Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that the reporting of the deaths of people in the public eye is disgusting

191 replies

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 15:29

MN HQ, feel free to move this elsewhere if you think more appropriate.

Not long off the back of the Caroline Flack circus (And let's not get into that again, I am referring directly to their reporting in regards to a dead woman) we have this morning the news that sadly Jake McLean, who isn't actually a celebrity in himself, but the ex boyfriend of two, has died following a car crash. HIs girlfriend, Yasmin Oukhello who appears in TOWIE, is in intensive care.

The articles this morning talk at great length about Jake's 3 years in prison 10 years ago, his ex girlfriend Lauren Goodger using her interviews from 2013, Yasmin's ex boyfriend and his love life.

Why? Just why? Jake has a family. He presumably has parents, or siblings, friends, people who love him. It is unlikely that Yasmin even knows he is dead yet.

Why does it become acceptable to report in this manner when it's someone (barely) in the public eye? Do we stand up at funerals and say "He was in prison and he went out with Sarah in 2012". No, of course we don't.

All the papers are doing are opening the floodgates for the standard comments of "who", "he's not a celebrity", "he's a criminal so good", "talentless Z lister", etc etc etc.

But he is ultimately a man who has died and his family and friends have to read this shit. I honestly think it's disgusting. Its all over the internet and in every shop I've been in this morning, so god knows how his poor mother feels.

OP posts:
WatchoRulo · 04/07/2022 16:46

I'm interested in the way we treat people in the public eye as opposed to anyone else.
It's not "we" though - it's only the tabloid press and people who keep it afloat by buying/clicking - and that's not all of us.
Are you arguing for some kind of regulation of the press? Because that's a very dangerous route for the few times when they actually uncover some wrongdoing.

CupidStunt22 · 04/07/2022 16:45

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:17

Well, I'm a woman, on a predominantly female site - do you get the impression I've been respected for my opinion? I certainly dont't. I see things on MN every day that I don't agree with but I certainly don't pile on (especially as it's hardly a controversial view!)

Are you under the bizarre impression that you should get automatic respect for all opinions you come forth with? Why?

I have no idea what you want from this thread. Vaguely famous person dies, tabloids wank on about their life. So what? It was ever so. Who cares?

ParanoidGynodroid · 04/07/2022 16:45

I'd never heard of either of them either. And I have looked at online news today and seen nothing about this.

I do see now that it has been mentioned on BBC news, but I only saw it because I looked for it; and the BBC say nothing about him having been in prison. Very little about him at all, actually.

Might I venture to suggest that you're perhaps not looking at the best quality news outlets, and that those you do - i.e. tabloids - are never respectful to anyone. Neither in life nor in death.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:45

WatchoRulo · 04/07/2022 16:43

I don't use Facebook, don't read tabloid press (or in fact any press on the whole), so I don't see this. If a relative of mine died I wouldn't be subjected to all the reporting because I don't read it.
If we all stopped reading this inane tattle, they wouldn't publish it.

True

But there's a poster on here, the case was quite public, and she's the mother of the murdered daughter.

She said on a thread yesterday (the one about the crass condolences) that when she looked on her social media, because it was headline news at the time she had to read awful comments about her daughter and it made things 100 times worse. We've all seen what idiots write on social media - trolling doesn't always have a reason.

The fact someone's in the public eye as a job doesn't make them any less or more devastated than that woman (who is another reason I always think of the ones left behind).

OP posts:
WatchoRulo · 04/07/2022 16:43

I don't use Facebook, don't read tabloid press (or in fact any press on the whole), so I don't see this. If a relative of mine died I wouldn't be subjected to all the reporting because I don't read it.
If we all stopped reading this inane tattle, they wouldn't publish it.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:41

WatchoRulo · 04/07/2022 16:40

Essex is a small place and they all date each other.
😂

You know what I mean. They do!

Programmes like Ex on the Beach wouldn't get off the ground if they didnt.

They all know each other from the same scene. Hardly the crime of the century - him dating a TOWIE girl doesn't indicate wanting fame, does it?

OP posts:
Crikeyalmighty · 04/07/2022 16:41

I don't go into politics, purely because they pick your life to shreds- sadly that's how it is these days

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:41

SavoirFlair · 04/07/2022 16:34

“I studied Sociology and celebrity culture”

Could I gently ask - if this is the case, why the outrage and surprise on this reporting? Or is it more you’re interested in the continued reporting on people who place themselves by association in the public eye?

I’m presuming the course material you studied didn’t begin with lesson 1 “If you can’t say anything nice then don’t say anything at all” and ended with “be kind” …and there was more analysis than this?

I’m curious to get your take on this though please - You mentioned Mike earlier, and this poor deceased chap.. surely we only know of these people because their “real” lives were exposed, by association or by design, to the newspapers?

So what I’m asking is, do you accept that some people could cultivate a sense of notoriety-by-association that means they become “newsworthy” due to being know ?

