Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tax childless adults

542 replies

Acidburn · 04/07/2022 13:41

Hi all

Just saw the below article on LBC news:

www.lbc.co.uk/news/childless-tax-birthrate-uk-cost-of-living-paul-morland/

AIBU to think that this insane?

OP posts:
HesterShaw1 · 05/07/2022 12:45

rainbowmilk · 05/07/2022 12:31

Ditto. Not had Xmas off or leave during July in 7 years as mums (it's always mums) go into uproar every time a rota is suggested. The mums I work with are constantly making comments about how they don't understand how women can be so cold as to not have kids, how their lives will never be complete without knowing that special kind of love, and how they're glad they have something in their lives other than work and a reason to keep their hours at a manageable level.

I'm truly glad I have never known or worked with people like that.

It's tough enough being infertile as it is.

The pain is awful at the time, but it does get better.

hatchyu · 05/07/2022 12:42

It's not as though every birth results in a productive citizen, either. Just look at all the useless losers out there burdening the rest of us with their keep, their crimes, their deadbeat parenting, and so on.

Surely this is true for adults who don't have dc too though.

GoodThinkingMax · 05/07/2022 12:38

I became infertile after a cancer scare and life-saving surgery at 32 years old. I have no children and my entire future was wiped out overnight. I'm a single person and a higher rate taxpayer, have been for years. I've never taken and will never take maternity leave, and I'm single so can't afford to go part time. I already pay more into the pot than many parents do. The idea that I should be paying even more on top because parents have made their "contribution" and my role is to finance them, is disgusting.

Absolutely @rainbowmilk And I'm so sorry for your situation - it is REALLY tough, in large part because of the kind of thinking demonstrated by the article in the opening post, and some of the ideas of some of the posters in this thread.

But it DOES get better - honestly it does. However, there are a lot of unthinking ignorant people in this world, who do treat childless women as some sort of freak. It's really hard to take, year in, year out.

I now get quite confrontational about it - there's so much evidence that people with more than 1 child in the west use up way more resources (of everything) than is their fair share. Someone with 3 children once tried to chide me about flying. I put her straight on that!

jc12689 · 05/07/2022 12:36

Ducksinthebath

Arguably those without children are already paying for so many services they don’t use (maternity care, schools, nursery hours) that this really does add insult to injury.

Schools? Are you serious? Are people really that stupid that they don't understand that everyone benefits from having an educated population, not just people with children.

I speak as someone with no children, but even I can understand that other people's children grow up to be my GP or a nurse or an engineer that massively benefits everyone in society.

Such a lazy thing to say.

rainbowmilk · 05/07/2022 12:31

Bubblebubblebah · 04/07/2022 22:26

However, as a childfree woman I have had to endure many comments from mothers (and yes it is women) about how I,m not a proper woman. I've had my holiday cancelled so a parent can have that time off. I've covered for parents having to leave early, mat leaves, supported women coming back to the workplace after mat leave.

Yup. This is our tax. Already paid

Ditto. Not had Xmas off or leave during July in 7 years as mums (it's always mums) go into uproar every time a rota is suggested. The mums I work with are constantly making comments about how they don't understand how women can be so cold as to not have kids, how their lives will never be complete without knowing that special kind of love, and how they're glad they have something in their lives other than work and a reason to keep their hours at a manageable level.

FourTeaFallOut · 05/07/2022 12:25

So, some women are being manoeuvred into aborting their potential third child because of the two child benefit policy on the one hand and here they are floating the idea that childless adults should be punished taxed for their lack of procreation?

Makes sense 🙄

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 05/07/2022 12:17

Covidagainandagain · 05/07/2022 11:56

No sure any of that is the fault of people without children though

But it is the fault of those in power who would be the ones taxing us. They tax us more every year for what? Not like they are using the money well currently.

Covidagainandagain · 05/07/2022 11:56

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 05/07/2022 09:42

What bloody services?

The 'schools' that are actually portacabins because the school hasn't been rebuilt for the huge amount of houses built in the area?

The schools with mostly new teachers in because the councils can't be arsed paying for experienced teachers so prefer to use the ones fresh out of uni?

The schools that have asbestos in the roof with gaping holes into classrooms that leak during rain as well?

The maternity care that doesn't even exist in certain hospitals (that used to until the council stopped that) and you have to travel for over an hour by ambulance to the nearest one?

No sure any of that is the fault of people without children though

KosherDill · 05/07/2022 11:54

rainbowmilk · 05/07/2022 11:51

I became infertile after a cancer scare and life-saving surgery at 32 years old. I have no children and my entire future was wiped out overnight. I'm a single person and a higher rate taxpayer, have been for years. I've never taken and will never take maternity leave, and I'm single so can't afford to go part time. I already pay more into the pot than many parents do. The idea that I should be paying even more on top because parents have made their "contribution" and my role is to finance them, is disgusting.

The answer to this is legalising voluntary euthanasia. I do not want to spend 20 years in a care home. I want control over the end of my life. Bonus - no poor person has to have children for my benefit, as apparently all parents are now doing rather than because they do whatever they want.

Honestly, childless people are second class citizens in this country and every year I get closer to emigrating.

Totally agree!

rainbowmilk · 05/07/2022 11:51

I became infertile after a cancer scare and life-saving surgery at 32 years old. I have no children and my entire future was wiped out overnight. I'm a single person and a higher rate taxpayer, have been for years. I've never taken and will never take maternity leave, and I'm single so can't afford to go part time. I already pay more into the pot than many parents do. The idea that I should be paying even more on top because parents have made their "contribution" and my role is to finance them, is disgusting.

The answer to this is legalising voluntary euthanasia. I do not want to spend 20 years in a care home. I want control over the end of my life. Bonus - no poor person has to have children for my benefit, as apparently all parents are now doing rather than because they do whatever they want.

Honestly, childless people are second class citizens in this country and every year I get closer to emigrating.

MercurialMonday · 05/07/2022 11:34

bigfootisreal · 04/07/2022 21:34

MercurialMonday
Studies have shown the difference is approx 6% so minimal.

I'm honestly not sure what your issue is.

If you honestly think fertility isn't in decline by mid 40s - well good luck with that.

ONS has as a cohort women over 45 as completed childbearing years - I do wonder if that will change with time but numbers of pg beyond that must be so low as not be statically significant currently.

My original point was the assumption women just needed to be educated out of their “silliness” in delaying motherhood which completely and conveniently ignores economic and structural factors that frequently dictate or very least influence that decision and assumes women aren't already aware of their biological which IME isn't true.

Perhaps this “education” was directed at men for once -as IME they aren’t as educated about this or the added risks that come with older sperm production perhaps that might have more impact.

As we still live in a mainly patriarchal society I would have though greater understanding in men around fertility might actually lead to at least attempts to understand structural pressures more - rather than default to "blaming" women.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 05/07/2022 11:11

Seems counterproductive. I had to save up to cover costs during maternity leave, paying extra tax would have made that more difficult potentially meaning I might have chosen to not have a child, or may have delayed it to the point it was more difficult with the associated increase in risks, which apart from the emotional/physical implications for me also carries a cost for the NHS.

We do need to consider what we do about our ageing population in the light of reduced birth rates in the UK. This has been known about for years but very little has been done because of political short-termism.

TankFlyBossW4lk · 05/07/2022 09:47

Utterly ridiculous idea. Make child care cheaper. This will go a long way to helping.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 05/07/2022 09:42

Ducksinthebath · 04/07/2022 14:16

Arguably those without children are already paying for so many services they don’t use (maternity care, schools, nursery hours) that this really does add insult to injury.

What bloody services?

The 'schools' that are actually portacabins because the school hasn't been rebuilt for the huge amount of houses built in the area?

The schools with mostly new teachers in because the councils can't be arsed paying for experienced teachers so prefer to use the ones fresh out of uni?

The schools that have asbestos in the roof with gaping holes into classrooms that leak during rain as well?

The maternity care that doesn't even exist in certain hospitals (that used to until the council stopped that) and you have to travel for over an hour by ambulance to the nearest one?

Cornettoninja · 05/07/2022 09:36

carefullycourageous · 05/07/2022 08:36

This thread is disturbing, the idea the contribution a human makes is only measurable by tax in vs tax out is clearly an incorrect way of viewing things. A person has value as a person. Society has collective value. I am enriched by both money and human happiness.

A person can contribute to society without ever paying tax. Clearly economically many have to pay tax, but it is not correct to measure a single human by money in money out.

I don’t disagree but in our society it costs money to exist so there are always going to be conversations about how this is funded and what the budget sheet looks like.

I also don’t think it’s possible for someone to exist without ever paying any tax at all in the UK. Not once you start taking things like VAT and inheritance taxes into account.

KosherDill · 05/07/2022 09:19

YesNoMaybeNot · 05/07/2022 07:20

If you suggest giving people who have had children generous tax credits to help compensation for the costs of raising children (and foregone career opportunities), a lot more people say they are OK with that.

Areyou going to give the childless extra credit when they get older then due to paying extra into the system all their working life that they aren't going to use aswell as paying into the more 'generous' system you want.

I mean fair is fair and all that.

Exactly.

It's not as though every birth results in a productive citizen, either. Just look at all the useless losers out there burdening the rest of us with their keep, their crimes, their deadbeat parenting, and so on.

Would smug parents like it if we charged them more or docked their pensions when their offspring turn out to be useless drains on society?

HesterShaw1 · 05/07/2022 09:13

While I know I've been as vociferous as anyone in decrying this bloody awful suggestion, surely the conversation we should be having is how to get over this "hump" when we'll have more older people than younger people, until it corrects itself. It'll take a while.

Decreasing numbers of people on the planet can oy be a good thing in the long run.

carefullycourageous · 05/07/2022 08:36

This thread is disturbing, the idea the contribution a human makes is only measurable by tax in vs tax out is clearly an incorrect way of viewing things. A person has value as a person. Society has collective value. I am enriched by both money and human happiness.

A person can contribute to society without ever paying tax. Clearly economically many have to pay tax, but it is not correct to measure a single human by money in money out.

ReeseWitherfork · 05/07/2022 07:58

YesNoMaybeNot · 05/07/2022 07:52

So when do those with DC ever payback their own education then?

When they’re earning money and paying tax.

YesNoMaybeNot · 05/07/2022 07:52

ReeseWitherfork · 05/07/2022 07:40

I’m confused at the notion that childless people benefit less from taxes because they don’t have kids needing school. Parents aren’t paying for their children’s education via tax; their taxes surely cover (paying back) their own education?

Everyone has a lifetime money pot that (in theory) they put into via tax, and take out via education and healthcare. It just so happens that the two come at different times (we take out a lot under the age of 18 and over the age of 65, but we put the bulk in between those two ages).

So when do those with DC ever payback their own education then?

MarshaBradyo · 05/07/2022 07:42

hatchyu · 05/07/2022 07:30

Ok I appreciate the post because I actually do want to hear why a couple of posters think what they do about numbers of next generation but if it’s just you’re all too dumb to get it then I don’t hear the reasons.

But where have I said anyone is too dumb to get it? I'm genuinely surprised people think population growth particularly in the west is caused by people having too many babies. And of course for the gov to plan anything & make policies people need to be aware of the issue. The alternative is stupid divisive suggestions like the ones in the OP which results in arguments. And as I said upthread I'm concerned about the issue of declining birth rates being pushed onto women.

No it’s not as rates here show decline but is that something to overturn?

Various jobs will decrease, people from other countries will want to move more and skills are there too

Out of interest what would you like the replacement rate to be?

ReeseWitherfork · 05/07/2022 07:40

I’m confused at the notion that childless people benefit less from taxes because they don’t have kids needing school. Parents aren’t paying for their children’s education via tax; their taxes surely cover (paying back) their own education?

Everyone has a lifetime money pot that (in theory) they put into via tax, and take out via education and healthcare. It just so happens that the two come at different times (we take out a lot under the age of 18 and over the age of 65, but we put the bulk in between those two ages).

hatchyu · 05/07/2022 07:30

Ok I appreciate the post because I actually do want to hear why a couple of posters think what they do about numbers of next generation but if it’s just you’re all too dumb to get it then I don’t hear the reasons.

But where have I said anyone is too dumb to get it? I'm genuinely surprised people think population growth particularly in the west is caused by people having too many babies. And of course for the gov to plan anything & make policies people need to be aware of the issue. The alternative is stupid divisive suggestions like the ones in the OP which results in arguments. And as I said upthread I'm concerned about the issue of declining birth rates being pushed onto women.

Newmumatlast · 05/07/2022 07:27

thesurrealist · 04/07/2022 21:49

"They?"
I'm paying through my taxes. I've also worked as a teacher educating your children and now work in the NHS improving services for you and your children.
I'm a higher rate taxpayer and do not begrudge my taxes being used for your children's education, healthcare etc. It's the social contract, just as I have no problems paying for my dads state pension and my brothers benefits. Shit can happen to anyone.

However, as a childfree woman I have had to endure many comments from mothers (and yes it is women) about how I,m not a proper woman. I've had my holiday cancelled so a parent can have that time off. I've covered for parents having to leave early, mat leaves, supported women coming back to the workplace after mat leave.

I've done my bit and I've had enough. No more.

I am a mum and I agree with you.

Childless people are paying the same taxes as the rest of us yet benefit less - that's just logic. They aren't getting access to free schooling, healthcare and other services for their children. It is right that they will usually be able to earn more and so pay more tax. And similarly will have more disposable income usually so contribute more to the economy also.

Yes you will get people who work full time, and have kids, and don't qualify for things like child benefit etc but also pay for private schooling etc so get less out of the pot despite having kids... but a lot of people with kids will be taking much more out than they put in.

Childless people are expected to relent on things like holiday requests at work to allow people with kids the convenience of certain time off. Society does treat women without kids as though they have failed to fulfil their destiny as women (I had IVF for first child so have experienced the comments from people about how I'm career driven, not maternal etc because I couldn't have children yet this has now flipped and I'm suddenly seen as maternal and motherly despite being the same person I was before and having the same ideas and approach to childcare as before).

I also think it is arrogant for people with kids to bang on about how they are contributing more to society because of having kids as though they are completely and utterly responsible for their kids achievements. My DHs mother was a neglectful alcoholic who abused him. He overcame this to get a great job, learn himself how to be a kind and considerate person, and contributes a lot of tax etc. She shouldn't take the credit for that - if he had turned out like her he wouldn't be contributing much at all. It's relatively easy to be a mum if everything works fertility wise but parenting well is another story.

The point is yes we need a certain number of kids but parents shouldn't feel they can be on their high horse then about contributing to society and childless people shouldn't be considered lesser or taxed for being childless.

YesNoMaybeNot · 05/07/2022 07:20

If you suggest giving people who have had children generous tax credits to help compensation for the costs of raising children (and foregone career opportunities), a lot more people say they are OK with that.

Areyou going to give the childless extra credit when they get older then due to paying extra into the system all their working life that they aren't going to use aswell as paying into the more 'generous' system you want.

I mean fair is fair and all that.