Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leasehold Property?

37 replies

girlfriend44 · 04/07/2022 17:34

Does anyone else not fully understand Leasehold?

I know Freehold is better as you own the land. All flats seem to be Leasehold though?

Is it so bad? Does anyone have a Leasehold property and can explain the pros and cons please?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cobden28 · 05/07/2022 21:48

I live in a privately-owned flat which is leasehold; I own the bricks and mortar outright but the land the flat sits on is owned by someone else. The deeds of the property clearly state the responsiblilties of the leaseholder (the person or organisation who owns the land) as well as your responsibilities as the property owner. If you're considering buying a leasehold flat then you could ask to see a copy of the terms of the lease before you sign on the dotted line, so that you're quite clear about what your responsibilities are.

Before I bought my present flat I had made an offer on another flat in the same block but which was freehold; as there was a flat below this one I as the potential freeholder would have had the responsibility of arranging buildings insurance & inspections and I didn't want the responsibility of that. My present, leasehold, flat has more cupboard storage space and a bigger & more private garden than the first flat anyway.

onthefencesitter · 05/07/2022 21:39

girlfriend44 · 05/07/2022 21:30

I've looked at one bedroom flats in my area and houses are more expensive.

yes of course, flats are cheaper than houses in the same neighbourhood. Also if you are comparing a 1 bed flat with a 3 bed semi-detached, thats not quite a fair comparison because the house is much bigger. there are not many 1 bed houses! You would have to compare the semi-detached with a flat of similar size- such flats do not exist in every area! I have found that the flats are still cheaper but this may not be the case in every area- in a lot of suburban areas, such flats would be marketed at wealthy downsizers and be far more expensive than any FTB property or even an average family home.

What I was saying is usually people move to a cheaper area in the same city/county to buy a house and they get on the housing ladder this way. Of course you don't need to do this, i stayed in my area but this meant getting a flat instead of a house.

onthefencesitter · 05/07/2022 21:36

Notarealmum · 05/07/2022 21:20

I think there’s some confusing information on this thread. By no means all flats are leasehold, in many cases owners have bought/own the freehold and neither situation is necessarily problematic. I certainly would not let leasehold put me off buying, OP, and I’ve owned a number of leasehold properties. As others have said, you’ll need to check there’s no conditions like no pets or no subletting (though you may not be bothered about either) and in the case of either leasehold or freehold I would want to check that there is a decent agent in place to manage the maintenance of the property, which will involve all flat owners paying an annual service charge to ensure sufficient funds for this.

share of freehold flats are technically still leasehold- www.homeviews.com/blog/what-does-share-of-freehold-mean/

'If you buy a property with a Share of Freehold, this means you own your property leasehold plus a share of the freehold for the building your property is in and the land it’s on. This usually applies to apartments. So owners of the apartments in a building each own their apartment leasehold, as well as holding a share of the freehold for that entire building and the land it sits on.'

yes its a technicality but it also means that on rightmove, i have seen share of fh flats still listed as leasehold esp in the past. its only when you ask,then you find out. Rightmove is improving on this front, i have seen it included in the ad nowadays.

girlfriend44 · 05/07/2022 21:30

onthefencesitter · 05/07/2022 21:04

Its not the only way- for the same price as my 2 bed flat in zone 3 north london (£400k), there are 648 results for houses in London. Most of those results wouldn't actually be in inner London, but in surrounding areas like croydon, essex, romford (which are part of the greater london authority). However, it is the only way to buy in a desirable/expensive area on a typical FTB budget (and this is often the case outside of London as well!)

Its all priorities though. I prioritize being near work, good schools and near my DH's family. Location above tenure as I am buying to live in rather than as an investment. If you were buying to make money, buy a house.

I've looked at one bedroom flats in my area and houses are more expensive.

OP posts:
Notarealmum · 05/07/2022 21:20

I think there’s some confusing information on this thread. By no means all flats are leasehold, in many cases owners have bought/own the freehold and neither situation is necessarily problematic. I certainly would not let leasehold put me off buying, OP, and I’ve owned a number of leasehold properties. As others have said, you’ll need to check there’s no conditions like no pets or no subletting (though you may not be bothered about either) and in the case of either leasehold or freehold I would want to check that there is a decent agent in place to manage the maintenance of the property, which will involve all flat owners paying an annual service charge to ensure sufficient funds for this.

