Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder if BAME people care more than others about women’s rights?

294 replies

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 04/07/2022 18:09

Do BAME people care more about women’s rights?

Today I read about attorney general Suella Braverman opposing the SNP’s plan to
speed up gender self-ID. By allowing anyone to claim to be the other sex, self-ID would of course give every man (trans or not, sex predator or not) access to all women’s services and spaces.

Yesterday, it was the equalities minister Kemi Badenoch stating that all new public
buildings must have single-sex toilets.

Health secretary Sajid Javid has told the NHS to stop replacing words that have a female meaning (such as ‘woman’) with expressions such as ‘person with a uterus’. The NHS and many large organisations have been doing this to avoid offending trans people. But it is baffling to many people, who then risk missing vital health information.

Dame Kelly Holmes supports the Fair Play for Women campaign to stop males competing in women’s sports, despite transactivists’ aggression.

And so many heroic resisters have been fighting legal battles: Allison Bailey, Keira
Bell, Raquel Rosario Sanchez, Shahrar Ali …

And it’s not only the fight to keep women’s single-sex rights. Sajid Javid has also
refused to shut up about grooming gangs, despite being (unfairly) accused of racism.

Those are just the few I can think of on the spur of the moment. I know there are
many more.

Of course there are many other, non-BAME feminists and allies fighting against the
withdrawal of women’s rights and protections. But the percentage who are BAME seems very noticeable.

Any ideas why?

OP posts:
GoodJanetBadJanet · 20/07/2022 22:36

That's just the thing isn't it. Always one more report, an inquiry, an investigation, a better grasp of the research and so on and so forth. The movement to stop talking to white people about race came from such things. Because the goal of racism is actually to deter you from doing your work. If I and other black people can spend their lives explaining to white people who have no vested interest in changing the material reality then the cycle continues and continues again until black people just get exhausted
Exactly this

WillMcAvoy · 20/07/2022 22:30

And people who call themselves left wing support the most anti-socialist me-me-me ideology, the gender identity movement. Strange days indeed

No. There are vast numbers of GC left leaning women. And men. This is simply not true.

TruthHertz · 20/07/2022 22:28

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 22:11

Those are exactly the kind of areas where we need better data. What's stopping black graduates from going into law, for example? I think there must be multiple factors here. But the conversation always seems to stop at 'racism'. Which I don't doubt is part of the problem but it's not the whole thing. Do black graduates want to work in law? Is there more appeal in higher paying industries like tech? Are they actually applying for these roles? If so, are they getting kicked out at application stage? What's happening at interview? I don't know the answers but I suspect it's complex.

Same with black maternal mortality. We need more and better data. Pain relief is part of it but it's not the whole picture.

What I would say, my general position, is that while these sorts of issues are important, they are the kind of difficult issues that need a lot of careful thought. It's not like we are dealing with 'gross' problems like not having the right to work or equal housing etc, but fine-grained issues that we don't properly understand, but we do have the willingness to resolve. And this situation is pretty excellent compared to where we were at even 30 or 50 years ago. And excellent compared to most of the rest of the world.

FWIW, I've worked in management at a mid sized law firm (not legally qualified through, in a sales/bid management capacity). I encountered fair number of Indians but much less black workmates.

Now I work in the construction sector I've encountered a lot more black people, although admittedly nearly all male (although that's the case with the sector in general). My guess would be that in professional sectors there is a much bigger emphasis on being traditionally 'well spoken' and fitting a particular image.

This is less the case in construction/plant and I know lots of managers who literally started at the bottom and gradually worked their way up in a manner that is more difficult in professions requiring specific qualification. At the mortar plant I go to they teach most plant workers how to use the batching system after they've been there a while. They then gradually learn how to fix common problems, and many become supervisors or stand in batchers. Some then get sent off to other plants and get management training and become plant/site managers.

