Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder if BAME people care more than others about women’s rights?

294 replies

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 04/07/2022 18:09

Do BAME people care more about women’s rights?

Today I read about attorney general Suella Braverman opposing the SNP’s plan to
speed up gender self-ID. By allowing anyone to claim to be the other sex, self-ID would of course give every man (trans or not, sex predator or not) access to all women’s services and spaces.

Yesterday, it was the equalities minister Kemi Badenoch stating that all new public
buildings must have single-sex toilets.

Health secretary Sajid Javid has told the NHS to stop replacing words that have a female meaning (such as ‘woman’) with expressions such as ‘person with a uterus’. The NHS and many large organisations have been doing this to avoid offending trans people. But it is baffling to many people, who then risk missing vital health information.

Dame Kelly Holmes supports the Fair Play for Women campaign to stop males competing in women’s sports, despite transactivists’ aggression.

And so many heroic resisters have been fighting legal battles: Allison Bailey, Keira
Bell, Raquel Rosario Sanchez, Shahrar Ali …

And it’s not only the fight to keep women’s single-sex rights. Sajid Javid has also
refused to shut up about grooming gangs, despite being (unfairly) accused of racism.

Those are just the few I can think of on the spur of the moment. I know there are
many more.

Of course there are many other, non-BAME feminists and allies fighting against the
withdrawal of women’s rights and protections. But the percentage who are BAME seems very noticeable.

Any ideas why?

OP posts:
beastlyslumber · 19/07/2022 20:53

Kendodd · 19/07/2022 20:45

You make it sound like a deliberate policy, why would that happen though?

That was the impression I got from the discussion, but I can't remember the specifics of what was said. If I remember who Coleman was talking to, I'll find a link for you.

beastlyslumber · 19/07/2022 20:52

You say 'the slave trade' Vlad as if there was only one! Obviously the Atlantic Slave Trade was a horrible abomination. But in the west, we abolished the slave trade and eventually made racism illegal, too. There are countries in the world which still now have flourishing slave trades, I'm sad to say. I'm proud to live in a country where slavery has been abolished.

TruthHertz · 19/07/2022 20:51

FWIW, the worst racism by far that I've heard in recent years has been from my Sikh workmates towards Pakistanis (I work for a Sikh company) and also from the Muslim guy I used to meet up to spar with when I kickboxed (always slating Indians).

I also have a Thai acquaintance who I've known for years and know a Latvian women who straight up say they don't like Indians or black people. The former also hates the Chinese and always says she wishes she could ban them from her restaurant because they're stingy.

This idea of white people being more racist than other ethnicities just isn't true IME. Although I also believe that in our society people are very aware of what they can and can't say, and I've no doubt that many people would air pretty bigoted opinions in the right company.

VladmirsPoutine · 19/07/2022 20:51

@Kendodd You're right about that but seeing how ingrained these mindsets are always annoys me especially when I made a deal with myself to never talk to white people about race again as it's akin to banging your head against a wall and then wondering why your head is bleeding. But you are right - that kinda rhetoric doesn't help when there are some out there who would be willing to listen.

VladmirsPoutine · 19/07/2022 20:46

I think it's fair to say that western culture has done better than most others so far in bringing about fairness, justice and equality for women and minorities.

@beastlyslumber I agree! The slave trade and colonisation was really just about 'helping' out those ethnics who'd have otherwise been lost without the west. The white slave owners who raped their slaves and the white women who used their black female slaves as 'nursing maids' were merely just teaching theory in a practical way. I'm from a place where tea is actually grown but oddly enough it's not Yorkshire. I've been to Yorkshire and haven't seen a tea plantation ever. What I have seen though are my parents fighting for reparations for their grandparents' stolen land which some white guy once thought looked pretty good. Thank goodness for the west. My ancestors would have been lost without them setting fire to their land then chaining them up to make them slaves.

Kendodd · 19/07/2022 20:45

beastlyslumber · 19/07/2022 20:28

There was an interesting discussion I heard on a podcast (think it was Coleman Hughes') which was examining the claim that it was increased welfare payments that broke up black families in the US - that there was a government policy of encouraging single parent (mother) families precisely for this reason. I think this is a claim made by Thomas Sowell, who is very interesting indeed on economics and black history in the states.

You make it sound like a deliberate policy, why would that happen though?

Spinfit · 19/07/2022 20:41

I think this might be more to do with cultural ideas around homosexuality and transgender men/women. There is a lot of discrimination still ongoing in many parts of Asia and Africa. Homosexuality is still illegal where I'm originally from (although the police do not enforce it thankfully and people are allowed to live as they wish).