ThatsALotOfPassionfruit · 05/07/2022 21:09

To the person who asked about shared ownership and leaseholds - generally while you only own a share (I.e anything less than 100%) it’ll be a leasehold as the housing association retain overall ownership. If you staircase and buy the lot it then becomes your freehold.

onthefencesitter · 05/07/2022 21:04

girlfriend44 · 05/07/2022 19:42

It's the only way to get on the property ladder as flats are cheaper but all are leasehold.

Its not the only way- for the same price as my 2 bed flat in zone 3 north london (£400k), there are 648 results for houses in London. Most of those results wouldn't actually be in inner London, but in surrounding areas like croydon, essex, romford (which are part of the greater london authority). However, it is the only way to buy in a desirable/expensive area on a typical FTB budget (and this is often the case outside of London as well!)

Its all priorities though. I prioritize being near work, good schools and near my DH's family. Location above tenure as I am buying to live in rather than as an investment. If you were buying to make money, buy a house.

girlfriend44 · 05/07/2022 19:42

It's the only way to get on the property ladder as flats are cheaper but all are leasehold.

OP posts:
Muckymaisonette · 05/07/2022 16:22

Then there's the people who bought ex local authority flats and suddenly are presented with large bills for structural repairs or stuck being unable to sell a flat in a building with unsafe cladding.

Getoff · 05/07/2022 16:06

Having owned a leasehold flat I would not recommend it to my worst enemy. They are increasingly difficult to sell and mine was only part of a 2 flat building.

Flats in England are leasehold, it is not true that flats in England are becoming "increasingly difficult" to sell. Why would it be true, the situation has not become any worse since leasehold flats were first built. On the contrary, recent granting of rights to acquire a share of the freehold and to self-manage must mean that leasehold is more attractive now than it has ever been.

The more flats that form part of the lease the more complex the whole situation is

I would say the exact opposite is true. It sounds like your problem is that you were in a small converted property. The more flats there are, the lower the overhead per person of paying for facilities, including good management. Had you been in a 300-flat purpose-built development, there would several full-time staff maintaining, cleaning and securing the building, there would be management committee of residents, some of them lawyers and accountants giving their time for free, with the committee holding the managing agent (who organises day-to-day maintenance) to account, getting the most work for the least money, and ultimately sacking and replacing them if not up to scratch

BorsetshireBanality · 05/07/2022 15:58

I owned a leasehold flat and it was a nightmare. Before I bought it the leaseholders had taken over the management and set up a company to do this. This company had to sort out the building insurance, repairs and general maintenance etc, look after service charges and keep up with all the legal necessities of being a company. I think it was a “common hold” rather than a freehold arrangement.

But people move on. One of the two new directors (flat owners) didn’t like paying the service charge so didn’t for years and did sod all else and the other director did sod all either, so the insurance didn’t get paid on time, company accounts were not prepared or filed, no repairs or maintenance done apart from routine stuff carried out by the other owners. The company was stuck off and it was a nightmare and expense to get it all up and running again. Luckily no disaster took place when the building wasn’t insured.

Lunarpsychobitch · 05/07/2022 15:04

I used to work in leasehold housing and personally wouldn't touch it with a barge pole.
Make sure you spend time with your solicitor going through the terms of the lease so you know in advance what you can and can't do.
Also ask them to explain the terms of your ground rent or sinking fund and if this is paid monthly, annually or a % of the price when you sell the property again. It might be worth noting that if a major renovation is required and there isn't enough money in the funds, the owner may be able to put the % you pay to this fund up with very little notice.

The number of years remaining on the lease is also really important to discuss with your solicitor because if you need to extend the lease, it can cost a few thousand pounds and you may also need to pay the owner a fee before they will give you permission to extend it.

DownNative · 05/07/2022 12:25

Tweeenies · 04/07/2022 19:45

Ex mortgage underwriter here.