VladmirsPoutine · 20/07/2022 22:24

@beastlyslumber That's just the thing isn't it. Always one more report, an inquiry, an investigation, a better grasp of the research and so on and so forth. The movement to stop talking to white people about race came from such things. Because the goal of racism is actually to deter you from doing your work. If I and other black people can spend their lives explaining to white people who have no vested interest in changing the material reality then the cycle continues and continues again until black people just get exhausted. White people are more than happy to have a look at the data and review their internal policies - they actively get off on that stuff. Because the end result will not change anything.

That's why people like myself are involved in things like providing resource cards to young black men about what their rights are and what they should do in the very likely event they get stopped by the police for the crime of wearing a hoody or driving a nice car. It's why we also have funding for young black boys and girls to get therapy from black therapists about the traumas they're experiencing because as a black kid on your way to the shop then suddenly finding yourself on the pavement with 4 white police officers on top of you can really wreck your mental health. For black girls getting feedback from their teachers that they have 'attitude' can change their entire view of themselves so the therapy really helps. Building a network of knowledge and resource sharing for black kids is pivotal too.

These are the things that will change the cycle (can't stop it entirely because white people won't let that happen - the status quo suits them too much) but these can help and act as a crutch. So whilst I agree we do need more 'research' and better 'data' - in the meantime I'm just gonna be breaking the cycle in tangible ways Smile

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 22:11

Those are exactly the kind of areas where we need better data. What's stopping black graduates from going into law, for example? I think there must be multiple factors here. But the conversation always seems to stop at 'racism'. Which I don't doubt is part of the problem but it's not the whole thing. Do black graduates want to work in law? Is there more appeal in higher paying industries like tech? Are they actually applying for these roles? If so, are they getting kicked out at application stage? What's happening at interview? I don't know the answers but I suspect it's complex.

Same with black maternal mortality. We need more and better data. Pain relief is part of it but it's not the whole picture.

What I would say, my general position, is that while these sorts of issues are important, they are the kind of difficult issues that need a lot of careful thought. It's not like we are dealing with 'gross' problems like not having the right to work or equal housing etc, but fine-grained issues that we don't properly understand, but we do have the willingness to resolve. And this situation is pretty excellent compared to where we were at even 30 or 50 years ago. And excellent compared to most of the rest of the world.

VladmirsPoutine · 20/07/2022 21:30

Black maternal mortality is a good example of an issue where we can see a problem but we don't understand why it's happening. It's not helpful to just say 'racism' and leave it at that - maybe it's down to racism, sure, but what does that mean on a practical level? We need to understand what's actually happening

In practice this means black women being more likely to be denied pain-relief due to for example the strong black woman trope. It can mean having your choices questioned and ignored due to the perception that you aren't competent/intelligent enough to make your own choices. It can mean being overlooked because your needs just aren't important enough to them (a factor behind the BLM movement). I hate to use so much of my own life experiences to elucidate certain points but one thing that my sister says that has stayed with her after giving birth was one of the nurses who I'm sure meant well holding her hand during delivery and telling her "you can do this! You're a strong black woman."

To address this point too because I thought surely this would make a difference:

Growing up and going to school in multicultural areas probably makes a difference too.

A lot of 2nd and now 3rd generation black adults went to the same universities as their white counterparts who now work in say advertising and marketing, law, policy etc yet there's still a lack of a diverse workforce in these industries. These black students have the same cultural reference points, speak English with the same level of nuance and fluency, actually have adopted the Britain as home (versus their parents who see home as say their native African country) yet in all this these black students still struggle to get on the ladder even with the same grades.

The issue doesn't end there because once you even get into these industries a whole new world of micro-aggressions is waiting for you.

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 21:12

I think those things/patterns take longer to resolve. Making people equal in law is the basic first step that has to happen, then culture eventually seems to follow along. Organisations and companies all have policies now, which I think can be helpful in terms of changing workplace culture. Growing up and going to school in multicultural areas probably makes a difference too.

I think we need much better data on some of these issues. Black maternal mortality is a good example of an issue where we can see a problem but we don't understand why it's happening. It's not helpful to just say 'racism' and leave it at that - maybe it's down to racism, sure, but what does that mean on a practical level? We need to understand what's actually happening - and be open to all possible explanations - in order to change the outcome. In general, we don't seem very good at going through logical steps to get to answers. We're very good at just throwing a label at a problem: racism! sexism! but not good at getting any further with it.

