Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mixing up classes in primary school

113 replies

Faciadipasta · 04/07/2022 17:17

My dc has found out today (with no warning) that their school has decided to mix up the 3 classes in their year group as they move from year 2 to year 3 in September. They are the only year that this is being done with. A LOT of the children were in tears at pick up today. I'm really worried that they will all have difficulties making new friends, and a lot of them are already saying they don't want to go to school any more now. If this has happened to your dc how did it go? Were the kids happier in the long run?
It just seems really mean, I'm sure they have reasons for doing it but I feel like these kids have already all had so much to deal with, being the cohort that were in reception when covid hit, so they've missed so much in terms of continuity and security within school and now they are having their friendship groups broken up as well. I think I'm almost as upset as my DS (who has been in tears since he got home) the reasoning the school has given is that the class sizes are uneven. They currently have 2 classes of 24 and 1 of 30 so they want to make them more equal. I do understand that point but I think only 2 children have actually left the year since they joined so why couldn't it just have been more balanced from the beginning?

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 04/07/2022 18:04

Classes were reshuffled every year at my DCs' school in the US. There were two classes per year. By the time they were ten they were a very solid, cohesive group, and that only developed more in their remaining years (to age 13/14).

Classes in my own school were set in stone and the result was that I didn't even know own the names of some of the girls in 'the other class' until we did a joint theatrical production in the last year of primary. Some of them became firm friends in secondary.

Happyhappyday · 04/07/2022 18:01

I grew up in the US where it’s totally standard for kids to change classes every year. Parents might request friends together but you all get mixed up. Most primary schools have 3-6 classes per year (I can’t speak for other districts but where I grew up & where dc go to school now, class sizes are 20-25). It didn’t bother me at all, quite the reverse, if you’re stuck in a class with bullies/problem kids, you’re not trapped with them for 6 years!

Mousemat25 · 04/07/2022 17:59

It’s a really bad idea for kids with / with suspected ASD who is get distressed with change. Speaking from experience here 😞

Smartiepants79 · 04/07/2022 17:58

Well it’s perhaps not been handled very well but it’s a completely normal thing to do and really shouldn’t be made into a big deal by the adults involved.
All the schools I ever had anything to do with mix up the kids every year if they’ve got more than one class.
There may be multiple reasons why school have decided that this is a good idea. Very possibly the classes are not actually working that well as they are and need a move around.
Life is constantly changing. People come and go. Kids need to be able to understand this and deal with it. If they went all through primary never having to deal with new people or new routines then they’d be very poorly prepared for secondary and life in the real world. They’ll still see their current friends at lunches and stuff.

detectora · 04/07/2022 17:57

Our school does this every year. It’ll be fine.

It’s good for them and in the long term helps to prepare them for high school.

Favouritefruits · 04/07/2022 17:55

They mixed up my child’s class two years ago I was really disappointed with the school, children upset and angry but if I’m honest I was wrong, it’s been great my son has more friends they seem to have spread out the ‘naughty’ children and the year group feels more like a big class than separate classes. Give it a chance and you might find out it’s worked out for the best too.

Quartz2208 · 04/07/2022 17:54

And High Schools are brutal at separating - most try to mix up the children from the local Primary schools as much as they can.

Quartz2208 · 04/07/2022 17:53

GCRich · 04/07/2022 17:40

Also, I get that kids need to be challenged, but isn't it always said that routine and security are the most important things for kids, and surely having the same class for as long as possible is a good way of providing kids with routine an security?

I think though if done properly (and there are some examples here that arent and I think the OPs school failed at rolling it out properly) it enables them to mix things up and keep routine and security so they are more used to a new environment before going to High School.

@Faciadipasta the best thing you can do is be positive about it and ask the school on what criteria they are changing - will friendship groups where possible be kept together.

DuringDinnerMints · 04/07/2022 17:52

They do this every year at our school. Each class is mixed year so sometimes they're with older kids, sometimes younger. They always make sure that no child is separated from all their friends and it's a chance to split up any kids who don't get on. They can also ensure that kids who need extra support are with a teacher who has the training and experience to help them.

Every year, there are tears but every year, they all make new friends and still play with their old friends at break times. As a result, they all seem to know everyone via siblings and changing friendship groups. It seems harsh at the time but helps them broaden their horizons, teaches them resilience and prepares them for secondary school, where they might not necessarily be with all their friends.

Mariposista · 04/07/2022 17:49

It is so so hard for the kids but they will adapt. It is good for them to be mixed up and made to interact outside their usual group. Friendships at this age can get very intense and cliquey very quickly, and if the friendship is meant to survive in the long run, it will do.

PatchworkElmer · 04/07/2022 17:48

It’s fine. Don’t overreact, you’ll make it into a bigger deal for him.

NewYorkPleasecake · 04/07/2022 17:47

My DC is in a one form entry school.

Oh how I wish we had the opportunity for a mix up every so often!

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 04/07/2022 17:40

My DDs class could do with mixing, its got an unhealthy dynamic. But school policy is no mixing...

They will have their reasons.

DD is at her fourth school, so has had a lot of mixing (she's Yr4 now). Mixing with more people is generally a good thing.