Put very simply, imagine with freehold you own the property and everything above and below it (although you have to allow pipes, aeroplane access etc). So if you have a house it's ideal.

As you can imagine, a flat therefore that is freehold is a bit of a nightmare - who own the roof for example? So what's usually done is that the exterior of the building is freehold, and you own your part of it on a lease (usually 100-1000 years). That way the freeholder (which can be a company) is responsible for things like the roof. Once your lease is due to expire you can usually pay to extend it again - anything less than about 80 years and lenders tend to get a bit twitchy though until it's extended - and that will affect the value.

Freehold flats are sometimes possible - but they are very complicated legally and so again this can affect the value and a lot of lenders don't like them.

Shared ownership is a little different - you buy a percentage of the property and rent part at less than market rates. So your overall monthly costs are usually less than buying outright and you can put down less of a deposit. You can "staircase" ie buy more and rent less percentage wise until you own it all.

I own my house in a shared ownership arrangement in Scotland. Currently, our share is 51%, but there is NO rent to pay on the rest either.

Since it was a pilot scheme in 2011, we can buy up to 90% of the house. It's 80% now for everyone else on the same type of ownership here.

WendellGeez · 05/07/2022 11:57

There seems to be a campaign to abolish leaseholds altogether and give LHs the right to aquire their freeholds at a bargain price, if I understand it correctly. The forums on Landlordzone have a lot of discussion about this if anyone is interested (or google "leasehold reform act"). Also, as of a few days ago, ground rents are no longer legal (!) but unfortunately that doesn't apply to my property as my lease pre-dates the Act.

onthefencesitter · 05/07/2022 11:16

Tweeenies · 04/07/2022 21:24

@Isleoftights if you own a share of the overall freehold, along with several others, then you're right, that opens the mortgage market up a bit more. If you didn't have the collective agreement, if you each truly owned the freehold to each individual flat, then it would be a lot more complex and difficult to get a mortgage.

My friend owns the ground floor flat in a converted house and also owns the freehold for both flats in the building. I don't think she had problems getting a mortgage for that. Her boyfriend owns the top floor flat so technically she is his freeholder! He did buy his flat before her and she was living with him, which was why she was able to build a relationship with the neighbour downstairs and buy the ground floor flat after she died.

Tweeenies · 04/07/2022 21:24

@Isleoftights if you own a share of the overall freehold, along with several others, then you're right, that opens the mortgage market up a bit more. If you didn't have the collective agreement, if you each truly owned the freehold to each individual flat, then it would be a lot more complex and difficult to get a mortgage.

WendellGeez · 04/07/2022 21:10

Isleoftights · 04/07/2022 21:03

Freehold flats are sometimes possible - but they are very complicated legally and so again this can affect the value and a lot of lenders don't like them.

I own a 'freehold flat'. What's complicated ? All the owners in the block (15) have an equal share in the freehold, which we collectively own. We appoint a management company to oversee day-today management. Most blocks in the area have a similar ownership structure. It works well. The flats are 'sought after' and there's no issue with 'lenders' liking them. On the rare occasion they become available, they sell very quickly.

I think it would be very complicated if Flat A (for example) wanted to add a balcony to his property and had to get permission from the other 14 freeholders!

WendellGeez · 04/07/2022 21:08

I have a flat on a 999 year lease. Contrary to pp I don't own the flat (the freeholder owns all the flats in the building), I only own a long lease on it. We have a management company (all leaseholders are members) and an agent to actually run the property. We had to fire our previous agents as they were incompetent and then take them to court to recover money they had stolen. Dealing with agents in general seems like a hassle but that's probably because I volunteered to be a director of the management company.

Isleoftights · 04/07/2022 21:03

Freehold flats are sometimes possible - but they are very complicated legally and so again this can affect the value and a lot of lenders don't like them.

I own a 'freehold flat'. What's complicated ? All the owners in the block (15) have an equal share in the freehold, which we collectively own. We appoint a management company to oversee day-today management. Most blocks in the area have a similar ownership structure. It works well. The flats are 'sought after' and there's no issue with 'lenders' liking them. On the rare occasion they become available, they sell very quickly.

