Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say No to a stranger

235 replies

Myhousemyrules22 · 04/07/2022 13:52

Firstly, I know I am not being unreasonable, I just need a rant and a whinge.

My manager has asked me to house one of our new locums and has accused me of being racists and sexist for saying no. Their race is not amongst any of the reasons I'm refusing but I'm furious it's been insinuated.

I previously had a different locum stay with me. They stayed 2 weeks, only Monday to Friday. I'd already worked with the woman for a year, built up a great rapport and friendship and she asked me as a favour as she had some temporary transport issues.

The new locum I met at 9.30 this morning. He is looking for a long term room to let (6-12 months). He's already said something that makes me think he's not someone I would like to be more than civil colleagues with.

My male manager has accused me of being racists because this new locum is of BME origin. The fact is he is a strange man and as a woman living otherwise alone I wouldn't feel comfortable. This then led to me being told I'm sexist (because I've previously agreed to my female colleague stay).

My house is my home. Surely I get to decide who stays without being accused of bigotry.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
YouOKHun · 06/07/2022 17:22

I agree with @billy1966 @AchatAVendre @Aquamarine1029 (and others). The apology with flowers is very telling and I would imagine he’s not really understood and is likely to return to type over time or repeat similar elsewhere. I don’t know about brilliant outcome but the correct outcome is for him to be sacked.

blubberyboo · 06/07/2022 11:45

@CandidaAlbicans2

none of us truly believed he used the word vagina exactly but OP hasn’t come back to clarify exactly what he did say.

however, he clearly was making some sort of reference to him not understanding what it is like to be a woman which means he still thinks he could have pushed a male employee into doing it, and also that she is somehow more delicate for being a woman.

he should simply have said “ I clearly have no ideas of boundaries and the limits of my own authority, and I apologise for dragging your name thru the gutter”

Emotionalsupportviper · 06/07/2022 10:48

CandidaAlbicans2 · 06/07/2022 09:12

@MadeForThis @purplecorkheart @billy1966 @Puzzledandpissedoff @blubberyboo @Emotionalsupportviper @MoveOnTheCards
I don't think the manager mentioned vagina. OP said:

He's come in with flowers and a personal letter of apology that pretty much tells me how he's a dumb man who has no idea about how it is to have a vagina

which to me reads as it was OP's interpretation of his actions that he clearly has no idea what it's like to be a woman

Apologies - I mis-interpreted OP's post.

Thank you for clarifying it. (I thought he was being a particularly patronising PITA and trying to be "funny")

Annoyedwithmyself · 06/07/2022 09:54

Yeah I think that's paraphrasing. Unless this guy's ambition is to be permanently unemployable.

CaptainMyCaptain · 06/07/2022 09:52

CandidaAlbicans2 · 06/07/2022 09:12

@MadeForThis @purplecorkheart @billy1966 @Puzzledandpissedoff @blubberyboo @Emotionalsupportviper @MoveOnTheCards
I don't think the manager mentioned vagina. OP said:

He's come in with flowers and a personal letter of apology that pretty much tells me how he's a dumb man who has no idea about how it is to have a vagina

which to me reads as it was OP's interpretation of his actions that he clearly has no idea what it's like to be a woman

That is also how I interpreted it. If he had actually said the 'vagina' bit that would be cause for another official complaint.

RincewindsHat · 06/07/2022 09:43

Catching up, sounds like his reality check got well and truly given :)

RincewindsHat · 06/07/2022 09:42

Holy wow! Your manager seriously expects you to take a strange man into your home when you live alone and when you decline (on vey reasonable grounds of safety) he calls you racist? Insanity. That wanker needs a reality check (your manager, I mean).

Puzzledandpissedoff · 06/07/2022 09:37

I don't think the manager mentioned vagina. OP said: "He's come in with flowers and a personal letter of apology that pretty much tells me how he's a dumb man who has no idea about how it is to have a vagina"

I know, Candida, but folk have mentioned it as if the manager actually used the words himself, which is why I was trying to clarify

Spot on, though, about the flowers and taxis ...

CandidaAlbicans2 · 06/07/2022 09:18

I agree with PPs that the flowers weren't a good move. They are a cliched apology of the "man does something dickish to a woman and this is what he thinks will sort it" type. The fact that it's extremely unlikely that he'd send apology flowers to a male colleague just highlights the inappropriateness of the gesture.

The offer of late night taxis is another bad idea as that can easily cause divisions in the workforce unless everyone on late shifts are offered them.

