Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that the reporting of the deaths of people in the public eye is disgusting

191 replies

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 15:29

MN HQ, feel free to move this elsewhere if you think more appropriate.

Not long off the back of the Caroline Flack circus (And let's not get into that again, I am referring directly to their reporting in regards to a dead woman) we have this morning the news that sadly Jake McLean, who isn't actually a celebrity in himself, but the ex boyfriend of two, has died following a car crash. HIs girlfriend, Yasmin Oukhello who appears in TOWIE, is in intensive care.

The articles this morning talk at great length about Jake's 3 years in prison 10 years ago, his ex girlfriend Lauren Goodger using her interviews from 2013, Yasmin's ex boyfriend and his love life.

Why? Just why? Jake has a family. He presumably has parents, or siblings, friends, people who love him. It is unlikely that Yasmin even knows he is dead yet.

Why does it become acceptable to report in this manner when it's someone (barely) in the public eye? Do we stand up at funerals and say "He was in prison and he went out with Sarah in 2012". No, of course we don't.

All the papers are doing are opening the floodgates for the standard comments of "who", "he's not a celebrity", "he's a criminal so good", "talentless Z lister", etc etc etc.

But he is ultimately a man who has died and his family and friends have to read this shit. I honestly think it's disgusting. Its all over the internet and in every shop I've been in this morning, so god knows how his poor mother feels.

OP posts:
Samcro · 04/07/2022 16:05

just googled why he was in prison....
at least it sounds truthful, normally people are sainted when they die.

trailrunner85 · 04/07/2022 16:05

I'm assuming you haven't been in a corner shop or on any of the main newspaper websites today

I've been on several newspaper websites today but this is the first I've heard of the story you're talking about. I'm very sorry this guy (whoever he is) has died but, as a pp says, you are adding to the noise you claim to dislike so much.

The tabloids are covering this story because they cover celebrity news. If you don't follow celebrity news it's extremely easy to avoid it. It's certainly not "all over the Internet" unless you're deliberately searching for this sort of stuff, or going on Mail Online etc.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:05

coffeecupsandfairylights · 04/07/2022 16:03

But I think reporting on man's death and then focusing extensively on his love and life and the love life of his ex girlfriend (James Locke got a lengthy mention, and he's the ex boyfriend of his ex girlfriend!)

It's wrong.

He chose to put himself in the public eye by dating (multiple) people who were already "famous". If you choose to date celebrities then it's hardly surprising that your private life will be splashed across the tabloids - both when you're alive and in the event of your death.

Doesn't make it right

I'm ignoring the comments about me spreading it - is eveyrone feeling particularly vicious today?

OP posts:
beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:04

SavoirFlair · 04/07/2022 16:01

I think @Feelingsillyandgiddy is making the fair point that you’re amplifying it by discussing it

but let me ask you @beautyisthefaceisee do you think there should be the media equivalent of a “statute of limitations” in reporting?

I mean, if someone who was involved in the Khmer Rouge or former Yugoslavia atrocities dies, do we not report on their actions because it was decades ago?

Well, yes, on a discussion forum. I'm not sure why I'm in the wrong here.

No, but that's very different.

www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-10980101/Jake-McLeans-overturned-car-pictured-Turkey-Lauren-Goodger-seen-time-died.html

This is the latest one. Speculation about alcohol (despite the fact they blood test all drivers), photos of Yasmin's ex boyfriend, lots of chat about Jake's ex girlfriend Lauren and the fact she's pregnant - I thinkt his one left out his years in jail, I stopped reading.

Necessary?

that is VERY different to talking about someone who committed atrocities.

An article reporting on the accident, the fact that he was in jail if need be (although I'm still not sold that that is necessary) and an update on Yasmin would be sufficient. There is a photo of the overturned car FFS. Someone's sadly deceased son is in there, 3 years in jail 10 years ago or not.

They're vultures. The fact you can find their name on google doesn't change that.

OP posts:
Feelingsillyandgiddy · 04/07/2022 16:04

I’d never heard of them until this post so you’ve definitely spread it much wider

coffeecupsandfairylights · 04/07/2022 16:03

But I think reporting on man's death and then focusing extensively on his love and life and the love life of his ex girlfriend (James Locke got a lengthy mention, and he's the ex boyfriend of his ex girlfriend!)

It's wrong.

He chose to put himself in the public eye by dating (multiple) people who were already "famous". If you choose to date celebrities then it's hardly surprising that your private life will be splashed across the tabloids - both when you're alive and in the event of your death.

