/07/2022 18:42

I’ve no idea what colour voice that poster has, but they are claiming to speak for the entire black population of planet earth, which is preposterous.

I mean they pretty much imply they are black by saying 'we'

And if black people aren't allowed to speak for black people without being told to get back in their box then thats pretty fucked up

SummerPuddings · 05/07/2022 19:03

LynneBenfield · 04/07/2022 19:29

I thought “BAME” as a term had been done away with?

To be replaced with....?

Sosiej · 05/07/2022 19:00

I’ve no idea what colour voice that poster has, but they are claiming to speak for the entire black population of planet earth, which is preposterous.

And you're not even black. Who said you get to be offended on my behalf? Away you go.

Palmfrond · 05/07/2022 18:42

Covidagainandagain · 05/07/2022 18:33

Ahh yes putting black voices back in 'their box', excellent move there 🙄

I’ve no idea what colour voice that poster has, but they are claiming to speak for the entire black population of planet earth, which is preposterous.

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 05/07/2022 18:37

MangyInseam · 05/07/2022 17:45

FWIW, I think you would have to be more specific than "BAME".

But if you broke people down into different communities I do think you would find differences in terms of political opinions around women's rights. That would likely show a variety of different things around activism, what they think women's rights means, and so on.

But if we are talking about the kind of women's rights issues that center around the effects of identity politics, I think that non-white women may be more likely to feel comfortable questioning, or at least like they can, question that paradigm openly. We've all seen how women who have the wrong opinions get accused of being homophobes, racists, anti-Semites, etc.

Kind of like if you look, in the US, at the people who are on the forefront of questioning identity politics, a lot of them are black. It's not, I think, that black Americans are so much less likely to like id pol (though maybe somewhat that's so) but they may be less scared of being called bigots or challenged in their jobs. Even if they do get name called there is an obvious contradiction that may make them more inclined to speak out because it is so maddening. When you look at university faculty active in this area and you can see the ones who are black seem to have some protection compared to those who aren't.

That’s interesting about black resistance to identity politics in the USA, MangyInseam. I haven’t followed US events so much — though I do remember it was a black woman who challenged the exhibitionist at the Wi Spa in California (and got slagged off for it by staff and by the press there and here).

Oh and of course the scandal of males identifying as transgender and winning women’s sports must be serious at a real grass-roots level in the USA, because people can get to university on sports scholarships. I’ve just realised that probably affects more black students than other groups.

OP posts:
Palmfrond · 05/07/2022 18:36

Nolongerteaching · 05/07/2022 18:31

@Palmfrond

i think Irish travellers are recognised as a separate ethnic group now. Still Irish but distinct from the main populace. Must be the same for Roma and Romany, no?

Show people I don’t know about but I think they consider themselves part of the travelling community.

This man always impresses me with his clarity

www.londongypsiesandtravellers.org.uk/story/from-the-fairground-to-university/

I’m not disagreeing with you, just pointing out that, according to the Mayor’s office, they are not BAME.
Thanks for the link.

Covidagainandagain · 05/07/2022 18:33

Palmfrond · 05/07/2022 18:14

Back in you box now please, Edward!

Ahh yes putting black voices back in 'their box', excellent move there 🙄

Nolongerteaching · 05/07/2022 18:31

@Palmfrond

i think Irish travellers are recognised as a separate ethnic group now. Still Irish but distinct from the main populace. Must be the same for Roma and Romany, no?

Show people I don’t know about but I think they consider themselves part of the travelling community.

This man always impresses me with his clarity

www.londongypsiesandtravellers.org.uk/story/from-the-fairground-to-university/

Palmfrond · 05/07/2022 18:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

EddyF · 05/07/2022 18:17

What box is that? I doubt you would have much chest in real life. Back to your sad little box.

Palmfrond · 05/07/2022 18:14

EddyF · 05/07/2022 18:11

It is because BLACK people globally lead in the fight for racial equality. We (they) are not scared to use their voices for causes they believe in. I have yet to meet a Black person who is concerned about being a ‘model minority’. They will call you out every single time. They literally have no time for you.

Back in you box now please, Edward!

EddyF · 05/07/2022 18:11

TruthHertz · 04/07/2022 21:57

It often seems to me that the B usurps the ME. You never hear people say brown lives matter.

It is because BLACK people globally lead in the fight for racial equality. We (they) are not scared to use their voices for causes they believe in. I have yet to meet a Black person who is concerned about being a ‘model minority’. They will call you out every single time. They literally have no time for you.

Palmfrond · 05/07/2022 18:01

Nolongerteaching · 05/07/2022 17:25

@Palmfrond

I dont know if the Roma community would agree.