If not, look up how Backgrid and Splash and other photo news agencies work. While folk cry outrage at “intrusion” and “people unable to live their lives in private”, you’d be surprised what actually takes place to get all those “overheard conversations with EXCLUSIVE photos” into the papers

Well, it was a good 10 years ago, and I've changed career since, but I still like to keep on top of what my pupils are likely to be seeing (The Jesy Nelson documentary for example). Don't get me started on tiktok!

I'm not surprised, or outraged.

I'm interested in the way we treat people in the public eye as opposed to anyone else.

Gareth Edwards - the press went to his family home to tell them they had HIV before he could. Stephanie Davis - she begged them not to run a false story as it would affect her baby but they laughed and did it anyway. Jacqueline Jossa has spoken out numerous times about the constant photos of her weight and nobody is interested. None of these people deserve it because they have a profession in the public eye, none of them. Even though Caroline is a contentious one, was it still necessary for her poor mother to see her blood splashed over the paper daily? (and yes, it wans't his, it was hers). And if you want to say otherwise - did that poor soul Milly's mother deserve to have her phone hacked? Because the murder was in the public eye? Do people deserve to have pictures of their crashed cars?

As I've admitted, it's pressed my buttons more today because I watched the documentary last night.

I understand they are exposed - you can tell an exposed story from a non exposed. Whatever "source" they asked this morning literally said they didn't know if Yasmin and him were still together. Great source.

I think it's worse now than ever before, and Idon't understand why anyone is defending it.

OP posts:
WatchoRulo · 04/07/2022 16:40

Essex is a small place and they all date each other.
😂

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:35

Imabouttoexplode · 04/07/2022 16:35

No one is being spiteful and vicious. They're disagreeing with you in a robust fashion and giving a strong challenge. People are allowed different viewpoints. Hold on to your own beliefs if you feel strongly about them and do try not to drag out the ridiculous feminist lines and women having to support women etc. You just lose credibility. Your standpoint should stand on its own merits.

I don't have an issue with viewpoints. I have an issue with people talking amongst themselves about my motives and questioning my credibility. Thought that was banned on MN?

OP posts:
beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:35

trailrunner85 · 04/07/2022 16:32

It's nobody's "fault", you absolute drama llama.

The point is, your Facebook feed will be a feed of updates from friends and from news sites you follow.
If your friends don't post celeb gossip, and you don't follow tabloid news sites, you won't see this stuff on Facebook. It's very simple.

All I see on Facebook is a mix of politics; articles on running; updates from my friends (mostly pics of kids tbh) and updates from musicians I like. Because that's what I choose to follow..

Why are you personally being so rude to me?

and no, that's not the point. I regularly get stupid ads (I bought a rainbow themed dress two years ago and I still get ads for dresses in that colour). Reading one celebrity story does not mean I follow it religiously. But I'm a 30 year old woman so statistically they are going to think I'm interested in that.

OP posts:
Imabouttoexplode · 04/07/2022 16:35

No one is being spiteful and vicious. They're disagreeing with you in a robust fashion and giving a strong challenge. People are allowed different viewpoints. Hold on to your own beliefs if you feel strongly about them and do try not to drag out the ridiculous feminist lines and women having to support women etc. You just lose credibility. Your standpoint should stand on its own merits.

SavoirFlair · 04/07/2022 16:34

“I studied Sociology and celebrity culture”

Could I gently ask - if this is the case, why the outrage and surprise on this reporting? Or is it more you’re interested in the continued reporting on people who place themselves by association in the public eye?

I’m presuming the course material you studied didn’t begin with lesson 1 “If you can’t say anything nice then don’t say anything at all” and ended with “be kind” …and there was more analysis than this?

I’m curious to get your take on this though please - You mentioned Mike earlier, and this poor deceased chap.. surely we only know of these people because their “real” lives were exposed, by association or by design, to the newspapers?

So what I’m asking is, do you accept that some people could cultivate a sense of notoriety-by-association that means they become “newsworthy” due to being know ?

If not, look up how Backgrid and Splash and other photo news agencies work. While folk cry outrage at “intrusion” and “people unable to live their lives in private”, you’d be surprised what actually takes place to get all those “overheard conversations with EXCLUSIVE photos” into the papers

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:33

phishy · 04/07/2022 16:33

Wonder how many of the articles OP read with bated breath before posting.

I've no idea what this means.

OP posts:
beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:33

Mumoftwoinprimary · 04/07/2022 16:32

But the PP who suggested I have a motive and must have come on here to, what, profit in some way from a man's death? The faux pretence that it's not all over the tabloids because its not on the bloody BBC so I must be here in bad intentions? You don't htink that's spiteful?

There are a number of tabloid journalists who use mumsnet as a way of researching / obtaining / publicising stories.

Mumsnetters are getting wise to this so a simple “what do you think about X” no longer does the job. If I was a tabloid journalist who had written a story about this and I wanted to get more clicks then one way of doing it would be to post a post like yours claiming to disapprove and then hope we all got cross too and looked up their story to find out all about it and be able to discuss it.

