Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say No to a stranger

235 replies

Myhousemyrules22 · 04/07/2022 13:52

Firstly, I know I am not being unreasonable, I just need a rant and a whinge.

My manager has asked me to house one of our new locums and has accused me of being racists and sexist for saying no. Their race is not amongst any of the reasons I'm refusing but I'm furious it's been insinuated.

I previously had a different locum stay with me. They stayed 2 weeks, only Monday to Friday. I'd already worked with the woman for a year, built up a great rapport and friendship and she asked me as a favour as she had some temporary transport issues.

The new locum I met at 9.30 this morning. He is looking for a long term room to let (6-12 months). He's already said something that makes me think he's not someone I would like to be more than civil colleagues with.

My male manager has accused me of being racists because this new locum is of BME origin. The fact is he is a strange man and as a woman living otherwise alone I wouldn't feel comfortable. This then led to me being told I'm sexist (because I've previously agreed to my female colleague stay).

My house is my home. Surely I get to decide who stays without being accused of bigotry.

OP posts:
blubberyboo · 05/07/2022 17:55

Or if your union rep really feels like a monetary compensation is deserved it needs to take the form of something one off so that you can move on and not forever be the office gossip

blubberyboo · 05/07/2022 17:50

Yea I’m not sure about the response really. As a knee jerk reaction it may seem nice for him to apologise with flowers, and them to offer you taxis home but I don’t think this gets to the root of the problem.

the vagina comment and flowers still screams loudly of him not understanding the gravity of what he has done and thinking that you are somehow so delicate with a vagina that he shouldn’t have asked you to house someone. He has misunderstood what his wife has tried to explain I reckon. Instead of accepting that a woman or any person can object to something without being defamed he is patting you down with something he wouldn’t do to a male employee in order to pacify you.

the taxi thing would make me so uncomfortable around the rest of my colleagues to be honest cos after a while they certainly will get pissed at you getting this special treatment and will gossip and moan about it behind your back every time you submit a claim. If your management changes then you have to have this whole fiasco explained to them over and over again never putting it to bed.

I think you need to make the focus all about a public and written apology , and the retraining for him with no reference to your genitals therein.

Aquamarine1029 · 05/07/2022 17:38

I can't even believe he gave you flowers, as if you're his fucking jilted girlfriend. That alone is so unprofessional it's staggering.

YankeeDad · 05/07/2022 17:36

The key question is whether you can continue working for this manager, with you and he each knowing that he humiliated his own self by making a stupid mistake. In his mind and heart, you will be associated with that mistake and with his humiliation, even though it is his own damn fault and purely a result of his own very poor judgement and lack of good sense.

If he is professional enough to contain that humiliation as his own problem, learn from it, and move on, then it would be potentially OK. However, he sounds highly unprofessional in general (he gave you flowers wtf ??? 🙄) so I would have doubts about that.

I am pleased that the organisation at least took you seriously and is signalling that they take your side, but what they are actually doing about it does look like trying to mend fences on the cheap, so to speak.

In the medium to long term, it seems unlikely that you will be able to be happy or to have undamaged career prospects unless he goes elsewhere or you go elsewhere, at least into a different department if not a different organisation.

The fairest outcome, and probably the best outcome for the organisation, would be if he were to leave very soon (voluntarily or not). A next best could be if he were "managed out," or at least managed away from your department if they want to give him the chance to show he has learned from his mistakes. But if he remains your manager, then you may well be better off starting to look elsewhere, maybe not immediately, but probably rather soon, rather than wait for clear evidence as to whether your career progression is being derailed while you continue to work for this knucklehead manager.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/07/2022 17:25

Just to clarify the bit about him having "no idea what it's like to have a vagina", is this what was actually said, or a reference you made yourself to being a woman?

Because if it's the first then I'd agree with PPs that he's actually learned nothing

billy1966 · 05/07/2022 17:15

They know that this is very, very serious incident that has occurred.

I would not be agreeing to working for him any longer.

He slandered, defamed, and tried to intimidate you to allow a man to stay with you in your home.

He called you ugly names when you said no.

The vagina statement is more of the same.

So offensive.

A less confident woman might have been coerced into this.

It is so shocking.

That list is a direct response to how seriously they realise this would be viewed.

An external review of how an incident so serious, in front of others, could occur, would not be unreasonable.

Do not agree to work with him again.

Get ACAS's advice.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/07/2022 17:13

Sounds reasonable so far, and I agree that HR will have worried about just how far you could take this, but I also agree that you should see how things go in the immediate future before accepting anything

It's just possible that someone like this could revert to type now he's done his little performance - possible too that any supporters he has could try to make things awkward for you, which could create further problems over something that's simply not your fault

What's your union rep's view?

