Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mixing up classes in primary school

113 replies

Faciadipasta · 04/07/2022 17:17

My dc has found out today (with no warning) that their school has decided to mix up the 3 classes in their year group as they move from year 2 to year 3 in September. They are the only year that this is being done with. A LOT of the children were in tears at pick up today. I'm really worried that they will all have difficulties making new friends, and a lot of them are already saying they don't want to go to school any more now. If this has happened to your dc how did it go? Were the kids happier in the long run?
It just seems really mean, I'm sure they have reasons for doing it but I feel like these kids have already all had so much to deal with, being the cohort that were in reception when covid hit, so they've missed so much in terms of continuity and security within school and now they are having their friendship groups broken up as well. I think I'm almost as upset as my DS (who has been in tears since he got home) the reasoning the school has given is that the class sizes are uneven. They currently have 2 classes of 24 and 1 of 30 so they want to make them more equal. I do understand that point but I think only 2 children have actually left the year since they joined so why couldn't it just have been more balanced from the beginning?

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 04/07/2022 20:08

Dd’s former primary mixed the children up at the end of reception, missed a year then did it once again the following year. So 3 times. They were due to be mixed up for year 6 but the children asked not to be so they remained in the same class until the end of primary. By this stage, many children had friends in both classes.

My dd didn’t like the change either. She struggled changing from one school year to the next as there was different classroom and teacher. However, I think the change was good for relationship building and stood her in good stead. When she went to secondary in year 7, a computer programme allocated a class at random.

The school didn’t mix the classes at when I was at my primary school and I think it is an advantage to change around to get used to the concept.

Ylvamoon · 04/07/2022 20:02

I'm going against the grain here, mixing up classes is rubbish for the DC & parents.

DS primary did it every single year- 120 kids randomly placed into 4 groups.

So all the friends they made during the year, poof gone! And while some DC are fine, they make friends easily ect. others struggle. Plus, it's near impossible to have that one close friend though (primary) school...
Same for us parents, you build relationships with others to facilitate DC's friendships, And each September/ October you start again while trying to hold on to the ones from previous years. Utter nonsense!

Drywhitefruitycidergin · 04/07/2022 19:57

Generally speaking I'm a fan of mixing. It's a good opportunity to rebalance ability/gender/additional needs & in the case of my dd2 tomorrow get her away from the horrible Queen Bee who isolates her from her other friends.
I think it'll be strange because this year's year 2 have been together since reception coz continuity was considered important during/post-covid but I'm sure they'll be fine.
I'm am disappointed that there has been no communication at all regarding staffing/transition day classes. Normally they announce Friday before so that those with children less keen on change have opportunity to big it up. Apparently not this year now we have no headteacher acting head & acting deputy head are mia.

cansu · 04/07/2022 19:45

You need to chill out. The kids take their cues from the adults. If you feed into the drama you will make them think it is worse than it is. They will likely consider friendships and make sure kids are with someone they like. They also get to play with anyone at playtime. It makes sense to have equal numbers.

Dishwashersaurous · 04/07/2022 19:44

It's completely typical to mix up classes from year two to year three. The move to juniors from infants. It's also the point where new children will join a school.

The only unusual thing is that it hadn't happened for two years because of covid.

Was there no one with older children at the school who could have said that this was typical and was going to happen?

SkygardenTower · 04/07/2022 19:41

I’m struggling to see how much more warning you would have liked? It is still a few week until the end of term and then 3 months before the mix up happens.

You say it would have been better to tell the parents first but then some will tell their kids, some won’t then the gossip will start, then parental pressure to influence the mix. It can do a lot more harm than good.

There is still time this term to get to know the new classes, get some contacts and maybe set up some play dates over the summer. A wider friendship group is good.

LifeInsideMyhead · 04/07/2022 19:25

Teddy - that makes some sense as they are not mixed on the most part - if they are together for yrs 1-6. My kids would have loved that.

I guess there are downsides to that too as most schools do mix.

Charlavail · 04/07/2022 19:24

DD's school has done this. In reality DD is one of six children being swapped with six children from the other class. She isn't with any of her friends now and with two children from her class who have been repeatedly unkind to her. I'm very worried about next year.

TeddyBeans · 04/07/2022 19:18

The school I worked at mixes the classes at the end of reception. They then remain in those classes for the rest of their primary education. The 2019-2020 cohort were the only ones that weren't mixed, because of the lockdown, to create a bit more stability for them going back to school. They were mixed at the end of year 1 instead.

A lot of thought goes into the mix, friendships that benefit the child remain, friendships that disrupt learning might be at risk. They still see each other at break times and after school. I can assure you that it's not done out of malice and the teachers have the best interests of all the children at the forefront of their decisions

NewYorkPleasecake · 04/07/2022 19:11

Mousemat25 · 04/07/2022 17:59

It’s a really bad idea for kids with / with suspected ASD who is get distressed with change. Speaking from experience here 😞

So they shouldn't do it for that reason, even if there are compelling reasons to do so and/or for the wider good?

LifeInsideMyhead · 04/07/2022 19:08

Hmmm. "The parents are the problem". I see this too often when schools want to minimise struggles that children have.

Often kids with additional needs (anxiety or autism for example) will "hold it all in" at school and then meltdown/ cry at home. The parents tell the school this and instead of using this information blame the parents. I see this is in some groups I run.