TruthHertz · 19/07/2022 20:34

Imagine a country in which 3 people all have £100 billion in wealth and everyone else has a tin of beans and 4 pence. You'd be the type to champion the fact that the country is in fact one of the richest on earth.

Well, yeah, I agree with this. When women (usually white and mc) start talking about male CEOs I'm always sceptical about this as a barometer of men's privilege - I mean, what % of men are even CEO? But that's class analysis for you. It doesn't look at the breakdown of the group.

I've heard all the soundbites before about privilege but at the end of the day the colour of someone's skin is the last thing I want to focus on when meeting and assessing an individual.

Some demographics still absolutely benefit from the atrocities committed by their forebears but I'm still pretty hmmm about inherited culpability. For instance, I hear so many women say they don't care about male issues because 'they've reigned supreme for so long'. But the individuals we're talking about today aren't the same individuals from the history books.

I don't think all this woke stuff, cancelling, blaming, etc, actually helps anyone. I'm also not convinced it even comes from good intentions for the most part. People don't speak like this in real life and most of this shit would die overnight if the internet spontaneously collapsed. The people who give their time to help others in real life would still be doing that, but for the most part these aren't the same people calling out everyone on twitter and trying for a podium in the oppression olympics.

beastlyslumber · 19/07/2022 20:32

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 19/07/2022 19:54

In fact, I'd say that the further we get from western influence the closer we get to barbaric practices.

Fucking wow. You'd better get back to the gentle and civilised practice of colonisation and teach the world how to be less barbaric.

I think it's fair to say that western culture has done better than most others so far in bringing about fairness, justice and equality for women and minorities.

beastlyslumber · 19/07/2022 20:28

There was an interesting discussion I heard on a podcast (think it was Coleman Hughes') which was examining the claim that it was increased welfare payments that broke up black families in the US - that there was a government policy of encouraging single parent (mother) families precisely for this reason. I think this is a claim made by Thomas Sowell, who is very interesting indeed on economics and black history in the states.

MangyInseam · 19/07/2022 20:28

Kendodd · 19/07/2022 20:18

With regard this -

And the disproportionately high number of black guys who abandon their wife and kids doesn't really help paint a picture of respect.

Let's assume for a minute it's true. Another thing I heard on radio 4 is that this is a legacy of slavery. During the African slave trade, slave owners would basically 'breed' children from slaves (please excuse the awful language) the mother/father/child relationship was smashed to pieces. This went on for generations and became an ingrained pattern of men having little involvement or responsibility for any children. Apparently this pattern is not so prevalent in Africa and is much more pronounced within communities that descend from victims of slavery.

I say all this without actually checking the numbers though and am just repeating what I've heard.

At the risk of attack from VladmirsPoutine I don't disagree with the comments about misogyny in rap or in India. I have a friend (not British or white) who lived in India for five years and who talked about how terrible her time was there married to an Indian man. She was beaten regularly by her husband, and his mother, went to the police who called her husband to collect her and told him to keep his wife under better control!

No, it isn't the legacy of the slave trade. There were actually more intact families when slavery was still legal in the US than there are now among black families in the US, and after slavery the proportion rose significantly. Up until the 1960s it was generally fairly close to while families and was much higher than it is now. It was only in the 60s that the number of intact families dropped like a stone, they did in the white community as well but not to the same degree. But the black community went from most kids being raised in two parent homes in the 50s to most being raised by single mums by, iirc, 1970.

MangyInseam · 19/07/2022 20:23

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 19/07/2022 19:54

In fact, I'd say that the further we get from western influence the closer we get to barbaric practices.

Fucking wow. You'd better get back to the gentle and civilised practice of colonisation and teach the world how to be less barbaric.

It doesn't make the point untrue though. How many women posting here would prefer to exchange their legal and social situation as a member of a western democracy with the legal and social status of a woman in some other place?

There are qualifications we could make around particular places but do you really think many women would make that exchange, and move to say, China, the UAE, India, maybe even a place like Japan? And if not, what's that about, if there are really no significant cultural differences?

Kendodd · 19/07/2022 20:22

@VladmirsPoutine

Can you please not do stuff like this -

I would love it now if you said something like 'W€lL AcTYeWaLLy My HuZbAnd iZ bLaCk & I'm a QuArTa 1nDIan and a QuArTa Bl@CK'

I want to listen to you and stuff like that is just distracting.

Kendodd · 19/07/2022 20:18

With regard this -

And the disproportionately high number of black guys who abandon their wife and kids doesn't really help paint a picture of respect.

Let's assume for a minute it's true. Another thing I heard on radio 4 is that this is a legacy of slavery. During the African slave trade, slave owners would basically 'breed' children from slaves (please excuse the awful language) the mother/father/child relationship was smashed to pieces. This went on for generations and became an ingrained pattern of men having little involvement or responsibility for any children. Apparently this pattern is not so prevalent in Africa and is much more pronounced within communities that descend from victims of slavery.

I say all this without actually checking the numbers though and am just repeating what I've heard.

At the risk of attack from VladmirsPoutine I don't disagree with the comments about misogyny in rap or in India. I have a friend (not British or white) who lived in India for five years and who talked about how terrible her time was there married to an Indian man. She was beaten regularly by her husband, and his mother, went to the police who called her husband to collect her and told him to keep his wife under better control!

VladmirsPoutine · 19/07/2022 20:03

Whatever. You don't know anything about my ethnicity or background.

I would love it now if you said something like 'W€lL AcTYeWaLLy My HuZbAnd iZ bLaCk & I'm a QuArTa 1nDIan and a QuArTa Bl@CK' Grin

Have you ever stopped to consider why it's 'now' acceptable to despite you calling it "bashing" to discuss inequality and inequity to bring up men and white people? Have you ever picked up a history book?

You make a really good example of something someone once said 'the fight for equity always feels like discrimination to those who've always been privileged.'

Imagine a country in which 3 people all have £100 billion in wealth and everyone else has a tin of beans and 4 pence. You'd be the type to champion the fact that the country is in fact one of the richest on earth.

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 19/07/2022 19:54

In fact, I'd say that the further we get from western influence the closer we get to barbaric practices.

Fucking wow. You'd better get back to the gentle and civilised practice of colonisation and teach the world how to be less barbaric.

TruthHertz · 19/07/2022 19:48

VladmirsPoutine · 19/07/2022 19:21

^Well, sorry you didn't like my points but you only have to listen to the constant reference to 'bitches' and 'ho's' in rap music to ascertain that there's a distinct lack of respect for women there. And the disproportionately high number of black guys who abandon their wife and kids doesn't really help paint a picture of respect. Things like female circumcision, forced
/child marriage, honour killings, etc, are also particularly prevalent in the wider BAME community. I mean have you seen the level of harassment women get in India? It's shocking.^

This comment sums up white feminists so beautifully I don't think I could have done a better job had I tried it to satirise it myself. Smile

This is the wonderful thing - because surely a person who holds these views and feels very confident espousing them as debating points in a discussion about BAME women would never think themselves racist at all. Indeed they are probably progressive, have a black neighbour who they always say good morning to, donate to charities, think critically about tory policies and so forth... (some of them even have black husbands and/or half black kids). The people we have to fear aren't the nazi flag waving, banana throwing people who use the n-word as a matter of course. No - it's the people who will post 'BLM' on their twitter feeds yet still wonder why the government aren't doing more about those 'islamics' and all those dead-beat black fathers. I love it.

Whatever. You don't know anything about my ethnicity or background.

I'm not any less critical of white people than BAME, but I'm a little sick of the double standards tbh. I mean, can you imagine if the thread had suggested that white people care more about women's rights? There'd be an uproar.

The real problem is people who claim to fight prejudice but are every bit as prejudiced as the people they decry. If anything they're even worse as we're not just talking about ignorance or outdated beliefs learned as a child. We're talking about well educated, intelligent people who've managed to rationalise that it's perfectly OK to be a bigot to a certain demographic because 'reasons' .

It's socially acceptable to bash men and white people nowadays but it always changes. Previously it was the Irish, BAME people, etc. In a 100 years it'll be another group. The problem IMO is when you start putting people in boxes and using class analysis to inform your actions on a personal level. Using the actions of other members of a demographic to guide how you treat entirely unrelated individuals that share certain characteristics (sins of the fathers etc).

VladmirsPoutine · 19/07/2022 19:25

In fact, I'd say that the further we get from western influence the closer we get to barbaric practices.

I forgot this part. The whole post was just so perfect I couldn't pick my favourite. These are the daughters of the witches you couldn't burn. These are the Amy Cooper's of our time.

VladmirsPoutine · 19/07/2022 19:21

^Well, sorry you didn't like my points but you only have to listen to the constant reference to 'bitches' and 'ho's' in rap music to ascertain that there's a distinct lack of respect for women there. And the disproportionately high number of black guys who abandon their wife and kids doesn't really help paint a picture of respect. Things like female circumcision, forced
/child marriage, honour killings, etc, are also particularly prevalent in the wider BAME community. I mean have you seen the level of harassment women get in India? It's shocking.^

This comment sums up white feminists so beautifully I don't think I could have done a better job had I tried it to satirise it myself. Smile

This is the wonderful thing - because surely a person who holds these views and feels very confident espousing them as debating points in a discussion about BAME women would never think themselves racist at all. Indeed they are probably progressive, have a black neighbour who they always say good morning to, donate to charities, think critically about tory policies and so forth... (some of them even have black husbands and/or half black kids). The people we have to fear aren't the nazi flag waving, banana throwing people who use the n-word as a matter of course. No - it's the people who will post 'BLM' on their twitter feeds yet still wonder why the government aren't doing more about those 'islamics' and all those dead-beat black fathers. I love it.