Aquamarine1029 · 05/07/2022 17:06

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 05/07/2022 16:59

Why would the department be paying for your taxi home late at night? - if that’s the case they would need to do that for all colleagues working lates.

I’m aware it’s off point, I can understand the other 3 actions as they directly in relation to the complaint, not this one tho?

It's bribery, plan and simple. Throwing whatever they can at the problem in hopes it goes away.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 05/07/2022 16:59

Why would the department be paying for your taxi home late at night? - if that’s the case they would need to do that for all colleagues working lates.

I’m aware it’s off point, I can understand the other 3 actions as they directly in relation to the complaint, not this one tho?

Aquamarine1029 · 05/07/2022 16:38

Myhousemyrules22 · 05/07/2022 12:26

Oooook. So it's been an interesting morning.

Turns out manager went home and told his wife who has proper laid into him (they have two young teenage daughters). He's come in with flowers and a personal letter of apology that pretty much tells me how he's a dumb man who has no idea about how it is to have a vagina (he looks like he's been crying all night) and he's basically jumping through every hoop HR tell him to to keep his job including;

A formal written apology
A statement to the department
He has to undergo some in-house diversity training, something about bullying as well as an out of house program in management.

I'm getting
Funded taxis home from late shifts
His apologies and retributions
A one off payment of thanks for previously housing a locum (I didn't ask for this, and I suspect it's pittence of hush money wrapped up in a 'we (hr) aren't saying sorry bow' but hey, I'll take it)
The right to come back to this at any point in the next 2 years if it's caused any unforeseen issues not yet felt.
I was offered the rest of the week off paid but I've done nothing wrong to hide away from and if I go away it makes me look like I am wrong.

I haven't signed anything yet to agree this can be put to bed because I want to see how things play out in the next day or two. HR said that's fine.

I've read this and thought about it.

It's not enough. He should be sacked with immediate effect.

What he has done and what he has accused you of is so egregious that him keeping his position of authority is absolutely unacceptable. This was not a "mistake." That is exactly what I would be telling HR. I'd tell them to take their "deal" and shove it.

purplecorkheart · 05/07/2022 15:34

madasawethen · 05/07/2022 13:21

Turns out manager went home and told his wife who has proper laid into him (they have two young teenage daughters). He's come in with flowers and a personal letter of apology that pretty much tells me how he's a dumb man who has no idea about how it is to have a vagina

How shockingly inappropriate! He STILL does not get it.
Needed his wife to tell a grown man he is wrong. Brings you flowers. Speaking about not having a vagina.

He would not have dared write that to a man nor have brought a man in flowers as an apology. Inappropriate and sexist.

He needs to be sacked.

I agree. To be honest he sounds like he is covering his ass and putting on a show for HR. The flowers and the no idea about what it is to have a vagina speaks volumes. I think he is worried about his job rather than you. if it was male workmate who complained him, he would not be bring flowers, telling about his wife's reaction. I assure you he was not crying all night either.

GabriellaMontez · 05/07/2022 15:18

I'm so glad your company took it seriously. Outrageous bullying behaviour.

gogogadgetgo · 05/07/2022 14:08

I don't get what the vagina bit has to do with it.

If you were a bloke it'd be okay to force you into taking him in?

Or if it was another woman it would be fine?

How about it's my property and I'll only have people I want to in my house?

I would also ask what's happening with the fact he made it public. Have you mentioned the comments you got from other team members? Frankly I would.

But glad it's been taken seriously.

Newestname002 · 05/07/2022 13:47

@Myhousemyrules22

^A formal written apology
A statement to the department
He has to undergo some in-house diversity training, something about bullying as well as an out of house program in management.
^

Glad he's beginning to get an inkling that he has been monumentally unprofessional and sexist at the very least, OP. Shame it took another woman (his wife) to make him really see the error of his accusations- and in public, too. I wonder if she suggested how she and their daughters would react if they'd been out in the position he put you in.

Also, yes, take your time in deciding what you wish to do next. Particularly continuing with him as your manager. He's really just covering himself, isn't he, now he's recognising - with assistance from others - how his own actions will now affect him.

Additionally, I hope HR, or whoever else is responsible (not just him) sends out a company-wide reminder of the company's policy (with an attached copy) on personal and corporate responsibility regarding bullying and the consequences of those behaving in this fashion. 🌹

FlipFlopShopInHawaii · 05/07/2022 13:46

That's a good outcome OP, and the fact they offered it all off the bat seems to me they're terrified of what you could do.