CandidaAlbicans2 · 06/07/2022 09:12

@MadeForThis @purplecorkheart @billy1966 @Puzzledandpissedoff @blubberyboo @Emotionalsupportviper @MoveOnTheCards
I don't think the manager mentioned vagina. OP said:

He's come in with flowers and a personal letter of apology that pretty much tells me how he's a dumb man who has no idea about how it is to have a vagina

which to me reads as it was OP's interpretation of his actions that he clearly has no idea what it's like to be a woman

PuckeredArseFace · 06/07/2022 08:39

Hmm, I don't think he's getting it either
I think he's just ticking the boxes to cover his arse

HappyDays40 · 06/07/2022 05:27

So glad it's sorted OP. I just find it really strange that they didn't sort out accomodation for the locum prior to taking the job or to expect the locum to have done. Did he just show up to work with a suitcase and a hopeful smile?

Flangelica · 06/07/2022 00:40

This was a very satisfying thread to read.

madasawethen · 06/07/2022 00:25

The personal letter and flowers incident to HR. Completely inappropriate.

I don't know how politically savvy you are OP but they know how serious this is. I wouldn't be settling for these token ok be quiet now offerings.

You should at least be getting a pay rise and promotion out of this

Personally, I would be sliding right into his job while he was on his way out.
But I'm old and experienced by way of getting screwed over a couple times earlier in my career, before wising up.

MoveOnTheCards · 05/07/2022 23:20

He actually wrote that about not having a vagina?

Johnnysgirl · 05/07/2022 22:17

Listen to billy1966, op.
This is not a "brilliant outcome!" at all. Yet...

billy1966 · 05/07/2022 21:29

billy1966 · 05/07/2022 19:36

OP,
The optics of this couldn't be more shocking for any organisation.

You have dozens and dozens of posters telling you that this is unbelievable behaviour.

Do not allow this fxxker to ever feel he can exert any control over you again.

I'm with @Aquamarine1029 .....flowers?

WTF.....I would be telling him where to stick his flowers.

You do owe this man nicey, nicey little woman.

You do NOT owe this man nicey, nicey woman.

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/07/2022 20:53

WTF.....I would be telling him where to stick his flowers.

I agree - it's rather patronising that he thinks a bunch or carnations (or whatever) will be enough to win you over after that bullying attempt.

And the "vagina" comment is a bliddy disgrace! I'd go back to HR about that TBH.

I'm not surprised his wife went down his neck - she knows EXACTLY how close he is to losing his job. And I'll bet if she heard that sexist "I don't know what it's like to have a vagina" she's kick his *rse again.

He's going from bad to worse, TBH. I don;t see how you can work with him again - ever.

billy1966 · 05/07/2022 19:36

OP,
The optics of this couldn't be more shocking for any organisation.

You have dozens and dozens of posters telling you that this is unbelievable behaviour.

Do not allow this fxxker to ever feel he can exert any control over you again.

I'm with @Aquamarine1029 .....flowers?

WTF.....I would be telling him where to stick his flowers.

You do owe this man nicey, nicey little woman.

AchatAVendre · 05/07/2022 19:36

Aquamarine1029 · 05/07/2022 16:38

I've read this and thought about it.

It's not enough. He should be sacked with immediate effect.

What he has done and what he has accused you of is so egregious that him keeping his position of authority is absolutely unacceptable. This was not a "mistake." That is exactly what I would be telling HR. I'd tell them to take their "deal" and shove it.

Yes, I think theres a good case for saying this amounts to gross misconduct warranting summary dismissal. I've certainly heard of people being summarily dismissed for much less.

The fact that he needed it pointed out to him that this is wrong. It doesn't sound like he gets it yet, because he think his idiotic behaviour only affects people with vaginas. Because he thinks its all right to ask a man to do this, a man who might have similar concerns because it is idiotic.

Imagine the legal case if you had been coerced into housing this stranger and he attacked you in your own home. Stranger things happen. The NHS makes bad appointments all the time because it is short of staff.

The bigger question is why does the NHS have so many managers who can't follow basic procedures and common sense and who cause decent workers stress and/or to leave? I don't even work in the NHS but even I know of a local issue involving a manager who has gained power by getting all but his useless devotees to leave, mainly it is women who have left and he makes his sexist comments to patients now and thinks he can get away with it.

