Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tax childless adults

542 replies

Acidburn · 04/07/2022 13:41

Hi all

Just saw the below article on LBC news:

www.lbc.co.uk/news/childless-tax-birthrate-uk-cost-of-living-paul-morland/

AIBU to think that this insane?

OP posts:
Spectre8 · 04/07/2022 22:10

As a single childless adult they can quite frankly fuck off if they think I will pay tax for not having a child.

mellicauli · 04/07/2022 21:50

This is typical Trump Era divide and conquer thinking - setting Mums against non Mums (or Brexit v Remainers or Scottish Independence vs Union preservers, Immigrants v the rest), stir it up. sit back, let them fight it out and while you fill your boots. Come on guys, this is what they want. No one is going to tax childlessness. It's a stupid idea.

I actually question whether he can really believe in this. We - a few Mums without the benefit of several years research to hone our point or the resources of one of the richest universities at our fingertips - can see several serious and obvious flaws within an hour or so. Where is the rigour of thought? Did he not think it through at all - for 10 minutes even?

thesurrealist · 04/07/2022 21:49

TheVillageElder · 04/07/2022 21:16

No different to us all having to pay towards hsc. Education and the needs of children is the next biggest cost for the society. So if they're not contributing to the next generation physically I suppose they can do so financially.

"They?"
I'm paying through my taxes. I've also worked as a teacher educating your children and now work in the NHS improving services for you and your children.
I'm a higher rate taxpayer and do not begrudge my taxes being used for your children's education, healthcare etc. It's the social contract, just as I have no problems paying for my dads state pension and my brothers benefits. Shit can happen to anyone.

However, as a childfree woman I have had to endure many comments from mothers (and yes it is women) about how I,m not a proper woman. I've had my holiday cancelled so a parent can have that time off. I've covered for parents having to leave early, mat leaves, supported women coming back to the workplace after mat leave.

I've done my bit and I've had enough. No more.

Antarcticant · 04/07/2022 21:46

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 19:34

This is a good response & a sensible article on the issue

www.newstatesman.com/quickfire/2022/07/taxing-childless-insult-not-a-solution

Agree - a very balanced response.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 04/07/2022 21:46

At the moment it’s those having children who are overwhelmingly funding the existence of the next generation even though we all benefit from it

LOL. Who do you think is paying for your maternity leave, antenatal care, postnatal care, kids’ healthcare and kids’ education? Not to mention free/cheap public transport, child benefit etc etc. Childless people are more likely to work full-time and without career breaks, so contributing more in taxes. And that’s before we even get into the financial and environmental burden of over-population.

And don’t kid yourself that your children will pay it back in the long run. Well over 90% of people cost the State more than they put in.

I’m all for funding the next generation, in the interests of humanity, but you’re not doing me a favour by having kids -it’s the other way round.

GoodThinkingMax · 04/07/2022 21:44

Given that childless adults subsidise everyone else via tax, Council tax, and NI, the idea is offensive.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 21:42

Feckless breeders who have 5 or more children cost the country far more so than the childless.

🙄 too much daily mail reading me thinks

Covidagainandagain · 04/07/2022 21:38

TheVillageElder · 04/07/2022 21:16

No different to us all having to pay towards hsc. Education and the needs of children is the next biggest cost for the society. So if they're not contributing to the next generation physically I suppose they can do so financially.

I've volunteered for years with children, including for several years specifically helping children in a care home. Their parents might have contributed to the next generation physically but I can assure you I contributed to their children's care financially and emotionally much more than they did.

Florenz · 04/07/2022 21:35

Ridiculous idea. Feckless breeders who have 5 or more children cost the country far more so than the childless. The onus should be on responsible reproduction, the ideal should be one child. No ban on further children but there should be policies that make it beneficial to have one child and no more.

bigfootisreal · 04/07/2022 21:34

MercurialMonday
Studies have shown the difference is approx 6% so minimal.

TruthHertz · 04/07/2022 21:32

Why actively try to increase the population when there's already far too many of us?

AffIt · 04/07/2022 21:30

TheVillageElder · 04/07/2022 21:16

No different to us all having to pay towards hsc. Education and the needs of children is the next biggest cost for the society. So if they're not contributing to the next generation physically I suppose they can do so financially.

As one of the childfree 'they' you so scathingly refer to who has been a net contributor my entire working life, may I respectfully suggest you take your opinion and shove it up your arse?

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 04/07/2022 21:27

TheVillageElder · 04/07/2022 21:16

No different to us all having to pay towards hsc. Education and the needs of children is the next biggest cost for the society. So if they're not contributing to the next generation physically I suppose they can do so financially.

Critical thinking not your strong point then.

YesNoMaybeNot · 04/07/2022 21:26

TheVillageElder · 04/07/2022 21:16

No different to us all having to pay towards hsc. Education and the needs of children is the next biggest cost for the society. So if they're not contributing to the next generation physically I suppose they can do so financially.

My DH is teacher. We are contributing. But hey keep sticking the knife in.

HTH.

growinggreyer · 04/07/2022 21:22

TheVillageElder · 04/07/2022 21:16

No different to us all having to pay towards hsc. Education and the needs of children is the next biggest cost for the society. So if they're not contributing to the next generation physically I suppose they can do so financially.

I have worked in education for the last 30 years. I have taught countless children to read, to write, to use the toilet, to fasten their shoelaces etc. But you think I haven't contributed to the next generation? I find it baffling how some people can be so thick and still operate a computer.

FrippEnos · 04/07/2022 21:20

TheVillageElder · 04/07/2022 21:16

No different to us all having to pay towards hsc. Education and the needs of children is the next biggest cost for the society. So if they're not contributing to the next generation physically I suppose they can do so financially.

childless people are already providing financial support. .

TheVillageElder · 04/07/2022 21:16

No different to us all having to pay towards hsc. Education and the needs of children is the next biggest cost for the society. So if they're not contributing to the next generation physically I suppose they can do so financially.

Sittingonabench · 04/07/2022 21:15

Yes end of life considerations do need to be talked about - it seems an uncomfortable conversation that no one wants to enter into (although incentivised birth apparently is fine). I personally would definitely sign up to voluntary suicide if quality of life was severely compromised. This is for my own selfish reasons of wanting a peaceful, dignified death on my own terms but a side effect would hopefully be less cost to the state in care, medical provision and pensions. If this was an avenue available then I believe many people would take it.

PestorPeston · 04/07/2022 20:59

The best way to raise the birth rate is not to have Tory Governments.
Tory - instant birth rate drop
Labour - takes a year or two but then birth rates rise.
But is a birth rate rise a good thing?
By the time someone has to wipe my arse for the rest of my life - I'd like the option of an exit button.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 20:39

@FortonServices what part do you think I missed? I don't have a narrative I just don't think you & your sisters example is representative of the population anymore than I think my anecdotal experience is....

MercurialMonday · 04/07/2022 20:29

It is less clear cut with men - but

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-40460246

In this study, scientists found that men aged 40-42 were linked with a 46% lower chance of having a baby by in vitro fertilisation (IVF) than men aged 30-35, when the female partner was under 30.

Namenic · 04/07/2022 20:28

Um- isn’t the obvious thing to increase immigration? Then we can spread out the areas where there is overpopulation to places where there is a decreasing population. Better for the environment and people.

MercurialMonday · 04/07/2022 20:26

bigfootisreal · 04/07/2022 18:18

This is not the case, fertility doesn't wane with age. There is no cliff edge at 35.

I made no mention of 35 I know that's base on very old French records and may well not be applicable to modern populations.

However - conception rates do drop with age
But women become less fertile as they get older. One study found that among couples having regular unprotected sex:
aged 19 to 26 – 92% will conceive after 1 year and 98% after 2 years
aged 35 to 39 – 82% will conceive after 1 year and 90% after 2 years
NHS

and miscarriage risks increase:
the risk of miscarriage was lowest in women aged 25-29 (10%), and rose rapidly after age 30, reaching 53% in women aged 45 and over. bmj

Despite that you can get people like DH GM who got pg and had healthy twins at 51 - it's just much rarer.

I've 45 - most women I know who really wanted children were trying at 40 as it does get harder for many to have successful pg - though science is improving the odds.

But fertility does decline with age - though I agree its not a cliff and I never said it was.

XenoBitch · 04/07/2022 20:19

It is not a tax. It is more like a fine. Name something else that you pay tax on for not having/doing. There isn't anything.

riesenrad · 04/07/2022 20:07

As I said upthread, it's a mad idea.

But it's not going to happen.