I think one thing leaders could do on a political level is encourage more integration in terms of values. Like, for example, yes you can practice your religion, but you can't have sharia law, you can't behead teachers because they've insulted your prophet. A British person can be of any race or background, but we should have some shared values that make it possible to get along and make life easier for everyone.

Kendodd · 20/07/2022 20:39

I think the problem with all of those examples (both sexist and racist) is that you can't pin down any one of those things individually as a racist act. All together a pattern emerges pointing in one direction though. But, if you called out one incident at the time, you would look unreasonable, because you could well be wrong about that one time and unfairly labeling someone as sexist or racist. I don't really know the way forward on this. Blind recruitment (for example) can only go so far.

Look at the recent stories about maternity care for black women. Tying any single event down as racist would be extremely difficult, but all added together...

VladmirsPoutine · 20/07/2022 18:14

R.e. the feminism board and generally speaking when women describe sexism say in the workplace such as a man repeating what a woman has said to much acknowledgement as opposed to the blank stares a woman receives when suggesting her idea. Or the fact that women talk in a lot more self-deprecating ways than men. Or that women have legitimate fears about men that shouldn't be considered hysterical. Or women fearing going for promotion because they feel they're not good enough and so forth or feeling intimidated by men. Most, well let's say a lot of women understand and even have experienced at least some of these. And those that haven't tend to sympathise and understand the issue. When you replace sexism with racism but still use the above scenarios you'll even have the most progressive people telling you you're over-thinking it if not just down right denying it happened at all.

TruthHertz · 20/07/2022 17:27

^Really don't like the argument I always see on here that goes something like "but that happened in America, not the UK."
So what? It happening anywhere is awful, it's not a competition and doesn't mean we might be any better just because "well look at what America did"^

Well, if you're going to make the distinction between different races then surely we can make the distinction between different countries and cultures.

Nolongerteaching · 20/07/2022 15:54

There was a case in NI in the 60s where a woman said she had been attacked (and got pregnant).

She admitted about ten years ago (?) that it wasn’t the truth. She was married and ashamed that she had an affair with a student from Africa.

That must stay with wrongly accused people and effect their behaviour afterwards. You can’t just get over that.

In the interests of accuracy I’ll try and find the correct details

GoodJanetBadJanet · 20/07/2022 15:46

But in general I think that racism is repugnant to most people. I've very rarely come across racist views being expressed, especially in the last ten years or so
Lucky you then.
I have, just the other week in fact.
Lots of people still sickeningly hold racist views, just because you haven't heard any for 10 years or so doesn't mean they're not really expressed anymore.
As the pp said,if they think they're in the right company they spout their shit.
Hopefully won't try it with me anymore as think made pretty clear was disgusted by what was being spouted.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 20/07/2022 15:26

You can't, and that's okay
Yeah, you didn't read the post, did you, either that or you didn't understand it?
I'm not asking for an education in race relations or black history
Nobody said you were 😕
and if I were, I certainly wouldn't be asking you, Janet, so no worries on that score.
🤣😂

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 15:12

I'm not changing the goalposts. I appreciate the examples you gave, and I'm just asking you to connect the dots. You can't, and that's okay.

I'm not asking for an education in race relations or black history, and if I were, I certainly wouldn't be asking you, Janet, so no worries on that score.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 20/07/2022 15:01

Bloody phone 😭
I've already given you two examples already and you've (as predicted) dismissed them as they're not in the UK so want more examples.
Forever changing goalposts.
I completely understand why @VladmirsPoutine says she's not talking to white people about race anymore, it must be utterly fucking draining 😭😂
I don't come to MN to be set homework assignments and do others donkey work.
If you were really bothered about learning, you'd have a look yourself.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 20/07/2022 14:58

I've already given you two examples already and you've (

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 14:49

She lost her job, her dog, her friends, had to move cities and go into hiding... I don't think a few people on MN saying 'maybe we should look at both sides' really diminishes any of that.