SpaceyCake · 04/07/2022 20:08

We own a leasehold property that isn't a flat and it's been ok. The ground rent is small and our lease is 999 years so not bad at all. Even though I sometimes moan about the service charges I think they are actually pretty reasonable, and they do cover quite a lot. We don't need to worry about maintaining any external areas, our house gets jetwashed annually and any external repairs are done promptly. We live in a "naice", kind of unique area where most of the houses and flats are leaseholds, and the residents' service charges cover the maintenance of the entire estate, and the estate is kept pristine. It's so nice to walk around when everything looks lovely, and all green areas and walkways etc are kept in good condition and the estate feels really safe. I recently learned where the border of the area that our management company looks after is, and once you cross to the other side you can really see the difference as the rest of the town looks quite tatty. I appreciate that not everyone wants to contribute to this sort of thing, but I love living where we are and will be sad to eventually move out.

Having said all this, I have heard stories about bonkers charges and other issues, so I guess it just depends on the place.

Tweeenies · 04/07/2022 19:45

Ex mortgage underwriter here.

Put very simply, imagine with freehold you own the property and everything above and below it (although you have to allow pipes, aeroplane access etc). So if you have a house it's ideal.

As you can imagine, a flat therefore that is freehold is a bit of a nightmare - who own the roof for example? So what's usually done is that the exterior of the building is freehold, and you own your part of it on a lease (usually 100-1000 years). That way the freeholder (which can be a company) is responsible for things like the roof. Once your lease is due to expire you can usually pay to extend it again - anything less than about 80 years and lenders tend to get a bit twitchy though until it's extended - and that will affect the value.

Freehold flats are sometimes possible - but they are very complicated legally and so again this can affect the value and a lot of lenders don't like them.

Shared ownership is a little different - you buy a percentage of the property and rent part at less than market rates. So your overall monthly costs are usually less than buying outright and you can put down less of a deposit. You can "staircase" ie buy more and rent less percentage wise until you own it all.

onthefencesitter · 04/07/2022 19:32

girlfriend44 · 04/07/2022 19:24

How do you buy a flat then as they all seem to be leasehold.

You buy a house if you don't want leasehold....or buy in Scotland.

For me, buying a house would mean paying £8k in season ticket fares for me and DH plus longer commute and I didn't want to do that.

Quartz2208 · 04/07/2022 19:32

I would say if you can find a leasehold that has the 900 years and low ground rent you are fine.

There are differences within the leasehold - I would be more wary of a lease of under 150 years (and not go anywhere near anything under a 100 without negotiating) and be very clear as to what is and isnt expected

or move to Scotland

onthefencesitter · 04/07/2022 19:28

Jdiosmio94 · 04/07/2022 18:55

Having owned a leasehold flat I would not recommend it to my worst enemy. They are increasingly difficult to sell and mine was only part of a 2 flat building. The more flats that form part of the lease the more complex the whole situation is.

Selling a leasehold property is also a lot more expensive as you normally have to pay admin fees to the management company in addition to your service charge and ground rent.

One of the most stressful periods of my life was when our then service provider decided they didn't want to manage the freehold anymore and I was stuck in limbo unable to well whilst we waited for the free holder to find a new management company, it meant I couldn't sell my flat for two years!

Buyer beware. If you don't own the physical ground the building stands on I wouldn't bother. Most management companies are run by crooks, though some properties my have a management company set up by the owners of the properties, even so this represents challenges as you've got to trust your neighbours will pull their weight and pay their way, and someone actually has to physically do all the admin and register it as a business in order to operate properly.

We appoint a managing agent to do the work and can switch as the residents own the freehold. Three flats in my block have sold in the last two years.

Flats are generally in areas where buying a house would be very expensive or you would be buying something v small. A house with the same floor area as my flat would be £600k. I doubt admin fees and service charges can add up to £150k! But at the end of the day, it depends on what the person wants. Most FTB don't have the £150k extra though...

girlfriend44 · 04/07/2022 19:24

How do you buy a flat then as they all seem to be leasehold.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread