Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tax childless adults

542 replies

Acidburn · 04/07/2022 13:41

Hi all

Just saw the below article on LBC news:

www.lbc.co.uk/news/childless-tax-birthrate-uk-cost-of-living-paul-morland/

AIBU to think that this insane?

OP posts:
IcedPurple · 04/07/2022 15:14

The fact is that when given a choice, most women don't want more than two or three children eve if they can afford to, and there will always be some people who don't want any and some people who can't have any.

Exactly. It's been shown pretty much universally that when women have access to contraception, education and life options other than being a mother, they will mostly choose to have only a few children, or perhaps none at all. No amount of extra taxes is going to change that.

Changes17 · 04/07/2022 15:14

I never understand the points about not paying for schools, nurseries etc if you don't have children. We benefited from them when we were children, so we pay for new generations to benefit now we can afford to pay. And in retirement, these new generations will be paying for your pension.

In a similar way, those of us of working age pay for hospitals we're less likely to be using now but may have as babies/children and will most likely use in the future.

PS this suggestion is mad and will never happen.

InTheNightWeWillWish · 04/07/2022 15:13

Maternity services are at breaking point. If we “incentivise” births without decent medical care we will just increase maternal and infant mortality rates, which would defeat the purpose of trying to raise birth rates. Pay a tax or pay a lottery with your life and the life of your baby, great choice.

This approach is a slippery slope to “incentivising” people who haven’t had the right number of children. If you want to raise birth rates, address the barriers for those who want children or more children (maternity services, childcare, maternity leave, paternity leave). Address the barriers for those who want children but can’t (funding for investigations, shorter waiting lists, support when they lose a pregnancy or child). Don’t force people who don’t want children to pay a tax or have children they don’t want. This is just going to create a bigger divide between parents and those who are childfree (both by choice and not by choice).

Cathod · 04/07/2022 15:12

The world is overpopulated. You can increase immigration to increase the number of young people.

AffIt · 04/07/2022 15:10

As a childfree-by-choice, higher-rate taxpayer who lives in Scotland, I am a net contributor to the population.

But - and I want to make this very, VERY clear - I DO NOT MIND THIS IN THE SLIGHTEST, as a healthy, well-educated population benefits me, too. In fact, I would happily pay more tax to ensure this. It's part of living in society.

If, however, I was to be taxed AGAIN for my choice, then I'd want receipts.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 15:10

It's a stupid idea but something will have to be done as there's enough working people in many west countries to fund the older population.

There's an awful lot of misinformation too. The western population boom has been caused by immigration & people living longer not too many children.

In the UK in the 1960s there were 5 working age people to every retired person, that will soon be 2 to 1. Over 65s now outnumber under 15s & whilst life expectancy has increased healthy life expectancy is a different matter. We are all going to have to pay a lot more tax.

Clarinet1 · 04/07/2022 15:10

HesterShaw1 · 04/07/2022 14:51

Oh hush - stop being so fucking snide. People are allowed to say anonymously on a forum they regret having children. NORMALLY they are met with understanding and empathy.

Besides, that's not what this poster said.

While I appreciate and support many of the arguments against the idea of a tax on childlessness which have been put forward, what I was basically saying was that, for someone like me, it would add insult to injury!

Thingstodotoday · 04/07/2022 15:08

@OperaStation if your procreations end up with your level of critical thinking then they won’t be much use to the ageing population anyway…

Tangled123 · 04/07/2022 15:08

Why not a small tax for everyone that funds childcare and /or maternity services to make having kids more affordable for parents? My husband would like a second kid but it would financially ruin us, even though we both have full time jobs. That’s what is putting me off.

Cherclueless · 04/07/2022 15:07

@ClaudineClare

My experience is totally anecdotal as a nurse in a deprived area but yes, many many of the younger people I see are requiring long term care for T2Diabetes (yes, I know not always lifestyle but usually is), Heart failure, which usually takes years to kill a patient and needs lots of medical intervention, caused (at least in part, a lot of the time) by obesity, alcohol, mismanaged diabetes etc… COPD caused by smoking, strokes caused by diet and inactivity.

I am not talking about conditions which are not lifestyle related but many many are and we need to do something to address this or quite frankly, we are screwed.

PrisonerofZeroCovid · 04/07/2022 15:06

This idea is ridiculous and also, frankly, quite chilling.

The fact is that when given a choice, most women don't want more than two or three children eve if they can afford to, and there will always be some people who don't want any and some people who can't have any. We've also (thankfully) reached a point in society where having children is less of an expectation and therefore people who, had they been born in the 50's/60's, would have had children as it was just what you did, now won't have any. Yes we're going to have a demographic hump but then those people will die and it will even out. Trying to keep the birth rate above two is like trying to hold back the tide.

Of course the elephant in the room is almost inevitable ill health in old age and the fact we're not only living longer, we're also dying for much longer and dying is very expensive.

ilovesooty · 04/07/2022 15:06

It's a disgusting proposal.

Gastonia · 04/07/2022 15:05

Perhaps with inflation increasing, savings will be worth less in real terms, so older healthy economically inactive people will come back into the workforce.

whumpthereitis · 04/07/2022 15:05

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 04/07/2022 14:31

Well then the only way to cope in the western world is increase immigration.

look the idea will never happen but it’s not that absurd. The narrative has been “your children, your problem” for decades- hence we have a vastly underfunded childcare system. If the narrative changes to seeing children and parents/ mothers as a benefit to a country I’m not necessarily against that.

Not seeing the problem with that. The fact that the UK population is inverse and falling doesn’t change the fact that on a macro level, the world is more than amply populated with the human species. Immigration seems a more logical solution than strong arming people into having children they don’t want.

anotherneutralname · 04/07/2022 15:03

Crikey, how hard of thinking the author must be.

How about:


  • high quality subsidised childcare

  • employer support for parental leave costs for small businesses

  • making sure absent parents of whatever sex pay the appropriate maintenance


And selfishly, how about a tax break for adopters, since they disproportionately have to reduce paid work in order to meet additional needs of children who experienced trauma?

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 15:03

OperaStation · 04/07/2022 14:01

You’ll still be substantially better off financially than those who have had children

So?

You know who else will be financially better off than childless women, men, even those with children. Until you fix the gender pay gap I don't care whether I have children or not I still earn less than men.

I bet this nob from Oxford doesn't suggest taxing men more

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 04/07/2022 15:02

As a single person, I get a poxy 25% discount on my council tax. A couple who have had three children in order to get their telegram (ha!) will be paying just 25% more than me for four extra people to use local authority services.

My taxes already pay for schools, nurseries, child benefit, paediatric care in hospitals… yet I’m apparently not supporting the next generation because I haven’t reproduced myself?

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 04/07/2022 15:02

As someone who very nearly faced the prospect of not being able to have children due to infertility (despite wanting them greatly) I find this absolutely disgusting. Whatever will they think of next…

IcedPurple · 04/07/2022 15:01

Just popping on to say that I agree with all of this apart from overpopulation. That's actually a myth. There is plenty of space and resources for everyone in the world. In fact, the entire global population could fit inside the state of Texas with a population density lower than that of NYC.

Yes, but that's not the way it works, is it?

People aren't evenly spread across the world, sharing 'space and resources' equally. Some countries have large populations and not much by way of space, natural resources or wealth. Other countries have all of the above shared by a small population, Norway being an obvious example.

Many parts of the world are definitely overpopulated. Not a myth at all.

whumpthereitis · 04/07/2022 15:01

I can see this incentivizing emigration, if anything. I imagine paying this tax would still work out cheaper than having children, so I’m not sure ‘save money, procreate’ is particularly accurate.

EmmaH2022 · 04/07/2022 15:00

Favvi · 04/07/2022 14:27

The most awful thing about this proposal is that it'll result in children being born to people who don't want them and just see them as dollar signs.

Hadn't thought of that. I'd need about a billion before I'd have a child.

As a 46 year old childfree woman, this is not the first time I'd heard this.

As well as being insane, has the man looked at population figures lately?

I'd don't know how they'd run this but we'd end up with childfree people trying to earn less. Many of us plan to retire much early than people with children already.

MintJulia · 04/07/2022 15:00

My ds is 14, so far in lost earnings and in direct costs I estimate he has cost me £120,000.

I don't begrudge him a penny but if I hadn't wanted a child, no form of tax would have changed that. What a stupid idea. I'd have emigrated first.

Inducing people to have an extra child through free childcare, less expensive homes, decent schools, flexible working etc, would be much more effective.

IncompleteSenten · 04/07/2022 15:00

There are what? Nearly 8 billion people in the world?
We have more than enough people. There is zero shortage of human beings.

What we have is a logistics issue.

How do we get people where we need them? How do we get people trained for the jobs that need doing? How do we tackle the raging racism and xenophobia that is the 'secret' reason people are so against free global movement and people and skill sharing?

Children don't have to be born in a country to grow up and live and work in that country and contribute.

User112 · 04/07/2022 14:59

What about those who CANT have children?

WTF IS WRONG WITH PEOPLE/GOVTS THESE DAYS?

Bubblebubblebah · 04/07/2022 14:59

It might incentivise me to leave the country for somewhere more progressive when I'm not seen as a vessel

Maybe that's part of the goal, isn't it. To send us elsewhere to lighten the pressure as we age. Keep just the fertile and/or willing.