TheMadGardener · 04/07/2022 19:07

At my school (3 form entry), we usually remix Reception as they enter Y1. This year we are remixing Rec ➡️ Y1, Y1 ➡️ Y2 and Y2 ➡️ Y3.

As other posters have said, there are various good reasons for this. For instance, in one of the current Y1 classes there has turned out to be very high levels of SEN and a group of children with very challenging behaviour. These will now be distributed between the three classes in Y2.
In the current Y2 classes, one class has turned out to have a high proportion of very able children. Another Y2 class has had several children leave so that class is much smaller than the other two. So they are being redistributed in Y3.
The whole year group will still get to play together, have lunch together and do multisports together. They will still get to see their old friends but will make new ones.

Snowraingain · 04/07/2022 19:04

They do it all the time. The kids are fine. The parents are just the problem.

LifeInsideMyhead · 04/07/2022 19:03

Our local primary does this every year. I hate it. Both my children have lost good friendships due to this and both struggle with quite so much change and then spend the summer all worried about the new class.

I've tried all the "but you'll see each other at playtime" but its not the same - they often don't play together as they bond as a class and have shared experiences.

They used to let you write down 3 friends and guarantee you one of them but they dont do that anymore (not surprised as it must be a nightmare to sort.)
I know keeping them the same every year isn't great - and its a reason against single form schools.... but I hate how its worked for my 2.

My eldest is at secondary and loves that her form class will stay the same throughout the school!

BotCrossHuns · 04/07/2022 18:59

We were mixed up every year from age 5 onwards. Parents had nothing to do with it. We didn't even find out until September - that was the exciting bit about the first day of school, finding out your class and teacher. No particularly effort made to keep friends together ,but they did try to balance classes in various other ways. Mostly you just got used to it - nobody expected the classes to be the same, so it wasn't an issue. You played with friends at playtime and lunch. And hoped to be back in the same class another year.

Vallmo47 · 04/07/2022 18:57

I understand Op. My daughter had this happen to her last year when she left year 4. She was on the fence about it but I was truly upset. I did hide this from her as best as I could but it was difficult. She asked for 3 of her closest friends to be in her class and she didn’t get a single one of her choices. The teacher explained it with “Because she’s the least worried about the changes” but it really annoyed me! Why should she lose all of her closest friends because the teacher thinks she will cause the least fuss?

If I’m completely honest I’m still not keen on this mix up. They’ve now mixed them up again for year 6 despite only some of the pupils leaving for secondary. I enquired why they couldn’t stay with their new friends from year 5 but was told it’s “good for them to get used to mixing ahead of secondary”.
We found out the new class and teacher today and amazingly she’s lucked out this time and knows a whole of two people.

What I will say in favour of this weird system is that she knows a larger group of children that she did before and yes, she’s a lot less worried about it this time around. Last year most kids were crying. I have not seen tears so far this year.
I do completely take your point about so many changes after the shitshow of covid, I made that exact point last year and they did not listen.

Keep positive about it. It will help your child 100%.

SheWoreYellow · 04/07/2022 18:53

Our primary used to not mix classes but the high school observed that they did not get on as well as those from other primaries who had mixed. So now they do.

SpringIntoChaos · 04/07/2022 18:51

We split classes every year...it's pretty standard practise in many schools...perfectly normal! Your children will take their cues from you...so don't be 'that' parent and teach your children resilience!

Quartz2208 · 04/07/2022 18:48

@Faciadipasta are you friends with the mums of the boys no longer in the class?

DS has 2 friends from pre school he has never been in the same class at school as - they are both (and always have been) in the same class and they are still close and we often meet up after school

He went to a party of his best friend - 6 boys 2 from their old class 2 from the new

DailyMailHater · 04/07/2022 18:48

This happened to my child after spending practically all of year 4&5 at home the classes were mixed for them going into year 6….lots of tears and worry from lots of children and parents at the time….by the time September rolled round the kids were fine with it and my child has had the best year at school…new friends, more confident and not worried about going to secondary (which for a child previously diagnosed with anxiety is amazing)

Zwellers · 04/07/2022 18:46

Just so say this they will be able to meet their friends moved to another class at playtime isn't necessarily true. At schools by me they have individual playgrounds and don't meet each other at all.
I think mixing is tbe worst thing ever.every year you lose your friends and have to start again. I spent primary school mostly alone because of this.

BiFoldChampion · 04/07/2022 18:45

It’s usual in my eldest school to change class every year from Reception to Year 6. And then with my youngest they will change going into Juniors so the same as your child.

Isaidnoalready · 04/07/2022 18:44

In our school when ds year was mixed up the parents went insane literally rocking and crying "for their children" the children were understandably scared and anxious more because of the parents reaction than anything else the head had dozens of parents showing up to berate him one started a bloody petition ffs it was an insane reaction and they didn't do there children any good the transition to secondary school hit those children hardest and a couple didnt make it and dropped out several are being home schooled now because the parents cannot get there own way

It's literally not the end of the world

RandomMess · 04/07/2022 18:43

It sounds counter intuitive but him having that experience of having to make new friends will help him find it easier when he needs to in the future. Some DC come too reliant on a small long established friendship group and then if there are fall outs it has a massive detrimental affect on them.

Flowers
NerrSnerr · 04/07/2022 18:40

My eldest really struggles with change but as they do it every year we just keep reminding her that she has been in a new class before and it has always been fine. Children need to learn to adapt and there's no reason why friendship groups need to change if they don't want them to.