Newestname002 · 05/07/2022 13:46

@Myhousemyrules22

^A formal written apology
A statement to the department
He has to undergo some in-house diversity training, something about bullying as well as an out of house program in management.
^

Glad he's beginning to get an inkling that he has been monumentally unprofessional and sexist at the very least, OP. Shame it took another woman (his wife) to make him really see the error of his accusations- and in public, too. I wonder if she suggested how she and their daughters would react if they'd been out in the position he put you in.

Also, yes, take your time in deciding what you wish to do next. Particularly continuing with him as your manager. He's really just covering himself, isn't he, now he's recognising - with assistance from others - how his own actions will now affect him.

Additionally, I hope HR, or whoever else is responsible (not just him) sends out a company-wide reminder of the company's policy (with an attached copy) on personal and corporate responsibility regarding bullying and the consequences of those behaving in this fashion. 🌹

123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 05/07/2022 13:39

Parpophone · 05/07/2022 13:32

@123becauseicouldntthinkofone Did you get your well deserved apology OP?

OP updated an hour before your post.

Thanks, i went for lunch and left open before replying so mustnt have refreshed

BadNomad · 05/07/2022 13:37

tells me how he's a dumb man who has no idea about how it is to have a vagina

It's not his lack of vagina that is the problem. But he's never going to get that. He'd need a brain for that.

Parpophone · 05/07/2022 13:32

@123becauseicouldntthinkofone Did you get your well deserved apology OP?

OP updated an hour before your post.

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 05/07/2022 13:29

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 16:08

I would be inclined to say your manager is sexist for assuming its a woman's job to host a locum

The fact he views women as 'support humans' seems pretty evident.

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 05/07/2022 13:23

Myhousemyrules22 · 04/07/2022 14:18

They can't insist but they're effectively trying to bully me into allowing it. I've emailed HR and copied in his manager (who works over multiple sites and isn't here today) and my union rep.

Its my house, I own it/pay the mortgage.

I appreciate the manager is desperate. Our department is on its knees through short staffing and rentals round here are currently in short supply. But that's not my problem. Its not so much the initial asking. I like to help people and yes the room is empty. Its the things he's then said about me for saying no that's infuriated me.

I know I'm not in the wrong. I suspect I'll have a very big apology by the end of the day.

well done there's a huge difference between you offering to share with the previous colleague you know well and your manager asking you to share with a stranger. The bullying accusations suggesting that no wasn't a reasonable answer and needed to be justified to your managers satisfaction is in my opinion a serious issue.

madasawethen · 05/07/2022 13:21

Turns out manager went home and told his wife who has proper laid into him (they have two young teenage daughters). He's come in with flowers and a personal letter of apology that pretty much tells me how he's a dumb man who has no idea about how it is to have a vagina

How shockingly inappropriate! He STILL does not get it.
Needed his wife to tell a grown man he is wrong. Brings you flowers. Speaking about not having a vagina.

He would not have dared write that to a man nor have brought a man in flowers as an apology. Inappropriate and sexist.

He needs to be sacked.

123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 05/07/2022 13:20

Myhousemyrules22 · 04/07/2022 14:18

They can't insist but they're effectively trying to bully me into allowing it. I've emailed HR and copied in his manager (who works over multiple sites and isn't here today) and my union rep.

Its my house, I own it/pay the mortgage.

I appreciate the manager is desperate. Our department is on its knees through short staffing and rentals round here are currently in short supply. But that's not my problem. Its not so much the initial asking. I like to help people and yes the room is empty. Its the things he's then said about me for saying no that's infuriated me.

I know I'm not in the wrong. I suspect I'll have a very big apology by the end of the day.

Did you get your well deserved apology OP?

AchatAVendre · 05/07/2022 13:14

Well, HR must have rightly recognised that you would have had a near watertight and highly embarrassing case against them for constructive dismissal or possibly a sex discrimination claim if they hadn't sorted this out.

I know employment rights are being eroded a bit in the UK, but seriously being expected to give up the privacy of your own home to house random male workers on the command of a manager as an expected part of your job?

I don't think there is an amount someone could actually be paid to make that worthwhile.

Johnnysgirl · 05/07/2022 12:46

letter of apology that pretty much tells me how he's a dumb man who has no idea about how it is to have a vagina
Not sure I get this? It's not just the fact that he expected you to take a man into your house at his request, isn't?
It's the fact that he made such a request at all. Man, woman or child; it hardly makes a difference?

Swipe left for the next trending thread