GCRich · 04/07/2022 17:40

Also, I get that kids need to be challenged, but isn't it always said that routine and security are the most important things for kids, and surely having the same class for as long as possible is a good way of providing kids with routine an security?

minipie · 04/07/2022 17:39

Ours always mixes at the end of Y2. It’s a good time to do it - half way through the school, KS2, they know the personalities/needs by then, but still plenty of time for them to settle into new groups.

It was great for my eldest (her class was dysfunctional with a bit of a queen bee thing going on). Think it will be good for my youngest too.

I realise it’s not so good for those lucky children who have a great friendship group in their original class, but those who haven’t been so lucky need a second chance. Plus all the comments above about balancing out numbers, needs, new joiners etc.

I agree that it’s not good to have done it without warning. I would guess they didn’t want parents kicking up a fuss?

GCRich · 04/07/2022 17:37

FeinsteinA · 04/07/2022 17:21

Particularly with this cohort, many additional support needs will have surfaced and they will need to be balanced across the year group to ensure best support. It isn't about friendships. A huge amount of thought will have gone in to it.

They will still see their friends at playtime or after school.

I can assure you that "A huge amount of thought will have gone in to it." is not necessarily true.

In my experience it is perfectly possible that - if challenged - the school will admit that it was done with no real thought and then try to deal with particular issues that arise by completing reallocating again! ie make changes to the original re-org plan to deal with issues eg "A wants to be in a class with B because A struggles to make friends but she is good friends with B", or "C is a nightmare and he picks on D all the time, so it makes sense to move them to different classes"

Sqeebling · 04/07/2022 17:37

We had to do this because a stupid DM decided against advice she wanted her precious twins to be in the same class in reception

A year later she changed her mind and they used the excuse of a couple of other fallen out friendships to mix up the classes

It destroyed friendships of DC and DM and it was a real shame

There were some awful new DMs and their DC in our new class

I hated the school with a passion for that

Mischance · 04/07/2022 17:36

I think it is very important that YOU do not react badly to this as it will compound your DS's distress unnecessarily. It happens in most schools. It would be best for you to be upbeat about this, so he can take his lead from you. The more he sees that it upsets you then the mor4e upset he will be.

You may be right that this has not been handled well, but letting him see how you feel will not help him.

NerrSnerr · 04/07/2022 17:35

Ours mix every year. It's fine. My daughter wasn't with her 'best friend' this year, and won't be next either. They still play at break and lunch when it means she has a wider mix of children she knows and plays with. They also did this when I was at primary school. They'll be fine.

TheNinthLock · 04/07/2022 17:35

I grew up on the continent and classes were mixed every year (the school was 3 form intake)

The school I work at (in the UK, also 3 form intake) mixes classes every 2 years, so from R into 1, 2 into 3 and 4 into 5. Then at the end of Y6 they all go to a selection of secondary schools.

Children change - what was once a good mix of pupils can become unhealthy, SEN may emerge, new children joining the school may have changed the dynamics and a rebalance is needed, academic abilities change and may need to be evened out.

The mixing should happen with a great deal of thought and benefit each child.

It is a good thing 🙂

RudsyFarmer · 04/07/2022 17:34

Happens yearly at my children’s school. They are a two class year group and they get a yearly mix up. I’ll admit there are tears but on the plus side new friendships develop.

Headteacher415 · 04/07/2022 17:32

We are one and a half form entry and so mix every year. There will be a lot of consideration given to keeping friendships together where possible. Your child will end up with twice as many friends - he will retain the friendships in his old class and make new ones.

PeterCannaeRun · 04/07/2022 17:32

Reassure them, they will still see their friends at break, lunch, before and after school and at play dates you arrange. Of course they will make new friends just like they did when they started school.

There are lots of reasons for mixing up classes especially a 3 form entry. Anything from evening out ability (low, middle and high ability children) any specific 1 to 1 children who require an LSA, boy or girl heavy which may or may not cause issues, friendships which parents think are wonderful are not necessarily wonderful in classrooms if they exclude other children or misbehave together.

Personally a class of 24 is easier compared to a class of 30 with a teacher and an LSA or volunteer (me, but with qualifications and over a decade experience) so I can understand the shuffle. Rather than moving a couple of children into the smaller classes they saw fit, and rightly so, to even up the classes based on other criteria.

They will be fine. My sons experienced this every 2 years at primary, 90 cohort, originally they were setted so shuffled round to different classrooms for high ability, middle and low during the morning for core subjects then they kept all classes as mixed ability.

Bluevelvetsofa · 04/07/2022 17:32

It’s a natural thing between KS1 and KS2. It isn’t as if it’s a completely new school with new children.

GoldenGorilla · 04/07/2022 17:31

A lot of schools do this every year (ours does).

your school has handled it badly as they should have told parents first and given more warning.

but it’s always been a good thing for us - it rebalances any additional needs, splits up unhealthy/obsessive friendships, puts people together who can work well. Kids adapt really quickly.

good thing to do is lots of play dates for the new class over the holiday - like invite the whole of the new class to the playground so they feel they know each other a bit.