5foot5 · 04/07/2022 16:03

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 15:57

It's in every paper and on every social media platform today. Hardly breaking news. Strange comment.

Not that strange a comment. I thought exactly the same.

This thread is the first I have ever heard of the man, so yeah, you have spread information about all these aspects of his life to me at least

SavoirFlair · 04/07/2022 16:01

I think @Feelingsillyandgiddy is making the fair point that you’re amplifying it by discussing it

but let me ask you @beautyisthefaceisee do you think there should be the media equivalent of a “statute of limitations” in reporting?

I mean, if someone who was involved in the Khmer Rouge or former Yugoslavia atrocities dies, do we not report on their actions because it was decades ago?

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:00

ColadhSamh · 04/07/2022 15:59

I hadn't heard of him or his girlfriend until you posted it here.

I'm assuming you haven't been in a corner shop or on any of the main newspaper websites today, then.

OP posts:
ColadhSamh · 04/07/2022 15:59

I hadn't heard of him or his girlfriend until you posted it here.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 15:57

Feelingsillyandgiddy · 04/07/2022 15:52

You’ve just done the same by sharing the information?

It's in every paper and on every social media platform today. Hardly breaking news. Strange comment.

OP posts:
beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 15:57

SavoirFlair · 04/07/2022 15:50

He's not just the ex-boyfriend of one celebrity. He dated two TOWIE participants and a Hollyoaks actor. I'd say this self consciously puts him into the public eye.

He isn't a celebrity

Define celebrity in 2022.

If he was a bus driver...who had been to prison, it would not be mentioned in his obituary

He wouldn't necessarily have a public obituary in the newspaper unless someone contacted the newspaper and paid for it - which then allows for reverence and hagiography no matter what the public or criminal record states.

For others who have had repeated column inches written about them, it's up to the news outlet to report what is a matter of public record.

Let's say I was a person you knew, who happened to collaborate with a handful of men with masks and pistols and barged into your mother's house? Perhaps you would be less concerned about the reporting of my life.

I don't object to them reporting about the crime that he committed (in 2009). But I think reporting on man's death and then focusing extensively on his love and life and the love life of his ex girlfriend (James Locke got a lengthy mention, and he's the ex boyfriend of his ex girlfriend!)

It's wrong.

OP posts:
Feelingsillyandgiddy · 04/07/2022 15:52

You’ve just done the same by sharing the information?

SavoirFlair · 04/07/2022 15:50

He's not just the ex-boyfriend of one celebrity. He dated two TOWIE participants and a Hollyoaks actor. I'd say this self consciously puts him into the public eye.

He isn't a celebrity

Define celebrity in 2022.

If he was a bus driver...who had been to prison, it would not be mentioned in his obituary

He wouldn't necessarily have a public obituary in the newspaper unless someone contacted the newspaper and paid for it - which then allows for reverence and hagiography no matter what the public or criminal record states.

For others who have had repeated column inches written about them, it's up to the news outlet to report what is a matter of public record.

Let's say I was a person you knew, who happened to collaborate with a handful of men with masks and pistols and barged into your mother's house? Perhaps you would be less concerned about the reporting of my life.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 15:42

SavoirFlair · 04/07/2022 15:38

Those actions which took place are part of the notoriety for which he was known for.

he lived a life that was self-consciously on public record and he most likely made money from his positioning of his life that way.

So I’m sorry but YABU - obituaries aren’t hagiography, you can’t pick and choose what’s good if much of your life was spent in criminality, or publicly dating people in pursuit of fame

Did you read my post?

Jake is the ex boyfriend of a celebrity tbe fact he hit the public eye when he went to prison was because Lauren goodger talked about him. He isn't a celebrity so no he didnt make money that way. And how do you know he dated her in pursuit of fame?! Essex is a small place and they all date each other.

I honestly canf get my head round how you think that a young man who lost his life in s tragic manner deserves that reporting because hes a celebrity.

If he was a bus driver or a shop worker who had been to prison, it would not be mentioned in his obituary or his funeral. He dkdnt sign up to that by dating someone (barely) in the public eye.

OP posts:
SavoirFlair · 04/07/2022 15:38

Those actions which took place are part of the notoriety for which he was known for.

he lived a life that was self-consciously on public record and he most likely made money from his positioning of his life that way.

So I’m sorry but YABU - obituaries aren’t hagiography, you can’t pick and choose what’s good if much of your life was spent in criminality, or publicly dating people in pursuit of fame