That doesn’t mean that you are a journalist. But a number of people (including myself) now know the name of this man and that he had been in prison. And had you not posted your message then I wouldn’t have.

Oh you couldn't pay me the millions to be a journo! I'm currently on another thread talking about working in a school.

Thanks for clarifying what they thought I meant, though! That makes sense.

I watched Caroline Flack's documentary last night and her wee mother's face is still with me (regardless of her actions, don't want to get into that, but it wasn't her mother) so maybe it's made me super sensitive this morning.

OP posts:
phishy · 04/07/2022 16:33

Wonder how many of the articles OP read with bated breath before posting.

trailrunner85 · 04/07/2022 16:32

It's nobody's "fault", you absolute drama llama.

The point is, your Facebook feed will be a feed of updates from friends and from news sites you follow.
If your friends don't post celeb gossip, and you don't follow tabloid news sites, you won't see this stuff on Facebook. It's very simple.

All I see on Facebook is a mix of politics; articles on running; updates from my friends (mostly pics of kids tbh) and updates from musicians I like. Because that's what I choose to follow..

Mumoftwoinprimary · 04/07/2022 16:32

But the PP who suggested I have a motive and must have come on here to, what, profit in some way from a man's death? The faux pretence that it's not all over the tabloids because its not on the bloody BBC so I must be here in bad intentions? You don't htink that's spiteful?

There are a number of tabloid journalists who use mumsnet as a way of researching / obtaining / publicising stories.

Mumsnetters are getting wise to this so a simple “what do you think about X” no longer does the job. If I was a tabloid journalist who had written a story about this and I wanted to get more clicks then one way of doing it would be to post a post like yours claiming to disapprove and then hope we all got cross too and looked up their story to find out all about it and be able to discuss it.

That doesn’t mean that you are a journalist. But a number of people (including myself) now know the name of this man and that he had been in prison. And had you not posted your message then I wouldn’t have.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 04/07/2022 16:29

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:05

Doesn't make it right

I'm ignoring the comments about me spreading it - is eveyrone feeling particularly vicious today?

I don't agree.

He chose to put himself out there - nobody made him date those people and no doubt he did so to try and get himself "famous" too. Don't date a series of celebrities who splash their lives over the tabloids if you don't want your private life out there for the world to see.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:29

calmlakes · 04/07/2022 16:27

I knew someone (distantly) who died young in an accident overseas. But because they hadn't engaged in any reality star nonsense they got brief and non intrusive write up in the papers that noted the incident.

I do think this individual's personal choices are what has led to his write ups being what they are.

I am sorry for your loss OP. 💐

Cheers, calmlakes.

I hadn't thought about why it touched a nerve, but maybe that's why. I don't care what these people do for jobs, but I do think about their mums and dads.

I was the same with Caroline Flack, and Stephen Gately. I just kept thinking about their poor siblings and parents who had to read this shit.

OP posts:
beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:28

trailrunner85 · 04/07/2022 16:27

Look up the daily mail, the sun and then come back and apologise

You've absolutely proved your point. The only newspapers covering this are the tabloids. Which people don't read if they don't want to read celebrity news.

You also said you saw this on Facebook this morning. And that's entirely down to you, and who you follow/who your friends are. Again, if you don't follow celebrity gossip or have friends that do, you wouldn't have seen this.

Fuck me, so it's my friends faults as well now!

OP posts:
trailrunner85 · 04/07/2022 16:27

Look up the daily mail, the sun and then come back and apologise

You've absolutely proved your point. The only newspapers covering this are the tabloids. Which people don't read if they don't want to read celebrity news.

You also said you saw this on Facebook this morning. And that's entirely down to you, and who you follow/who your friends are. Again, if you don't follow celebrity gossip or have friends that do, you wouldn't have seen this.

calmlakes · 04/07/2022 16:27

I knew someone (distantly) who died young in an accident overseas. But because they hadn't engaged in any reality star nonsense they got brief and non intrusive write up in the papers that noted the incident.

I do think this individual's personal choices are what has led to his write ups being what they are.

I am sorry for your loss OP. 💐

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:26

Mumoftwoinprimary · 04/07/2022 16:24

Yes, because the BBC regularly reports on things like that.

Look up the daily mail, the sun and then come back and apologise

Personally I choose to “vote with my feet” about things like this. I don’t like tabloid style journalism so I never ever read the tabloids. I get my news from places such as BBC News Online where - as you say - they don’t report on things like that.

If you don’t like the way the tabloids report then don’t read them. If enough of us do that then the tabloids will have to change their methods. But you can’t read them all and then tell us all to look up them all and then wonder why they print stories like this.

Hadnt actually thought about it like that in terms of the clicks.

OP posts:
beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:26

AtwilightRebellion · 04/07/2022 16:24

Nothing that I read or am on. I had to look up who you were talking about.

The outlets reporting it are not where I usually spend my time so yabu as 'reporting' is really only happening in tabloids and the like.

If it disgusts you then don't look.

"if it disgusts you dont look" Is that a society we want though? Journalists behaving however they like?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread