Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tax childless adults

542 replies

Acidburn · 04/07/2022 13:41

Hi all

Just saw the below article on LBC news:

www.lbc.co.uk/news/childless-tax-birthrate-uk-cost-of-living-paul-morland/

AIBU to think that this insane?

OP posts:
Favvi · 04/07/2022 14:27

The most awful thing about this proposal is that it'll result in children being born to people who don't want them and just see them as dollar signs.

Naunet · 04/07/2022 14:27

OperaStation · 04/07/2022 14:25

Yes, all of those things need to be funded and will always need to be funded. How do you propose that works when our working age population is massively depleted because of years of low birth rates? What we can afford to pay for via taxes will be massively depleted. Who will pay for hospitals and social care?

I’m not saying this idea is a silver bullet but it’s a sensible idea. We can’t just bury our heads in the sand.

Tax parents more then. Fair?

Keha · 04/07/2022 14:26

This happened in Romania under Ceausescu. Google decree 770.

Obviously bonkers. But I do think it's interesting that for a very long time we've not had to worry about not having enough young people, and a time may soon come when governments start to try and encourage more to have kids.

KILM · 04/07/2022 14:26

CurzonDax · 04/07/2022 14:06

This. Not to mention, how will this be judged how to tax childless people more? Will every childless person be taxed the same? Will couples be taxed more? When do you start taxing people this additional amount - when they turn 18/leave full-time education? (Great way to encourage teen pregnancies!). When do you stop taxing people? At retirement age, or when their own children turn 18, or leave home?
What about step parents? Parents who adopt? They haven't had children themselves, so haven't actually increased the population number, but they are the ones bringing the child up (and facing the costs of having to do this). Will the birth parents then be charged the additional tax? (I fear for those children who need to be taken into care, in this situation, if birth parents don't want the extra tax.)
Not to mention it's just a kick in the teeth for those who want, but can't have children.

As a childless adult (not through choice, we're struggling to conceive), I do not support this. What I would support, is the taxes that I currently pay being used to increase child benefit, or being used to assist parents more with ridiculously high childcare fees, or being used to increase statutory maternity/paternity pay.

This is why its a fucking stupid idea that would never happen. How will the government know if im infertile or not? They cant. How will they know im in a relationship unless im listing someone as partner/spouse on forms to them? What if im single and cant find anyone to have kids with? When does the tax start/stop, when a baby is born or when we start trying? What happens if my child dies, do i get taxed again? What if im on minimum wage and physically wont be able to afford childcare, are you going to pay for me to stay at home until the child is a teen? What happens if i try for 20 years but dont have one through no fault of my own, do i still get taxed?

'We need people to support the ageing population'
Er how the fuck is that my uteruses problem? How about we stop doing the population equivalent of having a baby in a shit relationship to 'bring you closer together' and stop throwing babies at the problem?
Isnt the problem that we pay all of these 'supportive' workers we so desperately need fuck all money and expect them to work under shit conditions? How does having more people not being able to do those jobs because you cant afford rent, bills and travel on the wages offered fixing the problem...

Its a stupid inflammatory article written by an idiot.

Naunet · 04/07/2022 14:25

OperaStation · 04/07/2022 14:04

They are childless so would be taxed.

I think people are getting too emotional about this. In countries that have an aging population the consequences are quite dire. Who is going to be working and paying taxes to support all of these retired people, often with complex care needs? Surely better to address it before it happens?

Don’t be ridiculous, we’re already over populated, we don’t need to keep growing in numbers like a plague of locusts, we need to find more sustainable solutions.

And it’s not the job of child free people to even further subsidise people who have children. Such an entitled point of view.

OperaStation · 04/07/2022 14:25

CurzonDax · 04/07/2022 14:06

This. Not to mention, how will this be judged how to tax childless people more? Will every childless person be taxed the same? Will couples be taxed more? When do you start taxing people this additional amount - when they turn 18/leave full-time education? (Great way to encourage teen pregnancies!). When do you stop taxing people? At retirement age, or when their own children turn 18, or leave home?
What about step parents? Parents who adopt? They haven't had children themselves, so haven't actually increased the population number, but they are the ones bringing the child up (and facing the costs of having to do this). Will the birth parents then be charged the additional tax? (I fear for those children who need to be taken into care, in this situation, if birth parents don't want the extra tax.)
Not to mention it's just a kick in the teeth for those who want, but can't have children.