Anyway, this is a derail. Could you give me an example of women using their 'feminity and whiteness as violence' in the UK? If you can't, that's okay.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 20/07/2022 14:40

No, I remember that thread. Not sure what part of it showed that Amy Cooper wasn't thoroughly lambasted
Oh, I think you need to give it another read then.

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 14:30

GoodJanetBadJanet · 20/07/2022 14:23

the white women who called the police on black people in these recent high profile cases were thoroughly lambasted and cancelled.
You (presumably) missed the huge thread on Amy Cooper here a while back with posters (one FWR regular in particular) but several more posters falling over themselves to paint her as a poor innocent victim and the black man as the aggressor.
It was sickening.

No, I remember that thread. Not sure what part of it showed that Amy Cooper wasn't thoroughly lambasted? She lost her job, her dog, her friends, had to move cities and go into hiding... I don't think a few people on MN saying 'maybe we should look at both sides' really diminishes any of that.

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 14:26

But we're a totally different country. We have a totally different history in terms of race relations. We have totally different institutions, structures, systems and cultures. The US has different problems with regard to race.

If you say that British white women use 'femininity and whiteness to force violence' then give me an example that relates to Britain. Or is it something that applies only to the US?

GoodJanetBadJanet · 20/07/2022 14:23

the white women who called the police on black people in these recent high profile cases were thoroughly lambasted and cancelled.
You (presumably) missed the huge thread on Amy Cooper here a while back with posters (one FWR regular in particular) but several more posters falling over themselves to paint her as a poor innocent victim and the black man as the aggressor.
It was sickening.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 20/07/2022 14:18

Just to note, the Emmet Till case happened in Missisippi in 1955 - a very different context from the UK in 2022 in terms of race relations.)
I know it did, but you asked for examples so I gave you some.
Really don't like the argument I always see on here that goes something like "but that happened in America, not the UK."
So what? It happening anywhere is awful, it's not a competition and doesn't mean we might be any better just because "well look at what America did"

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 09:48

How are femininity and whiteness used as violence? Could you give a couple of examples?

Amy Cooper Central park woman the other year.
The woman in the tragic Emmet Till case (her name escapes me, sorry)

Okay thanks, I understand where you're coming from.

(Just to note, the Emmet Till case happened in Missisippi in 1955 - a very different context from the UK in 2022 in terms of race relations.)

I won't go into details on specific cases, because it's a bit of a derail (and also all the ones I can think of are in the US) but I think it's correct to say that the white women who called the police on black people in these recent high profile cases were thoroughly lambasted and cancelled. This suggests to me that 'whiteness' and 'femininity' are not the ace cards that they're being presented as? If anything, these cases engendered a meme of 'Karen' which is used to stereotype white women as stupid racists with bad haircuts.

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 20/07/2022 09:17

Adelishious · 20/07/2022 05:24

@TwentyOneTwentyTwo
I wonder, do you not feel ashamed benefitting so much on the misery of others. Did you give your vaccine up to someone in India, or do you relinquish any of your wealth to help those over there. Likely not. Its easy to critisise those for the unfortunate events of others while still benefiting from the priveliges you enjoy on a day to day basis

What wealth would you like me to give? What benefit do you think I get from the misery of others? Are you saying that colonialism and the misery of others is okay if I haven't personally sent vaccines to India? Who do you think I'm criticising?

beastlyslumber · 20/07/2022 06:46

GoodJanetBadJanet · 19/07/2022 23:48

I think it's fair to say that western culture has done better than most others so far in bringing about fairness, justice and equality for women and minorities.
Fucking hell.
Maybe we should just get back to colonising everywhere, eh?!
Imparting our superiority over others?!
WTF did I just read, it's getting said more and more out loud on here, it's not just insidious or insinuating anymore!!

There's a really big leap from what I said to what you said! And no logical way to connect the two sets of statements. If you disagree with what I said, that's fine, you're free to put your point of view. But making up statements I haven't said and then denouncing them is a form of logical fallacy called 'strawmanning'. It doesn't win arguments - it makes you look like you don't have any. I'm sure that's not the case.