Originally, certainly in my part of London BAME was Black and minority ethnic which included Irish, Jewish, etc communities

It has become defined now as something different but I think it originally replaced a broad term for anyone who wasn’t white ethnically English

www.london.gov.uk/questions/2018/0064

The mayor’s office’s definition in 2018.

If you read it carefully you’ll see the utterly insulting implication that Gypsies, for example, are merely a “nationality or affiliation”.

Just imagining the officious pencildick who draughted it makes my piss boil.

apintortwo · 05/07/2022 18:00

When you look at university faculty active in this area and you can see the ones who are black seem to have some protection compared to those who aren't

And do you think that this drives equality? Is it fair that some people have this priviledge and implicit protection? And I'm talking about 2022, not the 17th century

VladmirsPoutine · 05/07/2022 17:59

Honestly, this just sounds creepy to me. Black people are people, you know. Human beings. Not 'otherworldly creatures' to be gazed at and spoken of as if somehow different and amazing for being black.

What a bizarre response to what I said.

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 05/07/2022 17:57

beastlyslumber · 05/07/2022 17:40

Mom, as I said at 15.13

So is this supposed to be an insult - calling me 'mom'? Is it like calling me a Karen? Sounds misogynistic to me. What's wrong with being a mother? This is mumsnet!

I like to see women of any ethnicity in power, as we are still far less powerful than men

I don't totally agree with this statement. Women have equal opportunities in the UK, although in some areas it is certainly more difficult for us to achieve - often because of the demands of motherhood. A female prime minister doesn't have less power than a male prime minister, even though it might be harder for her to get there. I also think it's a bad idea to promote women to power simply on the basis that they are female. Theresa May springs to mind as a woman I probably wouldn't cheer for.

”Mom, as I said at 15.13” - So is this supposed to be an insult - calling me 'mom'? Is it like calling me a Karen? Sounds misogynistic to me. What's wrong with being a mother? This is mumsnet!

Bloody autocorrect! Autobuggerup, more like. Sorry I didn’t notice that, Beastly. I typed Mmm to mean Yes. I’d never call anyone a Karen as it’s a horrible sexist ageist insult. But Mmm/ Mom is rather funny…

OP posts:
apintortwo · 05/07/2022 17:56

I doubt very much she wants to be tokenised and fetishised for her race

This is probably an accurate way to put it. Tokenisation and fetishisation of people

GoodThinkingMax · 05/07/2022 17:52

Any ideas why?

YABU. I give you the single name that destroys your hypothesis: Prut Patel.

Illiberal to the extreme.

apintortwo · 05/07/2022 17:51

I'm sure for others it's different but for me personally seeing a successful and competent Black woman just inspires something within me that no other 'person' would

Of course this is the case, as you would be identifying with the person in question. Others would feell inherent attachment to people who are similar to them. There's nothing wrong with that.

The problem is when role models are forced on others as if this feeling of admiration for someone was compulsory and there has to be something wrong with you if you don't hail xyz - as the OP is trying to do

MangyInseam · 05/07/2022 17:45

FWIW, I think you would have to be more specific than "BAME".

But if you broke people down into different communities I do think you would find differences in terms of political opinions around women's rights. That would likely show a variety of different things around activism, what they think women's rights means, and so on.

But if we are talking about the kind of women's rights issues that center around the effects of identity politics, I think that non-white women may be more likely to feel comfortable questioning, or at least like they can, question that paradigm openly. We've all seen how women who have the wrong opinions get accused of being homophobes, racists, anti-Semites, etc.

Kind of like if you look, in the US, at the people who are on the forefront of questioning identity politics, a lot of them are black. It's not, I think, that black Americans are so much less likely to like id pol (though maybe somewhat that's so) but they may be less scared of being called bigots or challenged in their jobs. Even if they do get name called there is an obvious contradiction that may make them more inclined to speak out because it is so maddening. When you look at university faculty active in this area and you can see the ones who are black seem to have some protection compared to those who aren't.

beastlyslumber · 05/07/2022 17:44

VladmirsPoutine · 05/07/2022 17:39

I really don't see how this can be a controversial statement at all. I'm sure for others it's different but for me personally seeing a successful and competent Black woman just inspires something within me that no other 'person' would. I'm sure for others seeing a successful xyz means a lot to them. I honestly think people like Serena Williams are nothing short of exceptional. I remember as a kid seeing a Black news presenter and of course I didn't know she was a news reader or a journalist or whatever but my mum still talks about how I approached the TV screen and just stared at the news reader as though she was other worldly.

Honestly, this just sounds creepy to me. Black people are people, you know. Human beings. Not 'otherworldly creatures' to be gazed at and spoken of as if somehow different and amazing for being black.

Serena Williams is awe-inspiring because she is an incredible athlete, with all that entails. I doubt very much she wants to be tokenised and fetishised for her race, after how hard she's worked to achieve her amazing success.