As a childless adult (not through choice, we're struggling to conceive), I do not support this. What I would support, is the taxes that I currently pay being used to increase child benefit, or being used to assist parents more with ridiculously high childcare fees, or being used to increase statutory maternity/paternity pay.

Yes, all of those things need to be funded and will always need to be funded. How do you propose that works when our working age population is massively depleted because of years of low birth rates? What we can afford to pay for via taxes will be massively depleted. Who will pay for hospitals and social care?

I’m not saying this idea is a silver bullet but it’s a sensible idea. We can’t just bury our heads in the sand.

LuaDipa · 04/07/2022 14:25

This.

Ridiculous idea.

Whopbamboom · 04/07/2022 14:25

It's a stupid idea for hundreds of reasons.

One of which being that it would disproportionately penalises groups such as same sex couples. Those in same sex relationships for example are already less likely to have children due to inequalities in access to fertility funding (amongst other things). It feels like a draconian suggestion that would put us another step closer to the likes of the USA who seem to be moving drastically backwards. Who's to say the next step wont be banning abortion in an attempt to "keep the birth rate up"?

It's a slippy slope when you start penalising people for not reproducing rather than addressing the reasons why many are choosing not to. (Not forgetting that for many it isn't a choice)

Sittingonabench · 04/07/2022 14:24

That is so ridiculous. Everyone pays taxes which contributes to education, nhs, etc. already. Childless people don’t get child benefit and while I agree some provisions could be better this should be paid by all not the childless. But ultimately we should be aiming for a controlled reduction in population which maintains societal structure while reducing our impact on the planet a pyramid structure is unsustainable.

CalistoNoSolo · 04/07/2022 14:24

I also agree with an environmental tax on children (and I have one). We dont need more and more babies. Japan manages with an aging population, low birth rate and low immigration. The fewer babies born right now and for a long time in the future, the better. Earth simply cannot sustain 7 billion people and it sickens and terrifies me how much damage we are doing to the environment because people are somehow more important than every single other species on the planet.

Bubblebubblebah · 04/07/2022 14:24

*our!!!

Bubblebubblebah · 04/07/2022 14:23

Screw childlesss taxes. Many of us are already net contributors so doing are bit.

If you are worried about care in old age, fight for euthanasia on demand. I would like that.

HesterShaw1 · 04/07/2022 14:23

There are far too many people in the world. Yes in the next few decades we will have a growing elderly population but you can't just make new humans to look after the old ones. At some point, we will get over this hump and the population will stabilise - lower. Good.

Paying people to have kids - can't see anything going wrong with that at all . No doubt some will find it offensive me saying this, but the kind of people who are incentivised to produce children for the financial perks, are unlikely to raise adults who will be paying loads of tax anyway.

And yes - I pay bloody loads of tax for things I don't use. So my answer is "fuck off".

Courtjobby · 04/07/2022 14:18

Will they refund everyone teh cost of IVF? 40k and counting...

YetAnotherSpartacus · 04/07/2022 14:18

Exactly, Ducks. Those who are unchilded already subsidise those who are.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 04/07/2022 14:17

I'm all for incentivising children, family support and childcare, mind. I just don't think you incentivise one group by penalising another.

tentative3 · 04/07/2022 14:17

OperaStation · 04/07/2022 14:00

I think it’s a good idea. We all depend on there being a younger generation. We are all f**ked if there is no younger generation and that’s the direction we’re heading in.

At the moment it’s those having children who are overwhelmingly funding the existence of the next generation even though we all benefit from it.

I also agree with educating women about having children earlier in life. I’m always gob smacked by the number who wait until they’re in their 40s. Mumsnet is full of women asking if they’re too old to have kids at 40 something and they will always be reassured by lots of people who have friends who had babies in their 40s. But this is totally misleading. Often it’s not their 1st, often they’ve had to go through hell to have that baby (think several rounds of IVF), and nobody tells you about the thousands of women who did leave it until they were in the 40s only to discover it’s never going to happen for them. Only this week I was speaking to a friend in her mid 40s who has given up hope after multiple rounds of IVF and a horribly late term miscarriage. We need to stop lying to women and telling them they can have it all.

Would I get a rebate if I die young and don't need care? Can I get a discount by only using medical professionals my age or older?

I contribute, via taxes, to education and healthcare for these future generations and am happy to do so. If you want me to be taxed separately, on top, to pay for kids for the simple reason I don't have them, then I want a say in who has them and when and I don't want to pay for schools, maternity services etc via tax or I'm paying twice. I also don't want to pay for any that turn out to be useless wasters who do nothing with their lives by choice.

Ducksinthebath · 04/07/2022 14:16

Arguably those without children are already paying for so many services they don’t use (maternity care, schools, nursery hours) that this really does add insult to injury.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 04/07/2022 14:15

I think, given that this person also suggested without irony that people could receive a telegram from the monarch upon producing their third child, that we're firmly in the realms of academic-demographic fantasyland here.

There are far too many nuances at work as to why a person (or a couple) might be unable or choose not to have children. In a civilised society you simply cannot have a situation where additional taxes are levied on infertile women or men, a majority of gay men and lesbians, and people on lower incomes, in order to 'incentivise' the fecundity of others.

I find it quite amusing that entire cohorts of people are right behind this idea, and yet these very same people will almost certainly get all beetroot-faced and huffy about the tired old 'girls getting pregnant so they can get a council flat' trope which is essentially the same principle in action.

tentative3 · 04/07/2022 14:13

Traveller3367 · 04/07/2022 13:45

That article is extreme and I don't agree with the concept but there needs to be an acknowledgement of the importance of having children and a next generation. Having children seems to be viewed as a selfish act. It's as if so many people think they are doing the world a favour by not having kids because of over population and climate change but then what happens when there aren't enough young people to work and pay taxes? Society collapses!
I do think nurturing the future generations should have more importance in the narrative of society

But the people having kids are overwhelmingly not doing so because they are worried about the future of humanity, they're doing so because they want to have kids.

As another poster said, it's basically one big pyramid scheme.

Dontevenstart · 04/07/2022 14:11

Given that this originally was put in an article on the basis that "we as a country are facing a crippling labour shortage" I would suggest that a) the demographer who came up with it gets in the bin, b) the paper that printed it gets in the bin and c) Brexit (which has caused the vast majority of labour shortage over here) and all those who implemented it, also get in the bin.

melodypondisasuperhero · 04/07/2022 14:07

This is ridiculous.

The cost of having children is insane, at least in the early years when you have to pay for childcare. I have one, I can’t afford another because I can’t pay my mortgage and £1.5k/month in childcare bills and I can’t afford to stay home either. Plenty of people may have no kids because they can’t afford it so instead of punishing them further financially maybe consider how to make having kids affordable?

But I’m from Sweden where childcare is almost free so it was definitely a shock to see how much it costs here.

CurzonDax · 04/07/2022 14:06

ReeseWitherfork · 04/07/2022 13:44

This isn’t incentivising having children, it’s punishing those who don’t. Surely two different things?

They could make having children far more desirable by improving parental leave and pay or making childcare more affordable. Simple.

This. Not to mention, how will this be judged how to tax childless people more? Will every childless person be taxed the same? Will couples be taxed more? When do you start taxing people this additional amount - when they turn 18/leave full-time education? (Great way to encourage teen pregnancies!). When do you stop taxing people? At retirement age, or when their own children turn 18, or leave home?
What about step parents? Parents who adopt? They haven't had children themselves, so haven't actually increased the population number, but they are the ones bringing the child up (and facing the costs of having to do this). Will the birth parents then be charged the additional tax? (I fear for those children who need to be taken into care, in this situation, if birth parents don't want the extra tax.)
Not to mention it's just a kick in the teeth for those who want, but can't have children.

As a childless adult (not through choice, we're struggling to conceive), I do not support this. What I would support, is the taxes that I currently pay being used to increase child benefit, or being used to assist parents more with ridiculously high childcare fees, or being used to increase statutory maternity/paternity pay.

OperaStation · 04/07/2022 14:04

TheWhalrus · 04/07/2022 13:54

Mad...there are people who'd very much like to be parents but can't (for various reasons, medical, financial, others). How do they fit into this?

They are childless so would be taxed.

I think people are getting too emotional about this. In countries that have an aging population the consequences are quite dire. Who is going to be working and paying taxes to support all of these retired people, often with complex care needs? Surely better to address it before it happens?

YetAnotherSpartacus · 04/07/2022 14:03

Nah. Put an environment tax on anyone wanting to reproduce.

Swipe left for the next trending thread