Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tax childless adults

542 replies

Acidburn · 04/07/2022 13:41

Hi all

Just saw the below article on LBC news:

www.lbc.co.uk/news/childless-tax-birthrate-uk-cost-of-living-paul-morland/

AIBU to think that this insane?

OP posts:
Covidagainandagain · 06/07/2022 13:25

FourTeaFallOut · 06/07/2022 13:20

This is all just different shades of the same misogynistic shit, more fool you if you pick it up and sling it at other women.

You know after years of being treated like a second class citizen, being told I should work every Christmas, I'm not worth of having time off in the summer, I must be a paedophile, I must be grooming children, I am a worthless member of society, I don't deserve to live in a house with more than 1-2 bedrooms, I shouldn't buy a house with a garden because gardens are for children, I should be taxed more, I should pay more council tax, I am a burden on society etc....

Every once in a while you are damn right I am going to pick up that shit and sling it back.

FourTeaFallOut · 06/07/2022 13:20

This is all just different shades of the same misogynistic shit, more fool you if you pick it up and sling it at other women.

Covidagainandagain · 06/07/2022 13:19

FortonServices · 06/07/2022 13:13

I'm amazed at how many women on here want to be paid for having sex. Because that's what it boils down to.

Be fair now, they only want to be paid for unprotected sex, that does usually come at a slightly higher rate after all

FortonServices · 06/07/2022 13:13

Jasminejoy · 06/07/2022 00:56

Fascinating how many people is this poll expect single or child free folk to subsidise their life choices.

I'm amazed at how many women on here want to be paid for having sex. Because that's what it boils down to.

FourTeaFallOut · 06/07/2022 10:18

That was Andrea Loathesome, wasn't it? It didn't get much traction thankfully.

rainbowmilk · 06/07/2022 08:48

Remember the fuss about Theresa May not being suitable to be the PM because she hasn’t got children? (Which means Boris should be the best PM ever. Oh wait.)

GoodThinkingMax · 06/07/2022 07:48

Sorry - formatting fail - the statement about being untrustworthy was made by the Conservative politician

GoodThinkingMax · 06/07/2022 07:47

Jasminejoy · 06/07/2022 00:56

Fascinating how many people is this poll expect single or child free folk to subsidise their life choices.

indeed!

I absolutely understand that each generation supports and is supported by the generation above and below. (it’s what we call “society”)

But I am fucking sick and tired of being told I’m:
selfish
a drain on resources
a non-contributor to society
not fully human or fully a woman
lacking in deep emotions
taking up housing which “should” be for families
somehow suspicious and untrustworthy*

simply because I haven’t reproduced.

* This was a gem in an election hustings I attended once. The Conservative contender’s parting shot at his Labour rival was “How can you trust a man who doesn’t drive a car or have children.” The delicious irony was that said Conservative later dumped his first wife and mother of their 3 children, for his young childless research assistant. Whose style was, according to this sexist man, more fitting for “my new position “ as MP.

Jasminejoy · 06/07/2022 00:56

Fascinating how many people is this poll expect single or child free folk to subsidise their life choices.

CounsellorTroi · 05/07/2022 23:18

I think it’s a good idea. We all depend on there being a younger generation. We are all fked if there is no younger generation and that’s the direction we’re heading in.

How would you define childless people for the purposes of this tax?

Infertile?
Step parents with no biological children?
People who are circumstantially childless?
People who have lost their only child?

And how are you going to get those who are childfree by choice to admit it if by doing so they’ll have to pay an extra tax?

chiffchaffchiff · 05/07/2022 17:28

I like your ideas @TheWeeDonkey

Funding child services especially. So many kids are failed by a system that doesn't support them through to independent adulthood. You only have to look at a few posts on the adoption board to see that even children lucky enough to be adopted (and their adoptive parents) are left to it as soon as possible.

hatchyu · 05/07/2022 17:27

Someone has probably already answered this, but how do we square the circle that we do not have enough young people to carry out work that needs doing, while at the same time the world is over populated?

population hasn't peaked yet globally but it's not far off & then it will start declining. I think the UK is supposed to be there in the next 2-3 yrs. The issue is the ones left in much of the west are going to be older. I don't think the immigration needed to "support" that here will be tolerated. I see more inequality, so people who can will go private for healthcare etc,more won't ever retire. Healthy life expectancy hasn't improved & I think for baby girls born in deprived areas HLE is 18 yrs lower than more affluent areas & men the difference is similar. The gap will likely grow.

TheWeeDonkey · 05/07/2022 17:19

riesenrad · 05/07/2022 15:02

I agree it's a silly idea, but silly ideas can spark good ones. Taxing childless/childfree couples is a mad idea. But what underlies that suggestion? Worries about looking after the elderly? Paying for pensions? Filling jobs? Well what other options are there.

It's a form of control, like these "quiverful" religions where the woman's role is to reproduce throughout her "useful" years.

You don't encourage people to have families but enforcing draconian rules like banning health care or taxing childless / child free families. You look at why people aren't having families. For example;

Take women's reproductive health seriously instead of treating menstrual conditions and miscarriage as "just one of those things".

Improve maternity care and support so that young families can afford to raise a family without living in debt.

Treat childcare services with the importance they deserve. So that children can have quality affordable care outside the home.

Take away the stigma of not having children and stop guilting women for not "raising tomorrow's workforce"

Just a couple of ideas

Covidagainandagain · 05/07/2022 17:08

ScrollingLeaves · 05/07/2022 16:52

FourTeaFallOut · Today 16:28

Viviennemary
^I think a lot more needs to be done to discourage people from having large families. No child benefit for a third or subsequent children would be a start. Paid maternity allowance for only up to two children. Thd world population is growing at an alarming rate. Less people equals less pollution and more food to go round.

CovidAgainandAgain
You only get benefits for 2 children, that has been the case since 2016/17

The exact point at which abortions started rocketing.

That chart you posted proves your point. It is so obvious really, but I had not realised abortions began to rocket as a result of the two child rule. It is rather a shock to see. Presumably many of those would have been accidents, and the parents might well have otherwise wanted very much to keep those children.

It just shows that when people, particularly in the US are anti- abortion, instead of picketing outside clinics, they might do better fighting for society’s care of the born child.
(If they don’t already. Perhaps some people do both.)

Someone has probably already answered this, but how do we square the circle that we do not have enough young people to carry out work that needs doing, while at the same time the world is over populated?

So squaring the circle assumes that we decide as a species that our comfort is more important than the impact it has on the world.

It also assumes that climate change doesn't just kill us all of anyway or make things so very very uncomfortable that all the extra children in the world wont fix the issue.

However, some people have made the point on the thread that AI and robotics is going to fix some of the issue.

For example if the issue is a lack of carers to look after people in their old age then, every checkout till getting automated, every factory gets automated etc etc frees up a proportion of the population to be carers.

However what this idiot (in the article) and some other people are worried about actually is money. If there aren't enough young people coming up behind them paying tax and NI then they might not get as high a pension payout etc.

And I guess the solution for that is the same as the solution to people potentially being out of work due to AI etc. Tax the companies using AI and robotics and use the money to fund a universal basic income for everyone including pensioners.

thesurrealist · 05/07/2022 17:03

It would be interesting to see of the people who earn over 130k are likely to be parents or not

Don't be daft, this is MN where most husbands earn this and if they don't their wives do Grin

ScrollingLeaves · 05/07/2022 16:52

FourTeaFallOut · Today 16:28

Viviennemary
^I think a lot more needs to be done to discourage people from having large families. No child benefit for a third or subsequent children would be a start. Paid maternity allowance for only up to two children. Thd world population is growing at an alarming rate. Less people equals less pollution and more food to go round.

CovidAgainandAgain
You only get benefits for 2 children, that has been the case since 2016/17

The exact point at which abortions started rocketing.

That chart you posted proves your point. It is so obvious really, but I had not realised abortions began to rocket as a result of the two child rule. It is rather a shock to see. Presumably many of those would have been accidents, and the parents might well have otherwise wanted very much to keep those children.

It just shows that when people, particularly in the US are anti- abortion, instead of picketing outside clinics, they might do better fighting for society’s care of the born child.
(If they don’t already. Perhaps some people do both.)

Someone has probably already answered this, but how do we square the circle that we do not have enough young people to carry out work that needs doing, while at the same time the world is over populated?

hatchyu · 05/07/2022 16:51

very unpopular though

hatchyu · 05/07/2022 16:50

where else will more money come from?

I think income tax is high enough & I would reduce VAT. I would bring CGT in line with income tax & look at IHT

totallyaddictedtocheese · 05/07/2022 16:47

Why is it that every 'issue' has to be fixed by us paying more tax? It's just the go to answer for everything. We pay more than enough tax already.

hatchyu · 05/07/2022 16:43

but then everyone hates the top percent on here so not much left for anyone that is liked

True

hatchyu · 05/07/2022 16:43

Ridiculous. I don’t understand either. Class sizes are bigger than ever, there aren’t enough school places. How on earth is there a plummeting birth rate?

That's not true. Some schools in London have closed due to lack of pupils. I think Southwark has a funding shortfall for 16 schools.

Covidagainandagain · 05/07/2022 16:31

FourTeaFallOut · 05/07/2022 16:28

The exact point at which abortions started rocketing.

Yep precisely

Although I was rather 🙄that anyone still buys into the 'having lots of children to claim benefits' trope, I thought that one had died out.

FourTeaFallOut · 05/07/2022 16:28

Covidagainandagain · 05/07/2022 16:24

You only get benefits for 2 children, that has been the case since 2016/17

The exact point at which abortions started rocketing.

Tax childless adults
FortonServices · 05/07/2022 16:27

RedWingBoots · 05/07/2022 16:24

@FortonServices you mean you can tax the parents of city bankers more?

Never going to happen. 😀

Well given those city bankers will already be paying a shed load of tax, no.

Let's face it, the parents of those children who end up being drains on society aren't earning enough to pay tax anyway. So that's never going to happen either. Which is why disadvantaging the childless is a stupid idea.

MarshaBradyo · 05/07/2022 16:26

FortonServices · 05/07/2022 16:22

If we tax the childless for not adding productive workers to the economy, then it seems fair to tax the parents of children who don't grow up to be productive members of society. In fact they should be taxed even more, for adding a drain on the economy to the population 😂

Given the stat below re earning to be a contributor and needing to be in top whatever percent basically most of us are drains

but then everyone hates the top percent on here so not much left for anyone that is liked 😆