TruthHertz · 19/07/2022 19:11

VladmirsPoutine · 18/07/2022 20:38

@Palmfrond You haven't done the research to argue with me. I've been involved in anti-racism work most of my life. I'm actually even of mixed heritage thus have white relatives. One thing I will tell you is that reverse racism doesn't exist. It's not a thing - it's akin to saying vegans have 4 elbows, in other words, bizarre and nonsensical. Class play a huge factor especially in the UK versus the US where the issue is a lot more polarised. The picture I posted wasn't just a group of random white women. You don't know the history.
The second post of mine you've pasted was in response to a poster who profoundly declared that objectivity of black women (black people) was based in 'black culture'. That same poster then went on to subsequently make more comments containing non-sequiturs like 'sO wHaT'Z tHe MoBo'Z aBoUt Th£n'.

Well, sorry you didn't like my points but you only have to listen to the constant reference to 'bitches' and 'ho's' in rap music to ascertain that there's a distinct lack of respect for women there. And the disproportionately high number of black guys who abandon their wife and kids doesn't really help paint a picture of respect.

Things like female circumcision, forced
/child marriage, honour killings, etc, are also particularly prevalent in the wider BAME community. I mean have you seen the level of harassment women get in India? It's shocking.

So, no, I don't think BAME people 'care more than others about women’s rights'. Maybe in the few privileged societies where they're a minority but not overall. In fact, I'd say that the further we get from western influence the closer we get to barbaric practices.

beastlyslumber · 19/07/2022 06:43

I think representation can be thought about somewhat differently nowadays, in a world where people represent versions of themselves on social media and we don't depend on film/TV for images of ourselves or others. I think it's more interesting and salient to think about how images are produced and mediated, and how they generate meaning. There's a great book by Thomas de Zengotitta which discusses this idea. Also 'Amusing Ourselves to Death' by Neil Postman.

Kendodd · 18/07/2022 21:52

I think a few different issues.
Perhaps being bombarded with images of beautiful women is just plain unhealthy for young girls, whatever their race.
Lack of representation in all industries and given the world we live in, even the beauty industry, for black women.
If true that womens magazines sell less when a black women is on the cover, well that's just a commercial decision by the companies involved.

Nolongerteaching · 18/07/2022 21:44

@Kendodd

I think there may be two different issues there, though - and neither recognise that the beauty standard is a white woman that looks like Gisele/Kate/Claudia - ie very slim, blonde, tall, long straight hair.

I remember reading an interview that stated that there had been a tiny amount of black women on womens mags like Cosmo/MC, etc and the reasoning was that the magazines didn’t sell with a black woman on the cover - at the height of Naomi Campbell’s reign on the catwalk how was that seen as acceptable?

Kendodd · 18/07/2022 21:35

Can I make a point about black female representation, or lack of it, as a beauty standard. About 25 years ago I used to work as a photographer in London doing 'make-over' style shoots with the public. The staff, photographers, makeup and sales, was a mixed bunch race wise, as was the customers. Black women, above all others, came in proud of how they looked, and spent the most money on photographs. White women tended to be the most embarrassed, some even apologised and tried to make jokes about how ugly they were. They spent the least.

I've always been a radio 4 listener and around this time I heard a programme about anorexia and other body hating issues. Apparently, it was young white women who suffered the most from these conditions and black women who suffered the least. One respected theory put by the experts on the programme was the representation of white models as the beauty standard. It was thought that young black girls just couldn't relate to this, they were to far removed and so at some point growing up they abandoned this template of beauty and instead looked to the real women they knew in their lives and styled themselves on their big sisters or aunts instead. These real women were not six foot tall skinny supermodels, and didn't need to be.

Young white women were surrounded by an image of beauty that was close enough that it could be them but they could never actually compare to. I know black women often lament lack of representation in fashion modelling but most of us ordinary women would never look anything like a model anyway so why even look there, better to look at the real women around you as a measure of beautiful.

I remember the programme so well because it so resonated with my experience at work. And I've just looked up the numbers to see if white girls still have higher rates of anorexia, they do.

beastlyslumber · 18/07/2022 21:27

Yes, I agree representation matters. It's important to have role models.