Changedmynamefor · 05/07/2022 19:23

Once again, I agree wholeheartedly with @billy1966 - Ive been thinking about this over the course of the day and I don't think I would ever feel comfortable working with him again. Given their response, they are obviously absolutely shitting it about what you plan to do - so you have quite a lot of leverage. Presumably you wish to carry on working there? I think I'd be looking for him to be moved out of your orbit now. However, I also think it might be worth you seeking some external advice beyond your union to understand just how much they have screwed up here and the potential consequences, so you have that knowledge in your back pocket as you negotiate?

billy1966 · 05/07/2022 18:55

Should have mentioned her 15 years as an exemplary employee.

billy1966 · 05/07/2022 18:41

Fundamentally, I don't for a second believe that a bollixing from his wife, and a WTF have you done?/you could be fired for this shit, will have changed who he is.

I think what he has done is so shocking and comes from such an ugly place that he is not for fixin'.

My extensive experience of misogynistic pricks, means that I don't believe he will change.

Most likely he's gotten a bad fright, will back off, lick his humiliated wounds and lay in the long grass waiting for an opportunity in the future, to even the score.

I have certainly seen this.

There is no way I would continue working for him.

I would make it abundantly clear on paper that such was the nature of his personal attack upon me, that I will never feel safe around him.

That I wouldn't trust him to not attempt to try an manage me out, which obviously would be grounds for constructive dismissal.

I think you need to note as much as possible on paper, and by reply get it acknowledged by them.

Have they sent their offer on paper?

Reply that whilst you appreciate the offer, you are deeply concerned for your safety and reputation around this man and will seek advice as to your future at the organisation.

He felt comfortable slandering, defaming and name calling you in front of colleagues because of what he wanted you to do in the privacy of your own home.

He is your manager, and he attempted to coercively control you.
This is a crime now.

You may think that the above is dramatic.

It is not.

A very dear friend of mine in her late 50's, working for a huge multinational was on speaker phone, being threatened by her boss if she did not take on the work load of her off sick colleague.
She started to cry as she explained that she was already covering for a mat leave colleague and simply couldn't do it as she was already working 10 hours straight a day.

She is no walkover.

Her husband was outside the door and recorded the latter part of the conversation as she was WFH.

The result has been a catastrophic shit show for her boss and she was on paid leave for 12 months before returning to work recently.

She has been assured categorically that he will never be involved with her again.

She has a lovely paper trail of his treatment of her but the tape is chilling.

They do not want this to go public.
Her HR director put his face in his hands when her husband played the recording for him, and told him that HE, her husband, believed it was a police matter, it was so serious.

This is only 18 months ago, and her excellent legal advice said that whilst she didn't know how far the police would realistically take it, it would be an absolute disaster for the company publicity wise if this was to reach the media that a senior member of management for 25 years was behaving this way.

Like the OP they too have done absolutely EVERYTHING to facilitate her return 6 months ago and so far so good.

StaunchMomma · 05/07/2022 18:07

Myhousemyrules22 · 05/07/2022 12:26

Oooook. So it's been an interesting morning.

Turns out manager went home and told his wife who has proper laid into him (they have two young teenage daughters). He's come in with flowers and a personal letter of apology that pretty much tells me how he's a dumb man who has no idea about how it is to have a vagina (he looks like he's been crying all night) and he's basically jumping through every hoop HR tell him to to keep his job including;

A formal written apology
A statement to the department
He has to undergo some in-house diversity training, something about bullying as well as an out of house program in management.

I'm getting
Funded taxis home from late shifts
His apologies and retributions
A one off payment of thanks for previously housing a locum (I didn't ask for this, and I suspect it's pittence of hush money wrapped up in a 'we (hr) aren't saying sorry bow' but hey, I'll take it)
The right to come back to this at any point in the next 2 years if it's caused any unforeseen issues not yet felt.
I was offered the rest of the week off paid but I've done nothing wrong to hide away from and if I go away it makes me look like I am wrong.

I haven't signed anything yet to agree this can be put to bed because I want to see how things play out in the next day or two. HR said that's fine.

What a brilliant outcome!

Really pleased for you, OP. You've handled yourself really well.x.

GoodThinkingMax · 05/07/2022 18:01

You are sSO NOT unreasonable

Ive been in almost the same situation. I was asked to temporarily house a new colleague whom I’d never met and his family. And from another culture. I said No.

However, I have offered to house a research associate and her family.

Difference is I’ve met her several times and were from similar cultural backgrounds.

It’s about what I’m comfortable with in my private space.